Corrections to Friis noise factor formulas for cascade networks

Ankitha E. Bangera · 2025

Read Corrections to Friis noise factor formulas for cascade networks by Ankitha E. Bangera (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-09900.txt.

Introduction

Ankitha Bangera corrects the formulas radio engineers use to add up noise through a chain of amplifiers. Friis' formulas are the standard estimate for a cascade network's noise factor, but Bangera's 2025 solo article shows the versions for the higher stages contain major errors. Starting again from the basic definition of a noise factor, the paper re-derives the stage-wise formulas cleanly.

The corrected total for an n-stage cascade is the product of its stage-wise factors, contrary to the received formula. A worked comparison puts old and new side by side. The derivation is also cross-checked against the known expressions for a staircase avalanche photodiode, a real device whose noise the formulas must reproduce. The paper is housekeeping of the consequential kind: system budgets built on the old formulas have been mispricing noise in every stage after the first.

Catalog record

CREATORAnkitha E. Bangera
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE26 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-09900

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Corrections to Friis noise factor formulas for cascade networks Ankitha E. Bangera Abstract The signal-to-noise ratio of a multistage cascade network is often estimated using the well-known Friis’ formulas for noise factors (or the noise figures in decibels). However, this article addresses the major errors in Friis’ noise factor formulas for higher stages. Additionally, we re-derive the correct formulas to calculate the stage-wise noise factors for cascade networks from the basic definition of noise factors. We then present a comparison of our derived formulas with Friis’ noise factor formulas. Contrary to Friis’ formula, we define the total noise factor of an n -stage cascade network as the product of its stage-wise noise factors. We further validate our derived formulas for a cascade network by correlating them with the expressions for a staircase avalanche photodiode. 1 Introduction Cascade mechanism is widely used in various domains such as microelectronics & photonics [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] , two-dimensional (opto-) electronics [ 1 , 7 , 8 ] , telecommunications & signal processing [ 9 , 10 ] , integrated circuits [ 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 ] , artificial intelligence [ 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 ] , chemical biology [ 20 , 21 ] , and so on. Some major applications of networks in cascade include photon detection [ 1 ] , light detection & ranging [ 1 , 22 ] , photovoltage multiplication [ 7 ] , noise attenuation [ 9 ] , biosensing [ 15 , 21 ] , medical imaging [ 23 , 24 ] , anomaly detection [ 16 , 17 ] , image enhancement [ 18 ] , and many more. To extract the actual signal component at the output of a network, it is critical to calculate its noise factors. In 1944, Friis defined the noise factor of a network as the ratio of its input signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) to its output SNR [ 25 ] . SNR is a key factor in determining the overall system performance. There have been efforts to improve the design of systems or individual components to attain high SNR [ 26 , 27 , 28 , 29 ] . This necessitates the accurate estimation of noise factors as well. To date, Friis’ noise factor formulas are often used to calculate the noise factors in multistage cascade networks [ 2 , 3 , 11 , 14 , 15 ] . However, some of the noise factor formulas proposed by Friis are incorrect and thus need a correction. This article briefly discusses the existing theory and the well-known Friis noise factor formulas for cascade networks [ 25 , 30 , 31 , 32 ] . We then re-derive the correct stage-wise noise factor expression and the corresponding total noise factor for cascade networks in terms of their stage-wise noise factors. Our derivation is based on the existing theory for cascade networks, where the output signal of the previous ‘ (x-1) -th’ stage will be the input to the next ‘ x -th’ stage. We then compare our newly derived noise factor expressions with Friis’ formulas, discussing the corrections required for Friis’ noise factors. For validation, we correlate our results for a cascade network with those of a staircase avalanche photodiode (APD). In this article, the terms such as ‘network,’ ‘amplifier,’ ‘circuit,’ ‘system,’ ‘device,’ or any similar term used to indicate a cascade ‘structure’ are interchangeable. However, the term ‘network’ is applied to maintain uniformity throughout the article. 2 Theory Fig. 1 shows the block diagram of an n -stage cascade network. In the block diagram, S_{\text{i}} is the source’s signal power at the input terminals of the cascade network (or input signal power); N_{\text{i}} is the source’s noise power at the cascade network’s input terminals (or input noise power); M_{x} is the gain of the network’s x -th stage (or stage-wise gains); G_{x}=M_{x}^{2} is the power gain of the network’s x -th stage (or stage-wise power gains), defined as the ratio of a network’s x -th stage’s output signal power to its input signal power; F_{x} is the noise factor at the network’s x -th stage (or stage-wise noise factors); N_{\text{int}(x)} is the noise power due to the internal noises or irregularities generated within the network’s x -th stage (or stage-wise internal noise powers), amplified only at the succeeding stages; N_{\text{ext}(x)} is the noise power of the externally added noise at the output of the network’s x -th stage, such that the noise is amplified only at the succeeding stages; \text{SNR}_{\text{i}(x)} and \text{SNR}_{\text{o}(x)} are the SNRs at the input and output of the network’s x -th stage; \text{SNR}_{\text{i}} is the SNR at the input of the cascade network (or input SNR); \text{SNR}_{\text{o}} is the SNR at the output of the cascade network (or output SNR); S_{\text{o}} is the signal power at the cascade network’s output terminals (or output signal power); and N_{\text{o}} is the noise power at the cascade network’s output terminals (or output noise power). Figure 1: Block diagram of an n -stage cascade network. 2.1 Existing noise theory and Friis’ noise factors (stage-wise internal noises excluded) The noise factor of a two-port network proposed by Friis [ 25 ] is defined as the ratio of the SNR at the network’s input terminals to the SNR at the network’s output terminals, which was later standardized by IEEE [ 30 ] . Here, SNR is the ratio of the signal power to the noise power at a particular set of terminals in a two-port network. The power gain of the two-port network ( G ) is defined as the ratio of its output signal power ( S_{\text{o}} ) to its input signal power ( S_{\text{i}} ). Haus’ [ 31 , 32 ] further studies on Friis’ formulations, express a two-port network’s noise factor as the ratio of the noise power at its output terminals ( N_{\text{o}} ) to the product of the noise power at its input terminals ( N_{\text{i}} ) and its power gain ( G ). According to Haus [ 31 , 32 ] , if N_{\text{ext}} is the noise power of the externally added noise at the output of the two-port network, such that, the noise power at the network’s output terminals is equal to the sum of the amplified input noise power and the externally added noise power at its output terminals; then, the two-port network’s noise factor is given by, \displaystyle F_{\text{T}_{1}}=\frac{N_{\text{o}}}{N_{\text{i}}G}=1+\frac{N_{\text{ext}}}{N_{\text{i}}G} (1) However, equation ( 1 ) is for a single-stage two-port network. Friis’ extended model for two-port networks in cascade [ 25 ] formulates the total noise factor of an n -stage cascade network shown in Fig. 1 , but without considering the internal noises or irregularities generated within its stages. Therefore, neglecting the stage-wise internal noise powers ( N_{\text{int}(x)} ), Friis’ total noise factor formula for cascade networks is given by, \displaystyle F_{\text{T}_{n}} \displaystyle=1+\sum_{x=1}^{n}\left(\frac{N_{\text{ext}(x)}}{N_{\text{i}}\prod_{y=1}^{x}G_{y}}\right) (2) However, according to Friis [ 25 ] and the IEEE standards [ 30 ] , the noise factor formula for a cascade network’s x -th stage (or stage-wise noise factors) is expressed as, F_{x}^{\text{Friis}}=1+\frac{N_{\text{ext}(x)}}{N_{\text{i}}G_{x}} (3) Therefore, the total noise factor for an n -stage

Read the complete text