Emergent Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless deconfinement in super-Coulombic plasmas

Ayush De, Leo Radzihovsky, Snir Gazit · 2025

Read Emergent Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless deconfinement in super-Coulombic plasmas by Ayush De, Leo Radzihovsky, Snir Gazit (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-05461.txt.

Introduction

A two-dimensional gas of charges that attract and repel over very long range might be expected to free its charges at any temperature. Ayush De, Leo Radzihovsky, and Snir Gazit simulated such super-Coulombic plasmas with large, exact Monte Carlo runs and found the opposite. As temperature rises the gas passes from bound pairs to free charges through a transition of the classic vortex-unbinding kind.

The surprise is explained by screening: the plasma rearranges so that, at large distances, its forces look like ordinary electric ones. The team confirmed that hidden force law with a new test-charge method and measured the crossover scale. They report the behaviour holds across different force laws and densities, a universal pattern rather than a quirk of one model.

Catalog record

CREATORAyush De, Leo Radzihovsky, Snir Gazit
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE38 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-05461

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Emergent Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless deconfinement in super-Coulombic plasmas Ayush De, Leo Radzihovsky, Snir Gazit Abstract We study the statistical mechanics of two-dimensional “super-Coulombic” plasmas, namely, neutral plasmas with power-law interactions longer-ranged than Coulomb. To that end, we employ numerically exact large-scale Monte Carlo simulations. Contrary to naive energy-entropy arguments, we observe a charge confinement-deconfinement transition as a function of temperature. Remarkably, the transition lies in the Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) universality class. Our results corroborate recent dielectric medium and renormalization group calculations predicting effective long-scale Coulomb interactions in microscopically super-Coulombic gases. We explicitly showcase this novel dielectric screening phenomenon, capturing the emergent Coulomb potential and the associated crossover length scale. This is achieved by utilizing a new test charge based methodology for determining effective inter-particle interactions. Lastly, we show that this Coulomb emergence and the associated BKT transition occur universally across generic interactions and densities. Introduction – Berezinskii-Kosterlitz-Thouless (BKT) criticality is a paradigmatic example of a phase transition beyond Landau’s theory of symmetry breaking. The BKT universality class has been shown to underlie critical phenomena in numerous physical systems displaying superfluidity and superconductivity in thin films Bishop and Reppy 1978 ; Bishop and Reppy 1980 , Josephson junction arrays Resnick et al. 1981 ; Newrock et al. 2000 , ultracold gases Hadzibabic et al. 2006 ; Murthy et al. 2015 , polaritonic systems Nitsche et al. 2014 ; Caputo et al. 2018 , among others. The underlying physical mechanism of the BKT transition is a proliferation of vortices, acting as disorder operators in the statistical mechanics of two-dimensional U(1) symmetric models Kosterlitz and Thouless 1973 ; José et al. 1977 . The transition is then driven by the subtle energy-entropy competition between the energy cost of unbinding opposite charge vortex pairs and the configurational entropy gain. Crucially, both follow logarithmic scaling with respect to the spatial separation between vortex anti-vortex pairs. The resulting phase diagram, when described in terms of a vortex Coulomb gas, features a low-temperature phase with confined, tightly bound vortex pairs and a high-temperature phase characterized by deconfined, free vortices. (a) (b) (c) (d) Figure 1: Monte Carlo snapshots of a super-Coulombic gas with confining power-law, r^{\sigma} , interaction, with \sigma=0.25 and particle density \rho=0.01 in its (a) confined and (b) deconfined phases separated by a BKT phase transition. The orange (blue) circles indicate positive (negative charges). (c) The power law vs temperature phase diagram for fixed particle density \rho=0.01 . (d) The particle density vs temperature phase diagram for fixed power law \sigma=0.25 . The red points indicate BKT critical points observed using our simulations; the phase boundary is constructed by interpolating between them. Recent experimental interest in systems with arbitrary long-range interactions Yan et al. 2013 ; Bruzewicz et al. 2019 ; Bendkowsky et al. 2009 ; Dunning et al. 2024 ; DeSalvo et al. 2015 has posed questions about the fate of the BKT transition in the presence of a more general power-law interaction, r^{\sigma} Giachetti et al. 2021 ; Defenu et al. 2023 ; Radzihovsky and Toner 2024 ; Giachetti et al. 2023 ; Yao et al. 2024 ; Xiao et al. 2024 . In particular, two recent works Giachetti et al. 2023 ; Radzihovsky and Toner 2024 , studying the long-wavelength physics of super-Coulombic gases, i.e., gases with longer-ranged than Coulomb interactions, proposed, by means of Renormalization Group (RG) and dielectric screening (with a length-scale dependent dielectric function) calculations, that generic super-Coulombic gases universally display a screening crossover to an effective Coulomb description. This emergence is also expected in higher dimensions Herbut and Seradjeh 2003 ; Radzihovsky and Toner 2024 . An intriguing corollary of the aforementioned Coulomb emergence is that two-dimensional super-Coulombic gases were predicted Radzihovsky and Toner 2024 ; Giachetti et al. 2023 to display a BKT class confinement-deconfinement transition at finite temperatures. This prediction starkly contrasts with the expectation of confinement at all temperatures, based on a naive energy-entropy argument that neglects screening. In this Letter, we employ numerically exact calculations to showcase the super-Coulombic to Coulomb crossover and the subsequent BKT confinement-deconfinement transition in a concrete microscopic model. We identify low (high) temperature confining (deconfining) phases, see Figs. 1a and 1b . To probe the emergent Coulomb interaction at long distances, we introduce a numerical method for extracting the interaction between test charges and determining the associated RG flow. The effective Coulomb coupling displays the universal Nelson-Kosterlitz jump Nelson and Kosterlitz 1977 at the deconfinement transition point, as expected for the BKT universality. The emergent Coulomb coupling in the bound phase increases sharply at low temperatures, reflecting power-law screening Radzihovsky and Toner 2024 , unlike conventional Coulomb gases, where it saturates to its bare value. Lastly, by studying this problem for different power laws and densities, we establish the generality of Coulomb emergence across a wide range of microscopic parameters and interaction forms, as shown in Figs. 1c and 1d . Microscopic model – We consider a two-dimensional super-Coulombic gas governed by the Hamiltonian: H=-K\sum_{i<j}n_{i}n_{j}\left|\frac{r_{i}-r_{j}}{a}\right|^{\sigma}, (1) where \sigma>0 dictates the interaction power law, K>0 is the bare coupling constant. n_{i}=\pm 1 are unit charges respecting the \sum_{i}n_{i}=0 charge neutrality constraint. a is a microscopic cut-off scale that in this study is fixed by the diameter of hard-sphere charges. For the case of a Coulomb plasma (i.e. the limit \sigma\to 0 ), the interaction takes a logarithmic form, \log(r/a) . Energy entropy balance – It is insightful to revisit the conventional energy versus entropy balance argument, as is presented for the BKT transition in the context of a 2D Coulomb gas, but for the case of our model. Following Eq. 1 , it can be inferred that separating a pair of bound super-Coulombic charges by a distance R incurs an energy cost \sim R^{\sigma} . On the other hand, the additional degree of freedom in the form of their relative spatial distance results in an entropy gain that scales as \sim\log(R) . Since in the limit R\to\infty , R^{\sigma}\gg\log(R) , the free energy is always reduced by minimizing the energy at all temperatures. One may thus naively expect super-Coulombic plasmas to always exhibit a single confined phase, consisting of bound charges. This contrasts with Coulomb gases, where the logarithmic scaling of both energy and entropy results in a confinement-deconfinement BKT transition at finite temperatures. The aforementioned argument is incorrect, as it neglects the predicted screening effects Radzihovsky and Toner 2024 ; Giachetti et al. 2023 resulting in a super-Coulombic to Coulomb crossover, as will be demonstrated explicitly in this work. Effective Coulomb coupling – The standard technique for studying the BKT transition in Coulomb gases involves tracking the effective Coulomb coupling as an order parameter. Typically, the renormalization of the bare Coulomb coupling is extracted in terms of the charge density-density correlation function SM ; Orkoulas and Panagiotopoulos 1996 . However, for a super-Coulombic gas displaying Coulomb emergence, the bare Coulomb coupling or the charge densities of emergent Coulomb particles are hard to define precisely, rendering the standard approach inapplicable. To address this, we devise a method to directly extract the effective potential experienced by fixed test charges in the presence of a super-Coulombic plasma medium. To that end, we consider a pair of opposite static test charges positioned at x_{1},x_{2} in the

Read the complete text