Cosmetic surgeries on knots in homology spheres and the Casson–Walker invariant

Kazuhiro Ichihara, In Dae Jong · 2025

Read Cosmetic surgeries on knots in homology spheres and the Casson–Walker invariant by Kazuhiro Ichihara, In Dae Jong (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-02682.txt.

Introduction

Kazuhiro Ichihara and In Dae Jong study cosmetic surgeries on knots inside homology spheres, in a 2025 paper. A cosmetic surgery replaces a knot's neighborhood in a way that yields the same three dimensional space as a different slope would. The question is which knots and which slopes can allow such a coincidence. The pair derive several constraints on both. Their main tool is a rational surgery formula for the Casson-Walker invariant, applied to two component links in the ordinary sphere.

Catalog record

CREATORKazuhiro Ichihara, In Dae Jong
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE24 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-02682

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Cosmetic surgeries on knots in homology spheres and the Casson–Walker invariant Thanks: This work was supported by JSPS KAKENHI Grant Numbers JP22K03301 and JP22K03324. Kazuhiro Ichihara, In Dae Jong Abstract . We study cosmetic surgeries on a knot in a homology sphere. Several constraints on knots and surgery slopes to admit such surgeries are given. Our main ingredient is the rational surgery formula of the Casson–Walker invariant for 2-component links in the 3-sphere. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary 57K30, Secondary 57K10 1. Introduction One of current active research problem in Dehn surgery theory is the cosmetic surgery problem, which asks under what circumstances two distinct Dehn surgeries on the same knot yield homeomorphic 3-manifolds. A pair of such surgeries is referred to as cosmetic surgeries . More specifically, they are called purely cosmetic if the resulting manifolds are homeomorphic via an orientation-preserving map, and chirally cosmetic if the homeomorphism reverses orientation. It is conjectured that no nontrivial knot in a closed, oriented 3-manifold admits purely cosmetic surgeries along inequivalent slopes. This is known as the purely cosmetic surgery conjecture . For further details, see [ 2 ] and [ 10 , Problem 1.81A] . In this paper, we study cosmetic surgeries on knots in homology spheres. We first focus on the purely cosmetic case. For a knot in an integral homology sphere, the following result holds as a corollary of a theorem by Boyer and Lines [ 3 , Theorem 2.8] . Proposition 1 . For any knot in an integral homology sphere, there are at most two pair of integral purely cosmetic surgeries. Here Dehn surgery is said to be integral if the algebraic intersection number of the meridian and a representative of the surgery slope is \pm 1 . The proof of Proposition 1 will be given later. The following result extends Proposition 1 to knots in rational homology spheres obtained by Dehn surgery on knots in the 3-sphere S^{3} . Theorem 2 . Let K be a null-homologous knot in a rational homology sphere obtained by Dehn surgery on a knot in S^{3} . Then K admits at most two pairs of integral purely cosmetic surgeries. Remark 1 . Recent studies on cosmetic surgeries on knots in S^{3} have made extensive use of Heegaard Floer homology. As a recent culmination of this approach, it has been shown that there is at most one pair of purely cosmetic surgeries on any nontrivial knot in S^{3} (directly as a corollary of [ 5 , Corollary 1.4] ). Moreover, for several classes of knots in S^{3} , the purely cosmetic surgery conjecture has been confirmed affirmatively. See [ 5 , 7 , 11 , 14 , 15 , 16 ] for examples. Remark 2 . For a hyperbolic knot in an arbitrary closed 3-manifold, it has been shown in [ 6 , Theorem 1.13] that there exists a finite set of pairs of slopes such that Dehn surgeries along any pair not in this set are never purely cosmetic. For a knot in an integral homology sphere, Boyer and Lines also provide a sufficient condition under which no purely cosmetic surgeries can occur. Proposition 3 ( [ 3 , (5.1) Proposition (iii)] ) . Let K be a knot in an integral homology sphere. If \Delta^{\prime\prime}_{K}(1)\neq 0 , then K admits no purely cosmetic surgeries. Here \Delta_{K}(t) denotes the Alexander polynomial of K , normalized so that \Delta_{K}(t^{-1})=\Delta_{K}(t) and \Delta_{K}(1)=1 . It is known that for a knot K in S^{3} , \Delta^{\prime\prime}_{K}(1) is equal to twice the second coefficient a_{2}(K) of the Conway polynomial of K . Thus, the following can be regarded as a partial extension of Proposition 3 to knots in integral homology spheres obtained by Dehn surgery on knots in S^{3} . Theorem 4 . Let \Sigma be an integral homology sphere obtained by Dehn surgery on a knot K_{0} in S^{3} along the slope 1/{q_{0}} for a non-zero integer q_{0} . Let K be a knot in \Sigma . Suppose that, identifying K with a knot in S^{3} before surgery on K_{0} , the linking number of K and K_{0} in S^{3} is zero. If a_{2}(K)-q_{0}a_{3}(L)\neq 0 , then K admits no purely cosmetic surgeries. Here a_{3}(L) denotes the third coefficient of the Conway polynomial of the link L=K\cup K_{0} in S^{3} . Next, we focus on the chirally cosmetic case. We denote by \lambda_{w} the Casson–Walker invariant for homology spheres. See [ 17 ] for the definition and basic properties of \lambda_{w} . The following result is also obtained from a result due to Boyer and Lines. Proposition 5 . Let K be a knot in an integral homology sphere \Sigma with \lambda_{w}(\Sigma)\neq 0 . Then K admits no integral chirally cosmetic surgeries. The proof of Proposition 5 will be given later. The following extends Proposition 5 to knots in rational homology spheres obtained by Dehn surgery on knots in S^{3} . Theorem 6 . Let \Sigma=K_{0}(p_{0}) be a rational homology sphere obtained by p_{0} -surgery on a knot K_{0} in S^{3} for a non-zero integer p_{0} . If p_{0}\neq\dfrac{3\pm\sqrt{96a_{2}(K_{0})+1}}{2} holds, then for any null-homologous knot K in \Sigma admits no integral chirally cosmetic surgeries. The following corollary follows from Theorem 6 immediately. Corollary 7 . Let \Sigma=K_{0}(p_{0}) be a rational homology sphere obtained by p_{0} -surgery on a knot K_{0} in S^{3} . If a_{2}(K_{0})=0 and |p_{0}|\geq 3 , then any null-homologous knot in \Sigma admits no integral chirally cosmetic surgeries. If the exterior of a knot admits an orientation-reversing self-homeomorphism, then the knot admits integral chirally cosmetic surgeries naturally. Thus, from the corollary above, we have the following. Corollary 8 . Let K_{0} be a knot in S^{3} with a_{2}(K_{0})=0 . For any integer p_{0}\geq 3 , the rational homology sphere \Sigma=K_{0}(p_{0}) contains no null-homologous knots with the exterior admitting an orientation-reversing self-homeomorphism. In particular, there are no null-homologous amphicheiral knot in \Sigma . For the definition of an amphicheiral knot in a general 3 –manifold, see [ 8 ] . A key ingredient in the proofs of Theorems 2 , 4 , and 6 is the rational surgery formula for the Casson–Walker invariant \lambda_{w} for 2-component links in S^{3} , established by Ito [ 9 , Theorem 1.5] . Here we give proofs of Propositions 1 and 5 for completeness. First we prove Proposition 1 . Let K be a knot in an integral homology sphere \Sigma . We denote by K(p/q) the 3-manifold obtained by p/q -surgery on K . From [ 3 , Theorem 2.8] , we have the following surgery formula: (1) \lambda(K(p/q))=\lambda(\Sigma)+(q/p)(\Delta_{K}^{\prime\prime}(1))/2-(\mathrm{sgn}(p)/2)s(q,p). Here \lambda denotes the (original) Casson invariant used in [ 3 ] , for which \lambda_{w}=2\lambda holds. See [ 12 , Section 6] for example. In the above, s(q,p) denotes the Dedekind sum for coprime integers p,q (see the next section for the definition). Suppose that K admits a pair of integral purely cosmetic surgeries. Then, by Proposition 3 , we have \Delta_{K}^{\prime\prime}(1)=0 . Moreover, by the homological reason, the surgery slopes must be \pm p for a positive integer p . Thus, by the formula ( 1 ), we have s(1,p)=-s(1,-p) . Since s(1,-p)=-s(1,p) holds, we have 2s(1,p)=0 . By the definition of s(q,p)

Read the complete text