Classical pair of states as optimal pair for quantum distinguishability quantifiers

Bassano Vacchini, Andrea Smirne, Nina Megier · 2025

Read Classical pair of states as optimal pair for quantum distinguishability quantifiers by Bassano Vacchini, Andrea Smirne, Nina Megier (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-02575.txt.

Introduction

Bassano Vacchini, Andrea Smirne, and Nina Megier wrote a 2025 paper on how best to tell two quantum states apart. Measures of state distance matter for many quantum tasks. They also help sort which memory effects show up when a quantum system shrinks under outside contact.

A key trait of these measures is that they never grow under noise maps that keep total probability fixed. The authors prove that this single demand pins down the top scoring pairs. The max is reached only by pairs of fully opposed states, ones with no overlap at all. Such pairs act like plain classical bits. The result gives a clean anchor for how quantum distance tools must behave.

Catalog record

CREATORBassano Vacchini, Andrea Smirne, Nina Megier
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE62 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-02575

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Classical pair of states as optimal pair for quantum distinguishability quantifiers Bassano Vacchini, Andrea Smirne, Nina Megier Abstract The capability to quantitatively distinguish quantum states is of great importance for a variety of tasks, and has recently played an important role in the study of quantum reduced dynamics and their characterization in terms of memory effects. A crucial property of quantum distinguishability quantifiers considered in the latter framework is the contractivity under the action of completely positive trace preserving maps. We show that this requirement warrants that the pairs on which these quantifiers attain their maximal value are pairs of orthogonal, and in this sense classical, states. I Introduction Quantifying the difference between probability distributions is essential in many and diverse fields, notably including statistics and information theory. In particular, f -divergences provide a unified framework for defining several distinguishability measures, such as the Kullback–Leibler and the Jensen-Shannon divergences, that further possess well-defined operational interpretations. In the quantum setting, distinguishing probability distributions extends to the problem of distinguishing quantum states. Accordingly, f -divergences for probability distributions can be generalized to define quantum distinguishability quantifiers, including the quantum relative entropy, the Holevo quantity for two-element ensembles, and the trace distance. These quantifiers are widely employed in quantum information, computation and communication, as well as in investigating general dynamical evolutions of quantum systems, in particular to identify the presence of memory effects or nonclassicality Bengtsson2017 ; Chruscinski2022a ; Vacchini2024 . A fundamental property of quantum distinguishability quantifiers is their contractivity under completely positive trace preserving maps. The latter represents a broad family of quantum-state transformations – arising, for example, from non-selective measurements or interactions with the initially factorized environment – and the contractivity ensures that such processes cannot enhance the capability to distinguish among the states of the system. In this article, we establish a direct connection between the contractivity of quantum distinguishability quantifiers under completely positive trace preserving maps and their optimal pairs, i.e., the pair of quantum states for which the quantifier attains its maximum value Wissmann2012a ; Breuer2012a . Specifically, we demonstrate that if a quantum distinguishability quantifier is contractive under completely positive maps, and its invariance guarantees invertibility of the map when restricted to commuting states, then the quantifier reaches its maximum value only and for all orthogonal state pairs, i.e., states that share a common eigenbasis and can thus be considered in this respect a classical pair. The relevance of classical states in assessing properties of quantum distinguishability quantifiers has been recently put into evidence also in Osan2022a ; Bussandri2023a ; Lanier2025a . Moreover, we present in a unified framework well-known contractive quantum distinguishability quantifiers for which the optimal pairs are all orthogonal states, as well as non-contractive quantifiers for which orthogonality does not guarantee optimality. Indeed, such a different behavior is possible and even desirable for certain information tasks DePalma2021a . We further investigate the contractivity of the quantum distinguishability quantifiers by relating it to invariance properties of the quantifiers. Specifically, we show that if the quantifier is contractive under the partial trace operation or jointly convex in its arguments, contractivity under completely positive trace preserving maps is in one-to-one correspondence with the invariance under unitary transformations and assignment maps. The rest of the paper is organized as follows. In Sect. II we recall the definition and key properties of classical f -divergences, also presenting some examples; we then move to the quantum setting, introducing the notion of quantum distinguishability quantifiers, the properties they satisfy and some significant examples that reduce to classical f -divergences when evaluated on couples of commuting states. In Sect. III , we derive the main result of the paper, i.e., the theorem proving that orthogonality of a couple of quantum states is a necessary and sufficient condition for their optimality for contractive distinguishability quantifiers, and we show how some well-known quantifiers can be understood within a unified framework by virtue of the theorem; instead, in Sect. IV , we present quantum distinguishability quantifiers for which contractivity under completely positive trace preserving maps does not hold, orthogonality being a necessary but not sufficient condition for the optimal pair. In Sect. V , the relationships between contractivity and invariance properties for a quantum distinguishability quantifier are presented. Finally, concluding remarks are given in Sect. VI . II Classical and quantum distinguishability quantifiers We introduce quantum distinguishability quantifiers starting from the classical framework, which allows us to take the unified perspective of f -divergences without lack of rigour but avoiding to deal with the many subtle aspects involved in the definition of quantum f -divergences. Indeed, due to non commutativity of the operators, different quantum generalizations of f -divergences can be considered, see e.g. Hiai2011a . It is important to stress that, while f -divergences include most of the well-known and studied distinguishability quantifiers Crooks , not all of them can be recast in this form. We mention in this respect the Bhattacharyya coefficient or classical fidelity Bhattacharyya1943a ; Bhattacharyya1946a and correspondingly the quantum fidelity Jozsa1994a based on Uhlmann’s transition probability Uhlmann1976a . The emphasis in this concise presentation is on the role played by the contractivity of the considered distinguishability quantifiers with respect to the action of transformations that can describe the effect of a noisy transmission channel, be it classical or quantum, also called data processing inequality. This feature leads to important invariances for the distinguishability quantifiers, in both classical and quantum formulations. We will consider in particular distinguishability quantifiers for which saturation of the data processing inequality under the action of a noisy transformation on a collection of states implies reversibility of the transformation on these states, as it happens for f -divergences in the classical case when the function f is strictly convex. This result will prove instrumental to the characterization of pairs on which these contractive distinguishability quantifiers take their maximum value. II.1 Distinguishability quantifiers expressible as f -divergences The motivation for the introduction of f -divergences is the comparison of classical probability distributions, typically describing signals arising from two distinct sources, to investigate the effect of the unavoidable noise on the propagation of these signals. The guiding idea is that the action of any realistic noise source along the transmission line should reduce the extent to which the signals coming from the two distinct sources can be seen to differ or diverge from one another. It is therefore of interest to introduce ways to compare probability distributions that keep this crucial feature into account. This task is accomplished by f -divergences, introduced in Csiszar1963a ; Csiszar1967a and independently in Ali1966a , that are a class of distinguishability quantifiers between probability distributions specified by a suitable convex function f . Let f be a non-negative continuous convex function defined on the positive real line, and suppose for the sake of simplicity to have a discrete set X of outcomes for the probability distributions. Definition 1 (Classical f -divergence Csiszar1963a ; Ali1966a ) Given the distributions \boldsymbol{p} with elements \{p_{i}\}_{i\in X} and \boldsymbol{q} with elements \{q_{i}\}_{i\in X} the quantity \displaystyle D_{f}(\boldsymbol{p},\boldsymbol{q}) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\sum_{i\in X}q_{i}f\left(\frac{p_{i}}{q_{i}}\right), (1) set equal to zero for vanishing q_{i} , is the f -divergence between \boldsymbol{p} and \boldsymbol{q} . This expression taking on positive values quantifies how

Read the complete text