Time path of turbulence and multi-fractality of magnetic field in the evolution of an active region

Valentina Abramenko · 2025

Read Time path of turbulence and multi-fractality of magnetic field in the evolution of an active region by Valentina Abramenko (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-02586.txt.

Introduction

Valentina Abramenko studies the magnetic field at the surface of the Sun in a 2025 solar physics study. She follows one mature active region as it crossed the solar disk and produced flares. Her data come from magnetograms taken by an imager aboard the Solar Dynamics Observatory.

Abramenko tracks turbulence through magnetic power spectra and multifractality through structure functions over time. Neither measure jumps sharply before or after single flares. Instead both shift smoothly and line up better with the region's overall complexity and flare productivity. The result suggests the surface layer organizes itself on its own track, apart from the more burst-like corona above it.

Catalog record

CREATORValentina Abramenko
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE34 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-02586

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Time path of turbulence and multi-fractality of magnetic field in the evolution of an active region Valentina Abramenko Abstract keywords Active Regions, Magnetic fields; Magnetic fields, Photosphere; Turbulence; Instabilities \setlastpage \inarticletrue {opening} 1 Introduction The solar surface is thought to be a thin layer of several hundred kilometers, hosting sunspots (sunspot groups), which are visible as dark features on white-light images and surviving usually several weeks. The above atmosphere is spread over a huge volume and undergoes fast, sporadic changes continuously, especially above sunspots. In the photosphere of the sunspot group, on one hand, and in the atmosphere above, on the other hand, we observe different physical conditions (temperature, gas pressure, velocities, etc.), different temporal rhythm of changes, different spatial scales of phenomena. Albeit, all this makes the joined system - a solar active region (AR). How the connection between the photosphere and corona works in an AR - a question which is still open. What kind of phenomena and on what temporal and spatial scales provide an energy and/or information exchange between the slow-varying photosphere and the bursty developing corona? The most plausible agent to connect the photosphere with upper atmospheric layers is the magnetic field: the magnetic field lines are thought to penetrate from the solar interior through the photosphere into the corona and eventually return back to the Sun. Moreover, it is thought than the magnetic field is capable to deliver into the corona the free magnetic energy necessary to feed the solar flaring process ( Fang et al. 2012 ; Vekstein 2016 ) (see, however, a recent publication Karimov et al. 2024 ). Concerning the flaring process, what do we know about the flare-related interaction between the photosphere and corona from observations? The so-called white-light flares ( Angle 1961 ; Hudson 1972 ; Cortellessa and Paizis 1975 ; Gan, Hénoux, and Fang 2000 ; Hudson 2016 ) are a response of the photosphere to strong beams of charged particles penetrating deep down during the flaring process occurring in the upper layers. Sunquakes ( Donea 2011 ; Judge et al. 2014 ; Russell et al. 2016 ) also seem to be the photospheric response to flares via seismic waves. Investigations of the flare-related magnetic field changes in the photosphere are rather scanty. Chen et al. 2007 and Wang et al. 2007 revealed that during a flare, the magnetic field in a sunspot can become more vertical, which can be explained by reconnection of magnetic field lines in the corona during the flare. Burtseva et al. 2015 showed that strongest flare-related changes in the photospheric magnetic field occur in pixels, where the kernels of the hard X-ray emission are located; the peak in the magnetic changes can occur before or after the X-ray peak. These authors interpret the result as a response of the photosphere to the current sheet formation and subsequent reconnection in the corona. A question about the reverse connection - from the photosphere to corona - seems to be much more complicated and less explored. The hypothetical concept that the observed growth of the sunspot area is accompanied by the emergence of magnetic flux tubes seems to be supported by numerical simulations ( Abbett, Fisher, and Fan 2000 ; Archontis 2008 ; Fang et al. 2010 ) (see also a review by Fan 2009 ), however, cannot help much in understanding the observed burst-like behavior of coronal magnetic energy release. The energy transfer mechanisms via magneto-hydrodynamic and acoustic waves for coronal heating ( Bingham et al. 2010 ; Verdini, Grappin, and Velli 2012 ) and solar wind acceleration ( Ofman 2010 ) are widely explored, however, these mechanisms can hardly help much in explaining the spontaneous flaring process, covering a huge variety of spatial and temporal scales. Again, we return to the magnetic field that penetrates and consolidates an active region, from sub-photosphere to the upper layers of the corona. As it is mentioned above, the energy necessary for flaring comes from the photosphere to the corona as energy of twisted magnetic field. How does the mechanism work? Presumably, twisting of the magnetic field lines and electric current generation due to turbulent motions of solar plasma provides the magnetic energy for flaring (see an excellent review of observational aspects in Archontis 2008 ). To this end, a measure of complexity of the photospheric field should be in accordance with the flaring productivity of an AR. The key question is what an entity/parameter should be taken as a measure of complexity. The first thing that comes to mind is the parameters of turbulence and multi-fractality. There were several publications demonstrating this concept from an observational point of view. Thus, in Abramenko 2005b based on high-resolution MDI magnetograms for 16 ARs and quantitative index of flare activity (derived as a sum of GOES flare magnitudes over the interval of observations of an AR), it was reported that the magnetic energy spectrum tends to be steeper for ARs with higher flare index. Hewett et al. 2008 ; McAteer, Gallagher, and Conlon 2010 , using the full-disk and high-resolution MDI data for ARs NOAA 9077, 10488 explored the spectra of multi-fractatity and magnetic energy and concluded that these measures are promising to ”… predict the true flare potential of individual active region in near-realtime.” Conlon et al. 2010 explored 5 ARs using a sophisticated wavelet transform method to calculate a fractal dimension and a Holder exponent of the magnetic field. Authors reported that ”when sufficient flux is present in an active region for a period of time, it must be structured with a fractal dimension greater than 1.2, and a Holder exponent greater than -0.7, in order to produce M and X class flares.” In Abramenko and Yurchyshyn 2010b ; Abramenko and Yurchyshyn 2010a a statistical study was performed for 217 ARs on the basis of high-resolution MDI magnetograms: a flare index was plotted versus the magnetic power spectrum index, \alpha and the multi-fractality index, \kappa , with correlation coefficients of 0.53 and 0.63, respectively. The scattering in both diagrams was rather broad (see Fig. 2a in Abramenko and Yurchyshyn 2010b and Fig. 7 in Abramenko and Yurchyshyn 2010a ), so that the rather high correlation was ensured by a small number of highly-flaring ARs. These authors emphasized that application of their methods (Fourier spectrum and structure functions scaling) requires high-resolution data (see more details below). These results suggested that there exists a statistical tendency of active regions to show stronger degree of turbulence and multifractality with the enhancement of flaring capability. Using the same methods, augmented by the box-counting routine, Georgoulis 2012 (the paper was accepted for publication in 2010) analyzed the 4-hour time series of low-resolution MDI full-disk magnetograms for 370 ARs, predominantly segregating them into two categories: flaring (with M- and X-class flares) and non-flaring (the rest). Author examined the fractal dimension, a multifractality-related exponent and the magnetic power spectrum exponent, comparing their pre-flare and peak values in flaring regions with the peak values in non-flaring regions and found that none of these parameters could reliably distinguish the flaring ARs from the non-flaring ones. In spite of this rather questionable statistical inference, the paper by Georgoulis 2012 was very useful in terms of stimulation to search

Read the complete text