Meaning as Use, Application, Employment, Purpose, Usefulness

Ruy J.G.B. de Queiroz · 2025

Read Meaning as Use, Application, Employment, Purpose, Usefulness by Ruy J.G.B. de Queiroz (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-07131.txt.

Introduction

Ruy de Queiroz reads one thread that runs through a famed thinker's whole work in a 2025 paper. The thinker is Wittgenstein, whose long road through math, mind, hue, and faith is oft read as a maze of turns.

De Queiroz, with the full shelf of drafts now open to search, finds one line held from first to last: what a sign means is its use. The words for use run in four tongues of term, from the war-time books to the last notes. Each tag men pin on the thinker, saint or foe of sense, misses that tire work, the paper holds. The thread is set out as a key to the whole shelf.

Catalog record

CREATORRuy J.G.B. de Queiroz
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE89 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-07131

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Meaning as Use, Application, Employment, Purpose, Usefulness Thanks: Preprint. Final version to be published in De Gruyter’s SATS: Northern European Journal of Philosophy. Ruy J.G.B. de Queiroz Abstract Arising from the whole body of Wittgenstein’s writings is a picture of a (not necessarily straight, linear, but admittedly tireless) journey to come to terms with the mechanics of language as an instrument to conceive ‘reality’ and to communicate an acquired conception of the ‘world’. The journey passes through mathematics, psychology, color perception, certainty, aesthetic, but, looking at it from a sort of birdview, it seems reasonable to say that these are all used as ‘test beds’ for his reflections and ‘experimentations’ towards an all encompassing perspective of such a fundamental gateway to human reasoning and life-revealing as language. Whatever labelling of Wittgenstein as a mystic, a logicist, a conventionalist, a skeptic, an anti-metaphysics, an anti-realist, a verificationist, a pragmatist, a behaviorist, and many others, does not seem to do justice to his absolute obsession with being a persistent ‘deep diver’ into the nature of language. Working with an open and searchable account of the Nachlass has allowed us to identify important aspects of the philosopher’s possible common line of thinking, in spite of changes of directions, some of them acknowledged by Wittgenstein himself. One of those aspects is the association of meaning with use, application, purpose, usefulness of symbols in language, which happens to show itself from the very beginning through to the very late writings. The German terms Gebrauch , Anwendung , Verwendung , Zweck in relation to meaning, sense of signs, words, sentences, appear in several texts since the WW1 Notebooks (1914–1916) up until very late manuscripts from 1950--51. 1 1 1 This is a followup to two recent papers, one already published in 2023, and another one which has just been accepted for publication. We have already made heavy use of Wittgenstein’s Nachlass , and continued to do so here, much more than it was done in any of the previous publications. Thus, as a new step in a series of essays going back a few decades, it certainly contains some overlap with previous publications intended to bring context and self-containedness to the present manuscript, this substantially reinforces earlier arguments. (Thanks to the editors of Wittgenstein Archives at the University of Bergen ( WAB ) who have awarded Wittgenstein scholarship with such a huge gift as the Nachlass in free online and searchable form!) Keywords— meaning as use, Wittgenstein’s Nachlass , Gebrauch/Anwendung/Verwendung/Zweck, reduction rules, semantical/dialogical games, verification and meaning, proofs and meaning, proof theory, type theory 1 Introduction The use of the open and searchable Wittgenstein’s Nachlass (The Wittgenstein Archives at the University of Bergen (WAB)) has served spectacularly in the quest for what seems to constitute a common thread of Wittgenstein’s view on the connections between meaning, use, purpose, and consequences, going from the Notebooks to later writings (including and beyond the Philosophical Investigations ). And this search for a baseline of Wittgenstein’s thinking on language looks for taking it as the basis for a proposal for a formal counterpart of a ‘meaning-as-use’ (dialogical/game-theoretical) semantics for the language of predicate logic. In order to further consolidate a perspective first raised back four decades ago, we have been bringing out key excerpts from Wittgenstein’s Nachlass , especially from the impressive repository of WAB. Having Wittgenstein’s Nachlass at hand with the possibility of working with computer-assisted search has proven extremely useful in reexamining not just the unpublished writings, but also the body of published work, to the extent that it has allowed us to identify important aspects of the philosopher’s possible common line of thinking, in spite of changes of directions, some of them acknowledged by Wittgenstein himself. One of those aspects is the association of meaning with use, application, purpose, usefulness of symbols in language, which happens to show itself from the very beginning through to the very late writings. The German terms Gebrauch , Anwendung , Verwendung , Zweck in relation to meaning, sense of signs, words, sentences, appear in several texts since the WW1 Notebooks (1914–1916) up until very late manuscripts from 1950–51, including (and beyond) the published text of the Investigations . In this context, it seems appropriate to refer to what the Editorial Preface of the revised fourth edition of the Investigations , by P. M. S. Hacker and Joachim Schulte says: Anscombe was not consistent in her translation of Gebrauch , Verwendung and Anwendung . We have translated Gebrauch by ‘use’, Verwendung by ‘use’ or ‘employment’, and Anwendung by ‘application’. ‘Use’ also does service for benützen . In general, however, we have not allowed ourselves to be hidebound by the multiple occurrence of the same German word or phrase in different contexts. It by no means requires always translating by the same English expression, but rather depends on the exigencies of the context and the author’s intention. So, for example, we have translated Praxis der Sprache in Investigations § 21 by ‘linguistic practice’ rather than by the more ponderous ‘practice of the language’, and Praxis des Spiels in § 54(b) as ‘the way the game is played’, because this is how Wittgenstein wanted it translated. By examining those passages quoted here from his unpublished as well as published works, we wish to contend that the results of the search in the Nachlass strongly support and augment the main thrust of our continuing research on the significance of Wittgenstein’s suggestion that meaning is revealed by explaining the purpose, the usefulness, the immediate consequences of a term or statement. In particular, we have recently shown in two previous papers (2023, published, and 2024, under review) that in spite of the dominant view of the picture theory of the Tractatus , one finds clear signs in very early (pre-Tractatus) writings of what became the so-called ‘meaning as use’ paradigm of the second phase. Some of those signs had not been explicitly uncovered before, and this was made possible due to the openness and the easiness of making computer-assisted search in the whole body of writings. By examining these new findings in the Nachlass , we have sought to connect Wittgenstein’s account of ’meaning as use’, specified by the ’calculus’ involved in specifying or using terms (or statements), with the pragmatist approaches to meaning as revealed in Peirce’s writings (1932) on the interaction between the Interpreter and the Utterer which seem to bear on the “game”/“dialogue” approaches to meaning (Lorenzen, Hintikka, Fraïssé). And this seems to be compatible with Wittgenstein’s own attitude towards the possible labelling him as a pragmatist, which one finds in a late manuscript (Ms-131, 1946) but not in the published Investigations : Wie aber, wenn die Religion lehrt, die Seele könne bestehen, wenn der Leib zerfallen ist? Verstehe ich, was sie lehrt? Freilich verstehe ich’s: Ich —— ich kann mir dabei manches vorstellen. (Man hat ja auch Bilder von diesen Dingen gemalt. Und warum sollte so ein Bild nur die unvollkommene Wiedergabe des ausgesprochenen Gedankens sein? Warum soll es nicht den gleichen Dienst tun, wie der Satz? – wie das, was wir sagen?) Und auf den Dienst kommt es an. Aber bist Du kein Pragmatiker? Nein. Denn ich sage nicht, der Satz sei

Read the complete text