Early linguistic fingerprints of online users who engage with conspiracy communities

Francesco Corso, Giuseppe Russo, Francesco Pierri, Gianmarco De Francisci Morales · 2025

Read Early linguistic fingerprints of online users who engage with conspiracy communities by Francesco Corso, Giuseppe Russo, Francesco Pierri, Gianmarco De Francisci Morales (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-05086.txt.

Introduction

Four researchers asked whether people who post in conspiracy forums write in a telltale style when they post elsewhere on Reddit, in a 2025 study. The team drew on more than five hundred million comments posted over ten years. They compared users active in conspiracy spaces with other users in general forums on news, humor, and hobbies. The question was whether word habits alone could set the two groups apart.

Programs trained on word use sorted the groups with about eighty-seven percent accuracy across more than twenty forum tests. Yet one global program did far worse than programs trained for each forum on its own. Style, it seems, bends to local norms even for these users. The authors argue that checks and responses must be tuned to each space rather than applied with one rule everywhere.

Catalog record

CREATORFrancesco Corso, Giuseppe Russo, Francesco Pierri, Gianmarco De Francisci Morales
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE61 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-05086

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Early linguistic fingerprints of online users who engage with conspiracy communities Francesco Corso, Giuseppe Russo, Francesco Pierri, Gianmarco De Francisci Morales Abstract Online social media platforms are often seen as catalysts for radicalization, as they provide spaces where extreme beliefs can take root and spread, sometimes leading to real-world consequences. Conspiracy theories represent a specific form of radicalization that is notoriously resistant to online moderation strategies. One explanation for this resilience is the presence of a “conspiratorial mindset”, a cognitive framework that fundamentally shapes how conspiracy believers perceive reality. However, the role of this mindset in driving online user behavior remains poorly understood. In this study, we analyze the psycholinguistic patterns of Reddit users who become active in a prominent conspiracy community by examining their activity in mainstream communities, which allows us to isolate linguistic markers for the presence of a conspiratorial mindset. We find that conspiracy-engaged individuals exhibit distinct psycholinguistic fingerprints, setting them apart from the general user population. Crucially, this signal is already evident in their online activity prior to joining the conspiracy community, allowing us to predict their involvement years in advance. These findings suggest that individuals who adopt conspiracy beliefs do not radicalize through community involvement, but possess a pre-existing conspiratorial mindset, which predisposes them to seek out and join extreme communities. By challenging the view that online social media platforms actively radicalize users into conspiracy theory beliefs, our findings suggest that standard moderation strategies have limited impact on curbing radicalization, and highlight the need for more targeted, supportive interventions that encourage disengagement from extremist narratives. Ultimately, this work contributes to fostering safer online and offline environments for public discourse. keywords computational social science, conspiracy theories, online social networks, radicalization, Reddit 1 Main Conspiracy theories are not merely fringe beliefs; they are influential, alternative narratives that explain events through the actions of secretive, malevolent groups douglas_understanding_2019 . While often dismissed as speculation, their real-world consequences are substantial: they have been linked to vaccine hesitancy and public health risks enders2022relationship , prompting official responses from public institutions. 1 1 1 EU Commission, 2021 In more extreme cases, they can pose a threat to democratic institutions themselves---as exemplified by the January 6th, 2021 attack on the U.S. Capitol, which was partly fueled by conspiracy-driven rhetoric. 2 2 2 Washington Post, 2021 These narratives can also serve as gateways to more radical ideologies, gradually reshaping individuals’ perception of reality basit2021conspiracy . At the heart of this process might lie the “conspiratorial mindset,” a cognitive predisposition to perceive and interpret events as the result of powerful, hidden actors imhoff2014speaking ; sutton201414 ; douglas2017psychology . Unlike rigid extremist ideologies, conspiracy theories act as a flexible interpretive lens that fosters deep distrust toward institutions, experts, and mainstream media van2022suspicion , which abstracts from specific conspiracy theories beliefs stromback2024disentangling ; frenken2021uniform . This mindset influences a broad range of behaviors, from political alignment imhoff2022conspiracy to health decisions kroke2024conspiracy , and encourages the rejection of official narratives in favor of often implausible alternatives. Despite extensive research on the detection and prevalence of conspiracy theories on online platforms tangherlini_automated_2020 ; faddoul_longitudinal_2020 ; samory2018spy , how conspiratorial beliefs reveal themselves in mainstream online spaces remains largely underexplored. In this study, we investigate the presence and influence of a conspiratorial mindset on patterns of self-expression in online environments. Specifically, we investigate whether this mindset is reflected in psycholinguistic fingerprints among users who will eventually engage with dedicated online conspiracy spaces when they participate in more conventional communities. We focus on language—both as the primary medium of online interaction and as a crucial indicator of ideological change Naab2023 . Furthermore, we use Reddit as our primary case study due to its large-scale, publicly accessible dataset and a unique structure based on topical communities, which enables the analysis of users’ behavior across both fringe and conventional communities. The role of social media as a vector of radicalization remains contested gunton2022impact , with ongoing debates over the extent to which online platforms expose users to extreme beliefs, reinforce polarization, and facilitate the spread of misinformation cinelli2021echo ; sunstein2018republic . Radicalization on online platforms is usually described as a gradual process, in which individuals first adopt extremist narratives before eventually becoming active participants in dedicated communities klein2019pathways ; phadke2022pathways ; samory_conspiracies_2018 . The conspiratorial mindset theory offers an alternative perspective, suggesting that individuals hold background cognitive schema that leads them to seek out more extremist content to fuel their convictions, akin to the dynamics of selective exposure festinger1957theory . As it has been argued, this phenomenon can accelerate ideological shifts by continuous self-exposure to reinforcing narratives, thereby deepening their engagement with radical ideas marwick2022far . In this scenario, it is crucial to understand whether joining a conspiracy community affects individuals’ behavior in more conventional and mainstream spaces. If conspiratorial narratives act as a gateway to more extreme worldviews, this transition might be observed by analyzing users’ self-expression over time buehling2025veiled . In particular, by focusing on psycholinguistic patterns, we aim to highlight potential pathways of radicalization and assess whether engaging with a conspiracy community changes the users’ communicative style williams2024does . Our findings provide robust evidence that the conspiratorial mindset is reflected in the psycholinguistic patterns of users engaging with conspiracy communities. This effect largely disappears when considering alternative target communities, further underscoring the distinctiveness of the linguistic patterns associated with the conspiracy mindset. Notably, this signature is not time-dependent: it does not manifest only after a user starts engaging with a conspiracy community. Instead, individuals who will eventually become active in a conspiracy community already exhibit signs of the conspiratorial mindset years prior to their involvement, challenging the idea that social media are the primary driver of radicalization. The findings of this study offer important insights into the dynamics of online conspiracy discussion, the challenges of governing digital platforms, and the enduring persistence of conspiracy beliefs. The presence of psycholinguistic markers of the conspiratorial mindset in individuals who later engage with dedicated conspiracy communities calls into question the view that radicalization is driven by exposure alone, highlighting instead the role of underlying psychological factors. Our findings highlight the limited effectiveness of standard moderation strategies in limiting radicalization and suggest the need for more targeted interventions. Rather than relying on punitive actions such as banning, platforms should explore progressive moderation approaches that support users in disengaging from extremist narratives and reintegrating into healthier communities costello2024durably , including preventive strategies such as educational initiatives dyer2019effect , media literacy programs kunst2024leveraging , and early detection frameworks o2023efficacy . Finally, examining how individuals predisposed to conspiratorial thinking participate in mainstream discussions can inform strategies to foster more inclusive and constructive online spaces. Such insights are crucial for addressing the broader societal conditions that fuel conspiracy beliefs and for rebuilding trust in institutions and society more broadly Drazkiewicz2022 . Figure 1: Directed Acyclic Graph (DAG) showing the design of our research. The two highlighted arcs show the hypotheses we investigate and test with our analyses, respectively RQ1: Conspiracy Mindset \rightarrow Language on mainstream Reddit and RQ2: Engage in r/conspiracy \rightarrow Language on mainstream Reddit . 2 Results The goal of this work is to quantify the presence of the conspiratorial mindset and the effects of

Read the complete text