Observations of Carbon Radio Recombination Lines with the NenuFAR telescope

Lucie Cros, Antoine Gusdorf ,, Philippe Salomé, Sergiy Stepkin ,, Philippe Zarka, Pedro Salas, Alan Loh, Pierre Lesaffre, Jonathan Freundlich, Marta Alves, François Boulanger, Andrea Bracco ,, Stéphane Corbel, Maryvonne Gerin, Javier Goicoechea, Isabelle Grenier, Jean-Mathias Grießmeier ,, Martin Ho · 2025

Read Observations of Carbon Radio Recombination Lines with the NenuFAR telescope by Lucie Cros, Antoine Gusdorf ,, Philippe Salomé, Sergiy Stepkin ,, Philippe Zarka, Pedro Salas, Alan Loh, Pierre Lesaffre, Jonathan Freundlich, Marta Alves, François Boulanger, Andrea Bracco ,, Stéphane Corbel, Maryvonne Gerin, Javier Goicoechea, Isabelle Grenier, Jean-Mathias Grießmeier ,, Martin Ho (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-08895.txt.

Introduction

Lucie Cros and co-authors listen to carbon recombination lines from cold galactic clouds with the new NenuFAR telescope. These faint radio lines trace the diffuse gas between stars. Two bright beacons, Cassiopeia A and Cygnus A, backlight the clouds. Tens of hours of listening at very low frequencies fed a new cleanup pipeline.

Toward Cassiopeia A, 398 carbon lines were caught across a wide quantum range. Cygnus A's lines were fainter, so groups were stacked to fit them. Line shapes pin down cloud temperature, electron density, and turbulence. Signal quality beat the best LOFAR reads on both targets. Wide surveys of the galaxy's diffuse gas now look feasible.

Catalog record

CREATORLucie Cros, Antoine Gusdorf ,, Philippe Salomé, Sergiy Stepkin ,, Philippe Zarka, Pedro Salas, Alan Loh, Pierre Lesaffre, Jonathan Freundlich, Marta Alves, François Boulanger, Andrea Bracco ,, Stéphane Corbel, Maryvonne Gerin, Javier Goicoechea, Isabelle Grenier, Jean-Mathias Grießmeier ,, Martin Ho
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE107 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-08895

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Observations of Carbon Radio Recombination Lines with the NenuFAR telescope Lucie Cros, Antoine Gusdorf ,, Philippe Salomé, Sergiy Stepkin ,, Philippe Zarka, Pedro Salas, Alan Loh, Pierre Lesaffre, Jonathan Freundlich, Marta Alves, François Boulanger, Andrea Bracco ,, Stéphane Corbel, Maryvonne Gerin, Javier Goicoechea, Isabelle Grenier, Jean-Mathias Grießmeier ,, Martin Houde, Oleksandr Konovalenko, Antoine Marchal, Alexandre Marcowith, Florent Mertens ,, Frédérique Motte, Michel Tagger, Alexander Tielens, Gilles Theureau ,, Peter Tokarsky, Oleg Ulyanov, Vyacheslav Zakharenko Abstract Context. Carbon Radio Recombination Lines (CRRLs) at decametre wavelengths trace the diffuse phase of the interstellar medium (ISM) of the Galaxy. Their observation allows to measure physical parameters of this phase. Aims. We observed CRRLs with the recently commissioned New Extension in Nançay Upgrading LOFAR (NenuFAR) telescope towards two of the brightest sources at low-frequency (10 to 85 MHz): Cassiopeia A and Cygnus A (hereafter Cas A and Cyg A respectively), to measure the density n e n_{\rm e} and temperature T e T_{\rm e} of electrons in line-of-sight clouds. Methods. We used NenuFAR’s beamforming mode, and we integrated several tens of hours on each source. The nominal spectral resolution was 95.4 Hz. We developed a reduction pipeline, mostly to remove radio frequency interference (RFI) contamination and correct the baselines. We then performed a first fitting of the spectral lines observed in absorption, associated to line-of-sight clouds. Results. Cas A is the brightest source in the sky at low frequencies and represents an appropriate test bench for this new telescope. On this source, we detected 398 C α \alpha lines between principal quantum numbers n = 426 n=426 and n = 826 n=826 . Cyg A is also a bright source, however C α \alpha lines were fainter. We stacked the signal by groups of a few tens of lines to improve the quality of our fitting process. On both sources we reached significantly higher S/N and spectral resolution than the most recent detections by the LOw Frequency ARray (LOFAR). The variation of spectral linewidths with the electronic quantum number provides constraints on the physical properties of the clouds: T e T_{\rm e} , n e n_{\rm e} , as well as the temperature T 0 T_{0} of the radiation field, the mean turbulent velocity \varv t \varv_{\mathrm{t}} and the typical size of the cloud. Conclusions. Our final constraints differ from those inferred from LOFAR results, with, on average, ∼ \sim 50% lower T e T_{\rm e} , ∼ \sim 35% lower n e n_{\rm e} and from 10 to 80% higher \varv t \varv_{\rm t} . The NenuFAR observations sample a space larger volume than LOFAR’s towards the same sources due to the differences in instrumental beamsizes, and the discrepancies highlight the sensitivity of low-frequency CRRLs as probes of the diffuse ISM, paving the way towards large area surveys of CRRLs in our Galaxy. I. Cassiopeia A and Cygnus A 1 Introduction Our understanding of the life cycle of interstellar matter, from molecular clouds to ionised phases, encompassing star formation, is incomplete. Two key questions are related to (i) the processes of radiative and mechanical feedbacks exerted by young massive stars on their neutral interstellar environment, and (ii) the ability of the neutral interstellar gas to return to a molecular phase. Both questions will gain insight from the determination of the ionisation fraction, or equivalently the fractional abundance of free electrons. Indeed, although neutral in the sense that its main constituents (H and He) are in neutral forms, the neutral ISM can maintain a small ionisation fraction (from \sim 10^{-8} in its densest, molecular phases to \sim 10^{-1} in the warm neutral medium). Several processes contribute to this ionisation. Stellar FUV photons (energies between 6 eV and 13.6 eV, the latter value being the ionisation potential of hydrogen), can penetrate into neutral gas and ionise carbon and sulphur atoms (respectively of 11.26 and 10.36 eV ionisation potential). This is the case in photodissociation regions (PDRs), and more precisely in the unshielded surface layer of dense molecular clouds directly illuminated by nearby young massive stars (e.g., Joblin et al. 2018 , Peeters et al. 2024 and references therein). This is also the case more generally in the diffuse interstellar gas, widely permeated by the ambient Galactic stellar UV radiation ( Heays et al. 2017 ) . Dynamical processes such as shocks can also partially ionise the gas (e.g., Godard et al. 2024 ), whereas cosmic rays are the only possible source of ionisation in the densest parts of molecular clouds ( Dalgarno 2006 , Padovani et al. 2009 , Padovani et al. 2018 ). Measuring the ionisation fraction in the ISM is paramount since beyond playing a key role in its chemistry, it controls its heating (e.g. through the photoelectric effect on interstellar dust grains), cooling (e.g. through the excitation of key species), and the excitation of key species (e.g. common molecular tracers with high dipole moments such as HCN and HCO + ). Until a few years ago, measuring the ionisation fraction had systematically been done by modelling the line emission from carefully selected species with astrochemical models (see e.g. Bron et al. 2021 , for a review) . Over the past 20 years, instrumental progress has resulted in the development of a new strategy to observationally constrain this parameter in the neutral interstellar regions, based on the observation of recombination lines, in particular from carbon, in various frequency ranges. Indeed, in presence of UV radiation, carbon is the main electron provider in these regions. Carbon atoms undergo a rapid cycle of ionisation followed by recombination with the free electrons present in the gas. During these recombinations, the species recombine in very excited electronic states and then cascade to lower energy states, emitting a large number of recombination lines. In the recent years, lines have been observed in the low frequency radio range ( < 1 GHz) in absorption against bright Galactic radiosources: the carbon Radio Recombination Lines, or ‘CRRLs’. For instance, Stepkin et al. 2007 observed series of carbon \alpha , \beta , \gamma and \delta recombination lines (hereafter ‘C \alpha ’, ‘C \beta ’, ‘C \gamma ’, ‘C \delta ’) in absorption towards Cassiopeia A (hereafter Cas A), respectively arising from principal quantum number n+1,n+2,n+3,n+4\rightarrow n de-excitations with the UTR-2Ukrainian radiotelescope around 26 MHz. Their detections of C \delta lines with n\in[625,1005] allowed them to estimate the electron temperature and density in line-of-sight clouds by fitting the evolution of the linewidth with the quantum number of the upper level of the transition. After Asgekar et al. 2013 proved the feasibility to use LOFAR to study low-frequency C518 \alpha to C548 \alpha RRLs towards sources like Cas A, Oonk et al. 2017 complemented this study of line-of-sight clouds towards this source with LOFAR observations in the 33 - 78 MHz and 304 - 386 MHz ranges. They detected series of hydrogen and carbon recombination lines in emission and absorption in three line-of-sight clouds, which led them to obtain better constrained measurements of the electron density n_{\rm e} and temperature T_{\rm e} , to pinpoint the origin of the CRRLs in the CO-dark surface layers of molecular clouds where most of the carbon is ionised but the hydrogen is already molecular, and to estimate

Read the complete text