Resonant neutrino self-interactions: insights from the full shape galaxy power spectrum

Hernán E. Noriega, Josue De-Santiago, Gabriela Garcia-Arroyo, Jorge Venzor, Abdel Pérez-Lorenzana · 2025

Read Resonant neutrino self-interactions: insights from the full shape galaxy power spectrum by Hernán E. Noriega, Josue De-Santiago, Gabriela Garcia-Arroyo, Jorge Venzor, Abdel Pérez-Lorenzana (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-07994.txt.

Introduction

Hernán Noriega and co-authors hunt for neutrinos that talk to each other, using the map of galaxies, in a 2025 paper. In a resonant self-interaction model, neutrinos scatter through a new mediator particle, which would smooth the cosmic web in a telltale way. The authors model that effect with the effective field theory of large-scale structure, reaching into mildly nonlinear scales for the first time.

They combine the full shape of a major galaxy survey's power spectrum with two anchors: the chemistry of the early universe, and the microwave background map. The survey plus the microwave data give the tightest limits yet on the interaction's strength across mediator masses. Even the chemistry anchor alone can corner one mediator mass. The verdict is sobering for the idea's fans: such interactions look unlikely to dissolve the current tensions in cosmology.

Catalog record

CREATORHernán E. Noriega, Josue De-Santiago, Gabriela Garcia-Arroyo, Jorge Venzor, Abdel Pérez-Lorenzana
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-07994

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Resonant neutrino self-interactions: insights from the full shape galaxy power spectrum Preprint: APS/123-QED Hernán E. Noriega, Josue De-Santiago, Gabriela Garcia-Arroyo, Jorge Venzor, Abdel Pérez-Lorenzana Abstract This paper investigates resonant neutrino self-interactions in cosmology by employing, for the first time, the effective field theory of large-scale structure to model their impact on the matter distribution up to mildly nonlinear scales. We explore a broad range of mediator masses in two main analyses: one combining BOSS Full Shape (FS) galaxy clustering with Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN), and another combining FS with Planck Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) data. Our results place the strongest cosmological constraints to date on the resonant self interactions when using FS+Planck data, reaching up to g ν < 10.8 × 10 − 14 g_{\nu}<10.8\times 10^{-14} at 95% confidence for the 1 eV mediator. Notably, FS+BBN can constrain the interaction for the 10 eV mediator independently of CMB data, yielding g ν < 7.33 × 10 − 12 g_{\nu}<7.33\times 10^{-12} at 95% confidence. Our results suggest that resonant neutrino self-interactions are unlikely to resolve existing cosmological tensions within the standard Λ \Lambda CDM framework. I Introduction The ability of cosmology to act as a trustworthy neutrino probe has been under scrutiny over the last decades. Thus far, it has worked well as an indirect indicator of neutrino physics, because the early Universe can test regions of the parameter space unreachable to neutrino experiments, from high-density environments at Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) to very low energies \mathcal{O} (keV-meV) at the cosmic microwave background (CMB) and large-scale structure formation Planck:2018vyg ; adame2024desiBAO ; adame2024desiFS . Many of those phenomena occur over large periods, which makes the Universe behave as a long-exposure experiment; this ultimately leaves unique traces on cosmological observables, which works to constrain low-energy neutrino properties including their total mass Archidiacono_2020 ; GARIAZZO2023 ; Green:2024xbb ; loverde2024massive ; Noriega:2024lzo ; Craig2024 ; Elbers:2024sha ; Wang:2024hen ; bertolez2024origin and self-interactions. In recent years, cosmology has been able to test neutrino models with greater accuracy thanks to its ever-increasing data, new observables, and theoretical advances. These improvements have also helped break the degeneracy between neutrinos and other cosmological parameters. Modern studies can test neutrino physics beyond the standard model and, in particular, neutrino nonstandard interactions (NSI) with mediators with masses below \sim\mathcal{O} (MeV). In these scenarios, there could be changes to the neutrino background Beacom2004 ; Hannestad2005 ; Chacko2020 ; Escudero2020relaxing ; Esteban2021 ; Barenboim_2021 ; Abellan2022 ; Chen2022 ; Sandner2023 ; Venzor2021 ; Huang2018 , or its perturbations Bell2006 ; Archidiacono2014 ; CyrRacine2014 ; Oldengott_2015 ; Oldengott_2017 ; Lancaster2017 ; Kreisch2020 ; Kreisch:2022zxp ; Park2019 ; Choudhury2021 ; Blinov2019 ; brinckmann2020self ; mazumdar2022flavour ; Huang2021 ; Das:2023npl ; RoyChoudhury2022 ; Taule2022 ; Pal2024yom ; Forastieri2015 ; Forastieri2019 ; Venzor2022 ; Venzor:2023aka ; calabrese2025atacama ; in particular, because the interaction reduces the neutrino free flow. Non free-streaming neutrinos have a scale-dependent impact that imposes a rich phenomenology to structure formation, which highly depends on the parameters related to the NSI. Studies have obtained strong upper bounds on the interaction couplings because the reduced free-streaming requires an extra radiation component to compensate for this effect (see for instance, Venzor2022 ). However, a long-standing anomaly has emerged for the heavy mediator scenario, where the data prefer a nonnull interaction, this includes CMB temperature fluctuations and the full-shape (FS) galactic power spectrum (except for Planck polarization data) Kreisch2020 ; Kreisch:2022zxp ; cerdeno2023constraints ; he2023self ; Camarena:2024daj ; Poudou:2025qcx ; He:2025jwp . Furthermore, the significance of the anomaly is high and can be tested with terrestrial neutrino experiments, even extending the model to include flavor physics Heurtier2017 ; Brune2019 ; Das2021 ; Schoneberg2019 ; Brdar2020 ; Esteban2021_probing ; Cerdeno2021 ; Deppisch2020 ; Bustamante2020 ; Akita2022 ; Dutta:2023fdt ; Medhi:2021wxj ; Ge:2021lur ; Escrihuela:2021mud ; Escudero2020_CMB_search ; Lyu2021 ; Seto2021 ; Fiorillo2022 ; Dutta2023 ; Denton:2024upc ; bhupal2024new ; Medhi:2023ebi ; Zhang:2024meg ; Berryman2018 ; DeRomeri:2024iaw ; BLUM2018 ; foroughi2025enabling ; Shalgar2021 ; Suliga2021 ; chang2022towards ; Wang:2025qap . In Ref. Venzor:2023aka , we first introduced the study of neutrino self-interactions in the resonant regime—where the interaction rate peaks at redshifts around \sim 4\times 10^{3}(m_{\phi}/{\rm eV}) —for linear cosmological perturbation data, where we tested mediator masses in the range m_{\phi}=10^{-2} - 10^{2} eV. We used data from the Planck collaboration along with expansion history measurements, including baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO) data from the baryon acoustic oscillation spectroscopic survey (BOSS) and local measurements of H_{0} . In that article, we found that resonant neutrino self-interactions (RNSI) moderately reduce the H_{0} tension, and it mildly prefers a nonnull interaction, when using the Planck+BAO+ H_{0} dataset, if the mediator mass ranges between 0.5 eV and 10 eV. Complementary constraints on neutrino resonant self-interactions arise from astrophysical observations, in particular from supernova neutrino signals, where interactions affect the duration of the neutrino burst, and from the diffuse supernova neutrino background (DSNB), which has been proposed as a probe for detecting such resonances Creque2021 ; chang2022towards ; cerdeno2023constraints ; Wang:2025qap . However, these resonances occur at energies much higher than the cosmological ones. The neutrino self-interactions modify the shape of the matter power spectrum due to its scale-dependent effects. This allows for CMB-independent constraints on the interaction coupling, as previously done in Camarena2023 to constrain heavy mediators by combining FS with BBN data. Other studies have explored the constraints on heavy mediators he2023self ; Camarena:2024daj ; He:2025jwp ; Poudou:2025qcx , and model-independent NSI Pal2024yom , by combining FS with CMB data. In this work, for the first time, we investigate the less-explored RNSI region, considering CMB-independent constraints and those obtained from FS combined with CMB data. To this end, we explore a wide range of mediator masses, covering a broad and phenomenologically rich region of parameter space. Finally, we compare our results with previous constraints from BAO and CMB data. The article is organized as follows. In Sec. II we present and review the equations of the RNSIs and analyze the impact of neutrino self-interactions on the matter power spectrum at both linear and mildly nonlinear scales. Next, in Sec. III we present the datasets and outline the methodology. Lastly, we discuss our results and give our concluding remarks in Secs. IV and V , respectively. II Cosmological perturbations To track the dynamics of self-interacting neutrinos, it is necessary to solve the Boltzmann hierarchy with collision terms. In the resonant region, the temporal evolution rate of the interaction \Gamma depends on the mass of the (scalar) particle, m_{\phi} , that mediates the interaction, as calculated in Venzor:2023aka following the formalism of Refs. GONDOLO1991 ; Vassh2015 . Here, it is important to recall that other inelastic processes are being ignored and only the neutrino self-interactions are considered. In the conformal Newtonian gauge Ma1995 , the linear-order hierarchy for the massive neutrino perturbations \Psi is Hannestad2000 ; Archidiacono2014 ; Forastieri2015 ; Venzor:2023aka : \displaystyle\dot{\Psi}_{0} \displaystyle= \displaystyle-\frac{qk}{\epsilon}\Psi_{1}-\dot{\psi}\frac{d\ln f_{0}}{d\ln q}\,, (1) \displaystyle\dot{\Psi}_{1} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{qk}{3\epsilon}(\Psi_{0}-2\Psi_{2})-\frac{\epsilon k}{3q}\psi\frac{d\ln f_{0}}{d\ln q}\,, (2) \displaystyle\dot{\Psi}_{l\geq 2} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\frac{qk}{(2l+1)\epsilon}\left[l\Psi_{l-1}-(l+1)\Psi_{l+1}\right]-a\Gamma\Psi_{l}, (3) where the dots denote conformal time derivatives, \phi and \psi are the metric scalar potentials, f_{0} is the unperturbed Fermi-Dirac distribution, \epsilon=\sqrt{q^{2}+a^{2}m_{\nu}^{2}} is the comoving energy, and q is the magnitude of the comoving momentum. The self-interaction conserves both energy and momentum but affects

Read the complete text