Model selection using the H ii galaxy Hubble diagram 2026 Model selection using the H ii galaxy Hubble diagram – References
Jun-Jie Wei, Fulvio Melia · 2025
Read Model selection using the H ii galaxy Hubble diagram 2026 Model selection using the H ii galaxy Hubble diagram – References by Jun-Jie Wei, Fulvio Melia (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-04819.txt.
Introduction
Jun-Jie Wei and Fulvio Melia used glowing gas galaxies as cosmic mileposts in a 2025 paper. Ionized hydrogen galaxies and giant star-forming regions obey a brightness relation that makes them standard candles, reaching far deeper in redshift than supernovae. Above all with fresh James Webb discoveries pushing the sample past two hundred sources covering most of cosmic history. Such reach can arbitrate between rival expansion models.
Fitting the Hubble diagram, the authors report their preferred nonstandard model strongly favored over the standard flat model and a dark-energy variant by an information criterion. They flag a caveat themselves: an unknown intrinsic scatter in the candle relation. Fitted freely, erases the gap and strains the inferred matter density against satellite values. The claim is presented with its weakness attached.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jun-Jie Wei, Fulvio Melia |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 21 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-04819
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Model selection using the H ii galaxy Hubble diagram 2026 Model selection using the H ii galaxy Hubble diagram – References Jun-Jie Wei, Fulvio Melia Abstract The proposal to use H ii galaxies (HIIGx) and giant extragalactic H ii regions (GEHR) as standard candles to construct the Hubble diagram at redshifts beyond the current reach of Type Ia supernovae has gained considerable support recently with the addition of five new HIIGx discovered by JWST. The updated sample of 231 sources now extends the redshift range of these objects to z ∼ 7.5 z\sim 7.5 , mapping the Universe’s expansion over 95 % 95\% of its current age. In this Letter we use these sources for model selection, and show that the R h = c t R_{\rm h}=ct universe is strongly favored by this probe over both flat- Λ \Lambda CDM and w w CDM, with relative Bayesian Information Criterion probabilities of, respectively, 91.8 % 91.8\% , 7.4 % 7.4\% and 0.8 % 0.8\% . A possible caveat with these results, however, is that an unknown dispersion, σ int \sigma_{\rm int} , in the HIIGx standard candle relation can weaken the model comparisons. We find that the inclusion of σ int \sigma_{\rm int} as an additional, optimizable parameter makes the likelihoods of flat- Λ \Lambda CDM and R h = c t R_{\rm h}=ct about equal, though at the expense of creating ∼ 2.5 σ \sim 2.5\sigma tension between our inferred matter density Ω m \Omega_{\rm m} and its Planck -optimized value. 1 Introduction H ii galaxies (HIIGx) are massive and compact, with a total luminosity almost completely dominated by the starburst. Analogously, giant extragalactic H ii regions (GEHR) also contain massive bursts of star formation, though these sites tend to be located in the outer discs of late-type galaxies. In both cases, most of the luminosity is produced by rapidly forming stars surrounded by ionized hydrogen. The HIIGx and GEHR are physically similar ( Melnick et al. 1987 ) , with indistinguishable optical spectra, characterized by strong Balmer emission lines in \mathrm{H}\alpha and \mathrm{H}\beta due to the surrounding, ionized hydrogen ( Searle & Sargent 1972 ; Bergeron 1977 ; Terlevich & Melnick 1981 ; Kunth & Östlin 2000 ) . These galaxies can serve as standard candles (e.g., Melnick et al. 2000 ; Siegel et al. 2005 ) because both the number of ionizing photons and the turbulent velocity of the gas (which is dominated by the gravity of the stars) increase as the mass of the starburst component rises. The luminosity in \mathrm{H}\beta , L(\mathrm{H}\beta) , is thus correlated with the ionized gas velocity dispersion, \sigma ( Terlevich & Melnick 1981 ) , with a small enough scatter that allows it to be used as a cosmic distance indicator (see Melnick et al. 1987 ; Melnick et al. 1988 ; Fuentes-Masip et al. 2000 ; Melnick et al. 2000 ; Bosch et al. 2002 ; Telles 2003 ; Siegel et al. 2005 ; Bordalo & Telles 2011 ; Plionis et al. 2011 ; Mania & Ratra 2012 ; Chávez et al. 2012 ; Chávez et al. 2014 ; Terlevich et al. 2015 ). In their most recent analysis, Chávez et al. 2025 used this correlation to map the Hubble flow from z\sim 0 to \sim 7.5 in the context of flat- \Lambda CDM, optimizing the cosmological parameters over more than 12 Gyr of cosmic expansion. In this Letter , we continue to build support for their pioneering work by using these same data, and the L(\mathrm{H}\beta) - \sigma correlation, to carry out model selection among three principal cosmologies: (i) flat- \Lambda CDM, (ii) w CDM and (iii) the R_{\rm h}=ct universe. The latter scenario has been developed and tested using over 30 different kinds of data, demonstrating that the observations favour it over the current standard model throughout cosmic history, especially at high redshifts, where JWST has made several groundbreaking discoveries (see Melia 2023 ; Melia 2024a ; Melia 2024b ; Melia 2024c and references cited therein). A full description of this model and many of the already completed tests are described in Melia 2020 . 2 Observational data and methodology We take the data from Chávez et al. 2025 , which includes an ‘anchor’ sample of 36 GEHRs and nearby HIIGx with independently measured distance moduli analysed in Fernández Arenas et al. 2018 , a full sample of 181 HIIGx analysed in González-Morán et al. 2021 , 9 newer HIIGx from Llerena et al. 2023 , and the 5 HIIGx newly discovered by JWST ( de Graaff et al. 2024 ) , constituting a total sample of 231 sources. Table 1: Flux and gas velocity dispersion of H ii Galaxies discovered by JWST a . Name z \log\sigma \log F(\mathrm{H}\beta) (\mathrm{km\,s^{-1}}) (\mathrm{erg\,s^{-1}\,cm^{-2}}) JADES-NS–00016745 5.56616 \pm 0.00011 1.731 \pm 0.016 -17.64\pm 0.21 JADES-NS–10016374 5.50411 \pm 0.00007 1.785 \pm 0.014 -18.14\pm 0.20 JADES-NS–00019606 5.88979 \pm 0.00008 1.622 \pm 0.019 -18.11\pm 0.27 JADES-NS–00022251 5.79912 \pm 0.00007 1.621 \pm 0.011 -17.86\pm 0.11 JADES-NS–00047100 7.43173 \pm 0.00015 1.868 \pm 0.024 -17.62\pm 0.39 a Taken from Chávez et al. 2025 . The \mathrm{H}\beta luminosity is calculated from the reddening corrected \mathrm{H}\beta fluxes, F(\mathrm{H}\beta) , and their 1\sigma uncertainties, as described in Terlevich et al. 2015 (see also Calzetti et al. 2000 ): L(\mathrm{H}\beta)=4\pi D_{L}^{2}(z)F(\mathrm{H}\beta)\;, (1) where D_{L} is the cosmology-dependent luminosity distance at redshift z . To illustrate the quality of these data, we list the corrected dispersions and their 1\sigma uncertainties of the new sources discovered by JWST in column (3) of Table 1 , along with the measured \mathrm{H}\beta fluxes and their errors in column (4). To account for the known systematic discrepancy between velocity dispersion ( \sigma ) measurements derived from \mathrm{[O\ III]} and Balmer emission lines, Chávez et al. 2025 implemented a velocity correction of \mathrm{2.1\,km\,s^{-1}} ( Chávez et al. 2016 ) for three JWST-NIRSpec HIIGx lacking Balmer-line \sigma measurements. This calibration factor was established through comparative analysis of datasets containing both measurement types. For the flux corrections, all \mathrm{H}\beta measurements underwent extinction adjustment using the Gordon et al. 2003 dust extinction law. For JWST-NIRSpec observations, Chávez et al. 2025 determined extinction levels through the Balmer decrement method utilizing \mathrm{H}\alpha/\mathrm{H}\beta flux ratios. In cases where \mathrm{H}\alpha fluxes were unavailable, they adopted the mean extinction value derived from the VUDS/VANDELS sample as a systematic baseline. The rest of the catalog may be found in Chávez et al. 2025 and references cited therein. The emission-line luminosity correlation with the ionized gas velocity dispersion ( Chávez et al. 2012 ; Chávez et al. 2014 ; Terlevich et al. 2015 ) may be expressed in the form \log L(\mathrm{H}\beta)=\beta\log\sigma+\alpha\;, (2) where \beta is the slope and \alpha is a constant representing the logarithmic luminosity at \log\sigma=0 . Since this luminosity indicator is cosmology-dependent, however, the coefficients \alpha and \beta must be optimized simultaneously with the rest of the cosmological parameters. Then, with Equations ( 1 ) and ( 2 ), we may write the distance modulus as \mu_{\rm obs}=2.5\left[\beta\log\sigma+\alpha-\log F(\mathrm{H}\beta)\right]-100.2\;. (3) The corresponding error ( \sigma_{\mu_{\rm obs}} ) in \mu_{\rm obs} is found via error propagation, i.e., \sigma_{\mu_{\rm obs}}=2.5\left(\beta^{2}\sigma^{2}_{\log\sigma}+\sigma^{2}_{\log F}\right)^{1/2}\;, (4) in terms of the 1\sigma uncertainties, \sigma_{\log\sigma} and \sigma_{\log