A Proposal to Extend the Common Model of Cognition with Metacognition

John Laird, Christian Lebiere, Paul Rosenbloom, Andrea Stocco · 2025

Read A Proposal to Extend the Common Model of Cognition with Metacognition by John Laird, Christian Lebiere, Paul Rosenbloom, Andrea Stocco (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-07807.txt.

Introduction

John Laird and three co-authors propose adding self-awareness to a standard model of mind in a 2025 paper. The Common Model of Cognition sketches the machinery any human-like mind needs, and it guides several long-running cognitive architectures. Metacognition, thinking about one's own thinking, sits awkwardly outside it.

Their proposal treats metacognition as ordinary reasoning over explicit descriptions of the agent's own abilities and processes, held in working memory like any other facts. That move needs only small extensions to what working memory holds, reusing the model's existing machinery rather than bolting on a separate module. Worked examples show the idea in action. A unified account matters because architectures built on the model would then gain self-monitoring the same way. The paper is a position piece for the cognitive architecture community.

Catalog record

CREATORJohn Laird, Christian Lebiere, Paul Rosenbloom, Andrea Stocco
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE23 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-07807

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Proposal to Extend the Common Model of Cognition with Metacognition John Laird, Christian Lebiere, Paul Rosenbloom, Andrea Stocco Abstract The Common Model of Cognition (CMC) provides an abstract characterization of the structure and processing required by a cognitive architecture for human-like minds. We propose a unified approach to integrating metacognition within the CMC. We propose that metacognition involves reasoning over explicit representations of an agent’s cognitive capabilities and processes in working memory. Our proposal exploits the existing cognitive capabilities of the CMC, making minimal extensions in the structure and information available within working memory. We provide examples of metacognition within our proposal. 1 Introduction The Common Model of Cognition (CMC) [ 9 ] was developed as an abstract consensus model of human-like minds , derived from the computational structures and representations of cognitive architectures [ 6 ] , and informed by our knowledge of the human mind and brain. The CMC specifies the fixed architectural structures for encoding, maintaining, using, and acquiring knowledge to produce behavior , emphasizing routine cognition. Here, we propose extending the CMC to include metacognition [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 7 , 12 , 17 ] . Broadly speaking, metacognition encompasses reasoning about any aspect of cognition, including reasoning, memory, perception [ 13 ] , motor skills, and learning. It can include partial or even incorrect theories of cognition, such as reasoning about perceived ESP capabilities. We focus on metacognition related to an agent’s own cognition. We also discuss metareasoning : reasoning about reasoning as a restricted form of metacognition. Examples of metacognition include: introspective monitoring, deliberate decision making, deliberate learning [ 10 ] , predictive and hypothetical reasoning, retrospective reasoning, strategy selection, and self-explanation. Figure 1 shows two approaches to metacognition in cognitive architectures. In the hierarchical approach, also referred to as the Nelson and Narens model [ 11 ] , specialized modules are added “on top” of cognition to implement metacognition, as exemplified by MIDCA [ 2 ] and Clarion [ 16 ] . Those modules monitor cognition, reason about it, and modify its processing. They access the current state of cognitive processing, the histories of processing, and representations of the agent’s procedural knowledge that drives cognition, with reasoning and metareasoning operating in parallel without intermixing. Figure 1: Alternative Metacognitive Architectures. In the CMC and cognitive architectures more generally, a capability is realized through architectural structures and knowledge. Therefore, we propose a unified approach, on the right side of Figure 1 , where cognition and metacognition differ only in what is the subject of reasoning. We propose minimal architectural extensions to make information about an agent’s cognition available in working memory. Versions of these extensions are found in existing CMC architectures, including ACT-R [ 1 ] , Sigma [ 14 ] , and Soar [ 8 ] . We also describe the sources of other non-architectural sources of information about cognition needed to support metacognition as a component of overall cognition. As with the original goals for the CMC, our goal is for our proposal of metacognition to apply to both humans and A(G)I systems with similar general capabilities. Our proposal does not permit information in long-term memories to be examined or reasoned over by other modules. Instead, it restricts reasoning and metareasoning to information available in working memory. It avoids new modules by incorporating the long-term knowledge used in metareasoning within its existing long-term memories. Restricting access to long-term memories sacrifices omniscient metareasoning but enables efficient processing and memory functionalities consistent with neural memory models. Furthermore, all existing cognitive reasoning and learning capabilities are available for metacognition, including interaction with the external environment. Below, we review the Common Model of Cognition and present our proposal for extending it to include human-like metacognition. Our proposal focuses on adding new representational distinctions and sources of information about cognition that become available to an agent to initiate, reason, and terminate metacognition. We attempt to identify the minimum architectural information required to support general metacognition, as well as non-architectural sources of information about cognition that are available to an agent. We include three examples of metacognition within this framework. 2 Common Model of Cognition Figure 2: The Common Model of Cognition. The CMC unifies many similar cognitive architectures by identifying common components, processing, connectivity, and constraints. It does not specify mechanisms or implementations, but emphasizes functionality, focusing on routine cognition and learning. Cognition is the collective processing of the component modules (working memory, procedural memory, declarative memory) and their associated processes (action selection, retrieval, learning). Figure 2 shows the structure and data flow among the modules, which include short-term working memory, long-term procedural memory, long-term declarative memory, learning, perception, and motor control. Long-term memories have associated automatic learning mechanisms that incrementally modify and extend their contents. The CMC posits procedural compilation, reinforcement learning, and declarative learning. Memories contain relations over symbols annotated with quantitative metadata . Examples include the recency of creation or access, probability, and derived utility. Metadata influences processing within a module, such as retrieval and learning. Data flow begins with perception and proceeds to working memory, representing an agent’s understanding of its current situation and goals. Procedural memory contains knowledge about selecting and executing actions that modify working memory. On each cognitive cycle, procedural memory, testing the contents of working memory, selects a single action, which makes one or more changes to working memory, resulting in a step in the cognitive cycle. Each of the other modules has a buffer in working memory through which procedural memory can initiate memory retrievals, motor actions, or top-down control of perception. Results from those module processes are added to their respective buffers. Thus, behavior unfolds as a sequence of steps, driven by procedural memory, making changes to working memory. We call such step-by-step behavior reasoning where the contents of working memory are what the reasoning is about and the knowledge in procedural and declarative memory determines the course of the reasoning. The original CMC encompasses routine and skilled performance, where working memory includes only information about the agent’s current goals and task state. 3 Phases of Metacognition Processing In our proposal, metacognition employs the same cognitive cycle process, utilizing the same modules, and often the same knowledge. Metacognition is distinguished by the fact that the information about the agent’s own processing is included in its reasoning: information about prior problem solving (“I see where I made a mistake on that problem and need to do something different in the future.”), specific skills (“I’m good at jigsaw puzzles.”), general competences (“I struggle with math.”), and the operation of individual modules (“I have trouble remembering the difference between affect and effect .”). Our proposal does not introduce new modules but relies on existing architectural structures and knowledge, which are extended to make new forms and representations of information available in working memory. The process of metacognition is not purely metacognition, but a combination of new and existing capabilities. In this section, we describe the three phases of metacognition: initiation, reasoning, and termination. We identify the types of knowledge needed in these phases. Then we describe our proposed extensions to meet those requirements, as well as sources of knowledge available for metareasoning. The following section steps through

Read the complete text