Superconducting properties of ultrapure niobium
N. E. Alekseevskiy(1), V. I. Nizhankovskiy(1) and K.-H. Bertel(2) · 2025
Read Superconducting properties of ultrapure niobium by N. E. Alekseevskiy(1), V. I. Nizhankovskiy(1) and K.-H. Bertel(2) (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-01330.txt.
Introduction
Alekseevskiy, Nizhankovskiy, and Bertel present a study, republished in 2025, of how ultrapure niobium carries current with no resistance. The team measured the key field and current limits in samples of different purity. Near its shift temperature, the purest metal acted as a type-one material, the kind that pushes magnetic fields out in full. As the temperature fell, it shifted to type-two behavior, letting fields thread through in thin tubes.
The width of the magnetism loops depended on the state of the sample surface. The team compared the main measures with traits of the metal's electron spectrum. In wires, how the top current changed with an applied field matched a force-free pattern of flow. The work remains a reference on how purity shapes this classic metal.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | N. E. Alekseevskiy(1), V. I. Nizhankovskiy(1) and K.-H. Bertel(2) |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 25 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-01330
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Superconducting properties of ultrapure niobium N. E. Alekseevskiy(1), V. I. Nizhankovskiy(1) and K.-H. Bertel(2) Abstract The results of determination of critical magnetic fields, magnetization curves and critical currents of niobium samples of different purity are presented. It is shown that ultrapure niobium near T c T_{c} is a superconductor of the first type and becomes a superconductor of the second type with decreasing temperature due to the temperature dependence of the Ginzburg-Landau parameters. The dependence of the hysteresis of the magnetization curves of massive samples on the surface state is investigated. A comparison of the superconducting parameters with the parameters of the electron spectrum of niobium is carried out. The dependence of the critical current of niobium wires on the longitudinal magnetic field agrees with the assumption of a force-free current distribution. Introduction Niobium is known to have a number of interesting physical properties. For example, it is apparently the only pure metal that exhibits the properties of a type-II superconductor. However, there are significant discrepancies between the theory of type-II superconductors and the experimental data obtained on niobium. In particular, the experimentally observed behavior of the magnetization curve in the region between the upper and lower critical fields, as well as the absolute value and temperature dependence of the Ginzburg-Landau parameters, do not correspond to theoretical concepts. Attempts to reduce these discrepancies by increasing the purity of niobium [ 1 , 2 ] or by extrapolating the properties of niobium alloys with tantalum or molybdenum to an ideally pure metal [ 3 ] have proven unsuccessful. Unlike niobium, similar experiments on tantalum [ 4 ] show that the purest samples of this metal behave like type-I superconductors, while contaminated ones are similar to type-II superconductors. Purity of metallic samples is characterized by the residual resistance ratio \alpha=R(300\,\rm{K})/\\ R(0\,\rm{K}) 1 1 1 Since niobium is a superconductor, the measurements of the value of R(0\,\rm{K} were carried out in a longitudinal magnetic field H\geq 8 kOe. . Niobium in cited above work [ 1 ] had \alpha=1,400 , in work [ 2 ] \alpha=2,000 and in work [ 3 ] \alpha=1,100 . To study the superconducting properties and the Fermi surface of niobium on the purest samples, it is necessary that the value of \alpha be greater than 10,000. This publication presents results obtained many years ago on ultrapure single crystals and wires of niobium and published in Russian [ 5 ] . Because interest to superconductivity of pure niobium has been revived recently [ 6 ] , it seems reasonable make old results obtained on uniquely pure samples available in English translation. 1 Experiment 1.1 Samples The complex and rather complicated purification process consisted of five steps was developed in Dresden [ 7 , 8 ] . It comprised the combination of liquid-liquid extraction, chlorination and thermal decomposition of NbCl 5 , followed by electron beam float zone melting, decarburization and degassing treatments. A review of the efforts directed to the preparation of ultra-high-purity niobium is given in [ 9 ] Critical temperatures, dependencies magnetization on the field and critical fields were measured on single crystal samples of different orientation and purity. Samples were made from rods with a diameter of 5-6 mm. To obtain the shape of an ellipsoid the rod was melt and stretched from both ends to form a narrowing with the minimum possible diameter in the zone melting. After annealing, the sample was separated at the thinnest point. Length of samples was about 2 cm. Photo of the typical single crystal sample is shown in the insert of Figure 1. Table I shows the orientations of the sample axis relative to the crystal axes, resistances ratio and the second critical field extrapolated to T=0 for massive single crystal samples on which the magnetization dependencies on the external magnetic field were measured. Table I Nb1 Nb2 Nb3 Nb4 Nb5 orientation [100] [100] [110] [111] [123] \alpha=R(300\,\rm{K})/R(0\,\rm{K}) 36,500 61,000 34,000 52,000 28,000 H_{c2}(0) , kOe 3.94 3.92 4.00 4.27 4.10 Besides massive single crystals, wire polycrystalline samples were prepared. Their parameters are given in Table II. 1.2 Devices The magnetometer consisted of two counter-connected coils, in one of which the sample being studied was fixed. To record the magnetization curves, the signal from the coils was fed to the integrating photoelectric microwebermeter F-18T and then to the y-coordinate of the two-coordinate recorder. A signal proportional to the current in the solenoid was fed to the x-coordinate. The temperature was setup from 4.2 to 10 K with an accuracy of 10 mK. It should be noted that in the first magnetization measurements we tried to use the conventional ballistic method, in which the sample is moved between compensated measuring coils. However, the studied single crystals turned out to be so perfect that even a finger click on the cryostat could lead to a jump in magnetization. Therefore, we had to abandon moving the sample. Critical current measurements were performed by the pulse method on polycrystalline wires made of pure niobium. Pulse setup allowed single sawtooth current pulses of up to 500 A with a duration of from 0.3 to 10 msec. Experiments were done at T=4.2 K in a longitudinal homogeneous magnetic field of up to 20 kOe. The use of a small measuring coil placed on a wire sample made it possible to simultaneously measure the potential difference arising on the sample and record the change in its magnetization. 2 Hysteresis of magnetization of massive samples The magnetization curves of all the massive samples had distinct hysteresis but there was no residual moment at H=0 . Maximum hysteresis was observed on the purest samples with a smooth, undamaged surface. The hysteresis detected could hardly be due to the geometry of the samples because their shape was approximately that of an ellipsoid (see insert in Figure 1). It also could not be a consequence of the capture of magnetic flux in the sample volume by lattice defects, since in this case a residual moment should have been observed. The absence of flux capture is confirmed by the shape of the partial hysteresis loops (Figure 1) and a decrease in the hysteresis of the magnetization curves when an alternating current with a frequency of 50 Hz was added to the direct supply current of solenoid that created the magnetic field; the amplitude of the alternating field was \sim 20 Oe. Figure 1: Magnetization curve of sample Nbl with minor hysteresis loops (copy from trace on a two-coordinate recording chart). Temperature 4.2 K. Surface oxidized by heating in air at 400 ∘ C for 4 min. Arrows give direction in which recording pen is moving. Insert: photo of the sample. Figure 2: Influence of surface treatment on magnetization of Nb1 (copy from two-coordinate recordings), temperature 4.2 K: dashed line - before treatment; solid line - after heating in air at 400 ∘ C for 4 min; dotted line - after etching. Since irreversibility apparently could not arise in the bulk of the sample, it is natural to assume that its appearance is due to the surface of the sample. To clarify the causes of hysteresis on the Nb1 sample with \alpha=36,500 , magnetization measurements were taken after various surface treatments, and