No Trade Under Verifiable Information
Spyros Galanis · 2025
Read No Trade Under Verifiable Information by Spyros Galanis (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-04944.txt.
Introduction
Spyros Galanis wrote a 2025 economics theory paper on when trade should not happen at all. Classic no-trade results say that rational traders who share the same starting beliefs cannot both expect to gain from a bet on an unknown outcome. Past work loosened rules about shared beliefs or perfect reasoning to explain real trading.
Galanis adds a fresh angle: what if private facts can be checked, so a claim about the true value can be verified by others? That checkable quality changes when deals can form. He draws lessons for insider trading rules, for thin markets with little trade, and for trading on public blockchains that use outside data feeds.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Spyros Galanis |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-04944
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
No Trade Under Verifiable Information Thanks: I would like to thank Arzé Karam, Jan Christoph Schlegel, an anonymous referee, and participants at the EC24 Workshop on Blockchains and Decentralized Finance at Yale, for useful comments. I would like to acknowledge financial support from the Economic and Social Research Council (ES/V004425/1). The previous title of this paper was “No Trade in a Blockchain”. Declarations of interest: none. Spyros Galanis Abstract No trade theorems examine conditions under which agents cannot agree to disagree on the value of a security which pays according to some state of nature, thus preventing any mutual agreement to trade. A large literature has examined conditions which imply no trade, such as relaxing the common prior and common knowledge assumptions, as well as allowing for agents who are boundedly rational or ambiguity averse. We contribute to this literature by examining conditions on the private information of agents that reveals, or verifies, the true value of the security. We argue that these conditions can offer insights in three different settings: insider trading, the connection of low liquidity in markets with no trade, and trading using public blockchains and oracles. JEL Classification Numbers: D82, D83, D84, G14, G41. Keywords: No trade, Blockchain, oracles, agreeing to disagree, information aggregation. 1 Introduction Contrary to common belief, asymmetric information by itself is insufficient to account for the high trading volumes observed in financial markets. Aumann, 1976 first showed that if agents share a common prior, then it cannot be common knowledge that they disagree on the probability they assign to an event. Milgrom and Stokey, 1982 use this result to show that if an allocation is ex ante Pareto efficient, then new asymmetric information will not lead to trade if agents are risk averse and hold concordant beliefs. There is now a large literature examining conditions that generate no trade, such as relaxing the common prior or common knowledge assumptions, or having agents who are boundedly rational or ambiguity averse. The current paper contributes to this literature by examining a different set of conditions that lead to no trade, specifically examining how agents’ private information can reveal or verify the true value of the security being traded. To provide an example, suppose that it is common knowledge that agent i always knows the true state and therefore the true value of the traded security. Then, no other agent would be willing to accept a buy or a sell order and there would be no trade, irrespective of whether the common prior assumption holds. The reason is that it cannot be common knowledge that we disagree on the value of the security, when it is common knowledge that agent i knows its value. Hence, accepting a trade ‘must’ be wrong if you are not agent i . Is it possible to further weaken this condition regarding the verifiability of the security’s value while still implying no trade? For example, we could require that the conjunction of everyone’s knowledge verifies the true value of the security. Alternatively, what if there is an agent who always knows whether the value of the security is above or below a certain threshold? Are these conditions necessary or sufficient to preclude trade? To motivate these questions, we provide three examples. The first is insider trading. The UK Criminal Justice Act 1993 states in Section 52 that ‘An individual who has information as an insider is guilty of insider dealing if […] he deals in securities that are price-affected securities in relation to the information’. This clause can be interpreted to mean that insider trading occurs when the insider possesses private information significant enough to affect the price—or underlying value—of the security. Put differently, the insider knows whether the value of the security lies above or below a certain threshold. Suppose that agents bet on the financial performance of a company, by trading a derivative on the price of its share. If an employee has insider information which always reveals the true value of the company, it is straightforward that she should not be allowed to trade. The reason is not that she can make huge profits by ‘taking advantage’ of other agents; it is because, if agents are rational, they will understand that this possibility exists and there will be no trade. A no trade result is detrimental in this case because the price of the derivative may not be sufficiently close to its true value, hence the market would fail in aggregating information. However, what if the employee’s knowledge is not enough to verify the true value of the company, but only whether it is above a certain threshold? By understanding the conditions on verifiability that result in no trade, we can determine under which conditions we should allow insiders to participate in a financial market. The second example links low liquidity with no trade. In 1998, the Long-Term Capital Management (LTCM) hedge fund was facing collapse due to the Russian debt default. The resulting fire sales and the costly disruptions for the world financial markets led the Federal Reserve Bank of New York to hold meetings to recapitalise LTCM. Cai, 2003 documents how market makers in the bonds futures market made huge profits using privileged information on customer order flow. What happens to trading if it becomes common knowledge that market insiders know which assets are distressed and therefore have a low value? If this leads to a no trade result, then the liquidity of the market will dry up, exacerbating the price impact of the insiders and the distressed sellers. Cai, 2003 shows, in fact, that market liquidity was very low during this episode. 1 1 1 Brunnermeier, 2001 provides an overview of the literature on asymmetric information and stock market crashes, whereas Brunnermeier and Pedersen, 2005 construct a model of predatory trading with distressed sellers. Karam and Bogoev, 2023 provide an empirical investigation of the connection between low liquidity and momentum trading. The third example is trading on the blockchain. A public blockchain enables a decentralised trading environment, where completing a transaction does not require a third party which custodies the agents’ assets, verifies their ownership, or executes the transaction. All transactions are public and trades are executed algorithmically using smart contracts , when pre-specified events occur. For example, paying an option on a real-world asset requires the reporting of its value within the blockchain, so that the smart contract can be executed. In practice, the verification and reporting of real-world events to the blockchain is performed by oracles . 2 2 2 Garratt and Monnet, 2022 show that oracles are unavoidable, because the truthful reporting about the realisation of publicly observed events cannot be implemented as a unique equilibrium in a completely decentralized environment. However, because users of the blockchain are anonymous, nothing stops oracles from participating in the trade, especially when they know it is going to be favourable for them. 3 3 3 More accurately, they are pseudonymous, because the history of transactions is public and can be linked to the unique addresses. Will this ‘insider trading’ make trading on the blockchain inherently undesirable? We examine conditions on the verifiability of securities (that is, revealing their true value) using three different environments.