Vacancy-Controlled Superconductivity in Rock-Salt Carbides: Towards Predictive Modelling of Real-World Superconductors

Simone Di Cataldo, William Cursio, Lilia Boeri · 2025

Read Vacancy-Controlled Superconductivity in Rock-Salt Carbides: Towards Predictive Modelling of Real-World Superconductors by Simone Di Cataldo, William Cursio, Lilia Boeri (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-07768.txt.

Introduction

Simone Di Cataldo, William Cursio, and Lilia Boeri revisit how missing carbon atoms shape superconductivity in metal carbides, in a paper from 2025. These rock-salt carbides are often taught as textbook cases of standard superconductors. Yet past calculations often missed the trends seen in labs. The team blends first-principles math with a search tool that hunts for stable crystal forms.

Across the full row of transition metals, they test how the pure form behaves. Where that form proves unstable, carbon-poor forms from the search step fix the match with lab data. Real samples are often made far from balance and carry many defects. The combined method gives a more honest model of such materials. The authors offer it as a general frame for real-world superconductors.

Catalog record

CREATORSimone Di Cataldo, William Cursio, Lilia Boeri
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE34 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-07768

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Vacancy-Controlled Superconductivity in Rock-Salt Carbides: Towards Predictive Modelling of Real-World Superconductors Simone Di Cataldo, William Cursio, Lilia Boeri Abstract We critically reexamine the superconducting properties of rock-salt transition-metal carbides (TMCs), often regarded as textbook conventional superconductors, combining first-principles electron–phonon calculations with variable-composition evolutionary structure prediction. Studying superconducting trends across the entire transition-metal series, we find that, when the rock-salt stoichiometric phase is dynamically or thermodynamically unstable, carbon-vacant structures identified through unbiased structure prediction permit to reconcile theoretical calculations with experimental trends. Our integrated use of structure prediction and electron–phonon calculations defines a general framework for realistic modelling of superconductors shaped by non-equilibrium synthesis routes and defect tolerance. I Introduction Comp. Exp. T_{c} Dyn. \Delta H N(E F ) T {}_{c}^{McM} \lambda \omega_{log} Alt. Dyn. N(E F ) T {}_{c}^{McM} \lambda \omega_{log} (K) st. (meV/at.) (eV \cdot sp. \cdot at.) -1 (K) (K) Comp. st. (eV \cdot sp. \cdot at.) -1 (K) (K) ScC < 1.4 Nowotny and Auer-Welsbach 1961 ; Samsonov et al. 1962 Y 106 0.36 5 0.6 461 Sc 6 C 5 Y 0.37 2 0.5 417 YC < 1.4 Y 356 0.41 10 0.8 364 Y 6 C 5 Y 0.36 5 0.6 328 TiC 0–3.4 Klimashin et al. 1970 ; Toth 2014 Y 0 0.07 0 0.0 562 Ti 6 C 5 Y 0.15 0 0.2 559 ZrC < 0.3 Y 0 0.06 0 0.2 473 Zr 6 C 5 Y 0.13 0 0.3 455 HfC < 1.2 Y 0 0.07 0 0.2 427 Hf 6 C 5 Y 0.12 0 0.3 394 VC 0–3.2 Geerk et al. 1977 Y 92 0.28 17 1.0 309 V 6 C 5 Y 0.31 0 0.0 483 NbC 0–11.5 Giorgi et al. 1962 ; Willens et al. 1967 ; Toth et al. 1968 ; Yan et al. 2020 ; Shang et al. 2020 Y 28 0.19 15 1.0 299 Nb 6 C 5 Y 0.17 1 0.4 389 TaC 0–10.3 Giorgi et al. 1962 ; Toth et al. 1968 ; Shang et al. 2020 Y 0 0.16 7 0.7 259 Ta 6 C 5 Y 0.17 1 0.5 301 MoC 14.1 Clougherty et al. 1961 ; Willens and Buehler 1965 ; Sadagapan and Gatos 1966 ; Toth and Zbasnik 1968 ; Willens et al. 1967 ; Sathish et al. 2012 N 288 0.33 - - - Mo 6 C 5 Y 0.32 18 1.4 209 WC 3.5–10 Willens and Buehler 1965 ; Willens et al. 1967 N 420 0.28 - - - W 6 C 5 Y 0.16 5 0.7 239 ReC 3.4 Popova et al. 1972 N 932 0.59 - - - Re 6 C 5 N 0.3 - - - Table 1: Summary of the thermodynamic and superconducting properties of various TMCs in the stoichiometric and vacant rock-salt structure. Green (red) cells highlight thermodynamical stability (instability) of the stoichiometric rock-salt phase. In red cells the calculated T_{c} for the stoichiometric phase is also in disagreement with experiment. \Delta H , N(E_{F}) , T_{C}^{McM} , \lambda , and \omega_{log} indicate the energy relative to the convex hull, the DOS at the Fermi energy, the calculated T_{c} , the ep coupling coefficient, and the average phonon frequency, respectively. Columns 1-8 indicate the properties of the stoichiometric (1:1) phase, while columns 9-14 indicate those of carbon-vacant (6:5) phase, for which the calculated and measured T_{c} values are in agreement. When available, direct references to experimental papers are given in the table. Other values are taken from Refs. Matthias et al. 1963 ; Vonsovsky et al. 1982 ; Toth 2014 . The T_{c} ’s are computed using the McMillan formula McMillan 1968 ; Allen and Dynes 1975 with \mu^{*}=0.15 . Transition metal carbides (TMCs) are a broad class of materials formed by early transition metals and carbon, which crystallise in a rock-salt (NaCl-type) structure Williams 1971 . They serve as high-performance materials for cutting-tools, coatings, heat and chemical shields, due to their exceptional resistance. These carbides are metallic conductors ( \rho\sim 10 {}^{-5}\Omega m ) Modine et al. 1989 with high thermal conductivity Radosevich and WILLIAMS 1970 . When the transition metal (TM) belongs to groups V (V, Nb, Ta) and VI (Mo, W), TMCs also exhibit superconductivity, with critical temperatures ( T_{c} ) reaching up to 18 K in NbN-NbC-TiN alloys Toth et al. 1965 ; Toth and Zbasnik 1968 ; Pessall et al. 1968 ; Morton et al. 1971 ; Vonsovsky et al. 1982 ; Toth 2014 , and high critical fields Fink et al. 1965 . So far, TMCs have found limited use in superconducting technologies due to their brittleness. However, there is a clear potential for applications as shock- and radiation-hard superconductors in extreme environments - such as cryogenic current leads on deep-space probes, kinetic-energy dampers, or compact fusion diagnostics - where the unparalleled hardness, erosion resistance and thermal stability of TMCs could outweigh manufacturing challenges. Understanding in detail the relationships between crystal chemistry and superconducting properties is a crucial prerequisite to further optimize these materials and unlock their full technological potential. To date, experimental data remains sparse and largely outdated, with most superconducting critical temperatures ( T_{c} ) reported in the 1960s and 1970s from samples synthesized at high temperatures. The data for TMCs with a finite T_{c} is summarized in Tab. 1 , where we included, to the best of our knowledge, all experimental reports Nowotny and Auer-Welsbach 1961 ; Samsonov et al. 1962 ; Klimashin et al. 1970 ; Toth 2014 ; Geerk et al. 1977 ; Giorgi et al. 1962 ; Willens et al. 1967 ; Toth et al. 1968 ; Yan et al. 2020 ; Shang et al. 2020 ; Clougherty et al. 1961 ; Willens and Buehler 1965 ; Sadagapan and Gatos 1966 ; Toth and Zbasnik 1968 ; Willens et al. 1967 ; Sathish et al. 2012 ; Popova et al. 1972 ; Matthias et al. 1963 ; Vonsovsky et al. 1982 ; Toth 2014 . The table highlights a high variability in reported T_{c} ’s for elements in groups V and VI, which has been historically attributed to differences in carbon vacancy concentrations. Giorgi et al. 1962 ; Toth et al. 1968 ; Schwarz and Rosch 1976 ; Geerk et al. 1977 ; Pickett et al. 1986 . The microscopic understanding of superconductivity in TMCs is still superficial and fails to explain most experimental observations. In particular, although T_{c} is known to depend strongly on carbon content, existing studies on the role of vacancies are limited to the thermodynamic and mechanical stability of nonstoichiometric phases Jang et al. 2012 ; Muchiri et al. 2022 . All first-principles studies of superconductivity so far have been based on the ideal 1:1 stoichiometric rock-salt structure, implicitly assuming its validity across the entire composition range. Recent work on group-IV and group-V compounds has interpreted variations in T_{c} in terms of the effect of electron filling of the transition-metal d states on the electron–phonon interaction Shang et al. 2020 ; Noffsinger et al. 2008 ; Sun et al. 2015 , but failed to address the strong dependence of T_{c} on vacancy concentration highlighted in Table 1 . TMCs containing group-VI elements were shown to be dynamically unstable in the 1:1 rock-salt structure, highlighting even

Read the complete text