Embeddings into the ultrapower of the Jiang-Su algebra
Ben Bouwen, Jennifer Pi · 2025
Read Embeddings into the ultrapower of the Jiang-Su algebra by Ben Bouwen, Jennifer Pi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-11983.txt.
Introduction
Ben Bouwen and Jennifer Pi study, in a 2025 math paper, when one algebra can be placed inside a giant averaged copy of two famous highly symmetric algebras. Such averaged copies, called ultrapowers, are key test beds in the theory of operator algebras. The algebras in view are prized for their regularity and for soaking up other structures.
The authors show the cone over any separable algebra of this type embeds into the ultrapowers of both target algebras. They extend the first result to whole fields of algebras that vary over a base space. One well-behaved fiber that embeds is enough to lift the whole field. The work widens what is known about these universal targets.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ben Bouwen, Jennifer Pi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 29 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-11983
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Embeddings into the ultrapower of the Jiang-Su algebra Thanks: This work was supported by DFF grant 1054-00094B, and by the the ERC grant EP/X026647/1. Ben Bouwen, Jennifer Pi Abstract . We study existence of embeddings into ultrapowers of the Jiang-Su algebra 𝒵 \mathcal{Z} and the Razak-Jacelon algebra 𝒲 \mathcal{W} . More specifically, we show that the cone over any separable C ∗ C^{*} -algebra embeds into the ultrapowers of both 𝒵 \mathcal{Z} and 𝒲 \mathcal{W} . We also show that the result for 𝒵 \mathcal{Z} generalizes to separable and exact continuous fields of C ∗ C^{*} -algebras for which one of the fibers embeds into the ultrapower of 𝒵 \mathcal{Z} , if this fiber is suitably well-behaved. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 46L35 1. Introduction Questions of embeddability into ultrapowers within operator algebras are ubiquitous, with the most famous being the Connes embedding problem: does every II 1 factor embed into an ultrapower of the hyperfinite II 1 factor? A naive C^{*} -analog of this question, regarding embeddings of C^{*} -algebras into an ultrapower of the Jiang-Su algebra \mathcal{Z} , can be quickly decided: any C^{*} -algebra with multiple non-zero projections cannot embed into \mathcal{Z}_{\omega} , since the latter is projectionless. However, the question of characterizing which C^{*} -algebras do admit embeddings into \mathcal{Z}_{\omega} remains open and difficult. In this brief paper, we make a few observations on embeddability of various C^{*} -algebras into the ultrapower of \mathcal{Z} and of the Razak-Jacelon algebra \mathcal{W} , a stably projectionless C^{*} -algebra with trivial K -theory constructed in [ Jac13 ] . The first asserts existence of an embedding for cones over separable C^{*} -algebras: Theorem A . The cone over any separable C^{*} -algebra embeds into \mathcal{Z}_{\omega} and into \mathcal{W}_{\omega} . This statement is obtained as a consequence of Proposition 2.2 . In the latter, we construct embeddings of the cone over the universal UHF algebra \mathcal{Q} into \mathcal{Z} and \mathcal{W} , which are used to embed the cone over \mathcal{Q}_{\omega} into \mathcal{Z}_{\omega} and \mathcal{W}_{\omega} , respectively. The statement above then follows by combining quasidiagonality of arbitrary cones over separable C^{*} -algebras [ Voi91 ] with an embedding of the cone into the double cone. Combining Proposition 2.2 with the results in [ Gab20 ] , we add \mathcal{Z}_{\omega} - and \mathcal{W}_{\omega} -embeddability to the following list of equivalences for separable, exact, traceless (in the sense of [ Gab20 ] ) C^{*} -algebras. Corollary B . For A separable, exact, and traceless, the following are equivalent: (1) A embeds into the cone over \mathcal{O}_{2} , (2) A is quasidiagonal. (3) A is AF-embeddable. (4) The primitive ideal space of A has no non-empty compact open subsets. (5) A is stably finite. (6) A is stably projectionless. (7) A embeds into the trace-kernel ideal of \mathcal{Z}_{\omega} . (8) A embeds into the trace-kernel ideal of \mathcal{W}_{\omega} . Our second result generalizes Theorem A to continuous fields of C^{*} -algebras under some additional conditions: Theorem C . Let E be a continuous field of C^{*} -algebras over a connected, compact, metrizable space X . Suppose E is separable and exact, and one of the fibers is simple, nuclear and \mathcal{Z}_{\omega} -embeddable. If this fiber is non-unital, or if E is unital, then E is \mathcal{Z}_{\omega} -embeddable. In the latter case, if the embedding of the fiber is unital, then so is the embedding of E . This follows from Theorem 3.4 , which asserts that \mathcal{Z}_{\omega} -embeddability passes to extensions. The proof makes use of extension theory, and specifically Elliott and Kucerovsky’s characterization of unitally absorbing extensions [ EK01 ] . As a particular consequence, we show that homotopy equivalence to \mathcal{Z} is a sufficient condition to embed into \mathcal{Z}_{\omega} for separable, exact C^{*} -algebras: Corollary D . Any separable, exact C^{*} -algebra A which is homotopy equivalent to \mathcal{Z} , embeds into \mathcal{Z}_{\omega} . 2. Existence of embeddings into ultrapowers of \mathcal{Z} and \mathcal{W} For an arbitrary C^{*} -algebra A , we denote the cone over A as (1) CA:=C_{0}(0,1]\otimes A\cong C_{0}((0,1],A). We also recall the definition of the ultrapower and the trace-kernel ideal of a C^{*} -algebra. For the entirety of this paper, fix a free ultrafilter \omega on \mathbb{N} . Definition 2.1 . Let B be a C^{*} -algebra. The ultrapower of B is defined as (2) B_{\omega}:=\ell^{\infty}(B)/\{(x_{n})_{n}\in\ell^{\infty}(B)\mid\lim_{n\to\omega}\|x_{n}\|=0\}. If moreover the set of tracial states T(B) on B is non-empty, the trace-kernel ideal of B is defined as (3) J_{B}:=\{(x_{n})_{n}\in B_{\omega}\mid\lim_{n\to\omega}\textstyle{\sup_{\tau\in T(B)}}\tau(x_{n}^{*}x_{n})=0\}. Proposition 2.2 . The cone over any UHF algebra embeds into \mathcal{Z} and into \mathcal{W} . Subsequently, the cone over \mathcal{Q}_{\omega} embeds into \mathcal{Z}_{\omega} and \mathcal{W}_{\omega} . Proof. Let M_{n} be a UHF algebra corresponding to a supernatural number \mathfrak{n} . We first show that CM_{\mathfrak{n}} embeds into \mathcal{Z} . Applying [ RW10 , Proposition 3.3] for p=1 and q=\mathfrak{n} gives a unital embedding of (4) Z_{1,\mathfrak{n}}:=\{f\in C([0,1],\mathbb{C}\otimes M_{\mathfrak{n}})\mid f(0)\in\mathbb{C}\otimes\mathbb{C},\ f(1)\in\mathbb{C}\otimes M_{\mathfrak{n}}\}\cong(CM_{\mathfrak{n}})^{\sim}, the unitization of CM_{\mathfrak{n}} into \mathcal{Z} . In particular, CM_{\mathfrak{n}} embeds into \mathcal{Z} . To show that CM_{\mathfrak{n}} also embeds into \mathcal{W} , write M_{\mathfrak{n}} as an inductive limit \varinjlim M_{n_{k}} of matrix algebras with connecting maps \mu_{k}:M_{n_{k}}\to M_{n_{k+1}} and n_{k}|n_{k+1} for all k . As such, CM_{\mathfrak{n}} is the inductive limit \varinjlim CM_{n_{k}} . Consider the Jacelon building blocks as in [ Jac13 ] : for \ell,m\in\mathbb{N} , (5) W(\ell,m):=\{f\in C([0,1],M_{\ell+1}\otimes M_{m})\mid f(0)=(1_{\ell}\oplus 0)\otimes c,\ f(1)=1_{\ell+1}\otimes c\text{ for some }c\in M_{m}\} and note that W(\ell,m)\cong W(\ell,1)\otimes M_{m} . Hence, the embedding (6) \iota:C_{0}(0,1]\to W(1,1):f\mapsto f(1)\oplus f induces embeddings \iota\otimes\id_{M_{n_{k}}}:CM_{n_{k}}\to W(1,n_{k}) for all k\in\mathbb{N} . Now let (7) \rho_{k}:=\id_{W(1,1)}\otimes\mu_{k}:W(1,n_{k})\to W(1,n_{k+1}), and note that \rho_{k} restricts to \id_{C_{0}(0,1]}\otimes\mu_{k} on CM_{n_{k}} and preserves the faithful trace \tau_{k} on W(1,n_{k}) induced by the faithful trace on C[0,1]\otimes M_{2}\otimes M_{n_{k}} coming from Lebesgue integration on [0,1] . Use part (i) of [ Jac13 , Lemma 4.1] to find * -homomorphisms \psi_{k}:W(1,n_{k})\to\mathcal{W} which satisfy \tau\circ\psi_{k}=\tau_{k} , where \tau is the unique trace on \mathcal{W} . In particular, this forces the \psi_{k} to be injective. Moreover, part (ii) of [ Jac13 , Lemma 4.1] implies that \psi_{k} and \psi_{k+1}\circ\rho_{k} are approximately unitarily equivalent. A one-sided intertwining argument (see for example [ Lin01 , Theorem 1.10.14] ) then shows that there exists a copy of the inductive limit \varinjlim(W(1,n_{k}),\rho_{k}) inside of \mathcal{W} , and since the \rho_{k} respect the connecting maps \id_{C_{0}(0,1]}\otimes\mu_{k}:CM_{n_{k}}\subseteq W(1,n_{k}) , \mathcal{W} also contains \varinjlim CM_{n_{k}}\cong CM_{\mathfrak{n}} . For the second part of the statement, note that the embedding C\mathcal{Q}\hookrightarrow\mathcal{Z} from the previous part of the proof induces an embedding (8) C\mathcal{Q}_{\omega}\subseteq\big(C\mathcal{Q}\big)_{\omega}\hookrightarrow\mathcal{Z}_{\omega}. This concludes the proof. ∎ Remark 2.3 . As a consequence of the main theorem in [ Rob12 ] , there exists a trace-preserving embedding of \mathcal{W} into \mathcal{Z} , which results in an embedding J_{\mathcal{W}}\hookrightarrow J_{\mathcal{Z}} . This means that the embedding into J_{\mathcal{Z}} can alternatively be obtained through its embedding into J_{\mathcal{W}} . Definition 2.4 . A C^{*} -algebra A is said to be traceless if every lower semicontinuous 2 -quasitrace can only take the values 0 or \infty . Corollary 2.5 . The cone over any separable C^{*} -algebra A embeds into \mathcal{Z}_{\omega} and into \mathcal{W}_{\omega} . If CA is traceless, then the embeddings lie within the trace-kernel ideals J_{\mathcal{Z}} resp. J_{\mathcal{W}} . Proof. Let A