Deriving physical parameters of unresolved star clusters
Karolis Daugevičius, Eimantas Kriščiūnas, Erikas Cicėnas, Rima Stonkutė, Vladas Vansevičius · 2025
Read Deriving physical parameters of unresolved star clusters by Karolis Daugevičius, Eimantas Kriščiūnas, Erikas Cicėnas, Rima Stonkutė, Vladas Vansevičius (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-08674.txt.
Introduction
Karolis Daugevicius and four co-authors probed the limits of measuring star clusters that cannot be split into single stars, in a 2025 paper. Such clusters are read from their total light, but bright stars that fall in the frame can skew the colors. A newer method adapts the measuring window to cut that skew.
The team built a large grid of fake clusters and made images of each from one hundred angles, in six color bands matched to a Hubble survey of Andromeda. Measuring those images let them test how exact the method can be. Clusters with and without late-stage stars differed clearly. Trusty results needed a window wider than the cluster's half-light radius. Very young clusters stayed hard to pin down by this route at any window size.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Karolis Daugevičius, Eimantas Kriščiūnas, Erikas Cicėnas, Rima Stonkutė, Vladas Vansevičius |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 79 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-08674
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Deriving physical parameters of unresolved star clusters Karolis Daugevičius, Eimantas Kriščiūnas, Erikas Cicėnas, Rima Stonkutė, Vladas Vansevičius Abstract Context. Recently, it has been noticed that the discrepancies in the integrated colour indices (CIs) between star clusters and models are mostly due to the projection of bright stars in the apertures. In order to reduce this problem, the method of adaptive aperture photometry has been proposed. This method has been applied to star clusters from the M 31 Panchromatic H u b b l e Hubble Andromeda Treasury (PHAT) survey, and studies show that the adaptive aperture photometry performs better than the conventional approach. Aims. The aim of this study is to determine the best achievable limits on the accuracy and applicability of the aperture photometry method for studying star clusters in the local Universe. Methods. We computed a large network of artificial 3D star clusters spanning the parameter space of the M 31 clusters. We then simulated images of these clusters by projecting each onto a 2D plane from 100 directions. Star cluster images were generated in six passbands to match the PHAT survey. To investigate the limiting accuracy of aperture photometry and the limits of its applicability to star cluster studies, we measured the simulated images and performed parameter determination tests. Results. We demonstrate that star clusters with and without post-main-sequence stars have significant photometric differences. We show that in order to obtain reliable physical parameters of star clusters, the CIs must be measured using an aperture with a radius larger than the cluster’s half-light radius. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the parameter determination of young clusters ( ∼ \sim 10 Myr) is problematic regardless of the aperture size used. Therefore, it is advisable to determine the parameters of these clusters using colour-magnitude diagram fitting methods, when possible. We also show that the randomness of the viewing angle can lead to a CI uncertainty of up to 0.1 mag, depending on cluster parameters and aperture size. VIII. Limits of aperture photometry for star cluster studies 1 Introduction Understanding star formation processes is one of the crucial current astrophysical problems as it is the main galaxy-building mechanism throughout the majority of cosmic time. It is widely accepted that the majority of newborn stars are formed in clustered environments – bound and unbound star clusters, and stellar associations ( Lada & Lada 2003 ) . However, most of the clusters and associations eventually dissolve into the galactic stellar field, thereby contributing to the build-up of the global stellar populations of galaxies ( Portegies Zwart et al. 2010 ) . Thus, studies of star clusters are key in finding solutions to unanswered questions about star formation. Knowledge of clusters’ physical (age, mass, metallicity, and extinction) and structural (size and ellipticity) parameters provides us with an insight into the formation and evolution of their host galaxy discs, and enables us to better comprehend general star formation processes. Star cluster studies in the Milky Way disc are rather limited due to the fact that the Solar System resides near the galactic plane. However, the proximity of other disc galaxies in our neighbourhood, such as Andromeda ( M 31 ) or Triangulum ( M 33 ), combined with the outstanding capabilities of Hubble Space Telescope (HST) imaging, provide us with an excellent opportunity to study a large number of unresolved and semi-resolved star clusters located in the discs of these galaxies. Parameters of extragalactic star clusters are derived using various methods and algorithms. Structural parameters of unresolved or partially resolved star clusters are most commonly evaluated by fitting 2D models to the observed surface brightness distributions ( Larsen 1999 ; Narbutis et al. 2014 ; Brown & Gnedin 2021 ) . Meanwhile, for star cluster parameter derivation, several families of methods are used, all of which exhibit varying accuracy and applicability limits and caveats. Many currently applied techniques for star clusters in the local Universe ( \lesssim 10 Mpc) rely on broad-band photometry. The most accurate methods are based on constructing clusters’ colour-magnitude diagrams (CMDs) from individual member stars and comparing them to the synthetic CMDs produced by simulating stellar populations or fitting theoretical isochrones ( Weisz et al. 2015 ; Johnson et al. 2016 ; Wainer et al. 2022 ; Čeponis et al. 2024 ) . However, such methods require that individual upper main-sequence (MS) stars are well resolved as it is necessary to obtain reliable measurements of stars below the MS turn-off (MSTO) point. Therefore, accurate and robust results are achievable only for relatively nearby and young star clusters, greatly limiting the number of objects that can be studied using CMD fitting methods; Wainer et al. 2022 have shown that parameter estimates are good up to 300 Myr and for clusters more massive than 1000 \rm{M_{\sun}} . Integral spectroscopy methods ( Caldwell et al. 2009 ; Caldwell et al. 2011 ; Caldwell & Romanowsky 2016 ) also provide accurate cluster parameter estimates, but given the capabilities of present-day observatories, only studies of rather massive extragalactic clusters can be performed. Another group of popular methods employed to derive cluster parameters fit stochastic theoretical stellar population models to the observed integrated cluster magnitudes and colour indices (CIs) ( Deveikis et al. 2008 ; Fouesneau & Lançon 2010 ; Fouesneau et al. 2014 ; de Meulenaer et al. 2013 ; Krumholz et al. 2015 ) . These techniques are applicable to study lower-mass, older, and more distant star clusters, greatly increasing the number of objects to be investigated. This enables us to study the star formation histories of galactic discs based on a wider range of star cluster masses, and on longer timescales. However, when such methods are used, the accuracy of the derived star cluster parameters strongly depends on the uncertainties of aperture photometry, and on whether projected background and foreground stars (hereinafter field stars), and the brightest evolved member stars are properly accounted for. Especially in the low-mass range ( \lesssim 3000 \rm{M_{\sun}} ), integrated photometry methods are extremely sensitive to stochastic effects of star clusters – mostly the stochastic sampling of the stellar initial mass function (IMF) – especially at young ages ( < 1 Gyr) ( Fouesneau & Lançon 2010 ; Beerman et al. 2012 ; Anders et al. 2013 ; de Meulenaer et al. 2013 ; de Meulenaer et al. 2017 ) . Most of the stochastic variation in cluster brightness and colour in the case of low-mass objects is driven by stars that have left the MS and already are in transient late-evolutionary phases. The upper MS and evolved star stages of low-mass clusters ( \lesssim 10^{4}\,\rm{M_{\sun}} ) are sparsely populated, causing cluster photometric parameters to vary in broad ranges. In many cases, these large differences are caused by only a single or a few evolved stars. Beerman et al. 2012 studied the effects of bright post-main-sequence (PMS) stars on the accuracy of star cluster parameters derived using the integrated photometry method. They showed that these evolved stars severely impact cluster measurements and the accuracy of derived ages and masses; parameters can be estimated more precisely when bright resolved PMS members are excluded from aperture photometry and only the unresolved light component is used. Furthermore, de