Direct numerical simulation of complete transition to turbulence with a fluid at supercritical pressure
P.C. Boldini 1 †, B. Bugeat 2, J. W. R. Peeters 1, M. Kloker 3, R. Pecnik 1 · 2025
Read Direct numerical simulation of complete transition to turbulence with a fluid at supercritical pressure by P.C. Boldini 1 †, B. Bugeat 2, J. W. R. Peeters 1, M. Kloker 3, R. Pecnik 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-06703.txt.
Introduction
Boldini and four co-authors simulated a boundary layer turning turbulent in this paper from twenty twenty-five. The fluid sits at supercritical pressure, beyond the point where liquid and gas blur. Two heat ranges were compared. In one the fluid stays liquid-like throughout. In the other it crosses the pseudo-critical line, where it pseudo-boils.
Crossing that line changed the breakdown route. Billow-like rolls formed near the line, plus pockets of reversed flow at the wall. Those reversals built shear layers that triggered an abrupt H-type breakdown. Without special forcing, transition still came early through a natural K-type path. Standard scaling laws still predicted skin friction and heat transfer well.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | P.C. Boldini 1 †, B. Bugeat 2, J. W. R. Peeters 1, M. Kloker 3, R. Pecnik 1 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 127 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-06703
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Direct numerical simulation of complete transition to turbulence with a fluid at supercritical pressure P.C. Boldini 1 †, B. Bugeat 2, J. W. R. Peeters 1, M. Kloker 3, R. Pecnik 1 Abstract The objective of this work is to investigate the unexplored laminar-to-turbulent transition of a heated flat-plate boundary layer with a fluid at supercritical pressure. Two temperature ranges are considered: a subcritical case, where the fluid remains entirely in the liquid-like regime, and a transcritical case, where the pseudo-critical (Widom) line is crossed and pseudo-boiling occurs. Fully compressible direct numerical simulations are used to study (i) the linear and nonlinear instabilities, (ii) the breakdown to turbulence, and (iii) the fully developed turbulent boundary layer. In the transcritical regime, two-dimensional forcing generates not only a train of billow-like structures around the Widom line, resembling Kelvin-Helmholtz instability, but also near-wall travelling regions of flow reversal. These spanwise-oriented billows dominate the early nonlinear stage. When high subharmonic three-dimensional forcing is applied, staggered Λ \Lambda -vortices emerge more abruptly than in the subcritical case. However, unlike the classic H-type breakdown under zero pressure gradient observed in ideal-gas and subcritical regimes, the H-type breakdown is triggered by strong shear layers caused by flow reversals – similar to that observed in adverse-pressure-gradient boundary layers. Without oblique wave forcing, transition is only slightly delayed and follows a naturally selected fundamental breakdown (K-type) scenario. Hence, in the transcritical regime, it is possible to trigger nonlinearities and achieve transition to turbulence relatively early using only a single two-dimensional wave that strongly amplifies background noise. In the fully turbulent region, we demonstrate that variable-property scaling accurately predicts turbulent skin-friction and heat-transfer coefficients. keywords † † affiliation: 1 Process and Energy Department, Delft University of Technology, Leeghwaterstraat 39, 2628 CB Delft, the Netherlands 2 School of Engineering, University of Leicester, University Road, Leicester, LE1 7RH, United Kingdom 3 Institute of Aerodynamics and Gas Dynamics, University of Stuttgart, Pfaffenwaldring 21, 70569 Stuttgart, Germany 1 Introduction Fluids at supercritical pressure have enabled the development of more efficient, compact industrial processes and continue to offer promising opportunities for future energy-conversion technologies ( Guardone et al. 2024 ) . Among different fluids, carbon dioxide ( \text{CO}_{2} ) has emerged as a promising working medium for power cycles in geothermal and concentrated solar energy systems, as well as for heat pumps in industrial heating applications. In the aerospace sector, supercritical fuel injection improves mixing and combustion efficiency in both air-breathing and liquid rocket engines ( Wang & Yang 2017 ) . Supercritical fluids also occur in nature – for example, the \text{CO}_{2} / \text{N}_{2} mixture in the lower atmosphere of Venus ( Morellina et al. 2020 ) . At supercritical conditions, i.e. above the thermodynamic critical point, the liquid–vapour boundary vanishes and strong variations in thermophysical properties occur within a narrow temperature range around the pseudo-critical temperature T_{\mathit{pc}} – also referred to as pseudo-boiling ( Banuti 2015 ) – at which the isobaric heat capacity reaches its maximum. In this non-ideal, single-phase thermodynamic region, the ideal-gas assumption fails. Supercritical fluids have been extensively investigated in fully developed turbulent flows. Yoo 2013 highlighted the complexity of supercritical heat-transfer measurements, in which thermophysical property variations may either enhance or deteriorate heat transfer. Early computational studies on turbulent flows at supercritical pressure mainly focused on closed flow configurations, such as pipes ( Bae et al. 2005 ; Nemati et al. 2016 ; He et al. 2021 ; Cao et al. 2021 ) , channels ( Patel et al. 2016 ; Ma et al. 2018 ; Kim et al. 2019 ; Guo et al. 2022 ; Li et al. 2023 ; Li et al. 2024 ) , and annular flows ( Peeters et al. 2016 ) . These studies underlined the significant impact of local property variations on large-scale structures and the presence of relaminarisation mechanisms. Semi-local scaling demonstrated to best characterise turbulence in variable-property flows, assuming weak density and viscosity fluctuations. However, in turbulent boundary layers with parahydrogen at supercritical pressure and transcritical temperature conditions, large density fluctuations of order \sqrt{\smash[b]{\overline{\rho^{\prime}\rho^{\prime}}}}/\overline{\rho}\approx 0.4-1.0 significantly alter near-wall turbulence and its statistics ( Kawai 2019 ) . As a result, semi-local scaling failed to collapse the velocity transformation. Conversely, many industrial applications operating at supercritical conditions frequently involve flows that have not yet reached a fully turbulent state. Even under the ideal-gas assumption, transition to turbulence remains of fundamental importance across subsonic, supersonic, and high-Mach-number flows ( Saric et al. 2002 ; Fedorov 2011 ) . In high-speed flows, real-gas effects have been studied extensively ( Candler 2019 ) , yet are often erroneously linked to non-ideal gas effects ( Guardone et al. 2024 ) . Unlike real-gas effects, non-ideal gas effects near the thermodynamic critical point are characterised by strong stratification ( Govindarajan & Sahu 2014 ) and abrupt variations in thermophysical properties. Transition to turbulence can follow different routes depending on the type of flow disturbances ( Morkovin 1969 ) . In this work, we focus on the transitional sequence typically observed under low levels of free-stream turbulence: (i) receptivity to external disturbances, (ii) primary modal or non-modal disturbance growth, (iii) secondary instability and nonlinear interactions, followed by the eventual breakdown to turbulence. Only recently, linear stability theory (LST) of boundary layers with fluids at supercritical pressure has been investigated ( Robinet & Gloerfelt 2019 ) . The first such analysis by Ren et al. 2019 for an adiabatic zero-pressure-gradient (ZPG) flat-plate boundary layer with supercritical \text{CO}_{2} revealed strong sensitivity to the temperature profile relative to the pseudo-critical temperature. As the flow crosses the pseudo-critical (Widom) line, i.e. under transcritical temperature conditions, a new inviscid mode (Mode II) emerges, exhibiting growth rates an order of magnitude greater than those of Mode I, which corresponds to the Tollmien–Schlichting (TS) instability. It is worth noting this dual-mode instability occurs only when heating from a liquid-like free stream. Unlike Mack’s second mode in hypersonics, Mode II is not of acoustic nature. Moreover, the Mode-II instability is largest for two-dimensional (2-D) perturbations, as also confirmed for low-Mach, diabatic boundary layers by Boldini et al. 2024b . Bugeat et al. 2022 further showed that Mode II is associated with a minimum of kinematic viscosity at the Widom line – a feature common to all non-polar supercritical fluids at transcritical temperature conditions. Thus, according to the generalised-inflection-point (GIP) criterion, such boundary layers are inviscidly unstable. In plane Couette flow, Bugeat et al. 2024 demonstrated that this inviscid instability arises from a localised maximum of density-weighted vorticity and consists of two phase-locked vorticity waves induced by shear and baroclinic effects around the kinematic-viscosity minimum. Alongside previous modal stability analyses, Boldini et al. 2024b investigated transient growth with fluids at supercritical pressure. When heating beyond the Widom line – where Mode II is unstable – optimal energy growth arises from an interplay between lift-up and Orr mechanisms. Conversely, wall cooling was found to resemble the effect of an adverse pressure gradient (APG) under the ideal-gas assumption. A similar trend appeared in cross-flow (CF) dominated three-dimensional (3-D) boundary layers ( Ren & Kloker 2022 ) , where the inviscid TS mode can be amplified far more than classical CF modes, effectively suppressing them – akin to imposing