Localised and Delocalised Charge Distribution in a Diamine Cation and Rydberg Excited State: A Challenging Test for Density Functionals

Benedikt O. Birgisson, Marta Gałyńska, Hemanadhan Myneni, Elvar Ö. Jónsson, Ragnar Bjornsson, Hannes Jónsson · 2025

Read Localised and Delocalised Charge Distribution in a Diamine Cation and Rydberg Excited State: A Challenging Test for Density Functionals by Benedikt O. Birgisson, Marta Gałyńska, Hemanadhan Myneni, Elvar Ö. Jónsson, Ragnar Bjornsson, Hannes Jónsson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-05077.txt.

Introduction

Benedikt Birgisson and five colleagues wrote a 2025 chemistry paper testing the accuracy of density functionals, the workhorse approximations of quantum chemistry. Their test case is a molecule called DMP, in both its ionized form and an excited state. The puzzle is whether its electric charge spreads over the whole molecule or settles on one half.

Getting this balance wrong is a known weakness of many functionals. The team ran calculations with functionals from every rung of the standard hierarchy, from the simplest local approximation to a machine-learned hybrid. They varied the share of exact exchange and applied self-interaction corrections. The study gives computational chemists a sharp benchmark for improving the tools used to model molecules.

Catalog record

CREATORBenedikt O. Birgisson, Marta Gałyńska, Hemanadhan Myneni, Elvar Ö. Jónsson, Ragnar Bjornsson, Hannes Jónsson
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-05077

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Localised and Delocalised Charge Distribution in a Diamine Cation and Rydberg Excited State: A Challenging Test for Density Functionals Benedikt O. Birgisson, Marta Gałyńska, Hemanadhan Myneni, Elvar Ö. Jónsson, Ragnar Bjornsson, Hannes Jónsson Abstract The balance between localised and delocalised electron distribution in the N,N’-dimethylpiperazine (DMP) molecule in the 3s Rydberg excited state and in the fully ionised DMP + provides a valuable test of density functionals, in particular the weight of Fock exchange (FE) in hybrid functionals and the scaling of explicit orbital-based self-interaction correction (SIC) applied to less elaborate functionals. We present results of calculations using density functionals of all rungs of Jacob’s ladder, ranging from LDA to the DM21 machine learned local hybrid as well as double hybrids. For DMP + , the commonly used hybrid functionals, such as PBE0(.25) with FE weight of 0.25, as well as PBE0(.32) with a weight of 0.32 only produce the more delocalised charge. The latter mimics the DM21 energy surface well. However, hybrid functionals with stronger FE, such as BHLYP and PBE0(.50) as well as some double hybrid functionals, also produce local energy minima corresponding to localised charge. When full SIC is applied to the PBE functional, an energy surface analogous to hybrid functionals with FE weight of 0.50 is obtained, while the scaling of SIC by 0.50, which has previously been shown to give improved atomisation energy and band gap of solids, only produces the more delocalised charge. For the 3s Rydberg excited state of DMP, two types of configurations with a localised hole are obtained in calculations using the PBE0(.32) functional, in addition to the delocalised hole, but only the latter is found with the PBE functional, showing that a significant reduction of the self-interaction error is needed in order to obtain agreement between density functional calculations and experimental measurements of the Rydberg state. † † affiliation: Science Institute and Faculty of Physical Sciences, U. of Iceland, 107 Reykjavík, Iceland † † affiliation: Science Institute and Faculty of Physical Sciences, U. of Iceland, 107 Reykjavík, Iceland † † affiliation: Faculty of Chemistry, Nicolaus Copernicus University in Toruń, 87-100 Toruń, Poland † † affiliation: Science Institute and Faculty of Physical Sciences, U. of Iceland, 107 Reykjavík, Iceland † † affiliation: Science Institute and Faculty of Physical Sciences, U. of Iceland, 107 Reykjavík, Iceland † † affiliation: Laboratoire Chimie et Biologie des Métaux, F-38054 Grenoble, France † † email: [email protected] † † affiliation: Science Institute and Faculty of Physical Sciences, U. of Iceland, 107 Reykjavík, Iceland The need for accurate description of the relative energy of a localised and a delocalised electron distribution is a challenge that often arises in the theoretical description of molecules, solid materials and biological systems. In mixed-valence compounds, for example, where two equivalent or near-equivalent redox sites are present, ionisation can result in the formation of either a localised or a delocalised electronic distribution. Demadis et al. 2001 ; Hankache and Wenger 2011 ; Heckmann and Lambert 2012 ; Blondin and Girerd 1990 ; Solomon et al. 2008 Accurate description of these phenomena in electronic structure calculations has turned out to be a significant challenge, revealing deficiencies in both wave function theory (WFT) and density functional theory (DFT) based approaches. In commonly used implementations of DFT, i.e. Kohn-Sham functionals, an overemphasis on delocalisation is often present. Cohen et al. 2012 ; Bryenton et al. 2022 The semi-local functional form for the exchange-and-correlation term leads to incomplete cancellation of the non-local self-interaction error in the Kohn-Sham estimate of the classical Coulomb interaction, the Hartree term, since it is based only on the total electron density rather than orbital densities. In Hartree-Fock (HF) calculations, however, where the self-interaction in the Hartree term gets cancelled out by the self-interaction in the infinite range, non-local Fock exchange (FE), there is an overemphasis on localised states. Hybrid functionals, where FE evaluated using the Kohn-Sham orbitals is included with some weight coefficient, can improve the balance between localised and delocalised states but the calculated results depend strongly on the value chosen for this parameter. The most commonly used hybrid functionals, with a weight of 0.20 to 0.25, can still overemphasise delocalisation. A common pragmatic way of dealing with this problem is to increase the weight of FE. For some systems a value of around 0.35 or even larger has been found to be necessary in order to describe correctly molecules with localised electron distribution. Parthey and Kaupp 2014 In the original hybrid functional Becke 1993 where the weight coefficient was derived approximately using the adiabatic connection formula, the FE weight is even larger, 0.50. However, too large value can lead to an erroneously localised description of intrinsically delocalised electron distribution. DFT functionals can be tested against high-level WFT results for small enough molecules. Kaupp and coworkers have discussed several inorganic Kaupp et al. 2016 ; Klawohn et al. 2018 and organic mixed-valence systems Kaupp et al. 2011 ; Renz et al. 2009 ; Renz et al. 2012 ; Renz and Kaupp 2012 ; Kaupp et al. 2016 that are challenging for DFT approaches. Overall, global hybrid functionals with a factor of 0.35 to 0.45 for FE, as well as range-separated and local hybrid functionals, have been found to give good agreement with high-level WFT calculations in many cases. Range-separated hybrid DFT functionals have recently been shown to describe delocalisation well in some organic mixed valence molecules. Körzdörfer and Brédas 2014 A less explored way of dealing with the problem is to apply explicit self-interaction correction such as the one proposed by Perdew and Zunger (PZ-SIC) Perdew and Zunger 1981 . There, a correction is made for each orbital separately and thus it represents an independent electron approach and the full correction is found to lead to results similar to HF calculations in many cases, such as for the atomisation energy of molecules. Klüpfel et al. 2012 A scaling of the PZ-SIC by a half based on a justification analogous to the adiabatic connection argument used in the derivation of the original hybrid functional Becke 1993 has been shown to give good estimates of atomisation energy as well as band gaps of solids. Jónsson 2011 ; Klüpfel et al. 2012 However, in order to obtain the correct - 1/r long range form of the effective potential, which is, in particular, important for the description of the diffuse electron in a Rydberg state of a molecule or a loosely bound anion, the full PZ-SIC is required. Gudmundsdóttir et al. 2013 ; Zhang et al. 2016 PZ-SIC has been implemented in a variational, self-consistent way with complex valued orbitals Lehtola et al. 2016 ; Ivanov et al. 2021 ; Ivanov et al. 2021 ; Mortensen and et al. 2024 and shown to give good results in studies of several molecules and solids, in particular where the delocalisation error is significant in commonly used Kohn-Sham functionals. Gudmundsdóttir et al. 2015 In a recent effort, machine learning has been used to construct density functionals of the local hybrid form where, among other things, data on the balance between localised and delocalised states is included in the training. Kirkpatrick et al. 2021 This deep mind functional, referred to as DM21, is generated by training a neural network

Read the complete text