Steps towards an Ecology for the Internet Conference: The sixth decennial Aarhus conference: Computing X Crisis; August 18–22, 2025; Aarhus N, Denmark The sixth decennial Aarhus conference: Computing X Crisis (AAR 2025), August 18–22, 2025, Aarhus N, Denmark DOI: 10.1145/3744169.3744180 ISBN: 979-8-

Anil Madhavapeddy, Sam Reynolds, Alec P. Christie, David A. Coomes, Michael W. Dales, Patrick Ferris, Ryan Gibb, Hamed Haddadi, Sadiq Jaffer, Josh Millar, Cyrus Omar, William J. Sutherland, Jon Crowcroft · 2025

Read Steps towards an Ecology for the Internet Conference: The sixth decennial Aarhus conference: Computing X Crisis; August 18–22, 2025; Aarhus N, Denmark The sixth decennial Aarhus conference: Computing X Crisis (AAR 2025), August 18–22, 2025, Aarhus N, Denmark DOI: 10.1145/3744169.3744180 ISBN: 979-8- by Anil Madhavapeddy, Sam Reynolds, Alec P. Christie, David A. Coomes, Michael W. Dales, Patrick Ferris, Ryan Gibb, Hamed Haddadi, Sadiq Jaffer, Josh Millar, Cyrus Omar, William J. Sutherland, Jon Crowcroft (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-06469.txt.

Introduction

Anil Madhavapeddy and co-authors argued in a 2025 paper that the internet needs an immune system, like a living ecosystem has. The net grew from a small set of link rules into a core global system with no built-in defense. It may soon hold a trillion nodes, facing floods of fake content and AI-driven attacks.

Growth has also piled control into few hands, and ad-driven tracking now rules the business model. The authors draw lessons from living systems, where species that help each other keep the whole web strong. They sketch steps toward a net that heals and adapts. The paper is a call to treat net design as ecology.

Catalog record

CREATORAnil Madhavapeddy, Sam Reynolds, Alec P. Christie, David A. Coomes, Michael W. Dales, Patrick Ferris, Ryan Gibb, Hamed Haddadi, Sadiq Jaffer, Josh Millar, Cyrus Omar, William J. Sutherland, Jon Crowcroft
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE43 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-06469

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Steps towards an Ecology for the Internet Conference: The sixth decennial Aarhus conference: Computing X Crisis; August 18–22, 2025; Aarhus N, Denmark The sixth decennial Aarhus conference: Computing X Crisis (AAR 2025), August 18–22, 2025, Aarhus N, Denmark DOI: 10.1145/3744169.3744180 ISBN: 979-8-4007-2003-1/25/08 CCS: Security and privacy Malware and its mitigation CCS: Security and privacy Artificial immune systems Anil Madhavapeddy, Sam Reynolds, Alec P. Christie, David A. Coomes, Michael W. Dales, Patrick Ferris, Ryan Gibb, Hamed Haddadi, Sadiq Jaffer, Josh Millar, Cyrus Omar, William J. Sutherland, Jon Crowcroft Abstract . The Internet has grown from a humble set of protocols for end-to-end connectivity into a critical global system with no builtin “immune system”. In the next decade the Internet will likely grow to a trillion nodes and need protection from threats ranging from floods of fake generative data to AI-driven malware. Unfortunately, growing centralisation has lead to the breakdown of mutualism across the network, with surveillance capitalism now the dominant business model. We take lessons from from biological systems towards evolving a more resilient Internet that can integrate adaptation mechanisms into its fabric. We also contribute ideas for how the Internet might incorporate digital immune systems, including how software stacks might mutate to encourage more architectural diversity. We strongly advocate for the Internet to “re-decentralise” towards incentivising more mutualistic forms of communication. Computing through crisis into the next decade of growth 1. Introduction Ecology is the study of relationships between living things and their environment across all scales, from blue whales in the ocean, to bacteria living on the surface of a leaf. It encompasses all life processes, interactions and adaptations; community structure and composition; competition and foodwebs; ecosystem structure and energy flow; landscapes and life histories; mutualism, parasitism and infectious disease; the abundance and distribution of organisms; and how ecosystems function Wikipedia 2025 . Meanwhile, the rather more abiotic Internet is the global system of computer networks that standardises protocols to communicate among each other. It lacks any central control structure and is a network of networks that connect private, public, academic, business and country networks, linked by a broad array of physical connection technologies Wikipedia 2025a . Bateson’s classic work “Ecology of Mind” notes that “the history of evolutionary theory is inevitably a metalogue between man and nature, in which the creation and interaction of ideas must necessarily exemplify evolutionary process ” Bateson 2000 . In this paper, we explore the idea of an ecology for the Internet, and how the Internet in its current phase of growth can draw parallels from ecological theory to become more resilient, sustainable, and trustworthy into the coming decades as it approaches a trillion connected nodes Sparks 2017 . To help guide our discussion, we will first clarify our teleology. We are using the term ecology directly, not merely as a weak metaphor for a collection of stakeholders in a socio-techno-economic system. We examine those dimensions of ecology that have no intentional purpose Knight & Allan 2021 and serve to preserve and advance life through selection pressures against competing strategies Bar-Cohen 2005 . The Internet, now entering its fifth decade of existence Paloque-Bergès & Schafer 2019 , needs to continue to be based on system designs that provide communication, whatever the adversary does; whatever and whoever the adversary is, even if the adversary is sometimes ourselves. 1.1. The Internet as an Ecology The Internet started from humble beginnings Coffman & Odlyzko 1998 and has now grown into a behemoth of interconnected nodes with zettabytes of traffic flowing across it daily Cisco 2024 . As growth continues to multiply, it is facing new existential threats; from the rise of nation-state actors, to the increasing sophistication of cyber-criminals, and the increasing complexity and layering of its protocols resulting in the ossification of its infrastructure Handley 2006 . Accelerating all of these threats are emerging AI technologies that can automate attacks in superhuman timescales Fang et al. 2024 , poison the wells of human information with fake or low-quality generated data Runco 2024 , and even manipulate the physical world through Internet of Things (IoT) devices Ren et al. 2019 . Biological Concept Internet Concept Section DNA Protocol specifications (RFCs), file formats § 3.1 Genes Software modules, protocol functions, reusable code § 2 Proteins Operating system processes, code regions § 3.2 Virus Malware, botnets, Internet worms § 2.1 Chromosome Software interfaces, formal specifications § 2 Organelle CPUs, RAM, NICs, SSDs § 3.2 Cell End nodes (IoT devices, servers, middleboxes) § 3.1 Tissues Clusters of hosts (data centers, edge clusters) § 3 Organs Domain-specific networks (e.g., CDN nodes) § 3 Organisms Entire Internet services (e.g., Google, Facebook) § 4 Populations Device ecosystems, software monocultures § 4 Communities Federated networks (e.g., ActivityPub, Bluesky) § 4.1 Ecosystems Overall Internet resilience § 4.1 Table 1. Just as biological processes exhibit self-organization, we explore in this paper how these principles might apply to the network of networks that is the Internet. The concepts are in rough order of increasing scale. The core purpose of the Internet is to facilitate communications in a decentralized, scalable and extensible manner. It is based on the end-to-end principle Kempf 2004 that dictates the network itself remain as simple as possible, with complexity pushed to the software on end hosts instead. This has permitted decades of evolutions of communications protocols ranging from the original ARPANET to the modern incarnation Paloque-Bergès & Schafer 2019 . However, the end-to-end principle has also led to the Internet’s current vulnerability to automated attacks as the network itself has no builtin “immune system” to protect itself with, and end hosts cannot upgrade quickly enough. However, individual Internet hosts can also deploy new software techniques in small clusters without requiring central “permission”. In this sense, they are very similar to the phenomenon of self-organisation that is primarily seen in biological systems. We therefore turn to ecological inspirations, such as plant-pathogen interactions and evolutionary theory, to help us to build a more resilient Internet with more active defence systems. Table 1 contains an illustrative mapping between biological and Internet systems, beginning firstly from the smallest components and then scaling up to entire populations. Throughout the rest of this paper, we will explore how these biological concepts can be applied to the Internet. Central to our discussion will be we can learn from the natural world to embed new concepts into the Internet architecture that will enable evolution towards a more resilient system despite the number of nodes growing into the trillions. We will also sketch out how some these ideas could be implemented in practice, and what challenges we may face in doing so. Our primary goal is to inspire further research and discussion on this topic, rather than to provide a comprehensive solution. 2. Resilience against attack Figure 1. The Internet needs to urgently evolve active defenses against new threats from AI-powered attacks. We discuss three such defences in this paper. The Internet protocol culture is one of open standards and collaborative processes. Rather than being dictated by central authorities, Internet standards emerge through “rough consensus and running code”, meaning ideas are adopted when working implementations demonstrate real-world value. Design principles like Postel’s Law ( “be liberal in what you accept, conservative

Read the complete text