Rethinking Citation of AI Sources in Student-AI Collaboration within HCI Design Education Conference: EduCHI 2025: 7th Annual Symposium on HCI Education; July 30-August 01, 2025; Bloomington, IN, USA EduCHI 2025: 7th Annual Symposium on HCI Education (EduCHI ’25), July 30-August 01, 2025, Bloomingto
Prakash Shukla, Suchismita Naik, Ike Obi, Jessica Backus, Nancy Rasche, Paul Parsons · 2025
Read Rethinking Citation of AI Sources in Student-AI Collaboration within HCI Design Education Conference: EduCHI 2025: 7th Annual Symposium on HCI Education; July 30-August 01, 2025; Bloomington, IN, USA EduCHI 2025: 7th Annual Symposium on HCI Education (EduCHI ’25), July 30-August 01, 2025, Bloomingto by Prakash Shukla, Suchismita Naik, Ike Obi, Jessica Backus, Nancy Rasche, Paul Parsons (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-08467.txt.
Introduction
Prakash Shukla and co-authors ask how students should cite AI help in design coursework. Standard citation rules rest on stable sources, clear authors, and the chance to look a source up again. AI output fits none of those well, since it changes each time and has no single author.
The team studied thirty-five team projects and reflections from 175 undergraduates in a user experience design course who could use AI tools freely. Citation habits ranged from careful credit to vague hints or none at all. The authors argue citation should become a reflective habit that makes students weigh how AI shaped their work. They suggest tools such as AI contribution statements and process-aware citation forms for design classes.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Prakash Shukla, Suchismita Naik, Ike Obi, Jessica Backus, Nancy Rasche, Paul Parsons |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 41 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-08467
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Rethinking Citation of AI Sources in Student-AI Collaboration within HCI Design Education Conference: EduCHI 2025: 7th Annual Symposium on HCI Education; July 30-August 01, 2025; Bloomington, IN, USA EduCHI 2025: 7th Annual Symposium on HCI Education (EduCHI ’25), July 30-August 01, 2025, Bloomington, IN, USA DOI: 10.1145/3742901.3742909 ISBN: 979-8-4007-1463-4/25/07 CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI CCS: Human-centered computing HCI theory, concepts and models Prakash Shukla, Suchismita Naik, Ike Obi, Jessica Backus, Nancy Rasche, Paul Parsons Abstract . The growing integration of AI tools in student design projects presents an unresolved challenge in HCI education: how should AI-generated content be cited and documented? Traditional citation frameworks—grounded in credibility, retrievability, and authorship—struggle to accommodate the dynamic and ephemeral nature of AI outputs. In this paper, we examine how undergraduate students in a UX design course approached AI usage and citation when given the freedom to integrate generative tools into their design process. Through qualitative analysis of 35 team projects and reflections from 175 students, we identify varied citation practices ranging from formal attribution to indirect or absent acknowledgment. These inconsistencies reveal gaps in existing frameworks and raise questions about authorship, assessment, and pedagogical transparency. We argue for rethinking AI citation as a reflective and pedagogical practice; one that supports metacognitive engagement by prompting students to critically evaluate how and why they used AI throughout the design process. We propose alternative strategies—such as AI contribution statements and process-aware citation models that better align with the iterative and reflective nature of design education. This work invites educators to reconsider how citation practices can support meaningful student–AI collaboration. 1. Introduction Artificial intelligence (AI) tools have increasingly become embedded within the design processes of students, transforming traditional methods of ideation, prototyping, and evaluation ( Lively et al. 2023 ; Chellappa and Luximon 2024 ; Papachristos et al. 2024 ) . As these tools become commonplace in educational settings, understanding how students articulate their use—and the rationale behind incorporating AI—is crucial for both pedagogical and ethical reasons. Proper citation and clear descriptions of AI tool integration in documentation not only support transparency but also enhance the reflective practices of design students regarding their design decisions ( Chen et al. 2021 ) . Central to design education is the practice of clearly articulating and justifying design decisions through structured argumentation. Design argumentation involves communicating the rationale behind design choices, explicitly connecting theoretical, empirical, and material grounds to support design claims ( Dalsgaard et al. 2013 ) . Providing design argumentation helps students to critically examine and communicate their design processes ( Dalsgaard et al. 2013 ) , and effective design argumentation enables students to convincingly “sell” their work, making their decision-making process transparent to stakeholders such as instructors and peers ( Gray 2018 ) . The ability to clearly articulate design rationale holds significant pedagogical value. Instructors rely on design argumentation to assess not only final solutions, but also students’ underlying thought processes and methods. Engaging students in design argumentation cultivates a shared vocabulary and sensitivity to design values ( Dalsgaard et al. 2013 ) . Feedback and critique, central to studio-based pedagogy, explicitly foreground design rationale and create discursive spaces where students’ decisions can be challenged and refined, providing important learning opportunities ( Dannels 2005 ) . Clear articulation of AI tool usage within design arguments thus allows instructors valuable insights into the design thinking processes of the students, the quality of their engagement with design methods, and the overall rigor of their approach. As AI becomes part of the design toolkit of students, design argumentation must now include AI-generated contributions alongside the design judgment of the students. In this context, argumentation and citation become deeply intertwined: citing AI use is not just about attribution—it helps make the reasoning behind design decisions visible. When students engage AI across stages like problem framing, ideation, wireframing, and evaluation, citing those interactions becomes essential to surface the collaborative nature of the process. Without such documentation, key aspects of student reasoning may be obscured, complicating assessment and limiting reflective learning. This tension calls for a closer look at whether existing citation frameworks adequately capture the evolving dynamics of student–AI collaboration and support educators in tracing design cognition in AI-mediated workflows. Traditional citation frameworks were developed for stable, authored, and retrievable sources, allowing educators to trace the intellectual influences of the design process of the students and assess their design cognition ( Lanning 2016 ) . However, as students increasingly integrate generative AI tools into their workflows, these frameworks fall short, introducing risks to both pedagogical clarity and assessment validity. The dynamic, non-retrievable, and context-dependent nature of AI-generated content—such as outputs from ChatGPT, Claude, or Midjourney—raises critical questions: How should students document their collaboration with AI? What counts as meaningful attribution? And how can educators distinguish between student-generated insight and machine-assisted output? Through a case study of 35 HCI student teams (175 students) in a UX design course, we examine how students currently cite—or fail to cite—AI in their design projects. This paper offers a series of provocations around the limitations of existing citation norms and the need to reimagine AI attribution as a pedagogical tool that supports transparency, reflection, and integrity in design education. These provocations include: • How might we re-imagine citation practices to better reflect the evolving reality of student–AI collaboration in design education? • Should AI citation be treated as a reflective, pedagogical instrument or merely an academic obligation? • How can educators balance the need for transparency with the potential stigma students may face when disclosing AI usage? • What new models, such as AI contribution statements or phase-based documentation, might more accurately represent the role of AI in the design process? 2. Background 2.1. Tension and Dilemma of Citing AI Sources Traditional citation practices are built on three foundational principles: credibility, retrievability, and accountability ( Lanning 2016 ) . These practices were designed to ensure that human-generated content can be easily attributed to the author, utilizing stable sources that allow for tracing the provenance of the given article or content as it evolves or improves over time. However, the current era of AI-generated content challenges these established norms, as content generated by AI systems is often dynamic and contextual, typically lacking stable reference points ( Alea Albada and Woods 2024 ) . Even when the reference points are stable, there is no guarantee that all content will be exactly replicated or retrieved, even when using identical prompts ( Cotton et al. 2024 ) . This tension about the suitability of old citation practices in the current era of AI raises important questions about how students should acknowledge the role of AI in their design-focused projects where process documentation is pedagogically significant. In response to the growing use of AI in student formation, style guides like APA and MLA have begun to offer provisional recommendations for citing AI-generated content ( McAdoo 2023 ; Istrate 2023 ) . These guidelines typically suggest treating AI as a type of software, focusing on citing the model name, version, and date of access. However, this approach, while pragmatic, falls short of fully capturing the nuanced role AI plays within the design process and timeline. Similarly, universities are developing institutional policies