Alignment and anisotropy of stresses in disordered granular media

Aashish K. Gupta, Christopher Ness, Sina Haeri · 2025

Read Alignment and anisotropy of stresses in disordered granular media by Aashish K. Gupta, Christopher Ness, Sina Haeri (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-06498.txt.

Introduction

Aashish Gupta and co-authors count the possible stress states inside a handful of grains to explain the behavior of heaps. Disordered granular matter resists statistical mechanics because the local stress arrangements are so degenerate. The team builds a minimal force-balance model for isolated clusters and studies two descriptors: which way the principal stress points, and how unequal it is.

Adding physically motivated pairwise constraints turns the toy into a predictor. Its forecasts for stress alignment matched simulations of hard spheres in hopper flow and in simple shear, quantitatively. The moral is combinatorial: the bulk behavior of an athermal pile may follow from a few primitive geometric motifs, counted carefully, rather than from exhaustive simulation of every grain.

Catalog record

CREATORAashish K. Gupta, Christopher Ness, Sina Haeri
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE22 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-06498

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Alignment and anisotropy of stresses in disordered granular media Preprint: APS/123-QED Aashish K. Gupta, Christopher Ness, Sina Haeri Abstract Characterizing the degeneracy of local stress states is a central challenge in obtaining the complete statistical mechanics of disordered media. Here, we introduce a minimal force-balance model for isolated granular clusters to probe the structure of the stress space through principal stress orientation and stress anisotropy. We further show that when complemented by physically motivated pairwise constraints, the model produces predictions for the stress alignment in packings of repulsive hard spheres. We compare these predictions against simulation data for grains in hopper and simple shear flows, finding quantitative agreement. This demonstrates the promise of modeling bulk athermal disordered systems through the combinatorics of few primitive geometric motifs. Granular packings pose unique challenges for statistical mechanics due to their athermal and dissipative nature. Traditional energy-based approaches fail, necessitating new statistical frameworks. Edwards and Oakeshott 1989 introduced compactivity X=\partial V/\partial S as a temperature analog for grains, where V is the system volume and S is the entropy associated with the number of possible configurations. This quantifies the ability of the system to accommodate volumetric changes ( Lechenault et al. 2006 ; McNamara et al. 2009 ) , enabling prediction of packing densities and volume fluctuations in dense assemblies ( Aste and Di Matteo 2008 ; Song et al. 2008 ; Hihinashvili and Blumenfeld 2012 ) . However, compactivity focuses solely on volume, neglecting the force networks crucial for mechanical stability ( Henkes and Chakraborty 2009 ; Bi et al. 2015 ) . To address this, Blumenfeld and Edwards 2009 introduced angoricity \hat{\alpha}=\partial S/\partial\hat{\Sigma} , a tensorial analog of inverse temperature with \hat{\Sigma} the global force-moment tensor. The probability of observing a granular cluster of local force-moment \hat{\sigma} is then P(\hat{\sigma}|\,\hat{\alpha})=(\Omega(\hat{\sigma})/Z(\hat{\alpha}))\,\exp(-\hat{\alpha}:\hat{\sigma}) , where \Omega(\hat{\sigma}) is the degeneracy in the stress state (innate frequency of occurrence in isolation), and Z(\hat{\alpha},\kappa) is the partition function. The comprehensive form of \Omega remains elusive, however, and conventional formalisms Bililign et al. 2019 ; Rey et al. 2021 ; Baranau and Tallarek 2024 characterize \hat{\sigma} using two scalar invariants of the stress, overlooking a crucial implicit physical invariant, namely the principal stress direction. These approaches thus predict the distribution and fluctuations of the macroscopic stress, but fail to capture the spatial organization of the stress fields. We argue that incorporating the relative orientation of principal stresses of contacting particles is essential in recovering this missing spatial structure. Here, we advance the understanding of stress transmission in granular media in three directions. First, we study an isolated cluster of identical grains and identify all theoretically admissible configurations satisfying equilibrium conditions. For each configuration, we compute the stress anisotropy and the orientation of the principal stress directions, making progress toward the question of the degeneracy of stress states. Second, we quantify the misalignment of the stress transmission directions for contacting particles in a cluster. This is key to reimagining the current statistical mechanics framework for force chain predictions. Finally, we address hopper and simple shear flow by particle simulation, as exemplars of real granular dynamics. We compare the stress distributions thus obtained to those of the isolated cluster, demonstrating that the primitive case contains sufficient physics to predict bulk behavior. As well as advancing the statistical mechanics of granular matter, our work guides the development of force chain screening algorithms, a mainstay of industrial granular technology research. Figure 1: Isolated Frictionless Cluster (IFC) model for stress transmission in 2D. (a)[i] Disk P1 acted on by forces {\bm{f}}_{i} at angles \theta_{i} measured counterclockwise from the outward normal at the first contact; the blue line making acute angle \beta with the outward normal and the dash-dotted perpendicular line show the minor \sigma_{2} and major \sigma_{1} principal stress directions; [ii] misalignment angle \delta between \sigma_{2} of P1 and P2; (b) subregions of the \theta_{2}-\theta_{3} space satisfying: equilibrium conditions (blue), minimum angular separations of 60 (green), inward directionality of forces (red), constrained angles and forces (turquoise); (c) example configuration with P1 and P2 neighbors located at (\theta_{2},\theta_{3}) and (\theta_{2}^{\prime},\theta_{3}^{\prime}) respectively. Dashed lines demarcate the constrained Regions I - IV described in the text; (d) angular configuration space showing (\theta_{2},\theta_{3}) from (c) (blue dot) lies in R IV , demanding that (\theta_{2}^{\prime},\theta_{3}^{\prime}) (red cross) lies in, or on the boundary of, the shaded region. Model. —We consider first a frictionless disk P1 of volume v in static equilibrium experiencing contact forces from three identical neighbors, Fig. 1 (a)[i]. The first applies a unit inward force \bm{f}_{1} . A second force \bm{f}_{2} acts at a rotation of \theta_{2} from the outward normal at \bm{f}_{1} , and \bm{f}_{3} at \theta_{3} . Forces \bm{f}_{2} and \bm{f}_{3} are thus uniquely determined for P1 in equilibrium. By incrementally varying \theta_{2} and \theta_{3} , we construct for each realization the force-moment tensor \hat{\Sigma}=\sum_{i=1}^{3}\bm{f}_{i}\otimes\bm{r}_{i} , with \bm{r}_{i} the contact points. We then define \sigma:=\hat{\Sigma}/v , which is related to the local Cauchy stress as \sigma=\frac{1}{v}\int_{v}\sigma_{c}\,dv and is thus symmetric and has real eigenvalues and eigenvectors. The direction of one eigenvector \gamma is \tan 2\gamma=2\sigma_{12}/(\sigma_{11}-\sigma_{22})=(f_{2}\sin 2\theta_{2}+f_{3}\sin 2\theta_{3})/(1+f_{2}\cos 2\theta_{2}+f_{3}\cos 2\theta_{3}) , with the other orthogonal. The orientation of the minor (most compressive) principal stress \sigma_{2} follows the eigenvector of the lower eigenvalue of \sigma . The stress inclination \beta for P1 is the acute angle between \sigma_{2} and the outward normal at \bm{f}_{1} , counterclockwise being positive. We define the anisotropy A=(\sigma_{1}-\sigma_{2})/(\sigma_{1}+\sigma_{2}) as the ratio of the maximum shear to hydrostatic stress. The values of \beta and A are invariant to changes in \bm{f}_{1} by a positive prefactor c ; for negative c , the minor and major principal axes are swapped, transforming \beta and A accordingly. Figure 1 (b) illustrates subregions of the \theta_{2}-\theta_{3} parameter space accessible under physically motivated constraints on \theta_{2,3} and \bm{f}_{2,3} . The region satisfying force equilibrium is bounded by the blue triangle with hypotenuse \theta_{3}=\theta_{2} ( \theta_{3}\geq\theta_{2} by construction). The green triangle is defined by \theta_{3}\geq\theta_{2}+60 , \theta_{2}\geq 60 and \theta_{3}\leq 300 , precluding particle overlaps. Red lines bound the region where only inward forces are permitted, representing noncohesive particles, with 0\leq\theta_{2}\leq 180 , \theta_{3}\geq 180 and \theta_{3}\leq\theta_{2}+180 . The turquoise intersection satisfies all constraints. Figure 2: Variation over \theta_{2}-\theta_{3} parameter space of (a)[i] the minor principal stress angle \beta , and (b)[ii] the anisotropy A . Dash-dotted line shows \theta_{2}+\theta_{3}=360 . The hexagonal regions (magnified in (a)[ii] and (b)[ii]) satisfy constraints on the minimum angular separation between neighbors and inward directionality of the forces. Results. —We first describe the features of \beta and A for positive \bm{f}_{1} , Figs. 2 (a)[i] and (b)[i]. Notably, \beta is antisymmetric whereas A is symmetric about \theta_{2}+\theta_{3}=360 , since reflecting P1 about the horizontal transforms (\theta_{2},\theta_{3}) to (360-\theta_{3},360-\theta_{2}) , leaving the stress state unchanged. A striking consequence of this is a discontinuity in \beta , jumping from -90 to 90 across the symmetry line. Though abrupt, these values actually correspond to the same vertical orientation, unlike other \pm\beta pairs. We observe other sets of curves across which \beta jumps from -45 to 45 , satisfying 1+f_{2}\cos 2\theta_{2}+f_{3}\cos 2\theta_{3}=0 . Taking stresses positive in tension, A<0 indicates particle compression. A particularly sensitive configuration arises when \bm{f}_{3} diametrically opposes \bm{f}_{2} ( \theta_{3}=\theta_{2}+180 ).

Read the complete text