On some modifications of the Niemytzki plane

Wojciech Bielas · 2025

Read On some modifications of the Niemytzki plane by Wojciech Bielas (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-01707.txt.

Introduction

Wojciech Bielas compares modifications of the Niemytzki plane in a 2025 paper. The Niemytzki plane is a classic odd space in topology. Its tangent discs sit on a half plane's edge line.

Bielas gives a test that ranks one modification against another. Swapping the discs for triangles with bounded angles is one such tweak. Under his test, the triangle space fails to match the classic one. The two spaces are thus not homeomorphic, not the same shape. Small tweaks to a classic space can change its kind. The test may sort other tweaks of the plane as well.

Catalog record

CREATORWojciech Bielas
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE20 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-01707

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On some modifications of the Niemytzki plane Wojciech Bielas Abstract . We present a criterion that compares modifications of the Niemytzki plane. It follows that if usual tangent discs of the Niemytzki plane are replaced by triangles with bounded angles, then the resulting space is not homeomorphic to the former. 2010 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary 54C30, 54G20; Secondary 54D70, 26A24 1. Introduction The Niemytzki plane is a classical object in general topology and its modifications still appear as counterexamples, compare [ 3 ] or [ 7 ] . Recently, there have been attempts to generalise it to larger dimensions, [ 2 ] . Following Hattori [ 4 ] , new topologies on the closed upper plane which lie between the usual topology and the topology of the Niemytzki plane are discussed in [ 1 ] . In this paper we show that the topology of the Niemytzki plane depends on the shape of tangent discs and that changing this shape may change the topology. We present a quantitative criterion controlling such changes, see Lemma 2 . Replacing tangent discs with appropriate triangles results in a finer topology, which is not homeomorphic to the Niemytzki plane. Additionally, we show that obtaining the mentioned criterion is possible because monotone functions g\colon\mathbb{R}\to\mathbb{R} are differentiable almost everywhere, which results from the Lebesgue monotone differentiation theorem, and if the derivative g^{\prime}(x) exists, then (1) \textstyle\underset{h\to 0}{\liminf}\;\frac{g(x+\varphi(h))-g(x-\varphi(h))}{2\varphi(h)}\frac{2\psi(h)}{g(x+\psi(h))-g(x-\psi(h))}\leqslant 1 for any continuous functions \varphi,\psi\colon(0,\infty)\to(0,\infty) such that \varphi\leqslant\psi and \lim_{h\to 0}\psi(h)=0 . If g^{\prime}(x)\neq 0 , then the lower limit in ( 1 ) equals 1 , but the case g^{\prime}(x)=0 needs an extra effort. Our notation and topological terminology is fairly standard, as in [ 3 ] or [ 7 ] , but notions concerning differentiation are taken from standard textbooks on real analysis. We will use the Jordan curve theorem, compare [ 6 , p. 31] . 2. Topologies induced by families of functions Here, we present a method for obtaining some modifications of the Niemytzki plane. If f\colon[-a,a]\to[0,\infty) is a continuous function, then put U(0,f)=\{(0,0)\}\cup\{(x,y)\in\mathbb{R}^{2}\colon f(x)<y<\max f[[-a,a]]\} and U(x,f)=\{(y+x,z):(y,z)\in U(0,f)\} , shortly U(x,f)=U(0,f)+(x,0) . We say that a family of functions f_{n}\colon[-a_{n},a_{n}]\to[0,\infty) is basic , if the following conditions are fulfilled. • Each f_{n} is continuous and even. • The range of any f_{n} is [0,\frac{1}{n}] , so \max f_{n}[[-a_{n},a_{n}]]=\frac{1}{n} . • Always the restriction f_{n}|_{[0,a_{n}]} is one-to-one and f_{n}(0)=0 . • If m<n , then the Euclidean closure of U(0,f_{n}) is contained in the set U(0,f_{m}) . Given a basic family \{f_{n}\colon n\geqslant 1\} , on the half-plane H=\{(x,y)\in\mathbb{R}^{2}\colon y\geqslant 0\} let us introduce a topology generated by the Euclidean topology and the sets U(x,f_{n}) . Note that, if \textstyle f_{n}(x)=\frac{1}{n}-\sqrt{\frac{1}{n^{2}}-x^{2}}, then the family \{f_{n}|_{[-\frac{1}{n},\frac{1}{n}]}\colon n\geqslant 1\} is basic and generates the topology of the Niemytzki plane. It is straightforward to check that if functions f_{n}\colon[-a_{n},a_{n}]\to[0,\infty) constitute a basic family, then the restriction f_{n}|_{[0,a_{n}]} is strictly increasing, the restriction f_{n}|_{[-a_{n},0]} is strictly decreasing, in fact, both restrictions are homeomorphisms, therefore their images are arcs with endpoints (0,0) , (a_{n},\frac{1}{n}) , and (0,0),(-a_{n},\frac{1}{n}) , respectively. But U(x,f_{n}) is a translation of U(0,f_{n}) by the vector (x,0) . The induced topology gives the same closure of U(x,f_{n}) as in the Euclidean topology, so we denote this closure \operatorname{cl}U(x,f_{n}) . The topology of the Niemytzki plane can be induced by parabolas, which is shown in the example below. Example 1 . Let a_{n}=\frac{1}{n} , p_{n}\colon[-a_{n},a_{n}]\to[0,\frac{1}{n}] , p_{n}(x)=nx^{2} for n\geqslant 1 . For all x\in[-\frac{1}{n},\frac{1}{n}] we have \textstyle\frac{1}{n}-\sqrt{\frac{1}{n^{2}}-x^{2}}\leqslant nx^{2} and for all x\in[-\frac{1}{2n},\frac{1}{2n}] we have \textstyle nx^{2}\leqslant\frac{1}{2n}-\sqrt{\frac{1}{4n^{2}}-x^{2}}. These give inclusions \textstyle B((0,\frac{1}{2n}),\frac{1}{2n})\subseteq U(0,p_{n})\subseteq B((0,\frac{1}{n}),\frac{1}{n}), which are sufficient to check that sets \{U(0,p_{n})\colon n\geqslant 1\} constitute a base at (0,0) for the Niemytzki plane, hence sets \{U(x,p_{n})\colon n\geqslant 1\} constitute a base at (x,0) , too. Recall that if 0<s<t , then \lim_{x\to 0}\frac{m|x|^{t}}{n|x|^{s}}=0 for any m,n\geqslant 1 . For this reason, higher parabolas induce different nevertheless homeomorphic topologies, as is shown in the next example. Example 2 . Let a_{n}=n^{-2/s} and p_{s,n}\colon[-a_{n},a_{n}]\to[0,\frac{1}{n}] , and p_{s,n}(x)=n|x|^{s} , where s\in(0,\infty) and n\geqslant 1 . Let us denote by N_{s} the half-plane H with the topology induced by the basic family \{p_{s,n}\colon n\geqslant 1\} . Then for all s,t\in(0,\infty) the function f\colon N_{s}\to N_{t} , given by the formula f(x,y)=(x,y^{t/s}) , is a homeomorphism. Each of the spaces N_{s} is homeomorphic to the Niemytzki plane, since it is homeomorphic to N_{2} . Note that for s=1 we obtain triangles as neighbourhoods of (0,0) , but they are arbitrarily ,,slim”, i.e. their angles at the vertex (0,0) tend to 0 . Proposition 1 . Given a basic family \{f_{n}\colon n\geqslant 1\} , if a<b and U(a,f_{n})\cap U(b,f_{n})\neq\emptyset , then (a) the complement of U(a,f_{n})\cup U(b,f_{n}) has two connected components C and D , one of which, say C , is bounded, (b) for any (u,w)\in C and (v,z)\in\operatorname{cl}U(a,f_{n})\cap\operatorname{cl}U(b,f_{n}) we have \textstyle w\leqslant f_{n}(\frac{b-a}{2})\leqslant z, (c) for any (u,w)\in C there exists c,d\in[a,b] such that c\leqslant d and (u,w)=(\frac{c+d}{2},f_{n}(\frac{d-c}{2})). (a,0) (b,0) (\frac{a+b}{2},f_{n}(\frac{b-a}{2})) {}_{y=f_{n}(x-a)} {}_{y=f_{n}(x-b)} (u,w) (c,0) (d,0) {}_{y=f_{n}(x-c)} {}_{y=f_{n}(x-d)} (v,z) {}_{(a-a_{n},0)} {}_{(b+a_{n},0)} Proof. Condition (a) follows directly from the Jordan curve theorem, where we have to consider two plane simple closed curves, determined by arc with endpoints (a,0),(\frac{a+b}{2},f_{n}(\frac{b-a}{2})),(b,0) (the boundary of C ) and (a,0),(b,0),(b+a_{n},\frac{1}{n}),(a-a_{n},\frac{1}{n}) (the boundary of D ). Condition (b) can be verified by examining the above picture. Given (u,w)\in C , consider translations of the graph of f_{n} so that c=u-f_{n}^{-1}(w)\mbox{ and }d=u+f^{-1}_{n}(w). If u=\frac{c+d}{2}\geqslant\frac{a+b}{2} , then \textstyle c=u-f^{-1}_{n}(w)\geqslant\frac{a+b}{2}-\frac{b-a}{2}=a, by condition (b) . Since c\leqslant u\leqslant b , we have c\leqslant b . If u=\frac{c+d}{2}\leqslant\frac{a+b}{2} , then \textstyle u-a\leqslant\frac{a+b}{2}-a=\frac{b-a}{2}, hence u-a belongs to the domain of f_{n} and we have f_{n}(u-c)\leqslant f_{n}(u-a) . Since u-c,u-a\geqslant 0 , we obtain u-c\leqslant u-a , which gives a\leqslant c . Similarly, we show that d\in[a,b] , which completes the proof of condition (c) . ∎ 3. Topologies induced by basic families Now, we present a necessary condition (a criterion) to have a homeomorphism between two topologies induced by basic families. Lemma 2 . Assume that \{p_{n}\colon n\geqslant 1\} and \{t_{n}\colon n\geqslant 1\} are basic families, inducing topologies \tau_{0} and \tau_{1} , respectively. If spaces (H,\tau_{0}) and (H,\tau_{1}) are homeomorphic, then there exist \varepsilon>0 and functions \gamma,\delta\colon(0,\varepsilon)\to(0,\infty) such that for every m>n there exists k such that \lim_{h\to 0}\delta(h)=0 and \liminf_{h\to 0}\gamma(h)\leqslant 1 , and t_{1}(\delta(x))\leqslant t_{k}\bigg(\frac{p_{m}^{-1}(x)\delta(x)\gamma(x)}{p^{-1}_{n}(x)}\bigg) for any x\in(0,\varepsilon) . The proof of this criterion shall be preceded by some lemmas, hence it is postponed to the last section. First, we will show how to use the lemma, showing that the topology generated by triangles with bounded angles is not homeomorphic to the Niemytzki plane. Example 3 . Let \alpha\in(0,\frac{\pi}{2}) , a_{n}=(n\tan\frac{\alpha n}{n+1})^{-1} , \textstyle t_{\alpha,n}\colon[-a_{n},a_{n}]\to[0,\frac{1}{n}]\mbox{ and }t_{\alpha,n}(z)=|z|\tan\frac{\alpha n}{n+1}. It is the basic family which induces a topology not homeomorphic to the Niemytzki plane. Indeed, suppose that there exists such a homeomorphism onto the Niemytzki plane. By Lemma 2 , there exist \varepsilon>0 and functions \gamma,\delta\colon(0,\varepsilon)\to(0,\infty) satisfying the hypothesis of the theorem for basic families \{t_{\alpha,n}\colon n\geqslant 1\},\{p_{n}\colon n\geqslant 1\} , where functions p_{n} are given by the formula p_{n}(x)=nx^{2} . For x\in(0,\varepsilon) we have p^{-1}_{m}(x)=\sqrt{x/m} , so substituting z=\frac{p_{m}^{-1}(x)}{p^{-1}_{n}(x)}\delta(x)\gamma(x) , in the counter and then z=\delta(x) in the denominator, we get 1\leqslant\frac{t_{\alpha,k}\big(\frac{p_{m}^{-1}(x)}{p^{-1}_{n}(x)}\delta(x)\gamma(x)\big)}{t_{\alpha,1}(\delta(x))}=\frac{\frac{\sqrt{x/m}}{\sqrt{x/n}}\delta(x)\gamma(x)\tan\frac{\alpha

Read the complete text