A Generalization of a Classical Geometric Extremum Problem

Petar Kenderov, Oleg Mushkarov, Nikolai Nikolov · 2025

Read A Generalization of a Classical Geometric Extremum Problem by Petar Kenderov, Oleg Mushkarov, Nikolai Nikolov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-07252.txt.

Introduction

Petar Kenderov, Oleg Mushkarov, and Nikolai Nikolov generalize a classical geometry puzzle about chords through a point inside a rounded body. Draw any straight line through the interior point until it meets the body's surface at both ends. The shortest such cut, they show, meets the surface where the boundary is smooth, with exactly one tangent plane at each end.

Moreover, the perpendiculars at those two ends meet on the flat plane through the point at right angles to the cut. For smooth bodies the mirror claim holds for the longest cut. Versions also work when the point sits outside the body, and when the cut is only locally shortest or longest. Convex polytopes get sharper results of their own.

Catalog record

CREATORPetar Kenderov, Oleg Mushkarov, Nikolai Nikolov
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE65 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-07252

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Generalization of a Classical Geometric Extremum Problem Thanks: The third-named author was partially supported by the Bulgarian National Science Fund, Ministry of Education and Science of Bulgaria under contract KP-06-N82/6. Petar Kenderov, Oleg Mushkarov, Nikolai Nikolov Abstract . Let ∂ 𝒞 \partial\,\mathcal{C} be the boundary of a compact convex body 𝒞 \mathcal{C} in ℝ n , n ≥ 2 \mathbb{R}^{n},\,n\geq 2 , and O O be an interior point of 𝒞 \mathcal{C} . Every straight line l l containing O O cuts from 𝒞 \mathcal{C} a segment [ A ​ B ] [AB] with end-points on ∂ 𝒞 \partial\,\mathcal{C} . It is shown that if [ A ​ B ] [AB] is the shortest such segment, then ∂ 𝒞 \partial\,\mathcal{C} is smooth at the points A A and B B (i.e. at both of them there is only one supporting hyperplane for 𝒞 \mathcal{C} ) and, something more, the normals to the unique supporting hyperplanes at the points A A and B B intersect at a point belonging to the hiperplane through O O which is orthogonal to [ A ​ B ] [AB] . If 𝒞 \mathcal{C} is a smooth compact convex body in ℝ n , n ≥ 2 \mathbb{R}^{n},\,n\geq 2 , the above property holds also when [ A ​ B ] [AB] is the longest such segment. Similar results have place also when O O is outside the set 𝒞 \mathcal{C} . The “local versions” of these results (when the length | A ​ B | |AB| of the segment [ A ​ B ] [AB] is locally maximal or locally minimal) also have a place. More specific results are obtained in the particular case when 𝒞 \mathcal{C} is a convex polytope. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 51M16, 52A20, 52A40, 49K05, 49K10 1. Introduction This article’s starting point was the following well-known geometric extremum problem: Given an angle in the plane and an interior point O , find a line l through O which cuts from the angle a segment [AB] of shortest length |AB| . It is known that this line exists and is uniquely determined by the following property (*) (see Figure 1): (*) the foot E^{\prime} of the perpendicular from the angle vertex E to l belongs to [AB] and |BE^{\prime}|=|AO| Figure 1 This characterization of the optimal line l suggests a way for its construction, described in the articles of Eves [ 5 ] and Coxeter and van de Craats [ 4 ] . It is mentioned in [ 4 ] that this procedure for constructing l generalizes a construction “published in 1647 by Gregory of St. Vincent” for the particular case when the angle \angle El_{1}l_{2} is right. Given an angle \angle El_{1}l_{2} and an interior point O in it, construct first the uniquely determined hyperbola h passing through O and having as asymptotes the lines containing the arms l_{1} and l_{2} of the angle. Next construct a circle c with [EO] as diameter (see Figure 1a) and find the second intersection point E^{\prime} of c and h (the first common point being O itself). Figure 1a The line l determined by the points O and E^{\prime} (and cutting the arms of the angle at A and B , respectively) has the property (*) . Indeed, the equality |BE^{\prime}|=|OA| follows from the well-known fact (see, for instance, Coxeter [ 3 ] 8.92 on p. 134) that any hyperbola secant (in particular, the secant l=OE^{\prime} ) meets the asymptotes in such a way that |OA|=|BE^{\prime}| . Note also that the angle \angle EE^{\prime}O is right by construction. It is interesting that, for the particular case when the angle \angle El_{1}l_{2} is right, the line l with the property (*) appeared very early in connection with a completely different problem. The famous Philo (or Philon) from Byzantium who lived in the years 280 - 220 BC, used this line to provide one more solution to the problem of cube doubling which occupied the minds of the ancient philosophers for a long time (see [ 13 ] ). For this reason, the line l providing the solution to the optimization problem formulated at the beginning of this article is frequently called the “line of Philon” (or “Philo’s line”). With the advent of the infinitesimals and calculus, which are well suited for solving optimization problems, the interest in the above optimization problem increased significantly. Neuberg [ 10 ] notes that the problem is mentioned in Newton’s Opuscules, t.I, p.87 . In two papers (from the years 1795 [ 7 ] and 1811 [ 8 ] ) M. Lhuilier published the results of his studies on this problem. In a footnote to the first page of [ 8 ] the editor of the journal mentions that the same problem is considered (with different means) by M. Puissant. An elementary proof of property (*) was published in the fourth edition of J. Casey’s book [ 2 ] (p. 39, Proposition 18). In 1887 E. Neovius [ 9 ] generalized the problem by allowing the point O to be outside the angle, and has found places for the point O such that the length |AB| of the segment [AB] has one local maximum and one local minimum when the line AB rotates around the point O . From the more recent studies of this problem, we mention the articles of H. Eves [ 5 ] , of O. Bottema [ 1 ] who used polar coordinates and trigonometry to simplify some of the results of Neovius, and the article of H.S.M. Coxeter and J. van De Craats [ 4 ] mentioned above. In the sequel, we focus our attention on another characterization of the optimal line l , which is somehow less popular nowadays: The perpendicular to the line l at the point O and the perpendiculars to the arms of the angle at the points A and B , respectively (dashed lines in Figure 1b), meet at a point . Figure 1b A simple proof that this property is equivalent to the property (*) can be found in the article of Eves [ 5 ] . Without proof and as “communicated by a friendly side” Neovius mentions, at the end of his paper [ 9 ] , that this property remains valid also in the case when the point O is outside the angle and the length |AB| of the segment [AB] cut from the angle by the line l is locally maximal or locally minimal. We call this property Concurrent Perpendiculars Property (CPP for short) and prefer to work with it because it does not involve the vertex E of the angle and is valid (for trivial reasons) also when the lines l_{1} and l_{2} are parallel. Besides, this property is more amenable to generalizations, which is the main goal of this paper. It turns out that CPP is a necessary (but not sufficient!) optimality condition in some other geometric extremal problems. For instance, let \mathcal{C} be any compact convex set in the plane \mathbb{R}^{2} with a fixed interior point O . Consider all segments [AB] cut from \mathcal{C} by a line l(\varphi) rotating around O with rotation angle \varphi . The length |AB| of the

Read the complete text