Getting Explicit Instruction Right

Richard Holden, Fabio I. Martinenghi · 2025

Read Getting Explicit Instruction Right by Richard Holden, Fabio I. Martinenghi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-10480.txt.

Introduction

Richard Holden and Fabio Martinenghi measure the effect of well run explicit instruction on test scores in Australia. Debate has grown over inquiry based learning, in which students drive their own discovery, versus direct teaching. All Australian students in key grades take national basic skills tests, giving the study a clean yardstick.

The team studied one mid performing school that adopted explicit instruction through peer modeling. Its teachers sat in on classes at a high performing school using the method. Year three and year five scores in reading and numeracy rose substantially after the change. The gains persisted over time. A synthetic control method, which builds a comparison school from similar ones, supports a causal reading.

Catalog record

CREATORRichard Holden, Fabio I. Martinenghi
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-10480

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Getting Explicit Instruction Right Richard Holden, Fabio I. Martinenghi Abstract There has been substantial public debate about the potentially deleterious effects of the long-run move to “inquiry-based learning” in which students are placed at the center of an educational journey and arrive at their own understanding of what is being taught. There have been numerous calls for a return to “direct” or “explicit” instruction. This paper focuses on identifying the causal effect of correctly implementing explicit instruction on student performance in standardized tests. We utilise a unique setting in Australia—a country in which all students in grades 3, 5, 7, and 9 undergo annual basic skills tests (“NAPLAN”). We use a synthetic control approach to study the effect of introducing Explicit Instruction in Charlestown South Public School—a median-performing school—on Year-3 and Year-5 NAPLAN scores in Reading and Numeracy. Importantly, this is achieved via peer modelling, with Charlestown teaching staff sitting-in during the classes of a high-performing explicit-instruction school. We find that the performance gains are substantial and persistent. Keywords : Education, Explicit Instruction, Pedagogy. 1 Introduction Over the last two decades, in many advanced economies, there has been a systematic decline in the academic performance of high school students. This is true, for instance, in the “Programme for International Student Assessment” (PISA) tests run by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), which tests the skills of 15-year-olds in mathematics, science and reading. In these tests, countries like the United States, United Kingdom, and Australia have seen sharp declines in absolute and relative terms. While the source of this decline is hard to pin down, many have speculated that a long-run trend in the way students are taught is to blame. This trend has involved a move away from teachers directly imparting learning to students, toward so-called “inquiry-based learning” in which students are placed at the center of an “educational journey” where they arrive at their own understanding of what is being taught. This approach emerged from the “constructivist” movement in education which emphasizes hands-on learning aimed at solving “real-world” problems. This has led to numerous calls for a return to “direct” or “explicit” instruction ( Hammond 2019 ) . This is sometimes called a “back-to-basics” approach to education. The purpose of this paper is not to litigate the cause of declining educational performance in many advanced economies. Rather, we focus on identifying the causal effect of correctly implementing the explicit instruction pedagogy on student performance in standardized tests. To do this, we utilize a unique setting in Australia—a country in which all students in grades 3, 5, 7, and 9 undergo annual basic skills tests (“NAPLAN”). We find strong causal evidence that a correct implementation of explicit instruction improves student performance and the magnitude is substantial, with point estimates ranging between 0.9 and 2.7 standard deviations. We emphasise the implementation aspect and build the counterfactual outcomes using a pool of schools that includes schools already integrating elements of explicit instruction in their pedagogical approach. Specifically, we use a synthetic control approach to study the effect of introducing Explicit Instruction in a median-performing school—Charlestown South Public School, New South Wales—on the school’s Year-3 and Year-5 NAPLAN scores, both in Reading and Numeracy (see Table 5 for more information on the performance percentiles of Charlestown South and the key schools used to construct synthetic Charlestown South ). Each year, all Australian students in grades 3, 5, 7, and 9 sit a basic skills tests known as “NAPLAN” (the National Assessment Program Literacy and Numeracy). These tests are administered each May in all schools across the country, and are intended to provide a snapshot of students’ current abilities in reading, writing, language (spelling, grammar and punctuation), and numeracy. There is a large and multi-disciplinary literature providing evidence of positive sign on the effectiveness of explicit instruction and similar pedagogical approaches. While Explicit Instruction is defined in various ways throughout the literature, we follow the definition from Archer and Hughes 2010 —a classic textbook on this topic. See Section 2.1 for details. Relevant studies in the education literature include Andreassen and Bråten 2011 , on reading for primary school students, Doabler et al. 2015 , on mathematics in Kindergarten, and Kroesbergen and Luit 2003 and Powell et al. 2021 , on using explicit instruction to teach mathematics to primary and secondary school students with special needs, respectively. For reviews focusing on the education literature, see Archer and Hughes 2010 , Hughes et al. 2017 , and Stockard et al. 2018 ’s comprehensive meta-analysis. Economists have also been interested in assessing the impact of explicit and structured teaching approaches on student outcomes. Difference‐in‐differences studies of the “Literacy Hour” and synthetic-phonics reforms find substantial gains in early reading outcomes (approx. 0.2-0.3 standard deviations; s.d.) and long-run benefits for low-performing students ( Machin and McNally 2008 ; Machin et al. 2018 ) . Using field experiments in the US, Fryer 2014 provides evidence that importing the direct instruction practices of charter schools—extended instructional time, data‐driven teaching, intensive tutoring—into public schools raises mathematics achievement by up to 0.18 s.d. one year after the implementation. Schwerdt and Wuppermann 2011 estimates a fixed-effects model on US data and finds that approaches where the teacher takes centre stage and presents the content in a structured format outperform problem‐solving approaches. Jacob and Lefgren 2004 uses a regression discontinuity design and focusing on mathematics, and Banerjee et al. 2007 and Piper et al. 2018 running RCTs in India and Kenya, respectively, to study the effect of structured approaches on numeracy and literacy skills—all finding positive impacts. Other examples of studies related to structured-teaching interventions are Romero and Sandefur 2022 , an RCT where 93 Liberian schools outsourced were randomly-assigned to be managed by private operators—who used scripted, highly-structured curricula—and Duflo et al. 2024 , where where one of the treatment arms of their RCT in Ghana was based on remedial tutoring that uses structured lesson guides. They also find positive impacts. Our paper adds to this literature in several ways. First, it shows the importance of a correct and high-fidelity implementation of Archer and Hughes 2010 ’s Explicit Instruction approach. In our case study, this is achieved by the teachers of the treated school emulating the teachers of a successful Explicit-Instruction school. Specifically, the principal and the teachers of the treated school visited the successful school for three days and learned how to best implement Explicit Instruction by sitting-in during their classes (called “modelling”, in the education literature). This seems not only to be an effective solution, but also a cost-effective one, compared—for instance—to hiring dedicated coaching staff for long periods of time (see Section 2.3 ), and particularly in high-income countries like Australia, where the cost of labour is high. The fact that this is happening outside of an experimental setting—and within a public-school context—should also reassure policy-makers that the performance gains we estimate are attainable. Second, our intervention of interest does not target a specific subject ( Machin and McNally 2008 ; Doabler et al. 2015 ; Machin et al. 2018 , e.g., ) or student sub-group ( Torgesen et al. 2010 ; Powell et al. 2021 ; Cortes et al. 2015 , e.g., ) , instead changing the

Read the complete text