OxO2 - A SSSOM mapping browser for logically sound crosswalks
Henriette Harmse, Haider Iqbal, Helen Parkinson, James McLaughlin · 2025
Read OxO2 - A SSSOM mapping browser for logically sound crosswalks by Henriette Harmse, Haider Iqbal, Helen Parkinson, James McLaughlin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-04286.txt.
Introduction
Henriette Harmse and co-authors present OxO2, a tool for mapping terms across data sets, in a 2025 paper. Groups often tag the same thing with terms from unlike term lists. The first OxO tool found such links, but some links were not sound and source notes were thin.
OxO2 fixes those flaws with a shared map standard that records who made each link. Sound links are drawn by a rule engine built for speed and low memory use. Time outs and crashes that hit some past searches are also addressed. Users can now join unlike data sets with more trust in each cross link.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Henriette Harmse, Haider Iqbal, Helen Parkinson, James McLaughlin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 28 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-04286
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
OxO2 - A SSSOM mapping browser for logically sound crosswalks Henriette Harmse, Haider Iqbal, Helen Parkinson, James McLaughlin Abstract EMBL-EBI created OxO to enable users to map between datasets that are annotated with different ontologies. Mappings identified by the first version of OxO were not necessarily logically sound, lacked important provenance information such as author and reviewer, and could timeout or crash for certain requests. In this paper we introduce OxO2 to address these concerns. Provenance is addressed by implementing SSSOM, a mapping standard that defines provenance for mappings. SSSOM defines the conditions under which logical sound mappings can be derived and is implemented in OxO2 using Nemo, a Datalog rule engine. To ensure reasoning is performant and memory efficient, Nemo implements a number of strategies that ensures OxO2 will be stable for all requests. Due to these changes, OxO2 users will be able to integrate between disparate datasets with greater confidence. Keywords OxO; mapping; crosswalk; FAIR Principles 1 Introduction The FAIR principles are a set of guidelines designed to make datasets and their metadata Findable, Accessible, Interoperable and Reusable for both machines and humans [ 33 ] , and require the use of FAIR vocabularies and/or ontologies [ 33 , 34 ] . Since their publication, the FAIR principles have been widely adopted to support FAIR data implementations [ 30 ] . Specific domains may aim to standardize on the ontologies they use, but often multiple ontologies are employed within a given domain [ 19 ] . At EMBL-EBI, the Experimental Factor Ontology (EFO) [ 21 ] is used to annotate EMBL-EBI datasets. However, many other ontologies are also used within EMBL-EBI, such as the Mondo Disease Ontology (MONDO) [ 31 ] , the Human Disease Ontology (DOID) [ 27 ] and the Human Phenotype Ontology (HP) [ 20 ] . When considering cross-domain integration, differences in frames of reference mean that different domains often standardize on different ontologies [ 32 ] . As an example, phenotypes (observable traits) are critical for diagnosing and treating diseases, and are studied in both model organisms (organisms that can easily be studied in a laboratory) such as zebrafish and mammals, as well as in humans. As such, zebrafish data is annotated with the Zebrafish Phenotype Ontology (ZP), mammalian data with the Mammalian Phenotype Ontology (MP) and human data with the Human Phenotype Ontology (HP), respectively. To study a specific phenotype, say increased heart size, researchers benefit from being able to combine data annotated with ZP:0000532 (increased size of heart), MP:0000274 (enlarged heart) and HP:0001640 (Cardiomegaly) [ 23 ] . In order to facilitate these kinds of integration across datasets annotated with different ontologies, there is the need to map the concepts from one ontology to the related concepts of another ontology. EMBL-EBI created the Ontology Xref (Cross-reference) Service - referred to as OxO - to address this need [ 19 ] . In this paper we will refer to this version of OxO as OxO1. OxO1 identified mappings between concepts of different ontologies by crawling the Ontology Lookup Service (OLS) [ 26 ] and reading the xref (cross-reference relationships) annotations for each of the ontology concepts. The notion of an xref is intentionally loosely defined as part of the Open Biological and Biomedical Ontology (OBO) Flat File Format Specification, which has historically been used to define ontologies in the bioinformatics community [ 14 , 28 ] . An xref mapping may be used to indicate an exact match, but it could as well refer to a broader or narrower match. A key feature of OxO1 is that it enables walking across ontologies – from a concept in one ontology to a concept in the next ontology – referred to as a crosswalk . This is illustrated in Figure 1, where the crosswalk between MONDO:0004981 and DOID:1579 is realized by mapping from MONDO:0004981 to EFO:0000275 , to OMIM:615770 , and finally to DOID:1579 . This is referred to as a mapping at a distance of 3, since mappings between ontologies were performed 3 times. Distances greater than 3 are not supported in OxO1 [ 19 ] . Since xrefs are not well defined, the meaning of these kinds of crosswalks across multiple ontologies are also weakly defined. Despite the loose definition of mappings in OxO1, it supports the following user groups. Researchers , such as biologists seeking new treatments for heart disease, who may want to study the phenotype ”enlarged heart”. Resource providers or data analysts integrating datasets annotated with different ontologies, such as ZP and MP. At EMBL-EBI, OxO1 is used by resources such as European Variation Archive (EVA) [ 11 ] , the Genome-Wide Association Study (GWAS) Catalog [ 9 ] and Europe PMC [ 12 ] . Figure 1: A crosswalk from MONDO:0004981 to DOID:1579 by mapping from MONDO:0004981 to EFO:0000275 to OMIM:615770 to DOID:1579 . The Simple Standard for Sharing Ontological Mappings (SSSOM) provides precise definitions for mappings, along with related provenance information, and clearly defines the conditions under which new mappings can be derived from existing mappings [ 22 ] . In this paper we introduce OxO2, a new ontology mapping service that implements SSSOM and offers a robust platform for browsing mappings between ontologies with logically sound crosswalks. In the next section (Section 2 ), we give a brief overview of SSSOM and explain how it enables logically sound crosswalks. Section 3 describes the value proposition of OxO2. In Section 4 , we motivate the design decisions of the OxO2 implementation, and in Section 5 , we review related SSSOM implementations. Finally, in Section 6 , we discuss the current limitations of our OxO2 implementation and future developments under consideration. 2 Background In this section, we explain how OxO2 uses Datalog (Section 2.3 ) to derive logically sound and complete mappings based on SSSOM chain rules (Section 2.2 ), in a performant and memory efficient manner (Section 2.4 ). Figure 2: A SSSOM mapping that maps DOID:8567 via SKOS:exactMatch to NCIT:C9357 . Table 1: An abbreviated list of SSSOM standard metadata elements with example data, partially based on [ 3 ] . Author and reviewer information are fictional. Name Description Example author_id Identifies the persons or groups responsible for asserting the mappings Henriette Harmse confidence A score between 0 and 1 denotes the confidence of correctness of a mapping. mapping_set_id A globally unique identifier for the mapping set http://w3id.org/mapping_commons/disease-mappings/onto-icd10 mapping_tool A reference to the tool or algorithm that was used to generate the mapping https://github.com/mapping-commons/sssom-py object_id The ID of the object NCIT:C9357 object_label The label of the object Hodgkin Lymphoma predicate_id The ID that relates subject and object SKOS:exactMatch reviewer_id Identifies the persons or groups that reviewed and confirmed the mapping Helen Parkinson subject_id The ID of the subject of the mapping DOID:8567 subject_label The label of subject of the mapping Hodgkin’s lymphoma 2.1 An Overview of SSSOM SSSOM [ 22 , 25 , 24 , 6 ] is briefly summarised here, along with an example to illustrate the value proposition of OxO2. Mappings are defined as a subject mapping via a predicate to an object. In SSSOM, this is expressed as a subject_id mapping via a predicate_id to an object_id , where the subject_id , predicate_id