BESS Participation Planning for Provision of Grid Services in Energy and Regulation Markets
Zeenat Hameed, Chresten Træholt · 2025
Read BESS Participation Planning for Provision of Grid Services in Energy and Regulation Markets by Zeenat Hameed, Chresten Træholt (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-08472.txt.
Introduction
Zeenat Hameed and Chresten Træholt plan battery market play in a 2025 paper. Grid batteries can sell energy and also regulation services that steady frequency. Each market has its own bids, prices, penalties, and wear costs. Owners need to know which mix pays best under price swings.
Their stochastic model works through market price scenarios across seasons. Representative days capture price patterns for each season type. The output is the share of hours to target each service. It also estimates costs and revenues for service combinations. Bid acceptance rules and degradation costs sit inside the model. Unlike control focused studies, this one prices the business case itself. The framework adapts to other regions and market sets.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zeenat Hameed, Chresten Træholt |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 24 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-08472
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
BESS Participation Planning for Provision of Grid Services in Energy and Regulation Markets Zeenat Hameed, Chresten Træholt Abstract This paper presents a stochastic optimization model for planning the participation of battery energy storage systems (BESSs) in energy and regulation markets. The proposed model quantifies and compares the business value of single and multi-market BESS services by accounting for their bid submission and acceptance procedures, pricing mechanisms and revenue streams, and penalty payments and degradation costs. By modelling the price uncertainties using market price scenarios (MPSs) and considering representative days for different price seasonalities, the model outputs the percentage of hours each market service can be targeted to maximize profits. This helps in quantifying the impact of operational and market requirements of different services on choice of markets for BESSs. It also helps in determining the approximate costs and revenues that may be accrued by the BESS owners by choosing combinations of available services under different price conditions. The model thus overcomes the key limitations of previous studies that were mainly conducted from a controller design viewpoint and were thus more focused on the operational control of BESSs. The proposed model is generalizable and extendable to BESS service provision in multiple markets of different regions. I Introduction Environmental concerns and climate‐change awareness have accelerated integration of renewable energy sources (RES) into power systems [ 1 ] . However, RES intermittency and low synchronous inertia undermine grid stability and reliability. Battery energy storage systems (BESSs) alleviate these issues—especially in regulation markets—by providing fast response and flexible control for frequency support and ancillary services [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] . Traditionally, system operators sourced regulation from fossil plants at administered rates [ 7 ] , but BESSs cannot hold capacity indefinitely due to limited state‐of‐charge [ 8 ] . Although capital costs are declining, BESS payback periods remain long, making optimal service scheduling essential for profitability [ 9 ] . Most existing work optimizes BESS operation from a controller‐design perspective, treating BESSs as standalone multi‐service units. For example, [ 10 ] proposes a control strategy for simultaneous energy arbitrage and ancillary services; [ 11 ] minimizes a commercial consumer’s bill by combining peak shaving with frequency regulation; [ 12 ] integrates day‐ahead dispatch with frequency and voltage regulation; and [ 13 ] replaces droop control with output‐regulation theory for voltage/frequency support. Although these approaches improve operational algorithms and correct forecast errors, they generally omit market‐specific parameters—bid submission and acceptance rules, pricing mechanisms, penalties for non‐delivery, and diverse revenue streams—which are critical to assessing BESS value from a business perspective [ 14 , 15 ] . Furthermore, most literature focuses on U.S. markets with locational marginal pricing and pay‐for‐performance schemes. European markets, by contrast, employ zonal pricing and pay for availability rather than performance [ 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 ] . To address this gap, we develop a stochastic optimization model that incorporates bid procedures, pricing rules, penalty structures, and degradation costs to quantify the business value of BESS participation across multiple electricity markets. II Nordic Market Mechanisms The Nordic market consists of a day‐ahead spot market, an intra‐day market (both administered by Nord Pool Spot), a regulation market, and a balancing market (operated by national TSOs: Svenska Kraftnät, Statnett, Fingrid, Energinet). Denmark uses zonal pricing, in line with other European regions [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . Spot and Intra‐day Participants submit hourly bids 24 h ahead; intra‐day adjustments are allowed until one hour before delivery. Both use a pay‐as‐clear mechanism: the marginal clearing price applies per MWh. Regulation Ancillary services—FCR-N, FCR-D, aFRR, mFRR, FFR—are procured via voluntary bids 1–2 days ahead. TSOs activate bids based on system needs: • FCR-N: Symmetrical response when f\leq 49.9 Hz or f\geq 50.1 Hz. • FCR-D: Separate up/down bids for f\leq 49.5 Hz or f\geq 50.5 Hz. BESSs target FCR-N and FCR-D due to fast ramping. Bids specify MW capacity and are paid pay‐as‐bid for availability; activated energy settles at balancing prices (aFRR/mFRR). Failure to deliver incurs penalties equal to lost availability plus imbalance charges [ 4 , 5 ] . Fig. 1: Nordic markets Balancing Deviations from spot/intra‐day schedules are settled via single‐ or double‐price mechanisms. If a regulation bid is accepted but not fulfilled, imbalance prices apply, potentially exceeding initial revenues [ 6 ] . Payment Structures • Spot (S-DCH/S-CH): Pay-as-clear per MWh—discharge (S-DCH) earns the spot price; charge (S-CH) pays it. • FCR-N/FCR-D: Pay-as-bid availability per MW; if activated, net discharge settles at up-regulation price, net charge at down-regulation price. Bids are in one-hour blocks; penalties cover lost availability and imbalance charges. This summary informs our model’s bid logic, revenue, and penalty formulations. III Method III-A Droop Control In the Nordic system, the day‐ahead spot market handles energy trades for the next 24 h, while real‐time balance relies on regulation and balancing markets. TSOs activate FCR‐N and FCR‐D bids (submitted 1–2 days ahead) for frequency support; balancing penalizes deviations from declared schedules. Although frequency varies millisecond‐wise, we sample per minute. BESS participation in FCR‐N, FCR‐D, and day‐ahead spot is modeled via per‐minute energy requirements E_{stm}^{\mathrm{dch}} (upward) and E_{stm}^{\mathrm{ch}} (downward) for each scenario s\in S , period t\in T , and market m\in M . These are derived from droop control points (P_{m1},P_{\max}),\,(P_{m2},0),\,(P_{m3},0),\,(P_{m4},-P_{\max}) : (P_{m1},P_{\max}),\;(P_{m2},0),\;(P_{m3},0),\;(P_{m4},-P_{\max}). For m=N (FCR‐N): P_{m1}=49.9 , P_{m2}=P_{m3}=50.0 , P_{m4}=50.1 . For m=D (FCR‐D): P_{m1}=49.5 , P_{m2}=49.9 , P_{m3}=50.1 , P_{m4}=50.5 . Applying linear interpolation, E_{stm}^{\mathrm{dch}}\;=\;\frac{1}{60}\,\begin{cases}0,&f_{st}^{m}<P_{m1},\\ P_{\max}-\dfrac{P_{\max}}{P_{m2}-P_{m1}}\,(f_{st}^{m}-P_{m1}),&P_{m1}\leq f_{st}^{m}\leq P_{m2},\\ 0,&\text{otherwise},\end{cases} (1) E_{stm}^{\mathrm{ch}}\;=\;\frac{1}{60}\,\begin{cases}0,&f_{st}^{m}<P_{m3},\\ \dfrac{P_{\max}}{P_{m4}-P_{m3}}\,\bigl(f_{st}^{m}-P_{m3}\bigr),&P_{m3}\leq f_{st}^{m}\leq P_{m4},\\ 0,&f_{st}^{m}>P_{m4}.\end{cases} (2) Since only FCR‐D upward is considered, E_{stm}^{\mathrm{ch}}=0 for m=D . For spot markets, with fixed bid energy E_{\text{spot}} : \displaystyle\text{S‐DCH (sell):}\quad E_{stm}^{\mathrm{dch}}=\frac{E_{\text{spot}}}{60},\quad E_{stm}^{\mathrm{ch}}=0, (3) \displaystyle\text{S‐CH (buy):}\quad E_{stm}^{\mathrm{ch}}=\frac{E_{\text{spot}}}{60},\quad E_{stm}^{\mathrm{dch}}=0. (4) These E_{stm}^{\mathrm{dch}} and E_{stm}^{\mathrm{ch}} values feed into the optimizer. Fig. 2: Binary decisions III-B Binary Decisions At each hour h\in H , for each market m\in M and scenario s\in S , the optimizer makes three binary decisions (Fig. 2 ): 1. \,x_{hm}^{\mathrm{bid}}\in\{0,1\} : whether to submit a bid. This depends on the BESS state‐of‐charge z_{st}^{\mathrm{SOC}} and market requirements E_{stm}^{\mathrm{dch}} , E_{stm}^{\mathrm{ch}} . 2. \,x_{shm}^{\mathrm{bid,acc}}\in\{0,1\} : whether the bid is accepted. If x_{hm}^{\mathrm{bid}}=1 , acceptance requires the bid price x_{h}^{\mathrm{price}} to meet the scenario‐specific threshold P_{shm}^{\max} . 3. \,w_{sh}^{\mathrm{ok}}\in\{0,1\} : whether the BESS fulfills its energy promise. If x_{shm}^{\mathrm{bid,acc}}=1 , this depends on matching per‐minute dispatch z_{stm}^{\mathrm{dch}} , z_{stm}^{\mathrm{ch}} to the market’s E_{stm}^{\mathrm{dch}} , E_{stm}^{\mathrm{ch}} ; failure incurs a penalty. III-C Regulation Market Payments Since availability payments of FCR-N and FCR-D markets ( m\in M_{\text{freq}} ) operate on pay-as-bid mechanism and are applied per MW, x_{h}^{\text{price}} is multiplied by the bid power ( P_{\max} ). To simplify, we assume the BESS always bids with P_{\max}=0.9 MW. Moreover, they also depend on binary decision variable x_{shm}^{\text{bid,acc}} as discussed in the previous section. Therefore, the payment for scenario s , hour h is given by: P_{\max}\,x_{h}^{\text{price}}\sum_{m\in M_{\text{freq}}}x_{shm}^{\text{bid,acc}}. (5) Since this expression is not linear, we use the Big- M method to linearize it. We introduce w_{sh}^{\text{avail}}\geq 0 and let: \displaystyle w_{sh}^{\text{avail}} \displaystyle=P_{\max}\,x_{h}^{\text{price}}\sum_{m\in M_{\text{freq}}}x_{shm}^{\text{bid,acc}}, (6) \displaystyle w_{sh}^{\text{avail}} \displaystyle\leq P_{\max}\,x_{h}^{\text{price}}, (7) \displaystyle w_{sh}^{\text{avail}} \displaystyle\leq M\sum_{m\in M_{\text{freq}}}x_{shm}^{\text{bid,acc}}, (8) \displaystyle w_{sh}^{\text{avail}} \displaystyle\geq P_{\max}\,x_{h}^{\text{price}}-M\left(1-\sum_{m\in M_{\text{freq}}}x_{shm}^{\text{bid,acc}}\right). (9) III-D Spot Market Payments Since spot market transactions of S-DCH and S-CH operate on pay-as-clear