Pólya’s conjecture on 𝕊 1 × ℝ \mathbb{S}^{1}\times\mathbb{R}

Pedro Freitas, Rui Zhu Wang · 2025

Read Pólya’s conjecture on 𝕊 1 × ℝ \mathbb{S}^{1}\times\mathbb{R} by Pedro Freitas, Rui Zhu Wang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-04341.txt.

Introduction

Pedro Freitas and Rui Wang test a famous eigenvalue guess on an endless cylinder, in a 2025 paper. Pólya's conjecture ties the vibration tones of a shape to its area, and it is still unproved in general. On the cylinder, the best shape for a given area is either a round disk or a band wrapped around the tube.

For disks, the authors bound the radius above which the conjecture could still hold. For bands, they settle exactly which heights make it hold. Combining both answers gives a clean rule for which of the two ideal shapes obeys the conjecture at any given area. A related set of inequalities by Li and Yau is also settled for the band case.

Catalog record

CREATORPedro Freitas, Rui Zhu Wang
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE56 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-04341

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Pólya’s conjecture on 𝕊 1 × ℝ \mathbb{S}^{1}\times\mathbb{R} Pedro Freitas, Rui Zhu Wang Abstract . We study the area ranges where the two possible isoperimetric domains on the infinite cylinder 𝕊 1 × ℝ \mathbb{S}^{1}\times\mathbb{R} , namely, geodesic disks and cylindrical strips of the form 𝕊 1 × [ 0 , h ] \mathbb{S}^{1}\times[0,h] , satisfy Pólya’s conjecture. In the former case, we provide an upper bound on the maximum value of the radius for which the conjecture may hold, while in the latter we fully characterise the values of h h for which it does hold for these strips. As a consequence, we determine a necessary and sufficient condition for the isoperimetric domain on 𝕊 1 × ℝ \mathbb{S}^{1}\times\mathbb{R} corresponding to a given area to satisfy Pólya’s conjecture. In the case of the cylindrical strip, we also provide a necessary and sufficient condition for the Li-Yau inequalities to hold. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary: 58J50, 35P15; Secondary: 58C40 1. Introduction Pólya’s conjecture for the Dirichlet Laplacian on a domain states that all its eigenvalues are greater than or equal to the first term in the corresponding Weyl asymptotics. It was formulated by Pólya in the first edition of [ P1 ] in 1954, who then proved it in 1961 for the case of domains that tile the plane [ P2 ] . Apart from the direct extension of this result to higher-dimensional Euclidean domains by Urakawa [ U ] , the conjecture is only known to hold for certain Cartesian products [ L , FS , HW ] , for Euclidean balls and sectors [ FLPS ] , and for certain families of domains tiling a given domain [ FS , FLP ] . The result in [ FS ] essentially states that if a domain \Omega satisfies certain geometric conditions and may be tiled by an arbitrary number of p equal isometric copies of a domain \Omega_{p} , then there exists p_{0} large enough such that \Omega_{p} satisfies Pólya’s conjecture for all p greater than or equal to p_{0} . This result is essentially qualitative, but, on the other hand, it is not restricted to Euclidean domains, thus showing that the conjecture may also be satisfied for certain families of domains on manifolds. To the best of our knowledge and until then, for the Dirichlet problem on non-Euclidean domains this had only been known to hold for the two-dimensional hemisphere [ BB , BLPS , FMS ] . One of the purposes of the present paper is to contribute to the understanding of what differences may be expected when considering Pólya’s conjecture on manifolds. To illustrate this behaviour, one of the examples given in [ FS ] is that of a cylindrical surface of the form \mathcal{C}_{h}=\mathbb{S}^{1}\times I_{h} , where I_{h} is an open interval of length h , and for which it is concluded that Pólya’s conjecture is satisfied provided h is sufficiently small [ FS , Example III.D] . On the other hand, a simple argument based on the behaviour of the first eigenvalue was presented there showing that for large enough h this will no longer be the case – see below and also Section 2.1 . This shows that topological issues may play a role, with the consequence that now tiling domains no longer necessarilly satisfy the conjecture, not even in a weaker form – see Proposition 2.1 . As far as we can tell, the only instance where tiling domains had been considered previously on cylindrical surfaces were first in a paper by Hersch, who also considered domains on the torus [ He ] , and also in a paper by the first author [ F ] . In either case, only a finite number of tiles were considered. Apart from illustrating the different possible behaviours mentioned above, another purpose of the present article is to provide an example of a quantitative version of the result in [ FS ] by characterising precisely the values of h for which Pólya’s conjecture is satisfied for \mathcal{C}_{h} . In this case the conjecture reads as \lambda_{k}\left(\mathcal{C}_{h}\right)\geq\frac{\displaystyle 4k\pi}{\displaystyle\left|\mathcal{C}_{h}\right|}=\frac{\displaystyle 2k}{\displaystyle h}, where \lambda_{k}\left(\mathcal{C}_{h}\right) and \left|\mathcal{C}_{h}\right| denote the k^{\rm th} Dirichlet eigenvalue and the area of \mathcal{C}_{h} , respectively. Since the first eigenvalue is given by \lambda_{1}\left(\mathcal{C}_{h}\right)=\pi^{2}/h^{2} , it is straightforward to see that this eigenvalue cannot satisfy the conjecture for h larger than \pi^{2}/2 . However, it is not clear whether the conjecture holds for all h smaller than or equal to this value and, in fact, we will show that there are indeed two disjoint open intervals for smaller values of h where the conjecture fails. More precisely, our main result is the following. Theorem A . Pólya’s conjecture on C_{h}=\mathbb{S}^{1}\times I_{h} is satisfied if and only if h belongs to \left(0,8-\sqrt{64-4\pi^{2}}\right]\cup\left[2+\sqrt{4-\frac{\pi^{2}}{4}},13-\sqrt{169-9\pi^{2}}\right]\cup\left[\frac{13}{4}+\sqrt{\frac{169}{16}-\pi^{2}},\frac{\pi^{2}}{2}\right]. On the intervals \left(8-\sqrt{64-4\pi^{2}},2+\sqrt{4-\frac{\pi^{2}}{4}}\right)\approx(3.0481,3.2380) and \left(13-\sqrt{169-9\pi^{2}},\frac{13}{4}+\sqrt{\frac{169}{16}-\pi^{2}}\right)\approx(4.0460,4.0824) the conjecture fails for \lambda_{8}\left(\mathcal{C}_{h}\right) and \lambda_{13}\left(\mathcal{C}_{h}\right) , respectively, and only for these eigenvalues in each case. From \pi^{2}/2 onwards the conjecture fails for \lambda_{1}\left(\mathcal{C}_{h}\right) and then for some higher eigenvalues as h is increased further. As a direct corollary of this result, we have the precise values of the area for which the isoperimetric domains on the infinite cylinder \mathbb{S}^{1}\times\mathbb{R} satisfy Pólya’s inequality. For two-dimensional manifolds, given a value for the area an isoperimetric domain is a domain with that area with the smallest possible perimeter. In the case of the infinite cylinder, isoperimetric domains are either a geodesic disk for areas smaller than or equal to 4\pi , or, for larger areas, a cylindrical strip \mathcal{C}_{h} bounded by two parallel circles as described above [ HHM ] . Corollary B . For a given value of the area, the corresponding isoperimetric domains on \mathbb{S}^{1}\times\mathbb{R} satisfy Pólya’s conjecture if and only if this area is in the range \begin{array}[]{ll}\left(0,2\pi\left(8-\sqrt{64-4\pi^{2}}\right)\right]\cup\left[2\pi\left(2+\sqrt{4-\frac{\displaystyle\pi^{2}}{\displaystyle 4}}\right),2\pi\left(13-\sqrt{169-9\pi^{2}}\right)\right]&\\ \hskip 170.71652pt\cup\left[2\pi\left(\frac{\displaystyle 13}{\displaystyle 4}+\sqrt{\frac{\displaystyle 169}{\displaystyle 16}-\pi^{2}}\right),\pi^{3}\right]\end{array} Proof. For a disk of area smaller than or equal to 4\pi , where the transition between disks and strips takes place, its radius is smaller than or equal to two, smaller than \pi , and we know that in this range Pólya’s conjecture is satisfied for disks [ FLPS ] . Since this is within the range of the first interval where Pólya’s conjecture holds for the strip, the result follows. ∎ Although as we have seen Pólya’s conjecture fails for some values of h below \pi^{2}/2 , we actually have that the corresponding averaged version compatible with Weyl asymptotics, known as the Li-Yau inequalities [ LY ] , holds in this range. In fact, in this case the values of h for which this happens may be extended up to \pi^{2} . Corollary C . The inequalities (1.1) \frac{1}{k}\sum_{i=1}^{k}\lambda_{i}\geq\frac{k}{h},\quad k=1,2,\dots hold for all k if and only if h\in(0,\pi^{2}] . This result has implications for the satisfiability of Pólya’s conjecture for Cartesian products involving \mathbb{S}^{1}\times I_{h} , such as \mathbb{S}^{1}\times I_{h_{1}}\times\dots\times I_{h_{m}} , which will be briefly discussed in Section 4 . The proof of Theorem A follows from a careful analysis of the integer lattice point counting problem associated with the eigenvalues on \mathcal{C}_{h} . In Section 2 we derive estimates for the eigenvalues which are sufficiently sharp to allow us to reduce the full problem to that

Read the complete text