Mechanistic models for panel data: Analysis of ecological experiments with four interacting species
Bo Yang Department of Biostatistics, University of Michigan · 2025
Read Mechanistic models for panel data: Analysis of ecological experiments with four interacting species by Bo Yang Department of Biostatistics, University of Michigan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-04508.txt.
Introduction
Bo Yang and four co-authors work on how to study small pond-like systems over time, in a research paper from 2025. Their data come from lab tanks where two kinds of tiny water fleas live with an alga and a fungus that infects them.
Data like these are hard to use, because the systems change in curved, noisy ways and some parts cannot be seen. The team uses a step-by-step filtering method to fit math models to the tank data. That lets them estimate key values, test ideas, and compare models. The same tools could help with field data from many sites watched over time.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Bo Yang Department of Biostatistics, University of Michigan |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 63 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-04508
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Mechanistic models for panel data: Analysis of ecological experiments with four interacting species Bo Yang Department of Biostatistics, University of Michigan Abstract In an ecological context, panel data arise when time series measurements are made on a collection of ecological processes. Each process may correspond to a spatial location for field data, or to an experimental ecosystem in a designed experiment. Statistical models for ecological panel data should capture the high levels of nonlinearity, stochasticity, and measurement uncertainty inherent in ecological systems. Furthermore, the system dynamics may depend on unobservable variables. This study applies iterated particle filtering techniques to explore new possibilities for likelihood-based statistical analysis of these complex systems. We analyze data from a mesocosm experiment in which two species of the freshwater planktonic crustacean genus, Daphnia , coexist with an alga and a fungal parasite. Time series data were collected on replicated mesocosms under six treatment conditions. Iterated filtering enables maximization of the likelihood for scientifically motivated nonlinear partially observed Markov process models, providing access to standard likelihood-based methods for parameter estimation, confidence intervals, hypothesis testing, model selection and diagnostics. This toolbox allows scientists to propose and evaluate scientifically motivated stochastic dynamic models for panel data, constrained only by the requirement to write code to simulate from the model and to specify a measurement distribution describing how the system state is observed. Keywords: Panel Iterated Filtering; SIRJPF model; PanelPOMP; Daphnia 1 Introduction Biological dynamic systems often contain elements or processes that are difficult to observe, even under controlled experimental conditions. These unobservable, or latent, components are often crucial to understanding system dynamics, or are of scientific interest themselves. Additionally, both the measurements obtained from the systems in question and their underlying dynamic processes often exhibit substantial stochasticity. The combination of these two factors complicates data interpretation and analysis in ecological studies. Given these inherent properties of ecological systems, it is essential to use models that can account for key latent mechanisms and the stochastic nature of the system when conducting inference ( Young, 1998 ; Bjørnstad and Grenfell, 2001 ) . Partially observed Markov process (POMP) models, also known as hidden Markov models or state space models ( Bretó et al., 2009 ; Auger-Méthé et al., 2021 ) , comprise a class of models suited to the description of such systems, which describe the latent process using a Markovian representation. A POMP model is mechanistic if it is based on scientific principles, which is usually equivalent to providing a causal description of the system that can explain the consequence of interventions. Statistical inferences on mechanistic models can provide insight into key latent mechanisms. Further, statistical tests between rival mechanistic hypotheses can inform qualitative understanding about suitable model structures. Thus, mechanistic models are invaluable tools for addressing challenges in ecology ( Mouquet et al., 2015 ) . Collections of time series on related but disjoint systems are called panel data, also known as longitudinal data. Each component system is called a unit, and the units may be sites in a field study (e.g., plots, lakes) or independent mesocosms or microcosms in a controlled laboratory setting. Studying the entire panel may allow precision in statistical conclusions that is unattainable from a single unit. Alternatively, scientists may be interested in specific differences between the units, requiring the investigation of the entire panel of data. For either of these goals, investigation of panel data leads to the challenging statistical task of fitting a collection of related nonlinear or non-Gaussian vector-valued POMP models, called a PanelPOMP model ( Bretó et al., 2020 ; Breto et al., 2025 ) . In this article, we demonstrate how recent methodological advances can facilitate data analysis for such models in a multi-species system. We use data from a controlled experiment involving the population dynamics of two freshwater plankton species ( Daphnia dentifera and Daphnia lumholtzi ) together with an alga, Ankistrodesmus falcatus , as food and a fungal parasite, Metschnikowia bicuspidata , that can infect both Daphnia species. These data were collected by Searle et al., 2016a to investigate how the competition between the North American native D. dentifera and the invasive D. lumholtzi is modified by their differing susceptibility to the parasite. Advances in data collection make this experiment representative of a growing class of situations where panel data is available on a complex multi-species system. Our model builds upon the ordinary differential equation model of Searle et al., 2016a . We include dynamic stochasticity, leading to a stochastic differential equation model which provides an improved statistical fit to the data while also assisting identification of model misspecification ( King et al., 2015 ) . We carry out likelihood-based inference using panel iterated filtering ( Bretó et al., 2020 ) which is a PanelPOMP extension of basic iterated filtering methodology ( Ionides et al., 2015 ; King et al., 2016 ) for POMP models. Iterated filtering methods have a plug-and-play property ( He et al., 2010 ) that they require a simulator for the dynamic model but do not need the ability to evaluate transition densities. The plug-and-play property permits practical consideration of a broad class of PanelPOMP models, assisting the creative task of developing scientifically plausible models that simultaneously have good statistical fit. POMP models have long been advocated as an appropriate framework for ecological systems ( Schnute, 1994 ; Buckland et al., 2004 ) . A major practical limitation has been the computational difficulty in carrying out inference. When Laplace approximations are applicable, the Template Model Builder approach is available ( Kristensen et al., 2016 ) . Iterated filtering techniques apply to a more general class of POMP models, but the high-dimensional nature of PanelPOMP models adds additional methodological challenges. We are not aware of any previous scientific studies where nonlinear, non-Gaussian PanelPOMP models (with some parameters shared between units and some parameters specific to each unit) have been calibrated to multi-species panel data via maximum likelihood. A central question when using model-based statistical inference to investigate ecological dynamics is to discover which biological details are necessary to include in a model to provide an adequate statistical explanation for the data. Our approach to answering this question uses standard tools of likelihood-based inference. We compare the model likelihood to statistical benchmarks, such as linear or autoregressive models, seeking to continue improving a mechanistic model until it captures the predictability of the data with at least comparable skill to a simple non-mechanistic analysis ( Wheeler et al., 2024 ; Li et al., 2024 ) . In doing so, we ensure that the proposed dynamic model provides a plausible mechanistic description of the dynamic system, supported by evidence that the model also provides a suitable quantitative description of data that arise from the system. To do this, we study residuals and conditional log-likelihood anomalies for each data point to identify relative weaknesses and strengths of different models. We calculate Akaike’s Information Criterion (AIC) to compare the overall fit of rival mechanistic models ( Akaike, 1974 ) . We compute profile likelihood confidence intervals, making appropriate adjustment for Monte Carlo uncertainty ( Ionides et al., 2017 ; Ning et al., 2021 ) . All these techniques are predicated on an ability to evaluate and maximize the log-likelihood