Discrimination of metric theories

F. J. Lobo, M. Rivera-Tapia, G. Rubilar, O. Jiménez, A. Delgado · 2025

Read Discrimination of metric theories by F. J. Lobo, M. Rivera-Tapia, G. Rubilar, O. Jiménez, A. Delgado (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-12243.txt.

Introduction

Lobo and co-authors ask whether a quantum clock can tell rival theories of gravity apart in two thousand twenty-five. Metric theories differ in set constants that tweak how mass bends space and time. A quantum clock that moves slowly through a weak field ends in a state shaped by those constants.

Quantum state tests can then sort the theories. The authors show that a single detection can rule out one named theory, and can split two theories with certainty. Success odds hinge on four factors: the gap in proper time between the two states, the clock's energy gap, path length, and speed. Long-lived nuclei such as thorium look best as clocks, and using many clocks at once lifts the odds further.

Catalog record

CREATORF. J. Lobo, M. Rivera-Tapia, G. Rubilar, O. Jiménez, A. Delgado
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE47 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-12243

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Discrimination of metric theories F. J. Lobo, M. Rivera-Tapia, G. Rubilar, O. Jiménez, A. Delgado Abstract We study the possibility of discriminating between metric theories within the Parametrized Post-Newtonian formalism. In this approach, the two-dimensional quantum state of a massive quantum clock becomes, after propagating at low speed and in a weak gravitational field, a function of the post-Newtonian parameters and thus a signature of a metric theory. To discriminate among metric theories, we resort to quantum-state discrimination strategies such as minimum error and unambiguous state discrimination. In particular, we show that it is possible to refute the hypothesis that a particular metric theory describes spacetime with a single detection event and that it is possible to discriminate with certainty between two different metrics, also with a single detection event. In general, the success probability of the discrimination strategy is a harmonic function of the product of the difference of the proper time corresponding to each quantum clock state, the energy difference between the energy eigenstates of the quantum clock, the propagation length, and speed. It is thus possible to find suitable length and speed scales such that the success probability is close to one by selecting a quantum system with the highest energy difference and the largest natural lifetime. According to this, atomic nuclei such as thorium are considered the most suitable quantum clocks. I Introduction The Einstein Equivalence Principle (EEP) lays at the foundations of General Relativity (GR), a theory whose predictions have been consistently tested through challenging experiments and observations. Interestingly, besides GR, there are other theories that follow the EEP. This includes metric theories such as GR, where matter and non-gravitational fields respond only to spacetime, but consider additional fields besides the metric, such as scalar fields, vector fields, and so on. These additional fields modify the manner in which matter and non-gravitational fields generate gravitational fields and determine the metric Clifton et al. 2012 . Once the metric has been determined, it is the only object that acts on the matter as prescribed by the EEP. Thus, metric theories are distinguished from each other by the particular way in which matter and possibly other gravitational fields determine the metric Shankaranarayanan and Johnson 2022 ; Papantonopoulos 2015 . The existence of alternative metric theories consistent with the EEP and competing with GR has led to the study, comparison, and experimental discrimination between them. A preferred approach to accomplish this is the use of the parametrized post-Newtonian (PPN) formalism Will 2014 . Within this approach, which holds in the slow velocity and weak gravitational field limit, the spacetime metric is perturbatively expanded about the Minkowski metric plus various terms depending on gravitational potentials and a set of dimensionless parameters. The values of these parameters distinguish a particular metric theory Hohmann and Scharer 2017 ; Alexander and Yunes 2007 ; Flathmann and Hohmann 2022 . Here, we study the possibility of distinguishing between metric theories within the PPN formalism using various strategies for discriminating non-orthogonal quantum states. This is a fundamental task in quantum information processing, essential for extracting classical information from quantum systems Bae and Kwek 2015 . It plays a crucial role in various applications, including quantum communication, entanglement, cryptography, and computing, and is deeply connected to fundamental principles such as relativistic causality and the no-signaling constraint. Quantum state discrimination strategies have already been demonstrated experimentally Barnett and Riis 1997 ; Clarke et al. 2001 ; Cook et al. 2007 ; Wittmann et al. 2008 , even in higher-dimensional quantum systems Mohseni et al. 2004 ; Waldherr et al. 2012 ; Becerra et al. 2013 ; Agnew et al. 2014 ; Solís-Prosser et al. 2017 ; Solís-Prosser et al. 2021 , achieving excellent agreement with theoretical predictions. We consider the temporal evolution of a massive quantum clock, that is, a massive particle endowed with a two-dimensional inner degree of freedom. The final quantum state of the clock is a function of the post-Newtonian parameters that characterize a metric theory. The quantum clock states of various metric theories are mutually non-orthogonal and, consequently, cannot be discriminated deterministically and with certainty at the same time. Thereby, quantum state discrimination strategies are required. We first show a simple scheme, based on a von Neumann measurement, that allows for ruling out the hypothesis that a particular metric theory describes spacetime. In the case of two competing metric theories, we use minimum-error discrimination. This makes it possible to determine which of the metric theories is verified, although with a minimal probability of error. This result can be improved using unambiguous state discrimination, which allows to distinguish between two metric theories without misidentification error, albeit resorting to a generalized quantum measurement and with a smaller success probability than using minimum-error discrimination. The success probability of each one of these three approaches is an armonic function of the product of the difference of the proper time corresponding to each quantum clock state, the energy difference between the energy eigenstates of the quantum clock, the propagation length, and speed. In addition, the propagation time of the quantum clock cannot exceed the natural lifetime of the energy levels. This favors as quantum clock systems with the highest energy difference and the largest natural lifetime. According to our numerical simulations, the most promising candidates for quantum clocks are low-energy states of atomic nuclei such as thorium Beeks et al. 2021 ; Tiedau et al. 2024 ; Yamaguchi et al. 2024 . Other choices such as atoms, molecules, electrons, and neutrons lead to vanishingly small discrimination probabilities. A challenging scenario occurs when discriminating metric theories that have very close post-Newtonian parameters, for example, when trying to rule out a metric theory whose parameters are within the uncertainty of a metric that we suspect describes spacetime. In this case, propagation lengths on the order of 10^{5} km and speeds on the order of 10^{3} km/s allow us to reach success probabilities of the order of 10^{-2} . Higher probabilities can be achieved on larger length or speed scales. This article is organized as follows. In Section II we briefly review the post-Newtonian formalism, the method used to couple gravity to a quantum system, and quantum state discrimination strategies. In Section III we present our main results on the discrimination of metric theories, and in IV we present our conclusions. II A brief review of the PPN formalism, the coupling of quantum systems to gravity, and the discrimination of quantum states. In this section, we briefly review the post-Newtonian parameterization of a spacetime metric and introduce a Hamiltonian operator for a low-speed massive particle interacting with a weak gravitational field. We then review the problem of quantum-state discrimination and related strategies. II.1 Parametrized post-Newtonian formalism The Parametrized Post-Newtonian (PPN) formalism provides a framework for comparing metric theories of gravity by quantifying deviations from Newtonian gravity in the weak-field, slow-motion limit. This formalism utilizes a set of parameters, each with a distinct physical interpretation Will and Nordtvedt 1972 ; Will 2014 : \gamma determines the amount of space curvature produced by mass; \beta characterizes the non-linearity of gravity, reflecting the extent to which gravity itself generates gravity. The PPN formalism also includes parameters that assess the effects of a preferred

Read the complete text