Entropic Dynamics approach to Relational Quantum Mechanics

Ariel Caticha, Hassaan Saleem · 2025

Read Entropic Dynamics approach to Relational Quantum Mechanics by Ariel Caticha, Hassaan Saleem (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-07921.txt.

Introduction

Ariel Caticha and Hassaan Saleem present a 2025 physics paper on relational quantum mechanics. In this view, the state of a system is not absolute but depends on relations to other systems. The authors rebuild that idea inside entropic dynamics, a framework that derives motion from probability, entropy, and information geometry.

Their models keep some fixed structure, such as a shared time slicing and flat space geometry. Within that limit, particle positions stay definite, as in classical physics. The team defines a new measure of mismatch between successive states, tuned to the geometry of quantum phase space. They show the models treat time relationally and can be made neutral under shifts and rotations in space.

Catalog record

CREATORAriel Caticha, Hassaan Saleem
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE52 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-07921

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Entropic Dynamics approach to Relational Quantum Mechanics Ariel Caticha, Hassaan Saleem Abstract The general framework of Entropic Dynamics (ED) is used to construct non-relativistic models of relational quantum mechanics from well known inference principles — probability, entropy and information geometry. Although only partially relational — the absolute structures of simultaneity and Euclidean geometry are still retained — these models provide a useful testing ground for ideas that will prove useful in the context of more realistic relativistic theories. The fact that in ED the positions of particles have definite values, just as in classical mechanics, has allowed us to adapt to the quantum case some intuitions from Barbour and Bertotti’s classical framework. Here, however, we propose a new measure of the mismatch between successive states that is adapted to the information metric and the symplectic structures of the quantum phase space. We make explicit that ED is temporally relational and we construct non-relativistic quantum models that are spatially relational with respect to rigid translations and rotations. The ED approach settles the longstanding question of what form should the constraints of a classical theory take after quantization: the quantum constraints that express relationality are to be imposed on expectation values. To highlight the potential impact of these developments, the non-relativistic quantum model is parametrized into a generally covariant form and we show that the ED approach evades the analogue of what in quantum gravity has been called the problem of time. 1 Introduction Many, perhaps all, the difficulties in the study of space and of time can be traced to their invisibility. We do not see space; we see matter in space. We do not see time; we see changes in things. Although these studies have resulted in an increased understanding of the properties of matter in space-time the problem remains that it is not always clear how to disentangle which properties should be attributed to matter and which to space. Newton managed to evade the issue and created a successful science of mechanics but only at the cost of adopting an absolute concept of motion relative to an abstract “mathematical” space and time. Leibniz objected that such absolute positions would not be observable and therefore not real. Instead, he advocated for a concept of motion defined in terms of the observable relative distances. Newton had, however, a definite dynamical theory to back him up, while Leibniz had no such support. As a result Newton won the day, and the relational argument lay largely dormant for almost two centuries until revived by Mach and specially by Einstein. In the latter decades of the 20th century, as a stepping stone towards a quantum theory of gravity, the thrust towards a fully relational dynamics was once again resumed in the form of Hamiltonian formulations of general relativity [ 1 ] - [ 4 ] . More recently the understanding of relational motion achieved a certain level of completion — at least within the context of classical physics — with the explicitly Machian line of research that originates with J. Barbour and B. Bertotti [ 5 ] - [ 7 ] . Barbour and Bertotti’s basic insight [ 5 ] was that a formulation in terms of the relative interparticle distances is not practical. Instead one should focus attention on the fact that two configurations that differ by arbitrary rigid ( i.e. , global) displacements and/or rigid rotations describe exactly the same physical situation. Thus, in formulating a relational dynamics, whatever measure one adopts to quantify the change from one configuration to the next, the actual intrinsic change should remain unaffected by independent rigid shifts and rotations of each configuration. This is achieved through a technique Barbour and Bertotti called “best matching” (BM). The idea is to introduce a quantitative measure of the “mismatch” between two successive configurations and then shift and rotate one configuration relative to the other to find the location that minimizes the mismatch. Thus, motion is not defined as relative to an absolute space, but relative to the earlier state of the system itself. Barbour and Bertotti’s intrinsic change and best matching have added an interesting twist: what is relational is not the notion of space but the notion of change. In ED too what is relational is the notion of change — the dynamics. With Quantum Mechanics (QM), however, new problems arise. In its standard Copenhagen interpretation QM is manifestly non-relational. It lives in Newton’s absolute space and time, or at best, in Minkowski’s absolute space-time, and its particles do not have definite positions much less definite relative distances. But then the interpretations of QM have always been a source of controversy and many have been proposed. One approach inspired by Barbour and Bertotti is due to Gryb [ 8 ] . Another relevant example, Rovelli’s relational interpretation, is tailored to formulating a background-independent quantum theory of gravity [ 9 ] [ 10 ] . We shall follow a different path. Our goal here is to formulate a non-relativistic relational QM within the framework of Entropic Dynamics (ED) [ 11 ] [ 12 ] . The ED program strives not merely to provide an interpretation to QM but in addition it seeks to derive or reconstruct its mathematical formalism using well established tools and principles of inference — probabilities, entropies, and information geometry. (For a pedagogical review see [ 13 ] .) With regard to interpretation, one appealing feature is that ED achieves a clear separation between the epistemic and the ontic elements. This allows ED to solve the measurement problem while evading the no-go theorems that afflict other realist \psi -epistemic interpretations [ 14 ] . ED is a conservative theory in that it grants a definite ontic status to things such as the positions of particles – they have definite values at all times – and grants a definite epistemic status to probabilities and wave functions without invoking exotic quantum probabilities. In contrast, ED is radically non-classical in that there is no ontic dynamics; ED is a purely epistemic dynamics of probabilities. As a method of quantization ED is singled out in that it does not rely on the prior formulation of a classical dynamics to which one must append some ad hoc quantization rules; therefore there are no operator ordering ambiguities, because there are no operators. In the present context, one does not first formulate a classical Machian dynamics à la Barbour-Bertotti with a corresponding classical criterion for best matching. Instead one directly formulates a quantum theory with its corresponding quantum BM criterion based on the natural geometrical tools available to ED, namely, information and symplectic geometry which lead, eventually, to the Hilbert space inner product. Some of Barbour and Bertotti’s ideas can be readily adapted and imported into the ED framework. In an earlier work towards a relational ED [ 15 ] some of the conceptual issues were successfully settled: in a dynamics of probabilities it should come as no surprise that the configurations to be compared involve probability distributions. A second crucial question is the particular choice of mismatch measure. In the classical context the measure adopted by Barbour and Bertotti was borrowed from Jacobi’s classical action principle and amounts to a variation on

Read the complete text