VALUING DIFFUSE GLOBAL PUBLIC GOODS FROM SATELLITE CONSTELLATIONS: EVIDENCE FROM GPS AND AIRLINE DELAYS
Lev Ricanati · 2025
Read VALUING DIFFUSE GLOBAL PUBLIC GOODS FROM SATELLITE CONSTELLATIONS: EVIDENCE FROM GPS AND AIRLINE DELAYS by Lev Ricanati (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-08209.txt.
Introduction
Lev Ricanati presents an economics paper, published in 2025, putting a dollar value on a quiet upgrade to the GPS system. In May 2000 the United States switched off Selective Availability, a deliberate scrambling that had limited civilian GPS accuracy. The paper asks what that accuracy jump was worth, using airline delays as the measuring stick.
Comparing flight records from the years just before and after the change, Ricanati estimates the time saved per flight from better navigation. Multiplying by passenger numbers and the value of their time gives welfare gains in the hundreds of millions of dollars for a single year. The paper closes by weighing what current threats to satellite public goods could cost.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Lev Ricanati |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 77 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-08209
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
VALUING DIFFUSE GLOBAL PUBLIC GOODS FROM SATELLITE CONSTELLATIONS: EVIDENCE FROM GPS AND AIRLINE DELAYS Lev Ricanati Abstract This paper studies the welfare impact of discrete improvements to global public goods in the context of the Global Positioning System (GPS). Specifically, I find that by disabling Selective Availability in May, 2000, and thus significantly increasing the accuracy of GPS, the United States generated at least $268 million (2000 dollars) of additional welfare gains. To quantify this welfare impact, I apply a difference-in-differences model to the Bureau of Transportation Statistics’s Airline On-Time Performance Data in the years 1999 and 2000. I use this model to estimate the time saved per flight attributable to the improved GPS and multiply these time savings by the number of passengers in the ensuing year and their values of time. I conclude by estimating the economic loss from current threats to the provision of satellite-based global public goods. † † footnotetext: The author is grateful to Nicholas Buchholz and Brian Weeden for their assistance in crafting this paper. 1 Introduction Due to the immense welfare benefits generated by global public goods (GPGs), small improvements in their efficiency can lead to large increases in global welfare. Classic examples of GPGs include global standard regulatory practices, weather monitoring satellites, and the preservation of diverse ecosystems. The welfare benefits of GPGs are often quite diffuse meaning that benefits are large in aggregate rather than per individual. One important GPG with diffuse benefits is the Global Positioning System (GPS). GPS is a network of 31 satellites owned and operated by the United States (US) that provides anyone around the globe with their location free of charge ( 23 ) . In this paper, I investigate the impact of discrete improvements to satellite based GPGs, specifically by analyzing an accuracy improvement to GPS in May 2000. I find that the improvement led to a welfare gain of $268 million (2000 dollars) in the year following implementation. 1 1 1 Equivalent to just over $504 million in 2025 dollars ( 18 ) . This amount is more than twice what the US congress appropriated for the system in 2000 ( 24 ) . Importantly, the welfare gains I calculate are only a small part of the total gains from this improvement. The increased accuracy of GPS improved the commercial viability of existing GPS-reliant industries and spawned entirely new ones such as smartphone navigation and precision agriculture ( O’Connor et al. 2019a ) . The total welfare generated by this improvement, both from its impact on existing industries and its enabling of new ones, was likely in the billions of dollars each year. This analysis illustrates how GPGs turn efficiency improvements into massive welfare gains. This is particularly important to understand amidst the recent rise in the use of GPS jamming and spoofing technologies in conflict zones, which has disrupted commercial flights and erased the benefits wrought from GPS. When it was initially designed and built, the widely available civil GPS signal was intentionally degraded in a policy known as Selective Availability (SA) which excluded non-military users from accessing precise GPS. While Selective Availability was in place, the civil GPS signal was only accurate to 300 feet, equivalent to the difference of trying to land on a runway and ending up one or two runway widths away ( 22 ) . At midnight on May 2nd, 2000, President Clinton disabled Selective Availability, instantly making the civil signal 10 times more accurate ( 17 ) . This decision transformed GPS overnight into a usable global public good without any cost incurred by the government or consumers. I focus my analysis of the economic effects of this decision on US airline delays. Using a government dataset of all domestic flights and their delays, I run a difference-in-differences regression to isolate the effect of SA on flight delays. Due to the lack of a natural control, I split the data and designate flights in 1999 as the control group and flights in 2000 as the treatment group. I conduct a series of regressions segmented by flight distance and amount of time post-treatment. The results of my analysis show that the removal of SA led to a general reduction in airline delays of 0.617 minutes per flight with savings of up to 3 minutes on longer flights in the first few months. I hypothesize that the mechanism for the reduced delays was pilots’ ability to adhere to flight plans more accurately throughout their flights. To estimate the welfare gains, I multiply the time saved per flight by the number of domestic US passengers per month and the Department of Transportation’s estimates for how much passengers value the time they spend traveling by air. This method results in a value of $268 million in welfare savings from all US passengers in the year following May 2nd, 2000. Global satellite constellations, like post-SA GPS, are true global public goods. They provide non-rival and non-excludable benefits to anyone with a receiver, which are relatively cheap to acquire. Welfare benefits from these constellations are accrued around the globe and are therefore difficult to quantify. This becomes a problem for governments deciding whether or not to invest in these systems. Lacking an easy cost-benefit analysis makes it more difficult to argue for the provision or improvement of satellite based GPGs. This can slow down the implementation of welfare-enhancing upgrades. This paper demonstrates that the removal of SA was indeed welfare-enhancing, hopefully motivating future investments into protecting and improving GPS services. I start by discussing relevant literature and then provide a brief history of GPS and SA. I proceed to talk about the origins of the data, including summary statistics and graphs. I then discuss the methodology I use as well as the assumptions I make, followed by the regression results. The results include a preliminary quantification of the welfare losses from 2 current threats to GPS provision, jamming and spoofing. Finally, I present policy recommendations for ensuring continuous GPS as well as directions for future research. 1.1 Literature Review A lot has been written about the economic impact of GPS, both on existing markets and through the creation of novel ones. Two oft cited reports, one in 2011 and the other in 2019, attempt to quantify the economic benefits of GPS ( O’Connor et al. 2019a ; Pham 2011a ) . The 2011 report places the economic benefit at $67.6 billion per year in the US. The author recognizes the growing nature of GPS enabled industries and predicts that this economic benefit could reach $122.4 billion per year ( Pham 2011a , p. 1) . The later report, in 2019, concludes that GPS added $1.4 trillion in economic benefits since it was opened to public use in 1983 with about 90% of those benefits accumulating in the 2010s ( O’Connor et al. 2019a , p. ES-3) . These reports also attempt to quantify what the cost of a disruption to GPS would be. Pham 2011a calculates the economic loss from a GPS disruption to be equal to the current benefit of GPS plus the monetary value invested into GPS technology, such as receivers ( Pham 2011a , p. 12) . One problem with