Spin-Dependent Scattering of Sub-GeV Dark Matter: Models and Constraints

Stefania Gori, Simon Knapen, Tongyan Lin, Pankaj Munbodh, Bethany Suter · 2025

Read Spin-Dependent Scattering of Sub-GeV Dark Matter: Models and Constraints by Stefania Gori, Simon Knapen, Tongyan Lin, Pankaj Munbodh, Bethany Suter (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-11191.txt.

Introduction

Stefania Gori and co-authors work out how light dark matter would scatter in solid targets in a 2025 paper. They focus on cases where the push from the dark matter depends on spin. For very light particles, below a stated mass bound, the hit mostly makes tiny sound waves in the solid, called phonons.

For heavier particles, the team links the rate to the known recoil of an atomic nucleus. They test three models in which a middle particle carries the force. Then they set bounds on the cross section from searches for that middle particle, from star cooling, and from beam tests. Some space above the bound may still be open to near term searches.

Catalog record

CREATORStefania Gori, Simon Knapen, Tongyan Lin, Pankaj Munbodh, Bethany Suter
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE119 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-11191

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Spin-Dependent Scattering of Sub-GeV Dark Matter: Models and Constraints Stefania Gori, Simon Knapen, Tongyan Lin, Pankaj Munbodh, Bethany Suter Abstract We calculate the scattering rate of sub-GeV dark matter in solid-state targets for spin-dependent dark matter – nucleon interactions. For dark matter particles with mass below 100 MeV, the scattering occurs predominantly through incoherent phonon production. For dark matter heavier than 100 MeV, we match onto the nuclear recoil calculation. To compare the sensitivity of future direct detection experiments with existing constraints, we consider three models with interactions which are mediated by spin-0 or spin-1 particles. This allows us to derive bounds on the cross section from searches for the mediating particle, including bounds from stellar cooling, beam dump experiments, meson factories and dark matter self-interactions. The existing bounds are very stringent, though for m χ ≳ 100 m_{\chi}\gtrsim 100 MeV there is parameter space which may be accessible with direct detection, depending on the exposure and background rates. I Introduction Advancements in experimental techniques, enabling increasingly lower energy thresholds, have been pushing direct detection of dark matter (DM) into the sub-GeV mass range Essig et al. 2022 . For DM which primarily couples to hadronic matter, the main signature in a solid or liquid target is a very soft nuclear recoil, potentially generating just a few phonons depending on the DM mass. The TESSERACT collaboration recently released their first science run for this signature, with a sub-eV energy resolution Chang et al. 2025 . This progress necessitates complementary theoretical work on two fronts. First, to achieve detectable scattering cross sections, a relatively low mass mediator particle is needed. Existing constraints on such mediators must be then translated into upper bounds on the direct detection rate accessible to future experiments. Second, for sub-GeV DM, the momentum transfer can be sufficiently small that the standard free elastic nuclear recoil approximation breaks down entirely. In this case, DM scattering excites collective modes with wavelengths longer or comparable to the interatomic spacing in the target material. Both questions have been comprehensively addressed for models in which the dark matter couples to nuclei primarily through a spin-independent interaction. Concretely, strong upper bounds on the direct detection cross section were obtained by combining bounds from stellar cooling, meson factories, cosmology and galaxy halo shapes, see e.g. Knapen et al. 2017a ; Green and Rajendran 2017 ; Batell et al. 2019 ; Dvorkin et al. 2019 ; Bondarenko et al. 2020 ; Chang et al. 2021 ; Elor et al. 2023 ; Balan et al. 2024 ; Cox et al. 2024 . These bounds indicate that the most viable parameter space exists for models with a light dark photon mediator, or models where the particle being detected is only a subcomponent of the full dark matter density. In addition, extensive rate calculations have been performed for a wide range of materials, for scattering into both single Knapen et al. 2018 ; Griffin et al. 2018 ; Cox et al. 2019 ; Trickle et al. 2020 ; Griffin et al. 2020 ; Caputo et al. 2020 ; Griffin et al. 2021 ; Trickle et al. 2022 ; Taufertshöfer et al. 2024 ; Ashour and Griffin 2024 and multiple phonons Knapen et al. 2017b ; Campbell-Deem et al. 2020 ; Kahn et al. 2021 ; Campbell-Deem et al. 2022 ; Caputo et al. 2021 ; Lin et al. 2024 ; Stratman and Lin 2025 . For anisotropic materials, the daily modulation of the scattering rate has also been computed Griffin et al. 2018 ; Coskuner et al. 2022 ; Griffin et al. 2021 ; Taufertshöfer et al. 2024 ; Stratman and Lin 2025 . For recent reviews on this subject and other detection channels, see Kahn and Lin 2022 ; Zurek 2024 . In this work, we consider models where the dark matter primarily has spin-dependent interactions with nuclei. We calculate the scattering rate in crystals 1 1 1 Spin-dependent interactions have also been considered in the context of molecules Essig et al. 2019 . , and survey the existing constraints on the cross section. We start in Section II by defining three benchmark models with spin-0 and spin-1 mediators, which generate the most motivated, non-relativistic operators for spin-dependent scattering. For each model, we must define a UV-completion in order to determine the bounds on the mediator particle and scattering rate. Since our goal is to find the maximum available parameter space for direct detection, we make choices which minimizes the strength of the existing bounds , while avoiding severe fine-tuning and/or elaborate dark sector model building. While it is inevitable that all bounds are model-dependent to a degree, we claim that alternative model building choices would generally strengthen the bounds. This section provides a brief summary of our choice of UV-completion, and establishes notation and conventions for the models, such that readers primarily interested in the results can directly proceed to Section VI . In Sections III and IV we provide more details on the models for spin-0 and spin-1 (axial vector) mediators, respectively. We survey the latest bounds in each case. The coupling of the mediator to the Standard Model (SM) is primarily constrained by stellar cooling, beam dump experiments, meson factories, and LHC searches. The coupling of the dark matter with the mediator is constrained by dark matter self-interaction bounds and/or theoretical consistency requirements. Combining these bounds yields an upper bound on the allowed direct detection cross section (see Ramani and Woolley 2019 for an earlier study). Section V describes the calculation for spin-dependent scattering into a (multi-)phonon final state. The scattering rate depends qualitatively on whether the nuclear spins in the crystal are aligned. If the nuclear spins have a high degree of coherence across multiple crystal cells, then coherent scattering contributes, similar to the case of spin-independent scattering (for a general discussion of the formalism for spin-dependent interactions in this case, see Trickle et al. 2022 ). While spin-polarized targets have been considered in the context of nuclear recoils Franarin and Fairbairn 2016 ; Catena et al. 2018 ; Jenks et al. 2023 , they likely pose additional experimental challenges. We therefore consider crystals in which the nuclear spins are oriented randomly , such that scattering is fully incoherent. Our calculation bears some similarities with the multiphonon computations for spin-independent interactions at moderate momentum transfer ( q\sim 10-100 keV), where the incoherent rate can be a good approximation to the coherent rate Campbell-Deem et al. 2022 . Incoherent phonon production in unpolarized crystals was also considered in the context of non-resonant axion absorption Bloch et al. 2024 . We have implemented the full calculation in the public code DarkELF Knapen et al. 2022 , as documented in Appendix E . Our main results can be found in Section VI . We compare the upper bounds on spin-dependent direct detection cross sections with the sensitivity of an idealized future experiment. Our qualitative conclusions are summarized in Section VII . The appendices contain additional results, as well as details on the UV completions and the DarkELF implementation of our calculations. II Models and constraints In order to obtain scattering rates which are large enough to be relevant for a near-future direct detection experiment, we must

Read the complete text