Active inference as a unified model of collision avoidance behavior in human drivers
Julian F. Schumann, Johan Engström, Leif Johnson, Matthew O’Kelly, Joao Messias, Jens Kober, Arkady Zgonnikov · 2025
Read Active inference as a unified model of collision avoidance behavior in human drivers by Julian F. Schumann, Johan Engström, Leif Johnson, Matthew O’Kelly, Joao Messias, Jens Kober, Arkady Zgonnikov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-02215.txt.
Introduction
Julian Schumann and six colleagues wrote a 2025 paper modeling how human drivers avoid collisions. Avoiding a crash takes fast threat detection and a quick, correct evasive move. Existing models cover only parts of this behavior, such as reaction time, or only one kind of scenario.
The authors propose one unified model based on active inference, a theory that describes behavior as minimizing free energy, a measure of surprise. In this view, a driver acts to make the world match what they expect, and swerves when events diverge from expectations. A single model that covers detection, decision, and movement could improve both driver training and the design of automated emergency systems in cars.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Julian F. Schumann, Johan Engström, Leif Johnson, Matthew O’Kelly, Joao Messias, Jens Kober, Arkady Zgonnikov |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 134 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-02215
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Active inference as a unified model of collision avoidance behavior in human drivers Julian F. Schumann, Johan Engström, Leif Johnson, Matthew O’Kelly, Joao Messias, Jens Kober, Arkady Zgonnikov Abstract Collision avoidance – involving a rapid threat detection and quick execution of the appropriate evasive maneuver – is a critical aspect of driving. However, existing models of human collision avoidance behavior are fragmented, focusing on specific scenarios or only describing certain aspects of the avoidance behavior, such as response times. This paper addresses these gaps by proposing a novel computational cognitive model of human collision avoidance behavior based on active inference. Active inference provides a unified approach to modeling human behavior: the minimization of free energy. Building on prior active inference work, our model incorporates established cognitive mechanisms such as evidence accumulation to simulate human responses in two distinct collision avoidance scenarios: front-to-rear lead vehicle braking and lateral incursion by an oncoming vehicle. We demonstrate that our model explains a wide range of previous empirical findings on human collision avoidance behavior. Specifically, the model closely reproduces both aggregate results from meta-analyses previously reported in the literature and detailed, scenario-specific effects observed in a recent driving simulator study, including response timing, maneuver selection, and execution. Our results highlight the potential of active inference as a unified framework for understanding and modeling human behavior in complex real-life driving tasks. Figure 1 : An illustration of the key principles of our active inference model in the opposite-direction lateral incursion scenario. Upper left panel: The modeled agent (at the bottom, facing forward) is continuously generating beliefs (represented by the arrows) about how the current driving situation will play out and what future observations it will make as a consequence of its own actions and the actions of the other vehicle. In ”normal”, non-conflict situations, the situation typically plays out as expected. The agent thus initially believes with high certainty that both itself and the oncoming vehicle will remain in their lanes and pass each other safely. This yields low expected free energy (EFE; green arrows) since the agent’s expected (and thus preferred) observations (e.g., making progress, avoid collisions) are aligned with the actual observations. Upper right panel: When the oncoming vehicle suddenly encroaches into the driver’s lane, the EFE increases rapidly (as indicated by the red arrows) because this new situation is likely to result in an observed collision in the future, which is strongly disfavored by the agent. In this situation, the agent’s belief about the oncoming vehicle’s future trajectory also becomes more uncertain, because the other vehicle can no longer be trusted to follow established traffic norms. The agent thus needs to imagine a better future with lower EFE – in this case, a scenario where it avoids collision by swerving left (lower left panel) and take action to make that better future come true (lower right panel). Collision avoidance is a critical skill for human drivers. It involves the rapid detection of threats (such as a vehicle ahead suddenly braking) and deciding on an appropriate evasive maneuver (for instance, braking or swerving). These maneuvers are complex, requiring not only precise execution but also continuous adjustments as the situation evolves. Furthermore, drivers need to account for the uncertainty in the future behavior of other road users: for example, will an oncoming vehicle encroaching into my lane continue across or move back to its own lane? Understanding how humans avoid collisions in traffic can provide insights into high-stakes, split-second decision making which has substantial implications for traffic safety. Behavior models play a key role both in understanding the mechanisms of human collision avoidance and in improving traffic safety. These models are applied in diverse contexts, such as collision risk estimation bargman_how_2015 , understanding effects of driver distraction engstrom_simulating_2018 , modeling take-over behavior bianchi_piccinini_how_2020 , representing human agents in simulated test environments montali_waymo_2023 , and providing behavioral benchmarks for autonomous vehicles olleja_validation_2024 ; engstrom_modeling_2024 . Besides immediate practical applications, modeling human collision avoidance behavior is an interesting subject of study in its own right. Being a highly complex and dynamic task with extremely high stakes, collision avoidance provides a unique testbed for theories and models of cognition previously not validated in the real world matusz_are_2019 ; shamay-tsoory_real-life_2019 ; carvalho_naturalistic_2025 . Most existing computational models of human collision avoidance are mechanistic, that is, are based on the explicit modeling of cognitive mechanisms underlying response timing and evasive maneuvering. However, they are typically fragmented, focusing either on specific scenario types (e.g., front-to-rear conflicts xue_using_2018 ; svard_computational_2021 ; guo_safety_2021 or merging siebinga_model_2024-1 ), specific explanatory factors (such as off-road glances bargman_how_2015 ; markkula_farewell_2016 or cognitive load engstrom_simulating_2018 ), or only reproduce certain aspects of human behavior (such as response times xue_using_2018 ; bianchi_piccinini_how_2020 ; svard_computational_2021 ; wei_modeling_2022 ; engstrom_modeling_2024 or the extent of steering li_modeling_2023 ). Altogether, these models cover a wide range of scenarios and diverse aspects of collision avoidance behavior. Yet, each one of these mechanistic models on its own is highly specific: they are not designed to generalize to multiple scenarios or describe multiple aspects of human behavior. Recently, machine learning models based on large datasets of human driving have demonstrated the ability to generalize across a wide range of traffic scenarios yuan_agentformer_2021 ; suo2021trafficsim ; gu_stochastic_2022 ; igl2022symphony ; meszaros_trajflow_2024 ; montali_waymo_2023 . Because such models typically generate full motion trajectories, they also have the potential to represent multiple aspects of collision avoidance behavior and not just a single metric of interest. However, a key challenge is that safety-critical behavior such as collision avoidance is often under-represented in the datasets used for training ivanovic_trajdata_2023 , which makes it hard to achieve representative human-like collision avoidance behavior solely based on learning from data schumann_benchmarking_2023 . Thus, there is currently a lack of models that can capture the key aspects of human collision avoidance behavior (response selection, timing, and execution) all at the same time and across different scenarios. This limits both practical applications (due to the need to develop a new model for every new scenario) and fundamental understanding of cognitive mechanisms underlying the behavior of humans in safety-critical situations in traffic (due to the lack of a unified explanation for multiple aspects of behavior). To address this gap, here we present a unified collision avoidance model based on active inference. Originating in computational neuroscience, active inference is a versatile general framework for understanding and modeling sentient behavior in living systems friston_active_2017 ; da_costa_active_2020 ; parr_active_2022 that has been previously used to model human behavior in diverse contexts smith_recent_2021 ; vasil_world_2020 ; bottemanne_active_2021 ; harris_active_2022 ; novicky_precision_2024 , including the modeling of human driver behavior such as car following wei_world_2023 , responses to driving automation failures wei_modeling_2022 , and managing uncertainty around occlusions and non-driving-related tasks engstrom_resolving_2024 . Building on the model of Engström et al. engstrom_resolving_2024 , here we propose an active inference-based model to capture a spectrum of human behaviors in collision avoidance. Our model incorporates several well-known cognitive mechanisms to represent the dynamics of human decision making in response to sudden stimuli, such as looming perception lee_theory_1976 ; gibson_ecological_2014 and evidence accumulation luce_response_1986 ; gold2007neural ; ratcliff2011diffusion ; markkula2014modeling . We evaluated our model against a range of previously reported empirical findings