The Bayesian Finite Element Method in Inverse Problems: a Critical Comparison between Probabilistic Models for Discretization Error
Anne Poot, Iuri Rocha, Pierre Kerfriden, Frans van der Meer · 2025
Read The Bayesian Finite Element Method in Inverse Problems: a Critical Comparison between Probabilistic Models for Discretization Error by Anne Poot, Iuri Rocha, Pierre Kerfriden, Frans van der Meer (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-02815.txt.
Introduction
Anne Poot, Iuri Rocha, Pierre Kerfriden, and Frans van der Meer present a 2025 paper on error from grid methods in inverse problems. The finite element method solves physics problems on a grid, but grid error can make answers both wrong and too sure. The Bayesian form of the method treats that error as uncertainty.
The authors test the Bayesian method against two rivals, a random mesh method and a statistical method. Passing the uncertainty through gave more accurate answers and less false confidence than the plain grid method. The Bayesian form also beat the random mesh form, thanks to how its error spread is built. The statistical form worked only with rich data. The authors call the Bayesian form the most robust choice.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Anne Poot, Iuri Rocha, Pierre Kerfriden, Frans van der Meer |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 65 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-02815
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Bayesian Finite Element Method in Inverse Problems: a Critical Comparison between Probabilistic Models for Discretization Error Anne Poot, Iuri Rocha, Pierre Kerfriden, Frans van der Meer Abstract When using the finite element method (FEM) in inverse problems, its discretization error can produce parameter estimates that are inaccurate and overconfident. The Bayesian finite element method (BFEM) provides a probabilistic model for the epistemic uncertainty due to discretization error. In this work, we apply BFEM to various inverse problems, and compare its performance to the random mesh finite element method (RM-FEM) and the statistical finite element method (statFEM), which serve as a frequentist and inference-based counterpart to BFEM. We find that by propagating this uncertainty to the posterior, BFEM can produce more accurate parameter estimates and prevent overconfidence, compared to FEM. Because the BFEM covariance operator is designed to leave uncertainty only in the appropriate space, orthogonal to the FEM basis, BFEM is able to outperform RM-FEM, which does not have such a structure to its covariance. Although inferring the discretization error via a model misspecification component is possible as well, as is done in statFEM, the feasibility of such an approach is contingent on the availability of sufficient data. We find that the BFEM is the most robust way to consistently propagate uncertainty due to discretization error to the posterior of a Bayesian inverse problem. keywords finite element method, inverse problems, discretization error, probabilistic numerics, uncertainty quantification MSC 35R30, 62F15, 65N21, 65N30, 74B05, 74S05 1 Introduction Inverse problems are abundant in science and engineering, ranging from climate modeling to medical imaging and from subsurface characterization to structural health monitoring. Because they are typically ill-posed, solving an inverse problem requires many evaluations of the forward problem, which may involve the numerical solution of a partial differential equation (PDE). The associated computational cost is severe, and the issue of limiting the cost can be targeted from various angles including approximation of the posterior [ 8 , 37 ] , efficient sampling strategies [ 20 , 6 ] , model order reduction [ 4 , 12 ] and machine learning techniques [ 33 , 25 ] . Recently, interest has increased in approaching numerical computation from a probabilistic point of view [ 17 , 10 ] , which allows the epistemic uncertainty associated with limited computation to be propagated to the posterior. In this work, we focus on probabilistic models for discretization error of the finite element method (FEM), in the context of Bayesian inverse problems in solid mechanics. In recent work [ 31 ] , we proposed the Bayesian finite element method (BFEM), which takes a Bayesian approach to solving PDEs and thereby provides a probabilistic model of discretization error. A Gaussian process prior is assumed over the solution space, and conditioned on observations implied by the FEM shape functions. We can contextualize BFEM as part of a family of Bayesian methods of weighted residuals, which encompasses a broad range of PDE solvers [ 30 ] . Instead of conditioning on FEM shape functions, one can condition on point evaluations to recover a Bayesian collocation method [ 9 ] or condition on volume integrals to recover a Bayesian finite volume method [ 39 ] . Bayesian physics-informed neural networks [ 40 ] fall in a similar category: their key difference with Bayesian collocation methods lies in the parametrization of the prior, for which an artificial neural network is used. On the other hand, various frequentist approaches to modeling solver error have been proposed, which typically rely on perturbing a traditional PDE solver in some manner to induce a distribution over the solution space. Conrad et al. [ 11 ] modeled uncertainty due to discretization error by adding locally supported noise to the FEM basis, whereas the random mesh finite element method (RM-FEM) by Abdulle and Garegnani [ 1 ] models the error by perturbing the node locations to randomize the basis itself. Note that not all methods fall neatly into these two categories. For example, various probabilistic solvers for ordinary differential equations (ODEs) based on Gaussian filtering techniques have been proposed [ 23 , 38 ] . Although such approaches can be generalized to PDEs as well [ 24 ] , they cannot be applied to PDEs on arbitrary domains, which is why they are left out of the scope of this work. For a broader overview and history of probabilistic solvers of ODEs and PDEs, the reader is referred to Hennig et al. [ 18 ] . Finally, we remark that discretization error is one of many forms of model misspecification. Several methods have been proposed that aim to capture model misspecification probabilistically. Alberts and Bilionis [ 2 ] adapt information field theory [ 13 ] by adding a tempering parameter to the prior, which calibrates the level of trust in the physical modeling. By learning this parameter, the reliability of the model can be inferred, and the uncertainty due to model misspecification can be propagated to quantities of interest. It is also possible to account for model misspecification by adapting the likelihood itself, as is done in the statistical finite element method (statFEM) [ 16 ] . Rather than assign a distribution directly to the solution field, a model misspecification component is added to the observation model, similar to [ 22 ] . The uncertainty due to model misspecification (in the form of discretization error) can be modeled by learning the misspecification parameters. The main contributions of this work are twofold: first, it is the first application of BFEM to an inverse problem. We verify that by modeling the discretization error probabilistically, and consistently propagating it to the posterior, the quality of the posterior can be improved. Second, we compare BFEM against RM-FEM [ 1 ] and statFEM [ 16 ] , which present alternatives to the Bayesian approach from the frequentist and model misspecification categories, respectively. Despite the wide range of probabilistic PDE solvers that have been proposed over the years, few works exist to comparatively study their performance, and this work contains the first comparison of the these three methods in an inverse setting. This paper is structured as follows: in section 2 , we summarize the BFEM, RM-FEM and statFEM models and describe how they account for error by adapting the likelihood of a Bayesian inverse problem. In section 3 , we present two numerical experiments. A pullout test is presented in section 3.1 as a 1D, low-data, material inference problem, followed by a three-point bending test in section 3.2 as a 2D, high-data, geometry inference problem. Finally, we conclude the paper and discuss its implications in section 4 . 2 Model definition For clarity of exposition, we assume our forward problem to be given by a second-order PDE over a domain \Omega with homogeneous Dirichlet boundary conditions: \displaystyle{\mathcal{D}}_{\bm{\theta}}u{(x)} \displaystyle=f{(x)} \displaystyle\text{ for }x \displaystyle\in\Omega (1) \displaystyle u{(x)} \displaystyle=0 \displaystyle\text{ for }x \displaystyle\in\partial\Omega Here, {\mathcal{D}}_{\bm{\theta}} is an elliptic, self-adjoint differential operator, which depends on a set of parameters {\bm{\theta}}\in{\mathbb{R}}^{k} . Note that the problems of linear elasticity we are interested in are generally not described by eq. 1 , due to possibly inhomogeneous Dirichlet and Neumann boundary conditions and u{(x)} being a vector field in {\mathbb{R}}^{d} . Nonetheless,