Potential absence of observed π 2 \pi^{2} linear-chain structures in 14 O via 10 C( α , α \alpha,\alpha ) resonant scattering
J. Bishop, A. Hollands, Tz. Kokolova, G.V. Rogachev, C. Wheldon, E. Aboud, S. Ahn, M. Barbui, N. Curtis, J. Hooker, C. Hunt, H. Jayatissa, E. Koshchiy, S. Pirrie, B.T. Roeder, A. Saastamoinen, S. Upadhyayula · 2025
Read Potential absence of observed π 2 \pi^{2} linear-chain structures in 14 O via 10 C( α , α \alpha,\alpha ) resonant scattering by J. Bishop, A. Hollands, Tz. Kokolova, G.V. Rogachev, C. Wheldon, E. Aboud, S. Ahn, M. Barbui, N. Curtis, J. Hooker, C. Hunt, H. Jayatissa, E. Koshchiy, S. Pirrie, B.T. Roeder, A. Saastamoinen, S. Upadhyayula (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-01534.txt.
Introduction
Bishop and a large team search for a claimed chain-like arrangement of alpha particles inside oxygen-14 nuclei, in a paper from twenty twenty-five. Carbon-14 was said to host a rotating band of states forming a straight alpha-particle chain. The mirror nucleus, oxygen-14, swaps the extra neutrons for protons, testing how the structure survives.
The team fired carbon-10 beams into helium-rich gas and tracked the scattering inside a time projection chamber. Their measured cross section did not reproduce the claimed states; theory transformed from the carbon data overpredicted several points. The likeliest reading, they argue, is that the original carbon states were never a chain band, with a spin assignment skewed by method limits. The work underscores how hard broad chain states are to pin down.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | J. Bishop, A. Hollands, Tz. Kokolova, G.V. Rogachev, C. Wheldon, E. Aboud, S. Ahn, M. Barbui, N. Curtis, J. Hooker, C. Hunt, H. Jayatissa, E. Koshchiy, S. Pirrie, B.T. Roeder, A. Saastamoinen, S. Upadhyayula |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 32 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-01534
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Potential absence of observed π 2 \pi^{2} linear-chain structures in 14 O via 10 C( α , α \alpha,\alpha ) resonant scattering Preprint: APS/123-QED J. Bishop, A. Hollands, Tz. Kokolova, G.V. Rogachev, C. Wheldon, E. Aboud, S. Ahn, M. Barbui, N. Curtis, J. Hooker, C. Hunt, H. Jayatissa, E. Koshchiy, S. Pirrie, B.T. Roeder, A. Saastamoinen, S. Upadhyayula Abstract Background The preference for light nuclear systems to coagulate into α \alpha -particle clusters has been well-studied. The possibility of a linear chain configuration of α \alpha -particles would allow for a new way to study this phenomenon. Purpose A rotational band of states in 14 C has been claimed showing a π 2 \pi^{2} linear chain structure. The mirror system, 14 O, has been studied here to examine how this linear chain structure is affected by replacing the valence neutrons with protons. Method A beam of 10 C was incident into a chamber filled with He:CO 2 gas with the tracks recorded inside the TexAT Time Projection Chamber and the recoil α \alpha -particles detected by a silicon detector array to measure the C 10 ( α , α ) {}^{10}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,\alpha) cross section. Results The experimental cross section was compared with previous studies and fit using R-Matrix theory with the previously-observed 14 O states being transformed to the 14 C using mirror symmetry. The measured cross section does not replicate the claimed states, with the predicted cross section exceeding that observed at several energies and angles. Conclusion A series of possibilities are highlighted with the most likely being that the originally-seen 14 C states did not constitute a π 2 \pi^{2} rotational band with a potentially incorrect spin assignment due to the limitations of the angular correlation method with non-zero spin particles. The work highlights the difficulties in measuring broad resonances corresponding to a linear chain state in a high level density. pacs Valid PACS appear here I Introduction The importance of \alpha -cluster phenomena, which are prevalent across light nuclei Ikeda et al. 1968 , is becoming increasingly apparent in the context of near-threshold states in open quantum systems Dobaczewski et al. 2007 ; von Oertzen 2002 ; Okołowicz et al. 2020 . Traditionally, the strongest evidence of \alpha -clusters exists in \alpha -conjugate nuclei with the 8 Be ground state and the Hoyle state ( J^{\pi}=0_{2}^{+} at 7.65 MeV) in 12 C Otsuka et al. 2022 ; Dunbar et al. 1953 ; Freer and Fynbo 2014 being two textbook examples. These \alpha -conjugate nuclei have had success in being described in terms of rigid geometric cluster configurations such as the D_{3h} model which well describes a variety of states in 12 C Bijker and Iachello 2002 ; Marín-Lámbarri et al. 2014 . Extending such geometric configurations to non \alpha -conjugate nuclei has also been an area of interest for the past few decades. In particular, the question of how the addition of valence neutrons or protons affects the underlying \alpha -cluster structure is of significant interest and offers a great test for ab initio models. There has been a great amount of interest in studying the possibility of a 3 \alpha -particle linear chain state in A > 12 systems. For 12 C, it has been long understood that the Hoyle state, by virtue of its moment of inertia, cannot be a linear chain configuration Neff and Feldmeier 2004 ; Kanada-En’yo 2007a ; Zimmerman et al. 2013 and this linear configuration is unstable. The addition of valence protons or neutrons modifies this for heavier systems, and the additional nucleons can make the system stiffer and therefore able to support such a state Suhara and Kanada-En’yo 2010 . Recently, evidence of the 3 \alpha -particle linear chain state was purported in 14 C via the 14 C( p,p^{\prime} ) inelastic scattering reaction Han et al. 2023 . Observation of the breakup of states into 10 Be + \alpha allowed for a series of states to be reconstructed using invariant mass. A selection of these states were suggested as corresponding to a rotational band of J π = 0 + , 2 + , and 4^{+} using spin-parity analysis with the angular correlation method Freer 1996 . Given the large moment of inertia of these states, which agree reasonably well with AMD (Antisymmetrized Molecular Dynamics) calculations for the linear chain configuration Baba and Kimura 2019 by Baba and Kimura, these states were given as evidence of the linear chain structure in 14 C with two p-wave neutrons around a 3 \alpha linear chain. Examination of states in the mirror system where the valence neutrons are instead valence protons allows for a great check of the mirror symmetries of such a system in terms of the Thomas-Ehrmann shift (which can provide information about the spatial extent of the valence neutrons) and also the robustness of mirror symmetry where the reduced width for mirror states should be similar. Observation of the same set of linear chain states in the mirror system will also provide proof or possible refutation of the observations in 14 C. Therefore, an experiment was performed to search for \alpha -cluster structures in 14 O via the 10 C( \alpha,\alpha) elastic scattering reaction. II Experimental Setup In order to measure the 10 C( \alpha,\alpha) reaction, a radioactive beam of 10 C was produced at the Cyclotron Institute, Texas A&M University using the K500 Cyclotron to provide a 7 MeV/nucleon 10 B beam which was incident on a LN 2 -cooled H 2 target at 870 Torr. Via the 10 B( p,n)^{10} C reaction, a secondary radioactive beam of 10 C was separated from contaminants using the Momentum Achromatic Recoil Separator (known as MARS). The beam then entered the chamber at an energy of around 2.7 MeV/nucleon with a typical intensity of 5000 pps. In order to measure the reaction, the Texas Active Target Time Projection Chamber (TexAT TPC) Koshchiy et al. 2020 was used and was filled with 405 Torr of He:CO 2 (96:4). Using the Thick Target in Inverse Kinematics (TTIK) approach Artemov et al. 1990 , the elastic scattering cross section was measured from an energy of around 6.5 MeV in the center of mass down to 2 MeV with the beam stopping inside the chamber (155 mm into the active area of the TPC). The tracks of the charged particles were measured using a segmented Micromegas detector which had a higher gas gain away from the central beam region in order to identify better the tracks from the scattered \alpha particles. The active region of the TPC starts 270 mm from the 4- \mu m-thick Havar entrance window. To measure the total energy of the \alpha particles with a good energy resolution, an array of MSQ-25 silicon detectors (5 x 5 cm 2 quad detectors) were placed downstream to pickup the recoil particles. The detectors, with thicknesses ranging from 625-700 \mu m, were sufficiently thick to fully stop the 4 He ions of interest. The acquisition was then triggered by a signal in the forward silicon wall. This setup is identical to that covered in previous work to study 14 O (\alpha,\alpha) Barbui et al. 2022 having run sequentially with the current work. The silicon