Complexity reduction of physical models: an equation-free approach by means of scaling Journal: Proc. R. Soc. A
Simone Rusconi, Christina Schenk, Razvan Ceuca, Arghir Zarnescu, Elena Akhmatskaya · 2025
Read Complexity reduction of physical models: an equation-free approach by means of scaling Journal: Proc. R. Soc. A by Simone Rusconi, Christina Schenk, Razvan Ceuca, Arghir Zarnescu, Elena Akhmatskaya (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-05029.txt.
Introduction
Simone Rusconi and co-authors propose, in a 2025 paper, a general recipe for slimming down complex physical models. Big models carry many parameters and scales, and one cure is to drop the terms that barely matter. Their method needs no peeking at the model's equations: it works only from the scales and dimensions in play, and it watches against keeping too many parameters.
The approach also gives numbers, not just hunches: thresholds on parameter values mark where a simpler model keeps the predictions that count. The authors show the recipe on the classic projectile model, a friendly test case. They note a side benefit for fitting models to data, since fewer parameters mean steadier estimates. The work speaks to modelers across physics and engineering who face bloated descriptions.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Simone Rusconi, Christina Schenk, Razvan Ceuca, Arghir Zarnescu, Elena Akhmatskaya |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 94 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-05029
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Complexity reduction of physical models: an equation-free approach by means of scaling Journal: Proc. R. Soc. A Simone Rusconi, Christina Schenk, Razvan Ceuca, Arghir Zarnescu, Elena Akhmatskaya Abstract The description of complex physical phenomena often involves sophisticated models that rely on a large number of parameters, with many dimensions and scales. One practical way to simplify that kind of models is to discard some of the parameters, or terms of underlying equations, thus giving rise to reduced models. Here, we propose a general approach to obtaining such reduced models. The method is independent of the model in use, i.e., equation-free, depends only on the interplay between the scales and dimensions involved in the description of the phenomena, and controls over-parametrization. It also quantifies conditions for asymptotic models by providing explicitly computable thresholds on values of parameters that allow for reducing complexity of a model, while preserving essential predictive properties. Although our focus is on complexity reduction, this approach may also help with calibration by mitigating the risks of over-parameterization and instability in parameter estimation. The benefits of this approach are discussed in the context of the classical projectile model. 1 Introduction When dealing with complex models, it is often useful to consider an asymptotic analysis with the aim of simplifying the model under consideration. Such an approach identifies a parameter \varepsilon>0 and investigates the limit for \varepsilon\to 0 of the solutions to the given equations. When \varepsilon is small, the solutions to the model considered in first place can be accurately reproduced by the solutions of the same equations with \varepsilon formally set to 0 , i.e., with some terms neglected. However, in general, it is hard to understand how small such an \varepsilon must be to consider it “small enough” and, then, to allow the use of solutions to the simplified model. In particular, for models involving very different scales or over-parametrization, reducing complexity and applying appropriate scaling becomes crucial for preventing instability in calibration [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] . This turns to be even more critical when feeding synthetic data from physical models into machine learning models [ 4 ] , as imbalances or miscalibrations in the data can significantly affect model performance [ 5 ] . Proper scaling ensures that synthetic data reflects realistic parameter distributions, helping to mitigate overfitting and instability in parameter estimation [ 1 ] . Ultimately, scaling improves calibration, stabilizes predictions and may lead to more reliable machine learning model training, even when using synthetic data. Our approach is based on already introduced methodologies, that we called Optimal Scaling ( OS ) [ 6 ] and Optimal Scaling with Constraints ( OSC ) [ 7 ] . Similarly to traditional nondimensionalization approaches, those allow recasting dimensional equations into unitless form. However, in contrast to traditional techniques, they do not require a problem-dependent insight into the phenomenon under consideration. In addition, they ensure a strong reduction of ranges of magnitudes assumed by the equations’ coefficients, provide accurate estimation of characteristic features of considered systems and allow reducing round-off and numerical errors. Such approaches were applied in [ 6 , 7 ] to the prospective Population Balance Model [ 8 ] for Latex Particles Morphology Formation (LPMF PBM) [ 9 , 10 ] . First, in [ 6 ] , we obtained dimensionless scaled equations with minimized variation of the relevant quantities. Such a feature was beneficial in diminishing numerical errors, and avoiding unphysical behavior of the computed solution. Second, in [ 7 ] , a quantitative criterion for locating regions of slow and fast aggregation was introduced to derive a family of dimensionless LPMF PBM of reduced complexity. Moreover, in [ 6 ] , the Optimal Scaling was also applied to liquid crystal and quantum models, helping to decrease the range of magnitudes assumed by the involved quantities, without compromising on accuracy of characteristic features of considered systems [ 11 , 12 ] . Here, we present an advanced variant of the Optimal Scaling approaches which inherits benefits of its predecessors and, in addition, takes control of over-parametrization. We refer to this method as Generalized Optimal Scaling ( GOS ). The proposed methodology can provide a quantitative criterion for identifying those values of physical parameters that allow discarding a few terms in the considered equations without significantly modifying their solutions. This technique does not depend on the model, and as such its application to any specific model will produce results which exhibit a certain dependency on the model, that needs to be investigated numerically. In order to concretely illustrate our derivations and findings, we consider the classical projectile model. The paper is structured as follows. Section 2 clarifies the employed notations and summarizes the projectile model we use in this work as a case study. Section 3 outlines the main achievements of the proposed scaling methods [ 6 , 7 ] and puts the OSC method, previously formulated in the context of the LPMF PBM, into a general framework. Section 4 improves further the generalized OSC by extending its functionalities with ability to reduce to its minimum the number of parameters employed in a model. A detailed formulation of the resulting GOS method is presented in Table 1 in comparison with the original OSC method. In Section 5 , we test the Optimal Scaling methodologies on the projectile model. Section 6 provides conclusions and discusses the capabilities of presented techniques. 2 Prerequisites 2.1 Employed Notation Through all this work, the following notation is employed. • We denote any scalar quantity \tilde{q} as \tilde{q}\coloneqq q\,[\tilde{q}], (1) being [\tilde{q}] the dimensions of \tilde{q} , i.e., its units of measure, and q the numerical value associated with \tilde{q} in the chosen units [\tilde{q}] . • The symbol \ll is used when a strictly positive number a is at least an order of magnitude smaller than another strictly positive number b , i.e., a\ll b\Leftrightarrow a/b\leq 10^{-1} . • The symbol \approx is used when the two strictly positive numbers a and b have similar magnitudes, i.e., a\approx b\Leftrightarrow 10^{-1}<a/b<10 . • The superscript T means “transpose”, e.g., the matrix \textbf{M}^{T} is the transpose of M . • The acronyms OS , OSC and GOS refer to Optimal Scaling, Optimal Scaling with Constraints and Generalized Optimal Scaling, respectively. 2.2 The classical projectile model: scaling strategies We choose the classical projectile model as an application for the scaling approaches considered in this work. First, we wish to discuss some possible strategies for scaling this model in the context of the Optimal Scaling to highlight the ideas behind the scaling methods under study. The rigorous scaling of the model is presented in detail in Section 5 . A ball is thrown vertically upward from a certain height above the surface of the Earth. The height \tilde{y}(\tilde{t}) reached at time \tilde{t} is measured in meters, while the elapsed time \tilde{t} in seconds, i.e., [\tilde{y}]=\mathrm{m} , [\tilde{t}]=\mathrm{s} . As presented in [ 13 ] , the variable \tilde{y} satisfies the Ordinary Differential Equation \frac{d^{2}\tilde{y}}{d\tilde{t}^{2}}=-\frac{\tilde{g}\,\tilde{R}^{2}}{(\tilde{y}+\tilde{R})^{2}},\quad\forall\tilde{t}\geq\tilde{t}_{0}\coloneqq 0\,\mathrm{s},\quad\mbox{with}\quad\tilde{y}(\tilde{t}_{0})=\tilde{h}_{0},\quad\frac{d\tilde{y}}{d\tilde{t}}(\tilde{t}_{0})=\tilde{v}_{0}, (2) being \tilde{g} the gravitational acceleration, \tilde{R} the radius of the Earth, \tilde{h}_{0} and \tilde{v}_{0} the initial height and velocity, respectively. As indicated in [ 14 ] , the dimensionless counterpart of ( 2