Resolving the Unresolved: Using NESSI to Search for Unresolved Companions in Low-mass Disk Wide Binaries

Zachary D. Hartman, Gerard van Belle, Sébastien Lépine, Mark E. Everett, Ilija Medan · 2025

Read Resolving the Unresolved: Using NESSI to Search for Unresolved Companions in Low-mass Disk Wide Binaries by Zachary D. Hartman, Gerard van Belle, Sébastien Lépine, Mark E. Everett, Ilija Medan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-07499.txt.

Introduction

Stars often come in groups of three or more. Nearly half of wide pairs of Sun-like stars separated by more than a thousand astronomical units are really a close pair plus a distant partner. The share of such higher groups seems to rise with the width of the pair. That pattern has shaped ideas about how the widest systems formed. The five authors ran a speckle imaging survey of nearby low-mass wide pairs to test whether the pattern holds there.

They found a higher-group share of 42.0 percent, plus or minus 10.9 percent. Counting systems where Gaia data hint at a partner raised the share to 62.0 percent, plus or minus 14.2 percent. Both figures match earlier results. But the share did not rise with separation, and the paper explores why low-mass stars might differ.

Catalog record

CREATORZachary D. Hartman, Gerard van Belle, Sébastien Lépine, Mark E. Everett, Ilija Medan
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE72 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-07499

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Resolving the Unresolved: Using NESSI to Search for Unresolved Companions in Low-mass Disk Wide Binaries Zachary D. Hartman, Gerard van Belle, Sébastien Lépine, Mark E. Everett, Ilija Medan Abstract Stellar systems consisting of three or more stars are not an uncommon occurrence in the Galaxy. Nearly 50% of solar-type wide binaries with separations > 1000 >1000 au are actually higher-order multiples with one component being a close binary. Additionally, the higher-order multiplicity fraction appears to be correlated with the physical separation of the widest component. These facts have motivated some of our current theories behind how the widest stellar systems formed, which can have separations on the order of or larger than protostellar cores. However, it is unclear if the correlation between wide binary separation and higher-order multiplicity extends to low-mass binaries. We present initial results of an ongoing speckle imaging survey of nearby low-mass wide binaries. We find an overall higher-order multiplicity fraction for our sample of 42.0 % ± 10.9 % 42.0\%\pm 10.9\% . If we include systems where Gaia indicates that a companion is likely present, this fraction increases to 62.0 % ± 14.2 % 62.0\%\pm 14.2\% . This is consistent with previous results from both higher-mass stars and a previous result for low-mass wide binaries. However, we do not detect the expected increase in higher-order multiplicity fraction with separation, as was seen with previous studies. We briefly explore why higher-order multiplicity statistics could be different in low-mass stars, and what the significance might be for models of wide binary formation. I Introduction Wide stellar binary systems with separations larger than 1000 au are some of the most important astrophysical laboratories for astronomers. These systems are typically found as common proper motion pairs through statistical methods by comparing different astrometric parameters of stars, such as their positions, proper motions, parallaxes, and radial velocities, and finding pairs in relative proximity that share common space motion ( Chanamé & Gould 2004 ; Lépine & Bongiorno 2007 ; Dhital et al. 2010 ; Lépine 2011 ; Shaya & Olling 2011 ; Tokovinin & Lépine 2012 ; Tokovinin 2014a ; Dhital et al. 2015 ; Deacon et al. 2016 ) . With the release of the Gaia data, the number of known wide binaries has dramatically increased in recent years ( Andrews et al. 2017 ; Oh et al. 2017 ; Oelkers et al. 2017 ; El-Badry & Rix 2018 ; Coronado et al. 2018 ; Jiménez-Esteban et al. 2019 ; Hartman & Lépine 2020 ; Tian et al. 2020 ; El-Badry et al. 2021 ) . For stellar astronomers in particular, these systems are useful tools for examining the properties of the component stars, notably because the components can be seen as two non-interacting “single” stars that are coeval and chemically homogeneous, like a mini star cluster ( Hawkins et al. 2020 ; Nelson et al. 2021 ; Lim et al. 2024 ) . Because of this, these systems are commonly used as calibrators for different scaling relations, such as gyrochronology relations ( Chanamé & Ramírez 2012 ; Janes 2017 ; Godoy-Rivera & Chanamé 2018 ; Silva-Beyer et al. 2023 ) and metallicity relations ( Lépine et al. 2007 ; Mann et al. 2013 ; Newton et al. 2014 ; Mann et al. 2014 ; Veyette et al. 2017 ; Andrews et al. 2019 ; Wheeler et al. 2020 ) . Furthermore, wide binaries with white dwarfs are commonly used to obtain age estimates for the white dwarfs ( Barrientos et al. 2024 ; Heintz et al. 2024 ) . Even with their relative importance to stellar astronomers, there are still open questions regarding the widest binary systems. In particular, our knowledge about the physical properties and statistics of these systems remains fragmentary, as highlighted in Offner et al. 2023 . This, in turn, has left the formation mechanism for the widest systems as an unsolved problem. Numerous scenarios have been proposed to explain how systems with separations larger than that of a protostellar cloud core can form in a star-forming environment. Some of these theories include the unfolding of triple systems ( Reipurth & Mikkola 2012 ) , the binding of stars during the cluster dissolution phase ( Kouwenhoven et al. 2010 ; Moeckel & Bate 2010 ) , the binding of adjacent protostellar cores in star forming regions ( Tokovinin 2017 ) , and turbulent fragmentation ( Bate 2014 ) . Recent work from Hwang et al. 2022 showed that the eccentricity distribution for wide binaries with separations larger than 1000 au is super-thermal, which matches predictions from both the turbulent fragmentation and the unfolding of triple systems scenarios. These two formation models also predict that the eccentricity should increase with larger separations. However, Hwang et al. 2022 found that the eccentricity distribution remained uniform up to 10^{4.5} au, which disagrees with the two scenarios. They do note that eccentricity measurements are less reliable at larger separations, and that other factors, such as gravitational interactions with the Galactic environment, may have an unknown impact on the orbits of large separation binaries. Regardless, Hwang et al. 2022 highlights that wide binary formation is likely the combination of a variety of different formation scenarios rather than just a single dominant channel. In order to further study how the widest systems form, one key property that must be determined across stellar mass is the higher-order multiplicity fraction of these systems, i.e., how many binaries are actually triples, quadruples, etc. In particular, a major difference between the turbulent fragmentation and unfolding scenarios is that the unfolding scenario predicts that the vast majority of systems will be higher-order multiples, while the turbulent fragmentation scenario does not. Therefore, measuring the frequency of higher-order multiples may give insights into how prevalent one scenario is over the other. While common belief is that wide binaries usually consist of two “single” stars, this idea has been consistently challenged over the past couple of decades. Over half of wide solar-type binaries are found to actually be higher-order multiples with this fraction increasing as a function of projected physical separation ( Raghavan et al. 2010 ; Tokovinin 2014b ; Moe et al. 2019 ; Offner et al. 2023 ) . This has also been observed for higher mass binaries ( Moe & Di Stefano 2017 ) . However, most studies have focused on higher mass systems as they are bright and make easier targets to search for close companions that are unresolved by large astrometric surveys like Gaia . Law et al. 2010 is one exception. In this study, they observed 36 M+M wide binaries and found that 45\%\begin{subarray}{c}+18\%\\ -16\%\end{subarray} are higher-order multiples, after bias-correcting their analysis. This bias-correction took into account selection bias from using the SDSS DR7 photometric catalog, the suppression of triple systems with an unresolved companion, narrow-angle incompleteness, and contrast-ratio incompleteness. They also found evidence of an increase of higher-order multiplicity as a function of projected physical separation. However, Law et al. 2010 had large uncertainties on their results and only observed wide binaries with separations less than 6500 au. Since then, there have been few studies directly examining the higher-order multiplicity of low-mass binaries. In a previous paper, we examined a sample of K+K

Read the complete text