Discrete vortex-based broadcast mode analysis for modification of dynamic stall

Het D. Patel, Yi Tsung Lee, Ashok Gopalarathnam, Chi-An Yeh · 2025

Read Discrete vortex-based broadcast mode analysis for modification of dynamic stall by Het D. Patel, Yi Tsung Lee, Ashok Gopalarathnam, Chi-An Yeh (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-01835.txt.

Introduction

Het Patel and co-authors pinpoint where to poke a wing to tame stall in this 2025 paper. When a pitching wing stalls, lift drops hard and fast. The team models the swirling flow as a network of vortex points and tracks how nudges spread through it.

Their broadcast analysis names the vortex spots, timing, and direction with the most leverage. The best moment falls just after flow splits, as the stall vortex forms. Shear layer spots beat all others for control. Flow tests with well-placed jets cut peak lift drops by wide margins in both flat and shaped wing cases.

Catalog record

CREATORHet D. Patel, Yi Tsung Lee, Ashok Gopalarathnam, Chi-An Yeh
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE74 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-01835

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Discrete vortex-based broadcast mode analysis for modification of dynamic stall Het D. Patel, Yi Tsung Lee, Ashok Gopalarathnam, Chi-An Yeh Abstract We integrate a discrete vortex method with complex network analysis to strategize dynamic stall mitigation over a pitching airfoil with active flow control. The objective is to inform the actuator placement and the timing to introduce control inputs during the transient process of dynamic stall. To this end, we treat the massively separated flow as a network of discrete vortical elements and quantify the interactions among the vortical nodes by tracking the spread of displacement perturbations between each pair of vortical elements using the discrete vortex method. This allows us to perform network broadcast mode analysis to identify an optimal set of discrete vortices, the critical timing, and the direction to seed perturbations as control inputs. Motivated by the objective of dynamic stall mitigation, the optimality is defined as minimizing the total circulation of the free vortices generated from the leading edge over a prescribed time horizon. We demonstrate the use of the analysis on a two-dimensional flow over a flat plate airfoil and a three-dimensional turbulent flow over a SD7003 airfoil. The results from the network analysis reveal that the optimal timing for introducing disturbances occurs slightly after the onset of flow separation, when the shear layer pinches up and forms the core of dynamic stall vortex. The broadcast modes also show that the vortical nodes along the shear layer are optimal for introducing disturbances, hence providing guidance to actuator placement. We validate these insights via flow simulations by placing an actuator near the leading edge of an airfoil to target the shear layer slightly after the separation onset. This results in a 12 % 12\% and 30 % 30\% reduction in peak lift for flows over the flat plate and SD 7003 7003 airfoil, respectively. A corresponding decrease in vorticity injection from the airfoil surface under the influence of control is observed from simulations, which aligns with the objective of the network broadcast analysis. The study highlights the potential of integrating the discrete vortex methods with the network analysis to design an effective active flow control strategy for unsteady aerodynamics. 1 Introduction Dynamic stall is a critical phenomenon that significantly limits the performance of unsteady wings due to large-amplitude fluctuations in lift force beyond the static limit ( McCroskey 1981 ; Carr 1988 ) . This phenomenon is intrinsically linked to the unsteady separation of flow over the wing surface, culminating in the formation of a dynamic stall vortex (DSV) ( McCroskey et al. 1976 ) . The DSV is a dominant flow feature of dynamic stall flows, generated by the accumulation of surface vorticity flux concentrated near the leading edge during the wing’s motion ( Eldredge and Jones 2019 ) . The severe unsteady aerodynamic loads associated with dynamic stall can impose significant performance and structural constraints, underscoring the importance of effective mitigation strategies with active flow control ( Karim and Acharya 1994 ; Greenblatt and Wygnanski 2001 ; Weaver et al. 2004 ; Kissing et al. 2021 ) . While active flow control has demonstrated promising capabilities in mitigating dynamic stall, its design can be challenging due to the highly unsteady and transient nature of the flow ( Gardner et al. 2017 ; Zhu et al. 2022 ; Gardner et al. 2023 ) . Particularly, the transient nature of the flow makes it difficult, yet ever crucial, to determine an effective timing and location for control inputs to be introduced. The timing of actuation for dynamic stall flows is unclear due to the intricate interplay between the time scale of the flow dynamics and that of the wing motion ( Feszty et al. 2004 ; Tadjfar and Asgari 2018 ; Lombardi et al. 2013 ; de Souza et al. 2025 ) . Such interplay also makes actuator placement a daunting question, since it causes separation point to travel over a great extent of the suction surface ( Weaver et al. 2004 ; Singh et al. 2006 ; Post and Corke 2006 ; Kissing et al. 2020 ) . Therefore, there is a critical need for formal theoretic approaches to determine effective timing and location of actuation ( Natarajan et al. 2016 ; Nair et al. 2021 ; Godavarthi et al. 2023 ) for mitigating dynamic stall. Complex network analysis emerges as an appealing tool to address the need, since analogous questions arise in the field of network science ( Newman 2010 ; Albert and Barabási 2002 ; Iacobello et al. 2021 ) . Determining a location for actuator placement is similar to identifying a hub for disease transmission over a human or animal network ( Nande et al. 2021 ; Safari et al. 2025 ) . Modulating the timing of introducing control input is also analogous to determining when to implement preventive measures for disease outbreak, such as social distancing and isolation ( Vinceti et al. 2020 ; Schlosser et al. 2020 ) . Therefore, not only does network science offer a broad and mature set of tools to address the aforementioned challenges for flow control ( Yeh et al. 2021 ; Sujith and Unni 2020 ) , but its use by the fluid dynamics community has also been witnessed in a growing number of studies, including model reduction ( Kaiser et al. 2014 ) , force prediction ( Iacobello et al. 2022 ) , and analyzing turbulent interactions ( Iacobello et al. 2019 ; Tandon and Sujith 2023 ; Li et al. 2021 ) . Constructing a network model requires the definitions of nodes and edge weights that quantify the interactions between the nodes. Establishing on a classic perspective in aerodynamics where fluid flows can be modeled as an ensemble of discrete vortices ( Anderson 2016 ; Saffman 1995 ; Eldredge 2007 ) , vortical elements have been adopted by many fluid dynamics studies as the nodes of fluid networks ( Bai et al. 2019 ; Lander and Holland 1993 ; Meena and Taira 2021 ) . To quantify the interactions between the vortical nodes, discrete vortex methods (DVMs) ( Katz 1981 ; Cottet and Koumoutsakos 2000 ) become a natural choice due to their extensive applications to aerodynamic studies ( Ramesh et al. 2014 ; SureshBabu et al. 2019 ; Herndon and Jaworski 2023 ; Alvarez and Ning 2020 ) . In general, DVMs model a flow by time-evolving the locations of discrete vortices in a Lagrangian manner. Moreover, they are capable of modeling unsteady aerodynamic flows by introducing new vortical elements into the flow while determining their circulation strength upon formation ( Clements 1973 ; Sarpkaya 1975 ; Ramesh et al. 2014 ) . Such introduction of finite-circulation vortices into the flow can be translated to vorticity injection that accounts for the formation of a dynamic stall vortex. Thus, in the context of DVMs, the objective of dynamic stall mitigation can be realized by modulating the strength of discrete vortices introduced to the flow, and such modulation can be achieved by perturbing the vortical elements present in the flow. Also, through an objective-informed combination of DVM and vortical network analysis, the effective timing, location, and direction of actuation can be identified by

Read the complete text