Elastic turbulence in highly entangled polymers and wormlike micelles

Theo A. Lewy, Suzanne M. Fielding, Peter D. Olmsted, Rich R. Kerswell · 2025

Read Elastic turbulence in highly entangled polymers and wormlike micelles by Theo A. Lewy, Suzanne M. Fielding, Peter D. Olmsted, Rich R. Kerswell (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-07146.txt.

Introduction

Theo Lewy and co-authors show, in theory, that thick polymer fluids can fall into a wild, turbulent state with no speed push from inertia. Their 2025 paper starts with a flat shear flow of a dense polymer fluid. Two widely used models of such fluids both mark that flow as unstable to flat ripples. Full simulations then follow where the ripples lead.

The flow breaks into narrow bands of fast and slow shear that merge, split, and jostle. This state, called elastic turbulence, arose even in fluids whose basic curve is smooth and steady in one-dimensional checks. The authors say it may explain chaotic states seen in worm-like soap fluids in the lab.

Catalog record

CREATORTheo A. Lewy, Suzanne M. Fielding, Peter D. Olmsted, Rich R. Kerswell
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE31 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-07146

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Elastic turbulence in highly entangled polymers and wormlike micelles Theo A. Lewy, Suzanne M. Fielding, Peter D. Olmsted, Rich R. Kerswell Abstract We show theoretically that an initially homogeneous planar Couette flow of a concentrated polymeric fluid is linearly unstable to the growth of two-dimensional (2D) perturbations, within two widely used constitutive models: the Johnson-Segalman model and the Rolie-Poly model. We perform direct nonlinear simulations of both models in 2D to show that this instability leads to a state of elastic turbulence comprising several narrow shear bands that dynamically coalesce, split and interact. Importantly, we show that this 2D instability arises not only in fluids that have a non-monotonic constitutive curve, and therefore show shear banding in 1D calculations, but also in shear thinning fluids with a monotonic constitutive curve, for which an initially homogeneous base state is stable in 1D. For the former category, the high shear branch of the constitutive curve is unstable to 2D instability in both models, so that the high shear band may be turbulent. In the Rolie-Poly model, the low shear branch is also likewise unstable. Our work provides the first simulation evidence for elastic turbulence in highly entangled polymeric fluids. It also potentially explains rheo-chaotic states seen experimentally in shear banding wormlike micelles. We additionally demonstrate elastic turbulence within both models in the planar Poiseuille geometry. Polymeric fluids show strongly nonlinear flow phenomena that significantly impact industrial processes such as the extrusion and moulding of molten plastics Larson 1992 . At a microscopic level, chainlike polymer molecules show sluggish viscoelastic relaxation dynamics and are easily disturbed by an imposed flow. Beyond a critical value of the Weissenberg number, defined as the ratio of flow rate to viscoelastic relaxation rate, this leads to nonlinear and unstable flow phenomena at the macroscopic level, even at negligible Reynolds number. Dilute polymer solutions have long been known to suffer linear instabilities driven by hoop stresses in flow geometries with curved streamlines Larson et al. 1990a ; Olagunju 1995 ; Pakdel and McKinley 1996 , with a pathway to elastic turbulence (ET) at high Weissenberg number Schiamberg et al. 2006 ; Groisman and Steinberg 2000 . ET has also been observed in dilute solutions in rectilinear geometries: experimentally in channels Pan et al. 2013 ; Qin and Arratia 2017 ; Shnapp and Steinberg 2022 and pipes Bonn et al. 2011 , and numerically in Kolmogorov flow Berti et al. 2008 ; Berti and Boffetta 2010 ; Lewy and Kerswell 2025 , channels Foggi Rota et al. 2024 ; Lellep et al. 2024 and plane Couette flow Beneitez et al. 2023 ; Beneitez et al. 2024 . The instabilities that underlie ET in dilute solutions are predicted to arise either linearly via a hoop stress Larson et al. 1990a , centre-mode Garg et al. 2018 ; Chaudhary et al. 2021 ; Khalid et al. 2021a ; Khalid et al. 2021b or polymer diffusive Beneitez et al. 2023 ; Lewy and Kerswell 2024 ; Couchman et al. 2024 mechanism, or via finite-amplitude perturbations Morozov 2022 ; Buza et al. 2022 . Whereas in dilute solutions the chainlike molecules behave independently, in concentrated solutions and melts they can be highly entangled with each other. Surprisingly, ET in these systems remains significantly under-explored to date. The central contribution of this Letter is to demonstrate ET for the first time in direct numerical simulations of concentrated shear thinning polymeric fluids. We study two widely used constitutive models in two rectilinear geometries, which lack hoop stresses in any initially laminar base state: planar Poiseuille flow ( pPf ), in which the base state has significant stress gradients, and planar Couette flow ( pCf ), in which the base state has uniform stress. We also identify a route to ET via the linear instability of an initially rectilinear base state. In pPf , this is consistent with existing predictions that normal stress gradients can cause instability in shear thinning fluids Wilson and Rallison 1999 ; Wilson and Loridan 2015 ; Barlow et al. 2019 ; Grillet et al. 2002 , as seen experimentally Picaut et al. 2017 ; Bodiguel et al. 2015 ; Poole 2016 . Early work also predicted linear instability of the shear thinning Phan-Thien-Tanner model in pCf Grillet et al. 2002 , but without making any link with ET. Indeed, our finding of ET in concentrated polymeric fluids in a flow geometry that lacks either hoop stresses or stress gradients is particularly unexpected. In concentrated polymers Cao and Likhtman 2012 ; Mohagheghi and Khomami 2015 and wormlike micellar surfactants Spenley et al. 1993 , an initially homogeneous shear flow is often unstable to the formation of coexisting bands of differing shear rate, with layer normals in the flow-gradient direction. This instability is driven by a region of negative slope in the underlying constitutive relation between shear stress and shear rate, such that the constitutive curve as a whole is non-monotonic Yerushalmi et al. 1970 . In addition to our work demonstrating ET in fluids with a monotonic constitutive curve, a significant additional contribution of this Letter is to uncover ET in shear banding fluids with a non-monotonic constitutive curve, again by means of both linear stability analysis and nonlinear simulations. Indeed, experiments on shear banded flows commonly reveal ET Fardin et al. 2010 ; Fardin et al. 2012a ; Fardin et al. 2012b , with the high shear band often turbid Berret et al. 1997 ; Lerouge et al. 2000 ; Bécu et al. 2007 ; Cappelaere et al. 1997 ; Lerouge et al. 1998 ; Rassolov et al. 2022 and chaotic Bandyopadhyay et al. 2000 ; Ganapathy and Sood 2006 . Historically, however, shear banded states have often been interpreted via one-dimensional (1D) calculations predicting a flat interface between stationary homogeneous bands Cates and Fielding 2006 ; Olmsted 2008 ; Olmsted et al. 2000 . Early attempts to capture complex spatiotemporal dynamics suggested possible ‘rheo-chaos’ of the high shear band Fielding and Olmsted 2004 , concentration coupling Fielding and Olmsted 2003 , or an undulatory instability of the banding interface Fielding 2005 ; Fielding and Wilson 2010 ; Wilson and Fielding 2006 . Importantly, our work suggests that many experiments should instead be interpreted in terms of the coexistence of an elastically turbulent high shear band with a laminar low shear band. Models — We consider incompressible flow that satisfies \nabla\cdot\mathbf{u}=0 , and the inertialess force balance equation: \begin{gathered}0=\mu\nabla^{2}\mathbf{u}+\nabla\cdot\mathbf{\Sigma}-\nabla p-G\mathbf{\hat{x}},\end{gathered} (1) with velocity \mathbf{u} , solvent viscosity \mu , polymer stress \mathbf{\Sigma} and pressure p . The imposed pressure gradient G\neq 0 in pPf and G=0 in pCf . For the polymer stress, we consider two widely used constitutive models of entangled polymeric fluids: the phenomenological Johnson-Segalman (JS) model Johnson and Segalman 1977 and the microscopically motivated Rolie-Poly (RP) model Likhtman and Graham 2003 . Both capture shear thinning and, in some parameter regimes, shear banding and can be written in the same compact way: \begin{gathered}\overset{\diamond}{\mathbf{\Sigma}}=2G_{\rm p}\mathbf{D}-\frac{2}{\tau_{\rm R}}(1-A)(\mathbf{I}+\mathbf{\Sigma}+\beta A\mathbf{\Sigma})-\frac{\mathbf{\Sigma}}{\tau_{\rm d}}+\mathcal{D}\nabla^{2}\mathbf{\Sigma},\end{gathered} (2) with the Gordon-Schowalter time derivative Gordon and Schowalter 1972 \begin{gathered}\overset{\diamond}{\mathbf{\Sigma}}\coloneqq\frac{\partial{\mathbf{\Sigma}}}{\partial t}+\mathbf{u}\cdot\nabla\mathbf{\Sigma}-a(\mathbf{\Sigma}\cdot\mathbf{D}+\mathbf{D}\cdot\mathbf{\Sigma})-(\mathbf{\Sigma}\cdot\mathbf{\Omega}-\mathbf{\Omega}\cdot\mathbf{\Sigma}).\end{gathered} Here \mathbf{D} and \mathbf{\Omega} denote the symmetric and antisymmetric parts of the velocity gradient tensor (\nabla\mathbf{u})_{ij}=\partial_{i}u_{j} . Both models have a polymer modulus G_{\rm p} , reptation time \tau_{\rm

Read the complete text