Eye of the vortex: bound spectra in tunable horizonless rotational analogs
H. S. Vieira, Kyriakos Destounis · 2025
Read Eye of the vortex: bound spectra in tunable horizonless rotational analogs by H. S. Vieira, Kyriakos Destounis (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-03451.txt.
Introduction
Vieira and Destounis compute the trapped sound tones of a swirling fluid vortex that mimics a rotating black hole, in the case where the vortex has no drain. Their 2025 paper belongs to analog gravity, where tabletop flows stand in for cosmic objects. A tuning knob can add or remove the point of no return.
With the knob at zero, the flow is pure rotation with no inward pull and no horizon. The tone spectrum of that setup matches what labs see in giant quantum vortices with solid or hollow cores. The authors say their model can mirror those cutting-edge experiments well. It may also hint at tones bound near real spinning cosmic bodies.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | H. S. Vieira, Kyriakos Destounis |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 41 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-03451
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Eye of the vortex: bound spectra in tunable horizonless rotational analogs H. S. Vieira, Kyriakos Destounis Abstract Analog gravity experiments are making remarkable strides in unveiling both the classical and quantum nature of black holes. By harnessing diverse states of matter, contemporary tabletop setups now replicate strong-field phenomena typically confined to the enigmatic regions surrounding black holes. Through these modern gravity simulators, physical processes once considered elusive may finally be brought into experimental reach. In this work, we investigate the bound spectrum of massless scalar excitations propagating within the effective geometry of a rotating acoustic metric. Specifically, we utilize an analog vortex endowed with a tunable parameter that emulates the spacetime of a rotating gravitational background. This model accommodates both the presence of a sonic horizon–characteristic of an acoustic black hole–for non-zero tuning parameters, and its absence when the parameter vanishes, yielding a horizonless, purely rotational vortex flow devoid of radial inflow. We focus on the latter case, where the vortex flow is purely rotational, and compute the spectral properties of the analog system. The resulting bound-state spectrum is found to be qualitatively consistent with that observed in recent experimental realizations of superfluid Helium giant quantum vortices featuring solid or hollow cores. This correspondence suggests that the analog spacetime geometry used here holds significant potential to replicate the phenomenology of cutting-edge laboratory experiments. In doing so, it offers new insight into the intricate landscape of analog black hole spectroscopy and, potentially, the physical topography of bounded, rotating astrophysical environments around black holes. I Introduction Gravitational-wave (GW) events from coalescing binaries are currently flooding ground-based detectors with data from compact binary sources. The LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA (LVK) collaboration has successfully detected more than 200 GW events Abbott et al. 2023 . These confirmed observations are sourced by mostly black hole (BH) and neutron star (NS) mergers, as well as BH-NS binary systems. Their characteristic imprint on the LVK detectors is divided in three stages; an initial inspiral stage, where the two compact objects meander around a center of mass whilst emitting GWs, thus their orbital distance is shrinking, followed by a merger phase, where the two objects plow into each other violently. The final stage is dubbed the ringdown , where the vibrating remnant tends into equilibrium by radiating away its final fluctuations in a series of damped sinusoids, known as the quasinormal modes (QNMs) Kokkotas and Schmidt 1999 ; Berti et al. 2009 ; Konoplya and Zhidenko 2011 . Concurrently, analog gravity simulators have shown great progress in the field of classical and quantum BH phenomenology Visser 1998 ; Fischer and Visser 2002 ; Barcelo et al. 2005 ; Barceló 2019 ; Braunstein et al. 2023 ; Yang et al. 2024 . Contemporary technological advances in controlling and manipulating such emulators have enabled the experimental realization of acoustic analogs of gravitational BHs Unruh 1981 . The past decade witnessed a large variety of laboratory experiments testing a diverse set of aspects of BH physics that led to tentative evidence of analog Hawking radiation Weinfurtner et al. 2011 ; Steinhauer 2014 ; Steinhauer 2016 ; Muñoz de Nova et al. 2019 ; Kolobov et al. 2021 ; Tian et al. 2022 , superradiance Richartz et al. 2015 ; Torres et al. 2017 and imprints of QNMs in perturbed analogs Torres et al. 2019 ; Torres et al. 2020 ; Smaniotto et al. 2025 . Bridging the gap between analog BH experiments and realistic GWs is now in full bloom. The latest experimental and theoretical developments in these areas illustrate that there is an overabundance of possibilities, even at cosmological scales Krusius et al. 1998 ; Volovik 2006a ; Fedichev and Fischer 2004 . Even though analog gravity was initially proposed by Unruh Unruh 1981 , in order to understand the quantum nature of spacetime through analog BHs with sonic horizons, beyond which acoustic excitation become supersonic and cannot escape the hole, at the moment the only observed phenomenon from binary mergers is the emission of GWs, as described above, which is a purely classical manifestation of strong-field gravity. The study of a remnant’s QNMs, dubbed as the BH spectroscopy program Dreyer et al. 2004 ; Ota and Chirenti 2022 ; Destounis and Duque 2023 ; Berti et al. 2025 , can serve as a validity test for analog BH spectroscopy Torres et al. 2019 . Since the experimental results from analog BH laboratories correctly hint the existence of QNMs, and even quasibound states (QBSs) Patrick et al. 2018 , so the observed analog Hawking radiation may provide, at least qualitatively, legitimate evidence for the quantum nature of gravitation Hawking 1974 ; Hawking 1975 . Most BH analogs that are built with fluids Unruh 1995 ; Berti et al. 2004 ; Coutant and Weinfurtner 2016 ; Torres et al. 2022 ; Vieira and Kokkotas 2021 ; Vieira et al. 2025 , optical lasers Corley and Jacobson 1999 ; Coutant and Parentani 2010 ; Leonhardt and Philbin 2008 ; Gaona-Reyes and Bermudez 2017 ; Peloquin et al. 2016 , Bose-Einstein condensates Garay et al. 2001 ; Gooding et al. 2020 ; Liao et al. 2019 ; Lahav et al. 2010 ; Ribeiro et al. 2022 ; Baak et al. 2022 ; Fabbri and Balbinot 2021 ; Solnyshkov et al. 2019 ; Klaers et al. 2010 ; Fischer and Schutzhold 2004 ; Vieira et al. 2023 , superconductors Shi et al. 2023 ; Blencowe and Wang 2020 ; Hirve et al. 2024 and even quantum circuits Tokusumi et al. 2018 ; Jannes et al. 2011 ; Katayama 2021 ; Katayama et al. 2023 have one thing in common; an acoustic horizon. Recent experiments also utilize superfluids Jacobson and Volovik 1998 ; Volovik 2005 ; Volovik 2006b ; Inui et al. 2020 ; Braidotti et al. 2022 ; Jacquet et al. 2022 , such as superfluid Helium. In some particular superfluid-Helium cases, the acoustic horizon can even be absent, i.e. there is no radial inflow of surface excitations. Recently, such laboratory contraption has been constructed and dubbed a giant quantum vortex Švančara et al. 2024 , due to the enormous amount of vortex quanta used to build the vortex Alperin and Berloff 2021 . It has been shown that such experiments, when perturbed with surface waves, produce both QNMs and QBSs, regardless of the absence of an event horizon Švančara et al. 2024 ; Smaniotto et al. 2025 . Utilizing such a circulating vortex without radial flow, and calculating its spectrum is, nonetheless, absent from the current literature. In this work we revisit an effective metric that describes acoustic excitations on a rotating geometry, with a tuning parameter that can turn the radial inflow on and off. This geometry can describe both the vortex flow experiments involving superfluid Helium without radial flow Švančara et al. 2024 ; Smaniotto et al. 2025 , and rotating acoustic BH analogs with radial flow. Here, we focus on the case of a horizonless acoustic analog, where radial flow is absent, in an attempt to qualitatively replicate the results presented in Švančara et al. 2024 , regarding the QBSs. We find both the co-rotating and counter-rotating QBSs of the rotational horizonless vortex. These are qualitatively compared with the results in Švančara et