Ramanujan, Landau and Casimir, divergent series : a physicist point of view

Gilles Montambaux · 2025

Read Ramanujan, Landau and Casimir, divergent series : a physicist point of view by Gilles Montambaux (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-08664.txt.

Introduction

Add up all the positive whole numbers and, by a famous formal trick, the answer comes out as minus one twelfth. Gilles Montambaux, writing alone in 2025, explains from a physicist's viewpoint why that absurd Ramanujan sum is more than a parlor game.

Two real effects carry the same mathematics. In Landau diamagnetism, the response of electrons in a metal involves a divergent sum that must be tamed the same way. In the Casimir effect, vacuum forces between plates hinge on the same regularization. Montambaux walks through both cases and shows a systematic way to pull the finite Ramanujan term out of the infinity. The essay ties a notorious piece of notation to measurable physics.

Catalog record

CREATORGilles Montambaux
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-08664

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Ramanujan, Landau and Casimir, divergent series : a physicist point of view Gilles Montambaux Abstract It is a popular paradoxical exercise to show that the infinite sum of positive integer numbers is equal to − 1 / 12 -1/12 , sometimes called the Ramanujan sum. Here we propose a qualitative approach, much like that of a physicist, to show how the value − 1 / 12 -1/12 can make sense and, in fact, appears in certain physical quantities where this type of summation is involved. At the light of two physical examples, taken respectively from condensed matter –the Landau diamagnetism– and quantum electrodynamics –the Casimir effect– that illustrate this strange sum, we present a systematic way to extract this Ramanujan term from the infinity. 1 Introduction Consider the sum of natural numbers: s(n)=1+2+3+4+5+\cdots+n (1) For the first n numbers, this sum has been calculated by young Gauss who found that s(n)={n(n+1)\over 2} (2) which of course goes to infinity when n\rightarrow\infty . But certain ways to calculate this infinite sum lead to the result written in a fancy form : s(\infty)=1+2+3+4+5+\cdots\longrightarrow-{1\over 12} (3) How can the infinite sum of positive numbers be finite and negative?! One can get this strange result by a subtle manipulation of infinite sums, as proposed by Ramanujan (see a brief reminder in Appendix A ). The problem is that this manipulation is poorly defined: if one subtracts two infinite sums, what meaning does their difference have? This difficulty was highlighted by Ramanujan in his letter to Hardy [ 1 ] , and much earlier, this type of result had been obtained by Euler. In the following, we give the result of Eq.( 3 ) and other infinite sums, the name of Ramanujan sum and will label them with the letter \mathcal{R} . By appropriate regularisations, mathematicians have shown ways to give a correct signification to this strange result. A regularisation is precisely a way to define the infinity, and extract a finite number from this infinity. In some sense, this sum is equal to ”infinity -1/12”. Furthermore, it is related to the Riemann \zeta function: \zeta(x)=\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}{1\over n^{x}} (4) which is well-defined for x>1 but diverges otherwise. Riemann extended its definition to negative (and complex) arguments using a method called analytic continuation, yielding the result \zeta(-1)=-1/12 . In this paper, we develop a tutorial presentation to understand the nature of this -1/12 , by taking two examples of physical quantities where this kind of infinite sum appears. One is the Landau diamagnetism of free electrons. The other is the energy of vacuum associated with the Casimir effect. Landau diamagnetism, the orbital reponse of a free electron gas to a magnetic field, is accompagnied by quantum oscillations when the field varies. The usual treatment of these oscillations provides an interesting clue to qualitatively understand the separation between the ”‘infinity”’ and the -1/12 contribution. This is developed in the next section. In a magnetic field, due to the quantization of the electronic spectrum into discrete Landau levels, the variation of the total energy with the Fermi energy exhibits a step-like behavior. By analysis of this behavior and using the Poisson summation formula, one separates the energy into three parts: a zero-field energy, an oscillating term known as de Haas-van Alphen oscillations, and a non-oscillating term proportional to 1/12 . This last term, the Landau diamagnetism, is a manifestation of a Ramanujan sum revealed by the magnetic field and it shows how an infinite sum is involved in a physical phenomenon. Then we follow the same type of systematic analysis for various infinite series to extract their Ramanujan sum . Using the same recipe for various infinite series, we separate the infinity in two parts, a power law which tells us how the sum scales to infinity and a correction to this infinite sum identified with the Ramanujan sum. This is done in sections 3 - 6 . The Casimir pressure is an attractive force between two metallic plates resulting from vacuum fluctuations of the electromagnetic field. In section 7 , we discuss the Casimir effect in which this kind of sum appears, first in a tutorial one-dimensional example, then in three dimensions. In conclusion, we argue that the ”infinite” sum appears to be a vacuum energy (the energy of the filled Fermi sea in the case of electrons), and the Ramanujan sum appears in the response to an external parameter, the magnetic field in the case of diamagnetism, the variation of thickness between the plates in the Casimir effect. We stress the pedagogical analogy between the two calculations. 2 Landau diamagnetism Figure 1: Density of states of 2D free electrons. Blue: zero field. In a magnetic field, the quantum states condense into Landau levels, of energy (n+1/2)\hbar\omega_{c} and degeneracy eB/h . We consider the total energy of a two-dimensional ( 2D ) electron gas. Due to Fermi principle, the electron states are populated up to an energy called the Fermi energy {\epsilon}_{F} which depends on the electron density. Figure ( 1 ) recalls how the electronic states are populated. For each energy there is a finite and constant density of states given by (we do not consider spin degeneracy): \nu({\epsilon})={m_{e}\over 2\pi\hbar^{2}}\ . (5) The total energy is therefore E({\epsilon}_{F})=\int_{0}^{{\epsilon}_{F}}\nu({\epsilon})\,{\epsilon}\,d{\epsilon}={m_{e}\over 4\pi\hbar^{2}}{\epsilon}_{F}^{2}\ . (6) In a magnetic field, Landau showed that the energy can take only a discrete set of values. Quantum states coalesce into the so-called Landau levels with energy (Fig. 1 ): {\epsilon}_{n}=(n+{1\over 2})\hbar\omega_{c} (7) where \omega_{c}={eB/m_{e}} is the cyclotron frequency. The total density of quantum states being conserved, each Landau level has a degeneracy {eB/h} per unit area. The total energy now reads as a discrete sum : E({\epsilon}_{F})={eB\over h}\left(1+3+5+7+9+\cdots\right){\hbar\omega_{c}\over 2} (8) with {\epsilon}_{n}<{\epsilon}_{F} . Therefore we have to calculate the infinite sum of odd numbers (This is a problem slightly different from the one of the sum of natural numbers that will be considered below). The sum is actually not infinite but cut by the Fermi energy {\epsilon}_{F} . We are interested in the dependence E({\epsilon}_{F}) that we write in the form: E({\epsilon}_{F})={m_{e}\omega_{c}^{2}\over 2\pi}\sum_{n\geq 0}(n+{1\over 2})\,\Theta[{\epsilon}_{F}-(n+{1\over 2})\hbar\omega_{c}] (9) where \Theta(x) is the Heaviside function. As seen on Figure ( 2 ), this sum has a step-like dependence in the Fermi energy (experimentally, the Fermi energy is rather fixed and the oscillations are seen when varying the magnetic field). This step-like behavior leads to oscillations of the magnetization known as de Haas-van Alphen oscillations [ 2 , 3 ] . Figure 2: Total energy of 2D electron gas in a magnetic field, as function of the ratio {\epsilon}_{F}/\hbar\omega_{c} . T=0K : black steps. Finite temperature k_{B}T\ll\hbar\omega_{c} , blue curve. At temperature T such that \hbar\omega_{c}\ll k_{B}T\ll{\epsilon}_{F} , one recovers the zero field quadratic increase, with a small field dependent correction, not visible at this scale (red curve). To highlight and characterize these oscillations, it is common to use the Poisson summation formula (Appendix B ) to obtain: 1 1 1 Textbooks usually rather consider the grand potential at finite temperature. The energy can be deduced with appropriate derivative of the grand potential [ 3 ] . \displaystyle E({\epsilon}_{F})={m_{e}\omega_{c}^{2}\over 2\pi}\left({1\over 2}\left({{\epsilon}_{F}\over\hbar\omega_{c}}\right)^{2}\right. (10) \displaystyle+\left.\sum_{m\geq 1}(-1)^{m}{\cos 2\pi mx+2\pi mx\sin 2\pi mx{\color[rgb]{1,0,0}-1}\over 2(\pi m)^{2}}\right) where x={\epsilon}_{F}/\hbar\omega_{c} . Examination of this formula

Read the complete text