Neutrino mass model at a three-loop level from a non-holomorphic modular A 4 A_{4} symmetry

Takaaki Nomura, Hiroshi Okada · 2025

Read Neutrino mass model at a three-loop level from a non-holomorphic modular A 4 A_{4} symmetry by Takaaki Nomura, Hiroshi Okada (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-02639.txt.

Introduction

Takaaki Nomura and Hiroshi Okada built in 2025 a model of neutrino masses generated at three loops, guided by a symmetry based on the modular group A4. In such models the pattern of lepton masses and mixing follows from symmetry rather than free choices. Their minimal version predicts masses, mixing angles, and both kinds of CP-violating phases, which they test statistically against data.

They also check side predictions: rare flavor-violating decays, the muon's magnetic anomaly, and lepton universality tests. A dark matter candidate is included, and its cosmic abundance comes out too high within the model's valid range. Adding one extra scalar particle fixes that without disturbing the neutrino predictions. The authors map where the extended model survives all constraints.

Catalog record

CREATORTakaaki Nomura, Hiroshi Okada
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE33 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-02639

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Neutrino mass model at a three-loop level from a non-holomorphic modular A 4 A_{4} symmetry Takaaki Nomura, Hiroshi Okada Abstract We study a three-loop induced neutrino mass scenario from a non-holomorphic modular A 4 A_{4} flavor symmetry and reach the minimum scenario leading predictions of the lepton masses, mixing angles, and Dirac and Majorana phases, which are shown through the chi square analyses. In addition, we discuss the lepton flavor violations, muon anomalous magnetic moment, lepton universality, and relic density of the dark matter candidate. And, we find that we need to extend our model if we satisfy the observed relic density of dark matter within the limit of perturbation where it can be done by adding one singlet scalar boson without changing predictions in neutrino sector. I Introduction Thanks to a successful construction of non-holomorphic modular symmetry framework via Qu and Ding Qu and Ding 2024 , we can safely deal with a beyond the standard model (BSM) without super-symmetric theories in using the framework for a flavor symmetry. In fact, the non-holomorphic symmetries have been applied to some non-supersymmetric models Ding et al. 2024 ; Li et al. 2024 ; Nomura and Okada 2024a ; Nomura et al. 2025a ; Nomura and Okada 2024b ; Okada and Orikasa 2025 ; Kobayashi et al. 2025 ; Loualidi et al. 2025 ; Nomura et al. 2025b ; Abbas 2025 in order to restrict the number of model parameters. In constructing a model, we have some advantage of applying non-supersymmetric framework to reduce number of new fields where extra fields are sometimes required to cancel a gauge anomaly in supersymmetric case. Radiatively induced neutrino mass models are one of the representative scenarios that do not demand the super-symmetric framework and one can naturally connect new particles to the SM model particles. Sometimes, the model can possess the dark matter candidate(DM) Ma 2006 that often requests an additional symmetry to stabilize it. Thus, constructing radiative neutrino mass models (with DM) using the non-holomorphic modular symmetry would be natural manner to make a model more attractive realizing more predictability. In our paper, we apply a non-holomorphic A_{4} flavor symmetry to a well-known three loop neutrino mass model Krauss et al. 2003 . Through the chi square numerical analysis, we successfully search for the minimum model to predict the lepton masses and mixing angles in addition to reproduce the current neutrino observables in Nufit 6.0 Esteban et al. 2024 . Then, we perform further numerical analyses in order to satisfy lepton flavor violations (LFVs), muon anomalous magnetic moment, (muon g-2 ), lepton universality, and the dark matter (DM). As a result, we find that relic density is too large within the limit of perturbation requiring a new interaction where it can be done by adding one singlet scalar boson without changing predictions in neutrino sector. This paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II, we explain our minimum three-loop neutrino mass model constructing the renormalizable Lagrangian in the lepton sector, Higgs sector, the charged-lepton sector, heavier Majorana fermion sector, and the active neutrino sector. Then, we formulate the LFVs, muon g-2 , lepton universality, and relic density of the DM. In Sec. III, we perform \chi square analysis and show some predictions for normal and inverted hierarchies in the neutrino sector. Employing the benchmark points of the best fit values in the lepton sector, we further demonstrate the numerical analyses for the LFVs, muon g-2 , lepton universality, and the relic density of DM. We have conclusions and discussion in Sec. IV. In Appendix A, we show the three-loop function in the neutrino sector. Leptons Bosons \overline{L_{L}} {\ell}_{R} N_{R} H S^{+}_{1} S^{+}_{2} SU(2)_{L} \bm{2} \bm{1} \bm{1} \bm{2} \bm{1} \bm{1} U(1)_{Y} -\frac{1}{2} 1 0 \frac{1}{2} +1 +1 A_{4} 3 3 3 1 1 1 -k_{I} -1 +1 0 0 +2 -1 Table 1: Field contents and their charge assignments in the model under SU(2)_{L}\times U(1)_{Y}\times A_{4} where -k_{I} is the number of modular weight. II Model setup In this section, we show setup of the model based on G_{\rm SM}\times A_{4} symmetry where G_{\rm SM} being the SM gauge symmetry and A_{4} is modular one. In lepton sector, We introduce singlet fermion which is triplet under A_{4} with modular weight 0. In scalar sector, we introduce two charged singlets distinguished by modular weight +2 and -1 . The SM leptons \overline{L_{L}} and \ell_{R} are also A_{4} triplets with modular weight -1 and +1 respectively. The assignments are summarized in Table 1 . By the assignments of modular weight, we can eliminate unwanted terms like \overline{N_{R}}L_{L}H and neutrino masses are generated at three-loop level as discussed below. The relevant Lagrangian under these symmetries is given by \displaystyle-{\cal L}_{\ell} \displaystyle={a_{e}}\left[y_{1}\overline{L_{L_{e}}}+y_{2}\overline{L_{L_{\tau}}}+y_{3}\overline{L_{L_{\mu}}}\right]e_{R}H+{a_{\mu}}\left[y_{2}\overline{L_{L_{\mu}}}+y_{3}\overline{L_{L_{e}}}+y_{1}\overline{L_{L_{\tau}}}\right]\mu_{R}H \displaystyle+{a_{\tau}}\left[y_{3}\overline{L_{L_{\tau}}}+y_{1}\overline{L_{L_{\mu}}}+y_{2}\overline{L_{L_{e}}}\right]\tau_{R}H \displaystyle+{a_{\nu}}\left[y_{1}(\overline{L_{L_{\mu}}}{L^{C}_{L_{\tau}}}-\overline{L_{L_{\tau}}}{L^{C}_{L_{\mu}}})+y_{2}(\overline{L_{L_{\tau}}}{L^{C}_{L_{e}}}-\overline{L_{L_{e}}}{L^{C}_{L_{\tau}}})+y_{3}(\overline{L_{L_{e}}}{L^{C}_{L_{\mu}}}-\overline{L_{L_{\mu}}}{L^{C}_{L_{e}}})\right]S^{-}_{1} \displaystyle+{b_{\nu}}\left[y_{1}\overline{e^{C}_{R}}+y_{2}\overline{\tau^{C}_{R}}+y_{3}\overline{\mu^{C}_{R}}\right]N_{R_{1}}S^{+}_{2}+{c_{\nu}}\left[y_{2}\overline{\mu^{C}_{R}}+y_{3}\overline{e^{C}_{R}}+y_{1}\overline{\tau^{C}_{R}}\right]N_{R_{2}}S^{+}_{2} \displaystyle+{d_{\nu}}\left[y_{3}\overline{\tau^{C}_{R}}+y_{1}\overline{\mu^{C}_{R}}+y_{2}\overline{e^{C}_{R}}\right]N_{R_{3}}S^{+}_{2} \displaystyle+M_{1}(\overline{N^{C}_{R_{1}}}N_{R_{1}}+\overline{N^{C}_{R_{2}}}N_{R_{3}}+\overline{N^{C}_{R_{3}}}N_{R_{2}}) \displaystyle M_{2}\left[y_{1}(2\overline{N^{C}_{R_{1}}}N_{R_{1}}-\overline{N^{C}_{R_{2}}}N_{R_{3}}-\overline{N^{C}_{R_{3}}}N_{R_{2}})+y_{2}(2\overline{N^{C}_{R_{2}}}N_{R_{2}}-\overline{N^{C}_{R_{1}}}N_{R_{3}}-\overline{N^{C}_{R_{3}}}N_{R_{1}})\right. \displaystyle\left.+y_{3}(2\overline{N^{C}_{R_{3}}}N_{R_{3}}-\overline{N^{C}_{R_{1}}}N_{R_{2}}-\overline{N^{C}_{R_{2}}}N_{R_{1}})\right]+{\rm h.c.}, (II.1) where we define Y_{3}^{(0)}=[y_{1},y_{2},y_{3}] Qu and Ding 2024 . The first two terms generates the mass of charged-leptons and parameters a_{e},a_{\mu},a_{\tau} are real without loss of generality by rephasing them into e_{R},\mu_{R},\tau_{R} , respectively. II.1 Scalar sector The scalar potential in the model is given by \displaystyle{\cal V} \displaystyle=\mu_{H}^{2}|H|^{2}+\mu^{2}_{S_{1}}|S_{1}^{+}|^{2}+\mu^{2}_{S_{2}}|S_{2}^{+}|^{2}+\lambda_{0}[(S_{1}^{+}S_{2}^{-})^{2}+{\rm h.c.}] \displaystyle+\lambda_{H}|H|^{4}+\lambda_{S_{1}}|S_{1}^{+}|^{4}+\lambda_{S_{2}}|S_{2}^{+}|^{4}+\lambda_{HS_{1}}|H|^{2}|S_{1}^{+}|^{2}+\lambda_{HS_{2}}|H|^{2}|S_{2}^{+}|^{2}+\lambda_{S_{1}S_{2}}|S_{1}^{+}|^{2}|S_{2}^{+}|^{2}. (II.2) The SM Higgs field is denoted by H=\begin{pmatrix}w^{+}\\ \frac{v+\tilde{h}+iz}{\sqrt{2}}\end{pmatrix}, (II.3) and v\approx 246 GeV is vacuum expectation value (VEV) in the Higgs basis after the spontaneous symmetry breaking, z is absorbed by the neutral gauge boson of the SM Z , and w^{+} is absorbed by the charged gauge boson of the SM W^{+} . The charged scalar masses are respectively given by \displaystyle m_{S_{1}}^{2}=\mu^{2}_{S_{1}}+\frac{1}{2}\lambda_{HS_{1}}v^{2}, (II.4) \displaystyle m_{S_{2}}^{2}=\mu^{2}_{S_{2}}+\frac{1}{2}\lambda_{HS_{2}}v^{2}. (II.5) In the numerical analysis we consider m_{S_{1,2}} to be free parameters. II.2 Charged-lepton mass matrix After the spontaneous electroweak symmetry breaking, the charged-lepton mass matrix M_{e} is given by \displaystyle M_{e}=\frac{v}{\sqrt{2}}\begin{pmatrix}y_{1}&y_{3}&y_{2}\\ y_{3}&y_{2}&y_{1}\\ y_{2}&y_{1}&y_{3}\\ \end{pmatrix}\begin{pmatrix}a_{e}&0&0\\ 0&a_{\mu}&0\\ 0&0&a_{\tau}\\ \end{pmatrix}. (II.6) Then, the charged-lepton mass matrix is diagonalized by a bi-unitary mixing matrix as D_{\ell}\equiv{\rm diag}(m_{e},m_{\mu},m_{\tau})=V^{\dagger}_{eL}M_{e}V_{eR} . Therefore, \ell_{L(R)}\equiv V_{eL(R)}\ell^{\prime}_{L(R)} where \ell^{\prime}_{L(R)} is the mass eigenstate. These three parameters are used in order to fit the mass eigenvalues of charged-leptons by solving the following three relations: \displaystyle{\rm Tr}[M_{e}M_{e}^{\dagger}]=|m_{e}|^{2}+|m_{\mu}|^{2}+|m_{\tau}|^{2}, (II.7) \displaystyle{\rm Det}[M_{e}M_{e}^{\dagger}]=|m_{e}|^{2}|m_{\mu}|^{2}|m_{\tau}|^{2}, (II.8) \displaystyle({\rm Tr}[M_{e}M_{e}^{\dagger}])^{2}-{\rm Tr}[(M_{e}M_{e}^{{\dagger}})^{2}]=2(|m_{e}|^{2}|m_{\mu}|^{2}+|m_{\mu}|^{2}|m_{\tau}|^{2}+|m_{e}|^{2}|m_{\tau}|^{2}). (II.9) For our convenience to construct the neutrino mass matrix below, we define \tilde{D}_{\ell} that is given by D_{\ell}\equiv m_{\tau}\tilde{D}_{\ell} . II.3 Heavier Majorana fermion mass matrix The heavier Majorana mass matrix is given by \displaystyle M_{N}=M_{1}\left[\begin{pmatrix}1&0&0\\ 0&0&1\\ 0&1&0\\ \end{pmatrix}+\tilde{M}_{2}\begin{pmatrix}2y_{1}&-y_{3}&-y_{2}\\ -y_{3}&2y_{2}&-y_{1}\\ -y_{2}&-y_{1}&2y_{3}\\ \end{pmatrix}\right]\equiv M_{1}\tilde{M}_{N}, (II.10) where \tilde{M}_{2}\equiv M_{2}/M_{1} can be real without loss of generality. M_{N} is diagonalized by D_{N}\equiv U_{N}^{T}M_{N}U_{N} ( \tilde{D}_{N}\equiv U_{N}^{T}\tilde{M}_{N}U_{N} )., therefore N_{R}\equiv U_{N}\psi_{R} . Here, \psi_{R} is the mass eigenstate. II.4 Active neutrino mass matrix The active neutrino mass matrix is given at three-loop level via the following Lagrangian in terms of mass eigenstates \displaystyle a_{\nu}\left(\overline{\nu_{L}}H\ell^{\prime C}_{L}+\overline{\ell^{\prime}_{L}}H^{T}\nu^{C}_{L}\right)S^{-}_{1}+b_{\nu}\overline{\ell^{\prime C}_{R}}Y\psi_{R}S^{+}_{2}+{\rm h.c.}, (II.11) where H\equiv hV^{*}_{eL} and Y\equiv V^{T}_{eR}yU_{N} . The Yukawa matrices y and h are respectively found as \displaystyle h \displaystyle=\begin{pmatrix}0&y_{3}&-y_{2}\\ -y_{3}&0&y_{1}\\ y_{2}&-y_{1}&0\\ \end{pmatrix}, (II.12) \displaystyle y \displaystyle=\begin{pmatrix}y_{1}&y_{3}&y_{2}\\ y_{3}&y_{2}&y_{1}\\ y_{2}&y_{1}&y_{3}\\ \end{pmatrix}\begin{pmatrix}1&0&0\\ 0&\tilde{c}_{\nu}&0\\ 0&0&\tilde{d}_{\nu}\\ \end{pmatrix}, (II.13) where \tilde{c}(\tilde{d})_{\nu}\equiv c(d)_{\nu}/b_{\nu} are complex free parameters. The neutrino mass matrix is then given by \displaystyle(m_{\nu})_{ij} \displaystyle\approx-\frac{\lambda_{0}(a_{\nu}b_{\nu})^{2}}{(4\pi)^{6}}\frac{m^{2}_{\tau}}{M_{1}}H^{*}\tilde{D}_{\ell}Y^{*}\tilde{D}_{N}FY^{\dagger}\tilde{D}_{\ell}H^{\dagger}\equiv\kappa\tilde{m}_{\nu}, (II.14) Here, F is a loop function via three loop diagram and it depends on the mass eigenvalues of \{\psi_{R},S_{1}^{+},S_{2}^{+}\} . 1 1 1 In general, the loop function also depends on the masses of charged-leptons. However, we

Read the complete text