Experimental Test of the Principle of Tomographic Locality

Tristan S. Lismer, Kaleb B. Felefele, Robert W. Spekkens, Kevin J. Resch · 2025

Read Experimental Test of the Principle of Tomographic Locality by Tristan S. Lismer, Kaleb B. Felefele, Robert W. Spekkens, Kevin J. Resch (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-07775.txt.

Introduction

Tristan Lismer, Kaleb Felefele, Robert Spekkens, and Kevin Resch report an experimental test of tomographic locality. The principle says a multipartite system's state can be fully determined by measurements on its individual parts. Quantum theory satisfies it, and reconstructions of quantum theory use it to rule out alternatives such as real-number quantum theory.

The team ran a prepare-and-measure experiment on the polarization of paired photonic modes, analyzing data within generalized probabilistic theories. In the full quantum setting they found no violation. As a control, restricting to the real-number fragment produced a clear failure signature, validating the method. The result supports a key structural assumption of quantum theory.

Catalog record

CREATORTristan S. Lismer, Kaleb B. Felefele, Robert W. Spekkens, Kevin J. Resch
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE61 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-07775

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Experimental Test of the Principle of Tomographic Locality Tristan S. Lismer, Kaleb B. Felefele, Robert W. Spekkens, Kevin J. Resch Abstract The principle of tomographic locality states that the operational state of a multipartite system can be fully characterized by the statistics obtained from measurements that are local to the individual subsystems. This property holds in quantum theory and features prominently in axiomatic reconstructions of the theory, where it serves to rule out a wide class of alternatives. For instance, quantum theory with Hilbert spaces defined over the real field (rather than the complex field) is an example of a theory that is ruled out in this fashion. Given its foundational importance, it is worthwhile to subject this principle to a direct experimental test. Specifically, we consider an experiment on the polarization degrees of freedom of a pair of photonic modes in a prepare-and-measure scenario and analyze the resulting data within the framework of generalized probabilistic theories. The signature of a failure of tomographic locality is that there are pairs of states on the bipartite system that can only be distinguished by the statistics they yield for non-separable measurements. In the full quantum setting, we find no evidence of a violation of tomographic locality. As a test of our analysis method, we also verify that if we restrict attention to those states and measurements that lie within the fragment described by quantum theory over the real field, then a clear signature of the failure of tomographic locality is observed. I Introduction In the formalism of generalized probabilistic theories (GPTs) Hardy 2001 ; Barrett 2007 ; Chiribella et al. 2010 ; Müller 2021 , every preparation of a system is associated with an operational state , a vector in a real vector space that specifies the statistics for all possible measurements on that preparation procedure. If, in a given theory, the operational state of a composite system can be fully described by the statistics it predicts for measurements that are local to the subsystems, then the theory is said to obey the principle of tomographic locality . If one conceptualizes quantum theory as a GPT, the operational state is simply the density operator and the principle is found to hold. For instance, a two-qubit quantum state can be written as a sum of products of Pauli operators (where identity is included in the set), so that learning the expectation values of all 16 such products via local measurements allows one to learn the state. Tomographic locality is exploited routinely in practical schemes for implementing state tomography in quantum experiments. In the field of quantum foundations, there has been a great deal of interest in identifying clear sets of axioms from which the formalism of quantum theory can be derived, and tomographic locality serves as a central axiom in the most prominent attempts to do so Hardy 2013 ; Barrett 2007 ; Chiribella et al. 2010 ; Müller 2021 . The axiomatic program has also promoted the methodology of foil theories , wherein alternatives to quantum theory are studied not as empirical competitors but for the the insight they yield into what is distinctive about quantum theory. For example, we can better understand the principle of tomographic locality by studying theories that violate it Centeno et al. 2024 . The most prominent example of such a theory is real-amplitude quantum theory (wherein the Hilbert space vectors are restricted to those having real components in some basis) Stueckelberg 1960 , as noted in Refs. Araki 1980 ; Wootters 1990 ; Hardy 2001 . Other examples of such theories include quaternionic quantum theory Hardy 2001 , fermionic quantum theory D’Ariano et al. 2014a ; D’Ariano et al. 2014b , exotic variants of classical theories D’Ariano et al. 2020 ; Scandolo 2019 ; Chiribella et al. 2024 , and a post-quantum theory constructed from Euclidean Jordan algebras Barnum et al. 2020 . Despite its foundational significance, there has not previously been a direct experimental test of the principle of tomographic locality. Such a test demands a means of analyzing the experimental data that does not presume the correctness of operational quantum theory, since the assumption of tomographic locality is built into the structure of quantum mechanics itself. The framework of GPTs is such a tool. It allows one to fit experimental data in a theory-agnostic way and without a prior characterization of any of the experimental procedures, as demonstrated in Refs. Mazurek et al. 2021 ; Grabowecky et al. 2022 . The scheme described in these works, termed GPT tomography , makes minimal assumptions about the experiment. First, it must be possible to treat the different components of a circuit as independent of the others, in the sense that each can be varied while the others remain fixed. For instance, it should be possible to vary the preparation procedure independently of the measurement procedure. Second, it must be possible to treat the runs of the experiment as independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.). We make both of these assumptions in our experiment. (Although considering the possibility of these assumptions failing is a worthwhile endeavour, it is not our concern in this work.) The technique of GPT tomography makes no assumption about the dimensionality of the GPT vector space describing the states and effects of a system; an estimate of the dimensionality instead emerges from the analysis. Here we show how GPT tomography provides a means of testing the principle of tomographic locality through a quantum optics experiment on the polarization degrees of freedom of a pair of photonic modes. We also benchmark our data analysis technique by applying it to an experiment wherein we artificially restrict the preparations and measurements in such a way that we expect to see the signature of a failure of tomographic locality. Specifically, we will not only do the analysis on the full data set but also on the subset corresponding to those preparation and measurement procedures where we are targeting states and effects that are confined to the real-amplitude sector of quantum theory. This analysis is meant to simulate what would occur in our experiment if nature were governed by real-amplitude quantum theory rather than complex-amplitude quantum theory. We begin by describing a scheme for testing tomographic locality in a generic experiment. Further on, we describe the particular experiment we conducted, the details of the data analysis technique, what one expects to see if quantum theory is correct, and the results of the data analysis. II GPT tomography The GPT framework represents states on a system A by vectors embedded in a real vector space V_{A} , and effects by vectors in the dual vector space V_{A}^{*} (an effect is a specification of a measurement and an outcome). We will here assume V_{A} to be a space of column vectors and V_{A}^{*} to be a space of row vectors, with the inner product given by matrix multiplication. States and effects of a composite system are represented by vectors in the tensor product of the vector spaces associated to the subsystems. Thus, for a system composed of two parts, A and B , V=V_{A}\otimes V_{B} . Each preparation procedure on the composite system AB is associated to a vector \bm{s}\in V_{A}\otimes

Read the complete text