Radiative corrections to the nuclear size and polarizability effects in atomic systems

Krzysztof Pachucki · 2025

Read Radiative corrections to the nuclear size and polarizability effects in atomic systems by Krzysztof Pachucki (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-08879.txt.

Introduction

Krzysztof Pachucki completes a precision calculation of how radiation corrects the nuclear size effects seen in atomic spectra. Atoms feel the nucleus's finite size, its recoil, and its polarizability as tiny energy shifts. At the accuracy modern spectroscopy reaches, radiative corrections to those shifts matter. The calculation covers the relevant order in the fine-structure constant expansion, for all three effects at once.

The payoff is a cross-check between two experimental worlds. The difference of mean square charge radii between deuteron and proton, extracted from ordinary electronic atoms, agrees very well with the value from muonic atoms. That agreement is nontrivial: muonic measurements once fueled a famous proton size puzzle. Complete radiative bookkeeping of this kind is what lets atomic physics testify about nuclear structure with confidence.

Catalog record

CREATORKrzysztof Pachucki
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-08879

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Radiative corrections to the nuclear size and polarizability effects in atomic systems Krzysztof Pachucki Abstract We perform a complete calculation of α ​ ( Z ​ α ) 5 ​ m \alpha\,(Z\,\alpha)^{5}\,m radiative corrections to the finite nuclear size, the recoil finite size and the nuclear polarizability effects in atomic systems. I Introduction With the increased precision of atomic isotope shift measurements amsterdam:25 and muonic atom determinations of the nuclear charge radii crema:25 , knowledge of nuclear recoil, finite nuclear size (fns), and polarizability effects became of great interest. The accurate calculation of these effects is important for the comparison of electronic and muonic atom isotope shift, from which one obtains the difference in the mean square charge radii between isotopes pachucki:24a . This difference is an important test of the low-energy interactions. For example, the second-order recoil correction (Z\,\alpha)^{6}\,m^{3}/M^{2} was recently found qi:25 ; pachucki:24b to be significant for the 3 He- 4 He isotope shift, due to the hyperfine mixing, and thus resolved a discrepancy between the electronic and muonic determination of the mean square nuclear charge radii difference. The nonradiative fns corrections including the leading recoil (Z\,\alpha)^{6}\,m^{2}/M have been the subject of recent works pachucki:23 ; yerokhin:23 ; pachucki:25a . The exact result without expansion in Z\,\alpha in the nonrecoil limit is a matter of solving the Dirac equation with extended size nucleus. It is nevertheless valuable to perform the Z\,\alpha expansion, because the explicit dependence on the charge distribution can be obtained. For example, at the order of (Z\,\alpha)^{6}\,m the finite size effect includes the r^{2}_{C}\,\ln(m\,r_{C}) term. Leading recoil corrections can also be calculated exactly using the recently derived formula for the recoil correction with extended size nuclei pachucki:23 ; yerokhin:23 , while the Z\,\alpha expansion leads to the r_{C}^{2}\,\ln(m\,r_{C}) term at (Z\,\alpha)^{5}\,m^{2}/M and a linear r_{C} term at (Z\,\alpha)^{6}\,m^{2}/M orders. In contrast to the above, the exact calculation of radiative finite size corrections is much more difficult, because it involves the electron self-energy. They have been calculated numerically in Ref. yerokhin:11 , but it is difficult to obtain the functional dependence on the nuclear charge distribution in this way. Therefore, they have been calculated analytically in the leading order \alpha\,(Z\,\alpha)^{5} in Refs. pachucki:93a ; eides:01 ; sgk:18 and at some higher orders yerokhin:11 ; sgk:18 . It is even more difficult to obtain the leading radiative recoil correction to the finite size effect. The exact formulas have recently been derived using a formulation of Heavy Particle QED (HPQED) pachucki:24c , but they have not yet been implemented numerically. In fact, the radiative recoil correction is the main source of uncertainty in hydrogen energy levels codata:22 , after the improved numerical calculation of the two-loop electron self-energy has been performed yerokhin:24 . In this work, we collect all known results for radiative finite size corrections at leading orders, present their comprehensive derivation, and in particular, obtain finite nuclear size effects of order \alpha\,(Z\,\alpha)^{5}\,m and \alpha\,(Z\,\alpha)^{5}\,m^{2}/M , which are important for determination of the nuclear charge radii from the electronic and muonic atomic spectroscopy. In addition we perform the calculation of the electron self-energy correction to the nuclear polarizability effect, which is currently the main source of uncertainty in H-D isotope shift pachucki:18 . II Expansion of the finite nuclear size effect in powers of \alpha Let us denote by E_{\rm fns} the shift in the binding energy of a hydrogenic system due to the finite nuclear size (fns). For a light atom we can perform the expansion of E_{\rm fns} in the small nuclear charge Z\,\alpha and in \alpha (together) \displaystyle E_{\rm fns}=E^{(4)}_{\rm fns}+E^{(5)}_{\rm fns}+E^{(6)}_{\rm fns}+\ldots, (1) where the superscript indicates the order in \alpha . The leading-order nuclear contribution is of order (Z\alpha)^{4} and is given by a simple formula, E^{(4)}_{\rm fns}=\frac{2\,\pi}{3}\,Z\alpha\,\phi^{2}(0)\,r_{C}^{2}\,, (2) where \phi(0) is the nonrelativistic wave function of the electron at the position of nucleus, r_{C} is the root-mean-square charge radius of the nucleus \displaystyle r_{C}^{2}=\int d^{3}r\,r^{2}\,\rho(\vec{r}), (3) and \rho(\vec{r}) is the nuclear charge distribution. Eq. ( 2 ) includes the exact dependence on the finite nuclear mass M through \phi^{2}(0)=\mu^{3}\,(Z\alpha)^{3}/(\pi n^{3}) , where \mu=mM/(m+M) . The mass dependence of higher-order corrections is much more complicated, and it is convenient to perform an additional expansion in the mass ratio, namely \displaystyle E^{(n)}_{\mathrm{fns}}=E^{(n,0)}_{\mathrm{fns}}+E^{(n,1)}_{\mathrm{fns}}+\ldots, (4) where the second superscript denotes a power in the m/M expansion coefficient. The leading expansion terms are known, but for the clarity of presentation we will repeat their derivation here and start from E^{(5,0)}_{\mathrm{fns}} . III (Z\,\alpha)^{5} Nonrecoil FNS The next to leading order E^{(5,0)}_{\rm fns} finite size correction in the nonrecoil limit, is given by the two-photon exchange amplitude T^{\mu\nu} \displaystyle E^{(5,0)}_{\mathrm{fs}}= \displaystyle\ \phi^{2}(0)\,\int\frac{d^{3}q}{(2\,\pi)^{3}}\,T^{00}(\vec{q}^{\,2})\,V^{2}(\vec{q}^{\,2}), (5) where \displaystyle V(\vec{q}^{\,2})= \displaystyle\ -\frac{4\,\pi\,Z\,\alpha}{\vec{q}^{\,2}}\,\rho(\vec{q}^{\,2}), (6) and \rho(\vec{q}^{\,2}) is the Fourier transform of \rho(r) . We will later identify \rho(-q^{2}) with the nuclear charge form factor as a function of the four-momentum square q^{2} and at the same time assume that \rho has a proper analytical behavior as a function on the complex plane. The two-photon exchange amplitude T^{\mu\nu} is \displaystyle T^{\mu\nu}(p)= \displaystyle\ \mathrm{Tr}\biggl[\gamma^{\mu}\,\frac{1}{\not\!p-m}\gamma^{\nu}\,\frac{\gamma^{0}+I}{4}\biggr], (7) with p=t+q , t\cdot q=0 , t=(m,\vec{0}) , and m is the lepton (electron or muon) mass. Performing the trace \displaystyle T^{00}(\vec{q}^{\,2})= \displaystyle\ -\frac{2\,m}{\vec{q}^{\,2}}\,, (8) E^{(5,0)}_{\mathrm{fns}} becomes \displaystyle E^{(5,0)}_{\mathrm{fns}}= \displaystyle\ -2\,m\,(4\,\pi\,Z\,\alpha)^{2}\,\phi^{2}(0)\,\int\frac{d^{3}q}{(2\,\pi)^{3}}\,\frac{\rho^{2}(\vec{q}^{\,2})}{\vec{q}^{\;6}}\,. (9) E^{(5,0)}_{\mathrm{fns}} requires the subtraction of infrared divergent terms, which correspond to the point nucleus and the leading E^{(4)}_{\mathrm{fns}} term, thus \displaystyle E^{(5,0)}_{\mathrm{fns}}= \displaystyle\ -m\,(Z\,\alpha)^{2}\,\phi^{2}(0)\!\!\int\!dq\,\frac{16}{q^{4}}\,\big[\rho^{2}(q^{2})-1-2\,\rho^{\prime}(0)\,q^{2}\big]. (10) The q -integral can be expressed as \displaystyle\int dq\,\frac{16}{q^{4}}\,\big[\rho^{2}(q^{2})-1-2\,\rho^{\prime}(0)\,q^{2}\big]=r^{3}_{F}\,\frac{\pi}{3}, (11) where r_{F} is defined by friar:79 \displaystyle r^{3}_{F}=\int d^{3}r_{1}\,d^{3}r_{2}\,\rho(\vec{r}_{1})\,\rho(\vec{r}_{2})\,|\vec{r}_{1}-\vec{r}_{2}|^{3}, (12) thus \displaystyle E^{(5,0)}_{\mathrm{fns}}= \displaystyle\ -\frac{\pi}{3}(Z\,\alpha)^{2}\,\phi^{2}(0)\,m\,r^{3}_{F}, (13) in agreement with Ref. friar:79 . This formula is exact only for the nucleus, which is described by the elastic charge form factor \rho . However, the elastic approximation is not always valid, in particular for large momenta q . In fact, values of the electron momenta in Eq. ( 11 ) are of order of the inverse of the nuclear size. For such high momenta, the electron sees individual nucleons instead of the nucleus as a whole. It is a small effect for electronic atoms, because this whole correction is small, namely O(Z\,\alpha\,m\,r_{C}) in comparison to the leading finite size E^{(4)}_{\mathrm{fns}} . But this is not the case of muonic atoms, where m\,r_{C} is of order 1 and we find significant inelastic effects pachucki:24a . In general, when large exchange momenta are involved, one may expect a significant inelastic contribution. The same effect appears at higher-order corrections; a part of fns comes from the low momenta exchange where the elastic approximation works as for E^{(4)}_{\mathrm{fns}} and a part from high momenta where elastic approximation does not work. For example, the so-called three-photon exchange correction E^{(6)}_{\rm nucl} comes from many scales of exchanged momenta, and presently only the elastic part E^{(6)}_{\mathrm{fns}} is known. In this work we assume the elastic approximation, which is usually assumed as a good starting point, and only in Sec. VIII we consider radiative corrections to the electric dipole nuclear polarizability effect in electronic atoms. IV (Z\,\alpha)^{5} Recoil FNS In contrast to nonrecoil correction from the previous section, the radiative recoil fns corrections have not yet been extensively studied in the literature. Let us first consider the nonradiative recoil fns correction

Read the complete text