A map of indefinite causal order
Jorge Escandón-Monardes · 2025
Read A map of indefinite causal order by Jorge Escandón-Monardes (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-04607.txt.
Introduction
Jorge Escandón-Monardes offers a guided map of indefinite causal order, a corner of quantum physics where the order of events itself can blur, in a 2025 paper. The idea grew from attempts to unite quantum theory with gravity, where a fixed timeline may not exist. The paper began as part of the author's doctoral thesis.
The tour starts with the motives for studying such order, then meets its best-known example, the quantum switch, where two operations can act in both orders at once. It moves on to the wider framework of process matrices and to layered causal structures. Live debates in the field close the map. The author aims it at newcomers who want the lay of the land before diving into research.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jorge Escandón-Monardes |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 52 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-04607
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A map of indefinite causal order Jorge Escandón-Monardes Abstract Prologue This document started as an excerpt of the PhD Thesis by Jorge Escandón, entitled “Indefinite causal order towards continuous-variable quantum systems”. It is intended as a map of indefinite causal order, which can be used to guide the trip of any explorer in the field. It offers an overview of the different approaches and the main ongoing debates in an organised way. But a map never replace the terrain, so it cannot be considered as an introduction to the field. All the tools required for a good trip are developed in the corresponding literature; they depend on the approach and the specific problems to be addressed. The map is written at a conceptual level, without mathematical technicalities while full of references. Anyone who is new to the field can use the map as a first sight before deciding where to start their journey, according to their own interest and background. Any experienced researcher can use the map to get quick access to all relevant literature in any of the threads related to indefinite causal order. The list of references is as complete as possible and is being updated continuously. We apologise for any work that may have been omitted and gently ask the reader to provide new references that they could consider relevant to the field. 1 Motivation Let me invite you to listen to your favourite song. Please, look for it and press play. Looking at this map can wait a few minutes. Ready? Cool! If you really played your favourite song, I could guess that you did not skip any part of it, you started listening from the first second of the recording until the last one. No pauses, no steps back and forth. A well defined sequence of sounds in a specific rhythm, carefully studied and performed by the artist. Now look for the album to which that song belongs. The order of the tracks in the album is most likely carefully designed as well, regardless you could choose the order in which you want to listen to them. If you want, you could randomly reshuffle the order of the tracks, although the whole experience would be a little different. Yes, you can reshuffle your playlist. But can you reshuffle the episodes of your life? Can you reshuffle the order of physical phenomena? In Nature, some things cannot happen if another event, its cause, has not occurred beforehand. For example, we cannot expect a water leakage from a pipeline before the pipeline breaks, nor a plane to fly before being built. The effects cannot precede their causes. The order of the events is well defined and arranged in a timeline that runs from past to future, as in the best of musical compositions. We say that physical events are sorted in a definite causal order . By the way, the arrow of time is like a stubborn leader who does not wait nor turn back for us. We better give up trying to pause or remix the song of Nature! Nevertheless, here we deal with indefinite causal order (ICO). There are good reasons to explore the possibility of events without a definite order. The first of them is to examine the boundaries of the theories that we use to describe the universe. The second reason is plain: quantum mechanics allows for it. In this “map” we are going to present the concept of indefinite causal order and make a quick journey through its different flavours. We will start with a broad conceptual motivation for studying ICO, based on the approach of Lucien Hardy to quantum gravity. Then, we will introduce the quantum switch, which is a particular instance of ICO, followed by the process matrices framework and the gravitational quantum switch. Finally, we will comment on some ongoing debates within the field. Now let us start the trip and let the arrow of time flow. 2 Hardy’s program Quantum theory and general relativity are the most succesful physical theories so far. They are able to explain together most of known physical phenomena. However, the golden dream of several physicists is to explain everything in one single theory involving both of them, that is, to achieve a sort of ‘‘quantum gravity’’ theory. The search for such a theory has been the motive for many researchers, Lucien Hardy among them. In 2007, introducing a very interesting approach, Hardy highligthed that general relativity is a deterministic theory where the causal structure is not predefined (it depends on the distribution of matter and energy), while quantum theory is a fundamentally probabilistic theory on a fixed causal structure 1 1 1 The causal structure of spacetime is usually understood as an order relation between spacetime points. Two points can be causally connected only if it is possible to send a signal from one to the other without surpassing the speed of light. We could say that the causal structure is a feature of the manifold describing spacetime, hence it depends on the distribution of matter and energy. In the case of quantum theory, we usually assume a fixed flat geometry, since quantum experiments are performed in a lab within a locally Minkowski spacetime. . According to his reasoning, a quantum gravity theory should be expected to combine the radical aspects of both theories. In other words, it should be a probabilistic theory with non-fixed causal structure [ 1 ] . In a subsequent paper [ 2 ] , Hardy discussed the consequences of an indefinite causal structure for computation. Algorithms, which are specific sequences of calculations, are the basic elements for computing. How could any algorithm be implemented or even defined when the causal structure and the order of events is non-fixed? Can an eventual quantum gravity computer outperform quantum and classical computers? By raising these questions Hardy implicitly invited the community of quantum information and quantum computation to join his research program. Inspired by Hardy’s ideas, at least three different approaches to indefinite causal order have been developed: • Quantum switch: The first approach is based solely on quantum computation. It defines a higher-order operation, called the quantum switch , which consists in the application of two or more quantum operations in a coherent superposition of different orders, controlled by an ancillary system. The order of the operations remains indefinite unless the control system is measured in the computational basis. The quantum switch is a process allowed by quantum mechanics and has been already implemented in a number of experiments. • Process matrices framework: In this approach, two parties are free to implement quantum operations on a quantum system according to the laws of quantum mechanics. Inside their labs there is a fixed Minkowski spacetime, but no causal structure is assumed out of the labs. Here, the connection between the outcomes and inputs of each lab is mediated by a process matrix . Physical processes such as state preparation, measurements and signalling from one lab to another can be fairly described by particular process matrices, but some non-physical processes are also allowed. Therefore, the process matrices framework goes beyond quantum mechanics, although without dealing with gravity explicitly. One important feature of