The Roles of Low-Noise Stations, Arrays and Ocean-Bottom Seismometers in Monitoring UK Offshore Seismicity associated with Subsurface Storage of Carbon Dioxide

Dominik Strutz, Andrew Curtis · 2025

Read The Roles of Low-Noise Stations, Arrays and Ocean-Bottom Seismometers in Monitoring UK Offshore Seismicity associated with Subsurface Storage of Carbon Dioxide by Dominik Strutz, Andrew Curtis (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-08560.txt.

Introduction

Dominik Strutz and Andrew Curtis weigh ways to monitor quakes near offshore carbon storage sites, in this 2025 paper. Buried carbon dioxide can trigger small tremors, and the UK land network sits far from North Sea sites. A design method scored each upgrade by the facts it would add.

A quiet mine station and a land array mainly lowered the size of quakes that can be spotted, with little gain in pinning down their spots. An extra land site added almost nothing. Sea-floor sensors, placed close to the action, sharply improved location accuracy. Two or three suit one site; three to five cover the wider licence area. Shaky wave-speed models capped precision throughout.

Catalog record

CREATORDominik Strutz, Andrew Curtis
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-08560

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Roles of Low-Noise Stations, Arrays and Ocean-Bottom Seismometers in Monitoring UK Offshore Seismicity associated with Subsurface Storage of Carbon Dioxide Dominik Strutz, Andrew Curtis Abstract \leadauthor Strutz and Curtis Preprint submitted to International Journal of Greenhouse Gas Control \maketitleabstract {summary} Abstract Effective seismic monitoring of subsurface carbon dioxide storage (SCS) sites is essential for managing risks posed by induced seismicity. This is particularly challenging in offshore environments, such as the Endurance license area in the North Sea, where the UK’s permanent land-based seismometer network offers limited monitoring capability due to its distance from the expected locations of seismic events. A Bayesian experimental design framework is used to assess enhancements of the network with a low-noise onshore station located at around 1 km depth in Boulby mine, the onshore North York Moors Seismic Array, an optimally-located additional on-shore monitoring site, and ocean bottom seismometers (OBS). We quantify the expected information gain about seismic source locations and introduce a practical method to incorporate signal-to-noise dependent detectability and velocity model uncertainty. We show that the Boulby station or an onshore array primarily lower the detection threshold for small-magnitude events (M=0-2), but offer limited improvement in location accuracy. An optimally-located additional land-based seismometer or local array provides little additional benefit. OBS deployments yield significant improvements in location accuracy due to their proximity to potential seismicity. Optimised networks of two to three OBS stations are effective for Endurance, while three to five OBS stations offer robust monitoring across North Sea carbon storage licence areas off England’s east coast. Velocity model uncertainty remains a key limiting factor for location precision across all configurations. We conclude that deploying OBS networks is the most promising strategy for enhancing microseismic monitoring capabilities at offshore SCS sites, though potentially more expensive. 1 Introduction One of the key strategies in achieving zero net emissions of carbon dioxide to the atmosphere is the deployment of carbon capture and storage technologies. These involve capturing and injecting CO_{2} into subsurface carbon dioxide storage (SCS) reservoirs. Such reservoirs are usually below about 800m depth in order for the CO_{2} to be in super-critical fluid state which makes direct monitoring of the migration of injected CO_{2} difficult. However, stress changes associated with CO_{2} migration tend to induce seismicity, so seismic events locations can be used to provide information about where CO_{2} has migrated post-injection. Figure 1: Geographic setup. The map shows the location of the Endurance and Hornsea 4 licence areas in the North Sea, as well as the location of the Boulby mine. The seismic stations used in this study are shown as rectangles, where the colour indicates the noise levels of the stations. See text for details about noise levels. Effective monitoring of seismicity in such sites before, during, and after CO_{2} injection is therefore essential for evaluating risk and ensuring safe operations. While induced seismicity is a concern in brittle crustal rocks that contain critically stressed faults ( Cerasi et al. 2018 ; Oye et al. 2022 ; Vilarrasa et al. 2019 ) , weak and poorly cemented sandstones in sedimentary basins are generally expected to deform slowly under tectonic forces, reducing the likelihood of faulting or fault reactivation ( Chadwick et al. 2004 ) . Nevertheless, the potential for induced seismicity remains, and monitoring is necessary to ensure the safety of the operation, especially in areas where SCS sites are near offshore wind farms or other infrastructure. An example of such an area is the Endurance licence area in the North Sea, where the injection of CO_{2} is planned near the Hornsea 4 offshore wind farm (see Figure 1 ). The UK’s current seismometer network ( British Geological Survey 1970 ) is limited to a one-sided configuration with sensors only on the British mainland, resulting in a suboptimal configuration for monitoring offshore seismicity. This study investigates how adding low-noise seismic stations (e.g., in Boulby mine), seismic arrays (e.g., North York Moors Seismic Array), an optimally-located additional on-shore seismometer, and offshore seabed stations can enhance the monitoring of seismicity in the North Sea. We use a Bayesian experimental design framework to determine the expected information gain (EIG) of different seismic network configurations. In our study, the EIG measures the expected reduction in uncertainty in the location of seismic events for any given seismic network configuration. We use the EIG to compare different configurations and provide examples of optimised networks with additional on-shore and OBS stations. We use a Bayesian design framework that accounts for the full uncertainty and non-linearity of the physics used to locate seismic sources. We show that the above land based interventions reduce the lowest detectable earthquake magnitudes across Endurance, without significantly improving the expected accuracy of event locations. The addition of three OBS stations in optimised locations would provide more information than any of the land based interventions tested, and would significantly improve confidence in the event locations. Five optimised OBS sensors may be sufficient to monitor Endurance and all of the neighbouring off-shore license areas. 2 Methods We use Bayesian experimental design with a specific focus on seismic event monitoring. Experimental design is conducted before an experiment is carried out, and hence before data from the experiment are available. We therefore begin by introducing the prior information on event location and magnitude, and the data likelihood, which together describe the state of knowledge before we have collected any data. Thereafter we introduce the Bayesian experimental design framework which is used to determine the effectiveness of any particular design. 2.1 Event Prior Information In this study we are interested in the source location of seismic events \bm{m} , which are the parameters of interest. Together with background seismic noise levels, the event location and magnitude {M} governs the detectability of events. However, in this study we do not focus on estimating magnitudes since they are typically inferred directly from local moment magnitude relations ( Green et al. 2020 ; Luckett et al. 2019 ) . We therefore regard {M} as a nuisance parameter. In other words, while both \bm{m} and {M} affect the observed data \bm{d} , we test and design optimal surveys to infer the source location \bm{m} only. Figure 2: Prior distribution in event Easting and Northing (in local coordinates). Darker blue areas indicate higher probability density. The prior distribution is a mixture of five Gaussian distributions with a standard deviation of 10 km horizontally and 0.5 km vertically. The means of each Gaussian are located at the injection wells at a depth of 1020 m. The Endurance and Hornsea 4 licence areas are shown for reference (see Figure 1 ). Prior information about the location of seismic events is typically based on the geological setting of the site and, in the case of SCS sites, seismicity is most likely to occur close to CO_{2} injection point(s). We therefore model the prior probability distribution over event locations as a mixture of five Gaussian distributions, where the centre of each Gaussian is at the location of the injection wells, at a depth of ca. 1000 m which is the depth of the reservoir seal of the Endurance aquifer ( Sutherland et al. 2022 ; Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy 2023 ; BP Exploration Operating Company

Read the complete text