Topological defects as effective dynamical dark energy

Haipeng An, Chengcheng Han, Borui Zhang · 2025

Read Topological defects as effective dynamical dark energy by Haipeng An, Chengcheng Han, Borui Zhang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-10075.txt.

Introduction

Haipeng An, Chengcheng Han, and Borui Zhang ask whether cosmic defects could imitate dark energy in a 2025 cosmology study. Recent survey data hint that dark energy may change over time rather than stay constant. Topological defects, relics such as cosmic strings and domain walls from the early universe, could add effects that look similar in the data.

Fitting current observations, the authors find no special preference for cosmic strings. A domain wall contribution at the percent level does improve the fit over the standard model by a modest margin. The authors present defects as a viable extension worth testing with future surveys, not as a settled answer.

Catalog record

CREATORHaipeng An, Chengcheng Han, Borui Zhang
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE22 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-10075

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Topological defects as effective dynamical dark energy Haipeng An, Chengcheng Han, Borui Zhang Abstract In this work, we consider the possibility that the dynamical dark energy hinted at by recent DESI data may be mimicked by the effects of additional components in the universe, potentially arising from topological defects. We find that the data does not show a particular preference for the existence of cosmic strings. However, a domain wall contribution at the percent level can improve the fit, yielding a Δ ​ χ 2 = − 1.72 \Delta\chi^{2}=-1.72 compared to the Λ ​ CDM \Lambda\rm{CDM} model. The improvement indicates that topological defects remain a viable and interesting extension to Λ \Lambda CDM, meriting further investigation with future cosmological data. I Introduction The driver of the accelerating expansion of our Universe is the most mystery in fundamental physics. In the standard model of cosmology, it is provided by the cosmological constant, which is equivalent to the vacuum energy of quantum fields and therefore is also known as the dark energy (DE). In this case, the equation of state parameter for dark energy, w_{\rm DE}=-1 . The equation of state parameter, w_{\rm DE} can be extracted from the measurement of the evolution of the baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO) using large scale structure surveys. Recent result from Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) found significant deviation of the Hubble expansion rate from what is predicted by the standard \Lambda CDM model in their second data release (DR2) DESI:2025zgx ; DESI:2025fii ; DESI:2025wyn . As shown in Fig. 1 , we can see that the measured Hubble expansion rate is larger than what is predicted by the \Lambda CDM model (shown by the red curve) at the redshift z\sim 0.5-0.8 . If this deviation is physical, it indicates that energy density in addition to the \Lambda CDM model is injected into our Universe in this redshift region. This deviation can be explained by introducing evolving DE with intriguing dynamics Guo:2004fq ; Hu:2004kh ; Huang:2025som ; Oriti:2025lwx ; Ormondroyd:2025iaf ; Luu:2025fgw ; Lee:2025yvn ; Nakagawa:2025ejs ; Anchordoqui:2025fgz ; Hur:2025lqc ; Pang:2025lvh ; Nesseris:2025lke ; Chaussidon:2025npr ; You:2025uon ; Kessler:2025kju ; Akrami:2025zlb ; Murai:2025msx ; deSouza:2025rhv ; Dinda:2025iaq ; Teixeira:2025czm ; Wolf:2025jed ; Li:2025cxn ; Lin:2025gne ; Smith:2025grk ; Wang:2025rll ; Csillag:2025gnz ; Bayat:2025xfr ; Moffat:2025jmx ; Cai:2025mas , non-cold dark matter Kumar:2025etf ; Abedin:2025dis , dynamical dark matter Wang:2025zri ; Chen:2025wwn , dark matter-DE interactions Huey:2004qv ; Das:2005yj ; Aboubrahim:2024cyk ; Chakraborty:2025syu ; Khoury:2025txd ; Shah:2025ayl ; Silva:2025hxw ; You:2025uon ; Pan:2025qwy ; Shlivko:2025fgv ; Yang:2025mws ; Cruickshank:2025iig ; vanderWesthuizen:2025iam , non-vanishing cosmic curvature contribution Dinda:2023kvg , modified theories of gravity from various UV considerations Zhu:2024qcm ; Pan:2025psn ; Paliathanasis:2025dcr ; Yang:2025mws ; Plaza:2025gjf ; Paliathanasis:2025hjw ; Scherer:2025esj ; Smirnov:2025yru ; Postolak:2025qmv , assuming existence of non-trivial local structures Banik:2025dlo ; Moffat:2025sik , modifying the recombination history of the Universe Mirpoorian:2025rfp . Figure 1: Hubble expansion rate measured by the DESI-2 from z=0.5 to z=1.35 . The data suggests an evolving dark energy model with an phantom-like equation of state (EOS) transitioning from w<-1 to w>-1 in recent times. In this work, instead of invoking an evolving dark energy component, we propose that there may be a missing part in the composition of our universe. In particular, the inclusion of topological defects can mimic the evolving dark energy. Topological defects, such as cosmic strings and domain walls, evolve differently from dark energy and dark matter. For the frustrated domain walls or cosmic strings, the equations of state satisfy, \displaystyle w_{\rm td}=\left\{\begin{matrix}&-\frac{2}{3},\quad\text{domain wall}\\ \\ &-\frac{1}{3},\quad\text{cosmic string}\end{matrix}\right.. (1) To fit the observed data, we consider the possibility that a non-negligible fraction of the present-day energy density of the Universe is attributed to topological defects. A substantial population of domain walls or cosmic strings is strongly constrained by current measurements of cosmic microwave background (CMB) anisotropies. These constraints typically require the cosmic string tension to satisfy G\mu<\mathcal{O}(10^{-7}) Planck:2013mgr , and the phase transition associated with domain wall formation to occur at \eta<O(1) MeV Lazanu:2015fua ; Sousa:2015cqa . These conditions translate into upper bounds on the fractional energy densities \Omega_{\rm cs}<\mathcal{O}(10^{-7}) for cosmic strings and \Omega_{\rm dw}<\mathcal{O}(10^{-4}) for domain walls. However, such limits are generally derived under the assumption that the topological defects remain in the scaling regime, where their energy density redshifts efficiently with cosmic expansion. In contrast, frustrated domain walls or cosmic strings redshift more slowly — their energy density dilutes less rapidly than in the scaling case. For a fixed present-day fraction, frustrated defects would have contributed less to the total energy density at earlier times, resulting in weaker constraints from the CMB. Moreover, frustrated topological defects do not cluster or form large-scale structures, which suppresses their impact on CMB anisotropies. The constraints can be further relaxed if the defects enter the horizon only at late times in cosmic history. This requires the defects to have a sufficiently large correlation length. Taking these effects into account, it remains plausible that topological defects could contribute up to a percent-level fraction of the current energy density of the Universe. In this work, we investigate this possibility and quantify its implications. Figure 2: The figure illustrating the difference of \mathrm{log}\left(H^{2}/H_{0}^{2}\right) between topological defects and \Lambda CDM. II The evolution of H(z) In our setup, we assume a flat universe with \Omega_{k}=0 . Then the expansion rate of the universe can be written as \displaystyle\frac{H^{2}(z)}{H_{0}^{2}} \displaystyle=\Omega_{\rm bc}(1+z)^{3}+\Omega_{\gamma}(1+z)^{4}+\Omega_{\nu}\frac{\rho_{\nu}(z)}{\rho_{\nu 0}} \displaystyle+\Omega_{\rm td}(1+z)^{3(1+w_{\rm td})}+\Omega_{\Lambda}, (2) where H_{0} is the Hubble parameter today, \Omega_{\rm bc}=\Omega_{b}+\Omega_{c} denotes the current fractional density of baryons and cold dark matter. \Omega_{\gamma} and \Omega_{\nu} represent the current fractional densities of radiation and neutrinos, respectively. The total matter density is defined as \Omega_{\rm m0}=\Omega_{\rm bc}+\Omega_{\nu} when neutrinos are non-relativistic. We adopt the dark energy as the cosmological constant with fraction \Omega_{\Lambda}=1-\Omega_{\rm m0}-\Omega_{\rm td}-\Omega_{\gamma} . We plot the ratio of the Hubble parameter of the topological-defect models to that of the \Lambda CDM model, with H_{0} and \omega_{b(c)}\equiv\Omega_{b(c)}h^{2} held fixed, as shown in Fig. 2 . From the plot, a bump appears whose peak is near the scale factor a\simeq 0.55\text{--}0.7 , corresponding to redshift z\simeq 0.4\text{--}0.8 , consistent with the Hubble parameter increase measured by DESI DR2, as shown in Fig. 1 . In our model, the sole free parameter is the present-day fractional density of topological defects. By varying this parameter, we find that the amplitude of the bump increases with increasing defect fraction. This behavior is expected: topological defects redshift faster than the cosmological constant but slower than matter, so they are negligible at early times. However, since their present-day fraction is fixed, their fractional contribution exceeds that of the cosmological constant across a wide range of redshifts, thereby mitigating the decline of the Hubble parameter compared to a model with only matter and a cosmological constant. To sample posteriors in parameter space, we employ the Metropolis-Hastings Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) algorithm, using the cosmological inference framework Cobaya Torrado:2020dgo which implements adaptive fast-slow-optimized MCMC samplers for Bayesian analysis. The theoretical predictions are based on a modified version of CAMB Lewis:1999bs , which is integrated within Cobaya . To constrain the model parameters, we utilize measurements from both baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO) and Type Ia supernovae (SNe). BAO

Read the complete text