Unveiling the role of vector potential in the Aharonov-Bohm effect Preprint: KEK-TH-2728 and J-PARK-TH-0317

Masashi Wakamatsu · 2025

Read Unveiling the role of vector potential in the Aharonov-Bohm effect Preprint: KEK-TH-2728 and J-PARK-TH-0317 by Masashi Wakamatsu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-07018.txt.

Introduction

Wakamatsu revisits the Aharonov-Bohm effect, where a charged particle's phase shifts in a region with no magnetic field, in this 2025 paper. The standard reading credits the vector potential, a quantity that depends on arbitrary gauge choices. That dependence makes many physicists treat the potential as mere bookkeeping.

Wakamatsu argues the potential carries real physical content. Within it sits a gauge-invariant piece that alone explains the observed phase shift. That piece is essentially unique and survives every regular gauge change. The paper also accounts for the leftover freedom in the potential. The conclusion defends a local explanation of the effect. It pushes back on accounts that need action at a distance.

Catalog record

CREATORMasashi Wakamatsu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE40 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-07018

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Unveiling the role of vector potential in the Aharonov-Bohm effect Preprint: KEK-TH-2728 and J-PARK-TH-0317 Masashi Wakamatsu Abstract The most popular interpretation of the Aharonov-Bohm (AB) effect is that the electromagnetic potential locally affects the complex phase of a charged particle’s wave function in the magnetic field free region. However, since the vector potential is a gauge-variant quantity, not a few researchers suspect that it is just a convenient tool for calculating the force field. This motivates them to explain the AB effect without using the vector potential, which inevitably leads to some sort of non-locality. This frustrating situation is shortly summarized by the statement of Aharonov et al. that the AB effect may be due to a local gauge potential or due to non-local gauge-invariant fields. In the present paper, we shall give several convincing arguments, which support the viewpoint that the vector potential is not just a convenient mathematical tool with little physical entity. Despite its gauge arbitrariness, the vector potential certainly contains a gauge-invariant piece, which solely explains the observed AB phase shift. Importantly, this component has a property such that it is basically unique and cannot be eliminated by any regular gauge transformations. To make the discussion complete, we also discuss the role of remaining gauge arbitrariness still contained in the entire vector potential. I Introduction Since its first theoretical prediction ES1949 , AB1959 , the Aharonov-Bohm effect has continued to provoke innumerable debates which concern the deep foundation of modern physics. (For review, see Peshkin1981 - WKZZ2018 , for example.) A central question is whether the electromagnetic potential is a physical entity or it is just a convenient mathematical tool Feynman1963 - Semon-Taylor1996 . Without doubt, most popular interpretation of the AB-effect is that the magnetic vector potential locally affects the complex phase of quantum electron wave function, thereby causing a change of phase that can be verified through interference experiments Tonomura1986 , Osakabe1986 . Nonetheless, it is also true that there are many researchers who are not completely satisfied with the vector potential explanation of the AB effect Healey2022 - Heras-Heras2022 . This is because the vector potential is a gauge-variant quantity with inherent arbitrariness. By this reason, they believe that the vector potential is just a convenient mathematical tool for calculating the electromagnetic force field as is in fact the case with the classical electromagnetism. This motivate them to look for explanations which do not use the gauge-dependent vector potential Healey2022 - ACR2016 . One of the most influential studies along this line would be the work by Vaidman Vaidman2012 , Vaidman2015 . He proposed an explanation for the AB effect via force between the solenoid current and the moving electron rather than via electromagnetic potential. Later, Vaidman’s paper was criticized by Aharonov, Cohen and Rohrlich ACR2015C . Through six thought experiments, these authors concluded that the attempt to dispense with scalar and vector potentials is at least incompatible with the attempt to interpret the AB effect as a local effect. They also pointed out a potential problem inherent in the local force explanation of the AB effect. According to this force interpretation, the change in the phase of the electron’s wave function implies a change in the electron’s velocity, which appears to be incompatible with the so-called dispersionless nature of the AB effect Zellinger1986 , Peshkin1999 1 1 1 The dispersionless nature of the AB effect means that the observed AB phase shift is independent of the velocity of the electron . Partially motivated by Vaidman’s work, several authors focused on the interaction energy between the solenoid current and the moving electron rather than the force between them Santos-Gonzalo1999 - LHK2022 . (See also a related older work by Boyer Boyer1971 .) They postulates that the change of the phase of the electron wave function along a path is proportional to the change of the above interaction energy along the same path. Then, by explicitly evaluating the change of the interaction energy along a closed path of the electron, they showed that it reproduce the standard answer for the AB phase shift. Highly nontrivial is the validity or invalidity of these authors’ further claim as follows. According to them, since the change of the above interaction energy along the path of the electron is a gauge-invariant quantity, the partial AB phase shift along a non-closed is also a gauge-invariant quantity, which in turn implies that it can in principle be observed. However, in a recent paper Waka2024 , based on the framework of a self-contained quantum mechanical treatment of the combined system of a solenoid, an electron, and the quantized electromagnetic field, we showed that there is no evidence to support their central claim, i.e. the proportionality assumption between the interaction energy of the solenoid current and the moving electron and the corresponding partial AB phase shift. To summarize the situation to date, we feel that any attempt to dispense with the vector potential in the explanation of the AB effect has not reached a complete success. On the other hand, there already exist several works, which support physically reasonable nature of the vector potential interpretation Adachi1992 - Li2012 . Only worry of this theoretical approach is the fact that the vector potential is a gauge-dependent quantity, which makes it difficult to completely dispel some researchers’ suspicion on its physical reality. The purpose of the present paper is to get rid of these doubts in the most convincing manner. The remainder of the paper is structured as follows. First, in sect. II , we analyze the nature of the vector potential generated by an infinitely-long solenoid with the special intention of confirming its physically substantial nature. It is demonstrated that the vector potential generated by an infinitely-long solenoid can be uniquely decomposed into the transverse component and the longitudinal component, provided that physically unacceptable multi-valued gauge transformation is excluded. To help understanding of the significance of the discussion in sect. III , we provide in sect. IV a brief introduction to some past works which tried to explain the AB effect, without using the standard vector potential interpretation. Also discussed there are the highly nontrivial claim in several recent literature, in which the authors insist that the partial AB phase-shift corresponding to a non-closed path of the electron can in principle be observed, thereby proposing several concrete settings of measurement for verifying their claim Kang2017 - LHK2022 . Sect. V summarizes the essential points of our vector potential interpretation of the AB effect improved upon in the present paper. II On the vector potential generated by an infinitely-long solenoid In order to discuss the essence of the AB effect in the simplest possible form, it is customary to consider an idealized setting of infinitely-long solenoid with radius R directed to the z -direction. The stationary and uniform surface current distribution of the solenoid is represented as \bm{J}_{ext}(\bm{x})\ =\ B\,\delta(\rho-R)\,\bm{e}_{\phi}. (1) Here we use the cylindrical coordinates \bm{x}=(\rho,\phi,z) with \rho=\sqrt{x^{2}+y^{2}} and \phi=\arctan\left(\frac{y}{x}\right) . Our aim is to find the vector potential generated by the above solenoid current distribution. There are various routes to reach this goal, but probably the most instructive way is to start with the familiar Biot-Savart law represented as (note that

Read the complete text