No Universal Prompt: Unifying Reasoning through Adaptive Prompting for Temporal Table Reasoning

Kushagra Dixit, Abhishek Rajgaria, Harshavardhan Kalalbandi, Dan Roth, Vivek Gupta · 2025

Read No Universal Prompt: Unifying Reasoning through Adaptive Prompting for Temporal Table Reasoning by Kushagra Dixit, Abhishek Rajgaria, Harshavardhan Kalalbandi, Dan Roth, Vivek Gupta (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-11246.txt.

Introduction

Abhishek Rajgaria and co-authors show, in a 2025 paper, that no single prompt style works best when language models answer questions about tables that change over time. Temporal table reasoning asks a model to pull facts from rows and columns and track how values shift. The team tested many prompting methods across varied table types. They found that success depends on the kind of entity involved, the layout of the table, whether extra context is needed, and how hard the question is.

To cope, the authors build SEAR, a prompting framework that adapts its approach to each table and question, in the way a person adjusts strategy. SEAR beat the fixed baseline methods across all table types in their tests. They also found that rewriting tables into one shared format further improved the reasoning. The work argues for flexible prompts over any universal recipe.

Catalog record

CREATORKushagra Dixit, Abhishek Rajgaria, Harshavardhan Kalalbandi, Dan Roth, Vivek Gupta
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE56 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-11246

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

No Universal Prompt: Unifying Reasoning through Adaptive Prompting for Temporal Table Reasoning Kushagra Dixit, Abhishek Rajgaria, Harshavardhan Kalalbandi, Dan Roth, Vivek Gupta Abstract Temporal Table Reasoning is a critical challenge for Large Language Models (LLMs), requiring effective prompting techniques to extract relevant insights. Despite existence of multiple prompting methods, their impact on table reasoning remains largely unexplored. Furthermore, the performance of these models varies drastically across different table and context structures, making it difficult to determine an optimal approach. This work investigates multiple prompting technique across diverse table types to determine optimal approaches for different scenarios. We find that performance varies based on entity type, table structure, requirement of additional context and question complexity , with "NO" single method consistently outperforming others. To mitigate these challenges, we introduce SEAR, an adaptive prompting framework inspired by human reasoning that dynamically adjusts based on context characteristics and integrates a structured reasoning. Our results demonstrate that SEAR achieves superior performance across all table types compared to other baseline prompting techniques. Additionally, we explore the impact of table structure refactoring, finding that a unified representation enhances model’s reasoning. 1 Introduction Figure 1: Examples of Different Table and Contextual structure, taken from different datasets with efficient reasoning method based on specific question, Full Tables are in Appendix C . Temporal table reasoning presents a unique challenge, requiring Large Language Models (LLMs) to not only interpret tabular data while understand the embedded temporal relationships. Unlike static tables that provide a fixed snapshot of structured information, temporal tables evolve over time, incorporating event sequences, timestamps and dynamic updates such as new columns and more. Reasoning over such structures essential for financial forecasting, historical trend analysis, medical diagnosis and event based decision making ( Gupta et al. 2023 ; Xiong et al. 2024 ) . However, existing LLMs often struggle with capturing these intricate temporal dependencies, underscoring the need for more effective reasoning frameworks. Recent research has examined the role of LLMs in table reasoning, demonstrating significant improvements in extracting and analyzing structured data ( Zhang et al. 2025 ) . However, studies like Wang and Zhao 2024 highlight persistent challenge in temporal reasoning, as models often struggle to consistently track evolving data and infer event sequences accurately. Moreover, they highlight the limitations of the dominant single-step reasoning technique primarily direct prompting and chain-of-thought reasoning Wei et al. 2022 , which often fail to generalize across different table structures and time sensitive queries. Despite the growing adoption of LLMs for table reasoning tasks, the impact of different prompting strategies remains largely unexplored. Numerous prompting techniques have been proposed to enhance LLMs’ reasoning capabilities, yet their effectiveness varies significantly depending on the table structure, question complexity and reasoning requirements. In this study, we evaluate five single-step prompting methods as baselines: Chain-of-Thought (COT), Evidence Extraction, Decomposition, Faithful COT ( Radhakrishnan et al. 2023 ) , and Program of Thought (POT) ( Chen et al. 2023 ) . Each of these methods is designed to enhance the logical and numerical reasoning capabilities of LLMs. However, the extent to which these methods influence table reasoning performance, particularly in context of temporal tables, has not been systematically analyzed. This study addresses this gap by analyzing the performance of multiple established baselines and a novel adaptive reasoning strategy on a Temporal Tabular Question Answering (TTQA) task. We aim to answer the following research questions: (RQ1) Given a table and a question, which reasoning strategy should be employed? (RQ2) Is there a Single reasoning method that can perform well across all types of tabular structure? (RQ3) Is there a unified representation that can encapsulate all different tabular structures in most effective manner for the TTQA task? To address these research questions, we conducted experiments on eight distinct tabular structures using multiple state-of-the-art LLMs for the TTQA task. To overcome the limitations of existing baselines we propose SEAR (Select-Elaborate-Answer & Reasoning) framework, a novel adaptive prompting strategy. Our motivation can be likened to a carpenter building a chair. They have many tools, such as a hammer, saw and drill. Each is capable of performing part of the task, but none of them can build the whole chair. It is the skillful selection and combination of these tools that brings the chair to life. Similarly, SEAR equips models with multiple reasoning tools, and then it is on the model’s capability to choose them for solving the task at hand. From 8 , we observe that models actually use multiple tools to answer these questions. SEAR operates in three distinct phases. In the Initial Select phase, it identifies high-level crucial steps, in the subsequent Elaborate phase it refines these steps by adding detailed instructions, ensuring comprehensive road map. Finally, the Answer & Reasoning phase leverages the structured plan to deliver accurate answers, supported by clean, logical explanations and where necessary, includes integration of Python code for computational tasks. Furthermore, we combined these three phases to create a single step reasoning strategy, which we call SEAR_Unified. Our results show that SEAR_Unified outperforms all single step baseline reasoning strategies by significant margins, and even standard 3-step SEAR and existing multi-step reasoning strategies such as Self Discover Zhou et al. 2024 . This demonstrates the supremacy and efficacy of our proposed reasoning strategy. Additionally, our study also includes detailed analysis of refactoring process, wherein we transform diverse tabular structure into a unified representation ("Refactor"), This approach not only reorganizes the tabular content but also streamlines additional context based on the specific question, enhancing overall clarity and conciseness. Our main contributions are: • Benchmarking Prompting Methods : We evaluate five single-step prompting methods and show that their effectiveness varies based on table structure, entity type, sparsity and question complexity. • Adaptive Reasoning Framework : We introduce SEAR, a multi-step adaptive prompting approach that generalizes well across diverse table structures, also we integrate them into a single unified adaptive prompt SEAR_Unified, outperforming individual methods. • Table Structure Refactoring : We propose refactoring as an enhancement, demonstrating its effectiveness in improving model reasoning by optimized table representation. • Comprehensive Evaluation : We conduct a systematic analysis across various table types, highlighting the impact of different reasoning strategies and structure modifications. 2 Why is Temporal Table Reasoning Challenging? Temporal table QA requires models to reason over structured data while accounting for time-dependent relationships. This challenge arises from three key factors: the diverse structures of tables, the domain-specific reasoning requirements, and the complexity of the questions asked. Structural Variability. Tables exhibit a broad range of formats from simple row-column layouts to complex, hierarchical, or semi-structured formats with merged cells and implicit relationships. For instance, HiTab includes multi-level indexing, while HybridQA interleaves tables with linked text. Additionally, tables appear in different representations (e.g., CSV, HTML, Markdown), requiring adaptable parsing. These structural differences complicate reasoning and demand preprocessing steps to normalize the input. SEAR addresses this by restructuring complex tables into flattened, interpretable forms, enabling more effective downstream reasoning. Domain-Specific Complexity. Reasoning strategies must adapt to the table’s domain. Wikipedia-based datasets like WikiTableQuestions demand general factual reasoning and entity linking. Financial datasets like FinQA or TAT-QA emphasize numerical reasoning, requiring multi-step arithmetic and temporal trend analysis. SEAR dynamically adapts to these needs by identifying relevant entities and values,

Read the complete text