On the Fundamental Impossibility of Hallucination Control in Large Language Models

Michal P. Karpowicz · 2025

Read On the Fundamental Impossibility of Hallucination Control in Large Language Models by Michal P. Karpowicz (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-06382.txt.

Introduction

Michał Karpowicz argues that some hallucination in large language models is not a bug to patch but a limit to respect. He models the model's inner parts as bidders in an auction of ideas. Each part holds partial knowledge and pushes its own answer.

When parts contest a shared fact, his theorems show four good properties cannot all hold at once. The system must fabricate detail, overstate confidence, ignore knowledge, or give a weaker answer. The result repeats when parts report probabilities, and inside the transformer itself. Confidence granted to the whole answer can exceed what the parts supplied. Builders should design around the limit, not promise it away. The paper names the trade-off precisely.

Catalog record

CREATORMichal P. Karpowicz
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE83 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-06382

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the Fundamental Impossibility of Hallucination Control in Large Language Models Michal P. Karpowicz Abstract We prove that perfect hallucination control in large language models is mathematically impossible. No LLM inference mechanism can simultaneously achieve truthful response generation, semantic information conservation, relevant knowledge revelation, and knowledge-constrained optimality. This impossibility is fundamental—arising from the mathematical structure of information aggregation itself rather than engineering limitations. The proof spans three mathematical frameworks: auction theory, proper scoring theory for probabilistic predictions, and log-sum-exp analysis for transformer architectures. In each setting, we demonstrate that information aggregation creates unavoidable violations of conservation principles. The Jensen gap in transformer probability aggregation provides a direct measure of this impossibility. These results reframe hallucination from an engineering bug to an inevitable mathematical feature of distributed intelligence. There are fundamental trade-offs between truthfulness, knowledge utilization, and response completeness, providing principled foundations for managing rather than eliminating hallucination. This work reveals deep connections between neural network inference, philosophy of knowledge and reasoning, and classical results in game theory and information theory, opening new research directions for developing beneficial AI systems within mathematical constraints. 1 Introduction Large language models have been known for producing convincing content that is factually incorrect, inconsistent, or well fabricated—a phenomenon known as hallucination. Despite extensive research efforts involving architectural innovations, retrieval augmented generation (RAG), training techniques with external feedback, and post-hoc verification methods, hallucination persists across all state-of-the-art models. This paper shows that hallucination is a manifestation of fundamental limitations of inference process itself: no LLM inference mechanism can simultaneously satisfy four essential properties required for perfect hallucination control. Specifically, it is mathematically impossible for any LLM to simultaneously achieve: (1) truthful (non-hallucinatory) response generation, (2) semantic information conservation, (3) relevant knowledge revelation, and (4) knowledge-constrained optimality . The impossibility result operates in three distinct but complementary settings. First, we introduce game-theoretic framework in which LLM inference is an auction of ideas with neural components (attention heads, circuits, activation patterns) competing to contribute knowledge to response generation. This perspective allows us to apply fundamental results from mechanism design theory to prove impossibility in the settings where agents have discrete, separable knowledge components. Then, we extend the result to include any system where agents output probability distributions trained with strictly concave scores. Finally, we use log-sum-exp inequality that is specific to attention head aggregation to show that the impossibility result applies directly to actual transformer implementations . 1.1 Illustrative Example Consider an LLM queried about recent diplomatic negotiations: "What was the outcome of diplomatic negotiations between Countries A and B in February 2025?" Assume the model has encoded knowledge that: (K1) countries A and B were engaged in talks, (K2) country A sought a trade agreement, and (K3) the actual outcome is unknown. Examining possible responses reveals the fundamental trade-offs: Complete Abstention : "I don’t have information about the outcome" is truthful but fails to utilize available relevant knowledge, violating the expectation that good inference should reveal accessible information. Hallucination : "The negotiations resulted in a comprehensive trade agreement reducing tariffs by 15%" utilizes all knowledge and provides a complete answer but fabricates specific details, violating truthfulness. Partial Knowledge : "Countries A and B were negotiating a trade agreement, but I don’t know the outcome" is truthful and utilizes available knowledge but may appear unsatisfying compared to the decisive hallucinated response (training objectives and human preferences favor complete narratives). Overcautious : "I’m not certain about any aspects of these negotiations" avoids hallucination but disclaims even known facts, violating truthfulness about available information. Each response strategy sacrifices different aspects of what constitutes an ideal response, illustrating the impossibility of simultaneously optimizing all desired properties. 1.2 Theoretical Contributions and Implications The motivating example above illustrates the key result of this paper that we prove formally in two complementary and general settings. First, we show that the conflict of expectations about responses is inevitable even in the easiest setting (deterministic in nature) of (one-hot-like) ground truth matching. Second, we go beyond and show that the conflict must also emerge with general probabilistic predictions, including neural networks and LLM transformers. This way we demonstrate that the impossibility of hallucination control is robust across universal frameworks, and that it emerges from the mathematical structure of information aggregation itself rather than from any particular theoretical or engineering choice. Theorem (Impossibility Theorem) . For any query space \mathcal{Q} containing non-trivial queries (requiring integration of available distributed knowledge), no LLM can simultaneously generate truthful (non-hallucinatory) responses, satisfy the semantic information conservation principle, guarantee revelation of relevant knowledge, and enforce knowledge-constrained optimality of responses. No matter how hard we should try to train LLM to generate responses that are perfectly aligned with query context and do not create factually incorrect, inconsistent, or fabricated statements, the trained LLM will always violate some aspects of what we may call a reasonable response. It may ignore available knowledge, it may present fabricated knowledge, it may be a reformulated query without any novel observations, or it may be a lucky hallucination guessing the correct answer without any support in the encoded knowledge. And so on, because there is no free lunch when there are inevitable trade-offs of inference, and we must accept that. Despite its name, the theorem should be interpreted as a constructive result. It offers a precise characterization of the fundamental tradeoffs in LLM design and provides several key insights: Fundamental Trade-offs : Rather than viewing hallucination as a bug to be eliminated, we should understand that different applications require different balances among truthfulness, information utilization, and response completeness. Architectural Guidance : The result suggests investigating multi-component architectures where specialized modules handle different aspects of the trade-off. Safety-critical applications might prioritize truthfulness modules and conservation of information, while creative applications could emphasize hallucinatory responses. Training objectives should explicitly balance these competing demands based on intended use cases. Research Directions : The proposed mathematical (and philosophical) framework opens new research paths at the intersection of mathematical game theory, information theory, and neural network inference, providing tools for analyzing and optimizing LLM behavior. To my best knowledge, unlike previous work treating hallucination as a statistical or architectural phenomenon, the game-theoretic approach offers the first formal proof of fundamental limitations in the inference process, explaining precisely why these limitations exist and how to work optimally within them . 2 Related Work Research on LLM hallucinations spans mechanistic interpretability, probabilistic frameworks, and empirical mitigation techniques. Below we present selected works in that domains. The auction-theoretic impossibility framework in this paper offers a fundamentally novel perspective distinct from these existing approaches. 2.1 Mechanistic Interpretability Mechanistic interpretability research examines internal LLM processes to identify hallucination origins. Yu et al. yu2024mechanisticunderstandingmitigationlanguage identify two failure modes: knowledge enrichment hallucinations from insufficient subject-attribute knowledge in lower MLP layers, and answer extraction hallucinations from failures in upper-layer attention heads selecting correct object attributes. Studies characterizing factual knowledge storage and retrieval complement our framework by providing empirical evidence of competing "agents" within LLM architectures. Meng et al. meng2023locatingeditingfactualassociations demonstrated methods for locating and editing factual associations, revealing how knowledge representations can be manipulated. Geva et al. geva2023dissecting identified a three-step factual recall process: (1) enriching last-subject position representations with subject-related attributes, (2) propagating relation information to predictions, and (3) querying

Read the complete text